Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Cost vs utility -- a survey

Posts

Cost vs utility -- a survey

#1

Ellis Walentine

Cost vs utility -- a survey

Ellis Walentine

>In the thread below about Bridge City Tools, Brent Smith brought up an issue that lurks in every tool purchase: cost versus utility. My sense is that our primary criterion when buying a tool is utility. We need a tool that accomplishes a particular task. From there, it seems the criteria are all over the map. Some people buy adequate tools and take pride in making them work. Others buy fancy or highly engineered tools because they appreciate the feel or the engineering or some other characteristic of the tool, or simply because they can afford it, so why not buy the "best" or most expensive one available?

What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

Just curious...

Ellis

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#2

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>I purchase my tools and equipments as a utility to get a project finished with the least cost....yet the tool/equipment has to meet the highest quality and last for a long time with good maintenance of same.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#3

JL

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

JL

>"How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?"

Tough one. When I started out woodworking, I bought more for utility. The least expensive tool to get the job done. As the years progressed (and as my skill levels have hopefully increased), I have realized that this was a false economy. The better tools are better. Yes, you can spend the time in tuning a Groz plane - or you can buy a Veritas or Lie-Nielsen.

If you enjoy spending the time tuning the tool, buy the less expensive or older tool. I have several old drawknives and planes that I have found over the years. They are great tools. But they did required a few hours of work to get them cleaned up.

Price is somewhat important. I don't have an unlimited budget. I don't like spending extra. I guess my philosophy is to buy the best tool that you can afford. Before you buy it, analyze. Will it do the job? Will it last? Does it have a resale value if you want to move on to a better tool?

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#4

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1st - I try to establish a baseline of quality. Doesn't have to be the finest/latest/bestest in any respect, but I buy the tool to do a job, not to create a job getting (keeping) the tool to do what it's supposed to do over time. This includes the tool/brands rep for durability. Old rubric - "Buy cheap and often or pay more once" has application here.

2nd - I consider brands/model above my baseline based upon a strict cost benefit analysis as applied to my own situation. Example: I bought a JET cab saw because in my shop it would do just as well as the best Powermatic, Felder, etc.

3rd - I consider any special circumstances for use. Examples: Having been cut buy a table saw blade with the memory of the pain still fresh, I'd have bought a SawStop over any other saw without hesitation if it had been available "back when." I bought high-alloy turning tools because, although they are a "consumable", they reduce my time at the grinder which means more time actually cutting wood. However, I buy cheap angle drills for lathe sanding because I know the dust is gonna kill them regardless of what I do, yet I use electric tools because the cost to run a more durable air-powered sander is highly disproportionate to the tool's cost.

4th - Of course, all of this is dependent upon actually knowing what the issues are when I go shopping.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#5

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Barry Irby

>I buy for utility. I want a tool that will do the job and not fall apart.

I see many of the so called upgrades and extra features as somewhat suspect and perhaps prissy. The KISS Principle applies here.

As an example, I have a Milwaukee Sawzall. Probably thirty years old. Its a beast. Combination eraser and Light Saber. It has the set screw that requires an Allen wrench to change the blade. I would sort of like to have the quick change blade feature, but I am fairly sure it would fall apart in about two hours.

Prejudice plays in in other ways. I have an old B&D Hammer drill. The chuck is so worn it is nearly impossible to use. Bought a Bosch SDS drill as an up grade. Researched them on line and then went to buy one at the borg. Bought the biggest one I could justify, but I noticed that some were made in China and some in Germany. Bought the biggest German made one I could justify.

And Mark is correct. Sometimes we don't actually know what the job will require when we actually get into it and we don't really know what the tool is capable of until we start using it. So, If you over buy and the tool is heavier than it need be and bigger but it does the job well, you can't likely tell it would have been easier with a lighter smaller tool. If you under buy and the tool won't perform or you dog it to death, you will be sure you should have bought its big brother and you may have to to finish the job.

I have a Rockwell/Delta contractors saw. The original 1 1/2hp motor failed and I replaced it with a 2hp. I used it with the original crappy fence for thirty plus years. Lowes sold off the Biesemeyer Fences for $80. My kind of deal. Had to upgrade the wings, they were grids, so I covered them with Formica, and installed the fence. Is it better? That's a really big YES, but it is a convenience, saves time, etc. At $80, heck of a deal, at $400 not so much. Not sure the end product has improved.

So, I buy REAL tools at the right price. Not only do I not buy the upgrades and gadgets, they put me off.

As a side note, Is anybody else "loyal" to their tools. I keep mine and fix them even when it does not make sense any more. I think I feel I owe them something for the service they have given me.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#6

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>Well JL's and Mark's posts above have pretty much nailed it for me. I would add that as a hobbiest with a long term view, I general scour the used market looking for reputable brand tools - sometimes looking for several years. Obviously this is not my livelihood at stake.

I had to chuckle at JL's example of the trade offs in purchasing hand planes because this was spot on for me. One of the very few new (not used) tools I have purchased is a Veritas shoulder plane. I purchased retail and higher end brand in this case because I was not confident that I could recognize good value in the used tool market, or that I had the experience or the wherewithal to 'clean up' a used shoulder plane. I also had a long overdue project (end tables for our living room) that would benefit immediately from this tool.

So utility is a primary concern - but value, functionality in long term, the availability of parts and service, and brand name all certainly play a role in my decision making. I'm highly unlikely to ever have a shop full of high end or beautiful tools.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#7

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Binen

>For me the purchase of a tool is both a goal to an immediate end but also an investment for the future. If the task is something I will probably not do regular basis or ever again then cost come to the top. I will buy the cheapest I can find that will accomplish the task. If the task is one I will be doing again then quality and ease of use become most important and cost drops to the bottom. When I put a tool in my box I try to buy something that will serve me the rest of my life. When I buy a one time use tool it does not go in my box but instead either on a yard sale or the trash.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#8

The 80/20 rule

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>In almost everything I can think of there is some variation of the 80/20 rule in the decision making process. This means that I can get 80% of the 'perfect', 'ideal', 'best' or what have you with 20% of the money or effort. The trick them becomes knowing how far up the price range I want to go to get something "better". "Better" factors in function to some extent but includes convenience, build quality, long term reliability, safety, and even ego satisfaction. Knowing what will be appropriate or 'best' is not easy for a novice. For eg. years ago I went from a used radial arm saw to a new Powermatic which was really nice but WAY more tool than any newbie needed [sold that when I moved] and now do everything I want with a contractor's table saw w/ a good blade-not as quickly but pretty much as well. My 18" jet bandsaw does fine for me. I didn't get a Laguna although the ego temptation was there for a while. And on down the line.

In car terms think Kia vs. Ferrari and everything in between.

The upshot is that I buy what I think will do do the job and last long enough without jumping to the most prestigious or expensive machine.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#9

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

mike from american sycamore

>Perhaps I am spoiled a bit because I use my tools for a living and I do try to buy the best. I have a good selection of Bridge City measuring tools and Lie-Nielsen hand plans. Fine tools in my hand makes me want to do my best.

I spend a lot of time in the shop and like to surround myself with nice tools and ones that will not let me down. My neighbor has a large boat, trailer to haul it, and a nice truck to pull it. He has decided to put his dollars in his boat, I put my money in to my tools.

I sold tools for years and always tried to guide the customer to buy the tool that would do the job for him. Every time I sold a tool to a customer because it was cheap it came back to haunt me.

Mike

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#10

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>My criteria changed once I went into business. As part of my business model I needed to make decisions about my "capital expendatures". Enjoyment of the tool took a back seat to durability, time savings, capacity, accuracy and practicality. Generally my tool acquisitions shifted to bigger machines that I felt were built for the long haul. They are pricier but tax write offs help ease the pain. However, they fit my business model and are serving me well.

Oddly enough the same goes for my hand tools. I focus on high quality and well built tools. When I am on a tight deadline I need my tools to perform well and not need a lot of extra sharpening time etc.

In business, time is money. And the less time I spend trying to make "just getting by" tools to do the job the better.

Tom

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#11

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

Woodworking is my hobby - not my living. Therefore I cannot justify any purchase from the standpoint of payback in labor saving or improved product. I think a pro would be much more concerned with price/payback than bragging rights (brand) or even longevity.

I am very lucky in that my youngest son is quite interested in woodworking. Therefore I buy tools that are the very best I can afford, as I want to pass them on to my son. As I am retired I have a somewhat limited disposable income, (also restricted by SHMBO opinion). I am fortunate enough that my financial situation allows me to purchase high end tools occasionally. I also try to purchase American made if possible or European when American made is not available. I do a lot of research on most items before purchasing. This site has greatly influenced all my purchase decisions. My criteria for purchasing the tool include the following in the order I consider most important. (1) utility (mainly accuracy), I would not hesitate to spend 25% more for increased accuracy or usable features on a $200 to $500 tool. (2) longevity (including warranty and part availability) (3)location of manufacture (4) price and (5) Brand (bragging rights & resale value - important only if I or my son upgrades the tool).

My son's and friend's helped me build my dream shop about 5 or 6 years ago. I have equipped it with a Limited edition Delta Unisaw (purchased when made in USA). Grizzly 8" joiner with spiral head, Yorkcraft 20" planer with Byrd head, MinMax MM-16 Band saw, Leigh D4 dovetail jig, Fisch morticer, Grizzly 3 hp Cyclone dust collector. Powermatic PM2800 drill press & PM 90 Lathe. Delta stationary sander & Miter Saw. 60 gal CH air compressor, Porter Cable routers, Biscuit joiner and belt sander & circular saw, Dewalt, PC and Ridged hand drills, PC & Bosch ROS. Many Bessy clamps as well as a large number of pipe and assorted clamps etc. Several Veritas and Lee Neilsen hand tools and several(old) Stanley planes, drawknives etc. I also have a fairly large collection of air tools and Binks spray equipment.

If my budget was a little larger, I would have several Festool items, a wide belt sander and a larger joiner.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#12

Re: The 80/20 rule...90/50 for me

pecker

>I have always found I can get 90% of the bang for 50% of the buck. Tools or TV's.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#13

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Since making the decision to move into semi-pro status my decisions have definitely changed. As a hobbyist, I was more about the tools and less about the work. I wanted to learn to sharpen perfectly by hand, use lots of hand tools, etc. Now, I am focusing on getting a tool with enough power and capabilities to last me for many years without needing a replacement. I want to make things, not repair tools.

How do I shop now? Well, I look at what my needs for a tool are. For instance, I'm shopping for a bandsaw now. I need one that will let me do at least 12" rips. I look for the machines that meet that feature at a minimum. Then I go at least one step higher. Plenty of 14" deluxe models will do that, but they have 1 1/2 hp motors. Moving up to a 17" model gets me a 2 hp motor, bigger throat, etc. By always buying more than I need, I know I won't be stuck in the future (at least not the near future). Once I know what level of machine to buy, I shop for the best I can get for as little money as possible. I have manufacturers I prefer, but I'm not snobbish about it. I do prefer to buy new as my life is about making things, not fixing tools.

In hand tools, I pretty much go straight to a quality tool, Lee Valley or Lie Nielsen. I no longer have time to fix old stuff. I use jigs and waterstones for sharpening because it's fast and repeatable. I have some old tools though, especially hand saws and I like them - but there, they do what I need and the price was right.

I will no longer "cheap out" on a tool. I know that in most cases I get what I pay for, so I'm sure to get something good. As prices climb, though, I find you get less than what you pay for, so shopping in the middle ground is where I like to be. And I don't like whiz-bang stuff or uni-taskers.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#14

an ever changing calculation; profession influence

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>What impresses me every time I visit a professional shop is how few tools they have and especially how few "premium" tools they have. This observation has had an impact on my tool buying.

A perhaps not so obvious reason the pros don't have many, or any, fancy tools is that someone experienced can likely cut good dovetails with a hack saw, to make one example. Which is to say they don't feel they need premium tools to do their work. I think all too often amateurs believe, with some justification, that better tools will lead to better results. I know I was failing at acceptable dovetails until I got a good saw. Now I might be able to use a hack saw.

Another observation has surprised me and that is that all woodworkers don't necessarily make stuff, or at least making stuff is not their primary motivation. These people can have different tool buying motivation than the makers of stuff.

For those that make stuff, woodworking is a paying hobby. The value of what I have made greatly exceeds what I have paid for tools. Hence, I have never been reticent at buying some tool I need, but I don't buy more than I need, because for me its just a tool. I don't get many visitors so bragging tools are not of much importance to me.

I have a lot of duplication because my building techniques have changed. I have several tools for assembling face frames- dowel jig, bead-loc, mortise chisel- but now I have settled on drill press and hollow chisel mortiser.

You likely had some purpose for your request; hope this was useful to you.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#16

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Curly Smith

>How many times do we need to have The Festool Discussion?

Can't we just agree that people have different reasons for buying the equipment that they buy? Can't we just agree that the free market provides a wide range of choices and let people make their own decisions?

Can we also agree that high price does not necessarily mean high quality?

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#17

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Jesse Cloud

>I once attended a short class taught by Lon Scheinling. I remember his advice was that if you were in woodworking because you enjoy it, then buy a tool you will enjoy using every time - anything else is just not contributing to why you are there. I firmly believe that, so I buy first quality tools. To be sure, there are some tools that are pretty much the same from all vendors, so there's no real choice. Also there is that totally utilitarian "honey do" chore that you hope will only come up once in your lifetime - then its hello Harbor Freight.

So I spend what it takes to have a set of tools I will enjoy using. If I have a tool that hasn't been used for a year, it goes on Craigslist. If the tool has a good rep, I get a good price for it (Harbor Freight generally goes in the trash). I'm not a collector, and not really looking for bragging rights.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#18

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Bill Howatt

>What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

I buy on the basis of what I need to do the job. Unfortunately, this may change over the years, ie, I may want to do something I never thought I would previously.

Good enough is a tool that does the job but also appears reasonably reliable and will maintain its alignment/calibration.

I am open to paying more for marginal increases in utility but it depends on how marginal and how much more. My basic rule is, when in doubt by the next best one.

Bragging rights mean very little to me. I get more fun out of saying this was made on my $200 starter lathe rather than on my much more expensive 20" General.

Since I don't live in a big city, shipping/availabilty is a consideration.

Bill

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#19

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Bill

Ellis Walentine

>Ulterior motives? Who, me? No, in all innocence I felt this is a topic that encompasses both the philosophy and the economics of what we do as woodworkers. It's another way to look at the perennial question of what motivates us. Talking about the rationale for tool buying decisions helps us to understand our own motives better, and the testimonials of others may enhance or inform our decision making process.

Reading your post, I was thinking back to my old shop, when I had tons of tools and machines (literally -- the scrap salvage guys took 30 tons of metal out after the fire). Few of those tools were of the super highly refined tools that have become commonplace in the past ten or 15 years. Yet, we cranked out lots of custom furniture and millwork and somehow got it done with the beaters we had. Making do has always been a woodworking mantra for me. But, now that I'm not obsessed with churning the work through the shop, owning a few really excellent new tools from the likes of our sponsors, Lie-Nielsen, Lee Valley, Tools for Working Wood and others has proven to be a revelation to me. For one thing, I can appreciate the improved capabilities of these tools, so I make good use of them. For another, the latest/greatest items are more pleasureable to use because of their heft, balance, precision, etc., and I have the time to enjoy the rewarding feeling of using them. But I'm still a user rather than a collector. I don't buy anything I won't use. Others are motivated by owning a wide variety of tools that are designed for the same purpose, and that's okay, too.

Anyhow, sorry for the longwinded reply. YMMV

Ellis

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#20

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Pete in Holland, MI

>I am kind of a middle of the road guy. When I buy tools, it is more for utility & cost, but they have to work and to the job they were purchased for. I am always wary of Harbor Freight & Flea Market tools. They may look good, but my shopping criteria on sources like this, is that tool requires good steel, assume won't have it. A friend got started in the woodworking hobby and struggled, because of the cheap tools he purchased. He has learned, and is transitioning into better stuff now.

My first 10 years of woodworking involved buying and rebuilding a Shopsmith, drill press, building a router table & disk sander, and rejuvinating many old planes, chisels, draw knives and other tools found at flea markets. Cost was a concern. It was also very satisfying bringing an old tool back from near death (I also restore old steam engines & tractors when the weather is warm).

In the last 15 years, I have been upgrading all of my power tools to bigger & higher quality tools (mostly JET). My woodworking has evolved, and expectations of the machines have evolved too. What was adequate before, isn't now.

While a friend was looking for a new table saw, salesmen were talking about cabinet saws, so smooth a nickel will stand on the table, etc. I have a contractor's saw. It cuts true & square & does the work I need it to do. I can justify spending 2-3X the cost on something that the current saw allready does.

I guess the best thing you can do is use your tools..... exclusively. If they are doing the job, then they are fine, and you won't know any better. When you use someone else's bigger & better tool, that is where you get into trouble, because you now have something to compare. This is a dangerous & costly misteak of many of us.

Pete

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#21

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Thomas S Stockton

>For me the answer is all of the above. When I need a tool and have the time I will do some research and try to find the best value vs price which most the time means buying a very well built tool with minimum bells and whistles. If I need the tool right know because my router or drill died I will go down to the local tool store and see what they have and buy what ever fits my needs best.

The other way I buy tools is to see what pops up on craigslist or woodweb, when I was looking to replace my old jointer I started the research on what was available and the perfect jointer at a great price popped up on woodweb. I did have to drive 8 hours each way to Portland but it was worth it.

I not totally sold on how wonderful some of these well engineered tools are sometimes they just end up being to complicated and expensive. For me one example is festool drills and routers I'm sure they are great tools and very well made but none of the extra functions are things that I need. In the case of their drills I can buy 3 really nice drills for the same price that do everything I need from a drill. And yes I do own a couple of Festool products because they fit my criteria for what I needed.

When I walk into someones shop and they have a stack of Festool stuff or an almost complete collection from Lie- Nelson it tends to send up red flags for me and the first thing I want to see is the work they are producing because that is what is important to me. Is their work good because it is real easy to spend money but it takes a lot of time and effort to get good at building furniture and I would rather see nice work made with a rusty sharpened screwdriver than poor work built with the most expensive tools.

A lot of my influence comes from People like Art Carpenter and James Krenov who built amazing furniture with a minimum of tools. Krenov in his books talks about how little you really need to make nice furniture.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#22

Freak . . .

steve mackay

>I'll be the freak in 'da room . . . I look, first, for an "antique" that'll do the task I've in mind. Even moving into the electron-age, I'd rather buy an old cast iron machine than a new plastic one. I'll deal with it's quirks. If I HAVE to buy new I find the price that will raise SWMBO's eyebrows then buy the next one up. I guess my bottom line is GI proof and affordable.

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#23

Clint Searl

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

Clint Searl

>An interesting question, the responses to which I think, a Full Dress Cleveland Shrink would have a field day analyzing. My observation is that woodworkers are more or less obcessive-compulsive and creatively rationalize the acquisition of any tool at any price. Witness the myriad brands, attachments, accessories, and doodads that are supposed to produce a better product.

Clint

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#24

WW'ers really don't think about cost vs. utility

wilbur

>The fact that I took on woodworking as a hobby means that I crossed the "I need to justify the cost" line a long time ago. :@)

Seriously, although the cost vs. utility issue is phrased as if it's an objective, quantifiable decision, it really is a subjective question. One person may see no added utility in a Lie-Nielsen bench plane above a rehabbed Stanley. Others may appreciate cherry handles and totes and brass accents and the appearance of a new plane. Does that mean that there is no utility in those design elements? Not if you think that the pleasure you get from a tool is worth what you paid for it.

To look at it from another perspective, being woodworkers, I'm sure we all appreciate a bookcase made from solid cherry. From a "utility" standpoint, that bookcase won't hold books any better than the cinder-block-and-2x-material bookcases we all had in college, and the price differential between a solid cherry bookcase and a pile of cinder blocks and 2x material is a lot higher than that between a LN plane and a used Stanley, or a Festool router vs. a Porter-Cable.

Now, this is not to say that everyone should dump their used Stanleys for Lie-Nielsens, or that everyone should sell their high-end gently used tools, take the proceeds and buy cheap used ones and pocket the difference. We all have our own perspectives on what "utility" is, which is what make the world go round. Where these conversations gets into trouble is when they transition from "This is what I would pay extra for," to "and therefore everyone else should make the same purchasing decision."

Re: Cost vs utility -- a survey

#25

Re: The 80/20 rule

Kneale Brownson..Packing for return to CO snows

>When I'm buying tools, I try to find the best deal I can get on the most durable tool for whatever the job is. I'm almost never convinced to buy something that's cheap just because I might use it only rarely. I've found that once acquired, a tool often becomes the one of choice for a number of other uses than the one that spurred the original purchase.