Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

If a tree falls in the woods...

Posts

If a tree falls in the woods...

#1

If a tree falls in the woods...

David

>I've had a couple of nice trees go down in the woods over the last year or so. I haven't been able to get to them and cut them down fully and am wondering if nice straight cherry and beech, uprooted but still growing at a 45 degree angle (supported by nearby trees) will become compression wood or do I still have a chance at getting some decent lumber out of these.

Forgive my wood ignorance.

DGW

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#2

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

Tom Dunlap

>It is likely to change tension/compression.

If not, wood would sag like old celery. Sagging happen to a degree unless the change can take place quickly.

I've worked on trees that tipped many years ago and stayed that way. The limbs continued to grow in their original direction then bent more vertically. The wood that was in place originally acts really weird when it's cut. I'm talking about arborcultural work, either pruning or removing. But...I can tell that the wood is different and doesn't hinge the same so I am extrapolating that difference to what to expect in lumber.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Would...

Dale Lenz

>think it should take several years for the reaction to affect the wood in the bole of the tree. There could be some reaction wood from the last year or two since the tree began to lean, those growth rings will be removed in the slabbing at the mill. I plan on sawing a walnut of similar situation as soon as the landowner bring them to my house. Have only been waiting six months now, : ' (.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#4

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>David, I don't think the wood would be affected by the leaning against another tree.

I would like to caution you though, cutting a tree in this position is a serious challenge. Even if you have experience felling trees, I would suggest that you not work alone, the dynamics are quite different.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#5

If a tree falls in the woods...be skeptical

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Reaction wood is wood that results when a tree grows under mechanical stress. The part of the cherry you are interested in (heart wood) has been dead for several years before the tree blew over, so it is what it was.

Beech is a nearly worthless wood for most applications. There is a reason that there is rarely a commercial market for it except rail ties.

Turning a single tree into lumber can be a economically, in terms of time and money, unsound endeavor, especially so if the tree is not large. If the tree blew over it may indicate that the tree had a problem and was weak. Closely examine the area around the roots for rot that may have progressed into the trunk where the desirable lumber is hoped to be.

Presuming your email address indicates that you live near Utica, NY.... there is a huge mill between Vernon Center and Clinton that saws nothing but cherry and maple. You can buy from them at prices vastly less than from your local Woodcraft store.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#6

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

David

>Thanks for the words of caution. For better or worse, I get a fair amount of practice with widow makers. Seems they love to fall across trails. Kind of like which side lands down when you drop buttered bread. Thanks again, it's nice to be reminded about these things.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#7

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

Ned Bulken

>it's called turning stock...

seriously, the experts have spoken. If you need help with that beastie though, drop me a line. I'm just over in the Canastota area. I'm no lumberjack, but I can help with hauling on a safety line if you need someone.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#8

What's the name of the Mill?

Ron in Sterling, CT

>Bill,

I go past that area 2 or 3 times a year on our trips back and forth between MI and CT. What is the name of the mill? I just might stop by and check it out.

Ron

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#9

Re: What's the name of the Mill? *LINK*

Ned Bulken

>Ron,

If it is who I think it is their info is listed on the link below. Be advised that Mcdonough Lumber had a fire at the mill Aug '08 I've not heard that they're back in action yet, but I'll check it out.


contact info for Mcdonough Lumber

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#10

Re: What's the name of the Mill?

David

>That would be the place.

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

#11

Re: If a tree falls in the woods...

David

>Thanks Ned, I just may be in touch!