Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT--Paving question

Posts

OT--Paving question

#1

OT--Paving question

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>I would like to have the lower portion of my driveway paved. When I had a smaller driveway, I used to do my own sealing (not hard--sort of like gloppy, black, paint), but I don't know much about paving. I got 2 quotes. One from the guy who is going to do my next door neighbor's. I told him that and asked if they could do them around the same time and cut down on transporting the machines, etc., it might give them a break and get us a price break. The section of drive is 175 ft. long and about 11 ft. wide. It is an incline and has a bend. Both guys quoted removing vegetation, grading, compacting, and paving with 2 1/2 to 3" of "airport mix" or "fine" asphalt (one guy says they are the same thing; I have no idea). Both seem like nice guys. They are local, family-owned businesses, doing this work a long time. I do not have any direct (or indirect) experience with either.

One guy's quote came in at $3,750. Not bad, I thought. The guy who's doing my neighbor's drive came in at $5,300. To me, that sounds like a huge difference for the same job. I told him about the other quote; he was surprise it was so low and said his 'costs' were about $3,000 on the job to start. He called back today and said he could come down to $4,900. Still much higher to me.

My question--what more could he be doing for that extra $1,150? (Plus tax, I presume) I would recognize quality in a woodworking job or something else, but on an outdoor thing that will get weathered and water running down it and snow and ice and there's no way they can guarantee it for long--is that worth another $1100? Any ideas? Thanks in advance.

Re: OT--Paving question

#2

Re: OT--Paving question

Gene DiNardo

>Ask about the details,

What mix are they using FJ,ID2,volumetric superpave etc.

Will they be including any repairs, patching,leveling,crowning, etc.

How do they finish their edges, form, taper, curb, etc.

How thick is the paving, 1.5",2",2.5",4".

What about the apron, do they go to the curb, sidewalk ?

If the paving meets a structure (Garage,House,accessory Bldg.) do they grout (tar) the seam ?

Just make sure you're comparing apples to apples.

Hope this helps.

Re: OT--Paving question

#3

Re: OT--Paving question

Justin Szeliga

>Is Charlie McAnn one of the quotes?

Re: OT--Paving question

#4

JL

Re: OT--Paving question

JL

>I recently asked about the cost of paving our little road. The basic cost was $2,900 for each 10' x 100' section with 2 to 2 1/2" of mix. So your estimate of $5,300 sounds pretty reasonable to me. I checked with two of our local paving companies and they were within $100 of each other.

Re: OT--Paving question

#5

Re: OT--Paving question

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Sent you an email.

Re: OT--Paving question

#6

Re: OT--Paving question

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Thanks, Gene. Excellent questions! These are the very thing I don't know about to ask. Thanks! Some don't apply, but some are important.

Re: OT--Paving question

#7

Re: OT--Paving question

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Thank you. I feel a little better about that larger quote. If my 2 quotes were within $100 or even $300, I'd feel a little better about this. With such a wide disparity in price, I feel as if either someone is a ripoff, trying to take advantage, or that someone is cheap and does shoddy work. I hope neither is the case and it's just the economy. The guy with the higher quote has been busy, in spite of the economy, so he doesn't need the work necessarily.

Re: OT--Paving question

#8

daughter had same experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>daughter had the same experience. In this case the highest quote was from the most established company. I asked a friend that works for Dept of Transportation and he told me that all paving mixes are not created equal. Maybe that fact is the difference. Most of the raw material cost is the asphalt and it is expensive of late.

Re: OT--Paving question

#9

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

>As Gene said, find out about the mix. Airport mix has larger gravel in it, so the finish appears more pitted and open looking than the fine asphalt, which costs substantially more. Also, check to see if the 2.5" they're quoting is the compacted thickness. It sounds a bit thin to me. Keep in mind that if the asphalt is too thin or the roadbed isn't well enough prepared, the road will be more easily damaged and you'll end up paying to have it redone in a few years. I had my driveway paved with 3 1/2" of airport mix a couple years back and it has held up very well -- no dents or ruts from oil delivery trucks, heavy equipment trucks, Fedex trucks, etc.

Another cost factor is the price of oil. There is a direct relationship between oil price and asphalt price. Make sure your bidders are using current, realistic figures. It could be that one ov them is using an asphalt supplier whose costs are higher.

Finally, find out about the edge treatment. That is key to a long-lasting driveway that won't erode at the edges.

Ellis

Re: OT--Paving question

#10

Re: OT--Paving question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Joanne, as with any construction contract....ask for previous customers, go see them if possible, ask questions of them about how the project has faired over time, and if possible, inspect the work.

Also, ask the city, county if the contractor has had any complaints on his work.

Re: OT--Paving question

#11

Re: OT--Thanks, guys

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>I will ask more questions about edges, the mix, and thickness. I will also ask for some references.

Re: OT--Paving question

#12

Get a quote on concrete.

Basil

>Used to cost about 1/3 more for a 6" thick concrete drive but then you'll never have to worry about oil spills, freezing weather or sealing it every few years.

....and this is from a fellow that still has a gravel drive...the cobblers wife goes barefoot.

Re: OT--Paving question

#13

Kind of late but...

Don Orr

>...hopefully helpful. Also ask about what they are going to do underneath the asphalt. Base preparation is important for a solid, long lasting job. I believe they should be digging out old dirt/gravel and putting in something that will drain and another layer that will compact densley that the asphalt will lay onto smoothly and solidly. At least that is what our contractor did with our driveway.

Re: OT--Paving question

#14

Not too late

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Thanks Don. They said they'd grade and compact. They did not say whether they'd add anything to the existing gravel (which is kind of thin at this point). Good question for me to add. I'm calling a 3rd paver to see what he comes up with.