I am not an Electrician, but
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
>I don't think it would meet code, if it were not considered safe enough.
That being said. I would ask the electrician if he were wiring his own new home, would he still do it this way. I would like for him to do it the way he would wire his own home.
I just went out into the shop to check something out. With a hammer and chisel, I surgically removed part of the plastic housing from the back of a receptacle to reveal the works inside.
What this revealed, is that the little piece of brass or whatever metal plate, is stamped and folded in such a way that it, from the supply side has the female thread for the screw, which provides a contact area for ~ 1/2" of wire contact, plus another 1/2" on the screw side with lots of pressure from a tight screw on both sides.
As it bend around on its path to the stab in ports for the male cord prong contacts, it provides a 3/8" contact area which the wire is pushed up against by the little spring loaded gib on the other side, when the stab-in holes are used. With a short piece of wire sticking in there, I would estimate that the spring only provides one pound of pressure or less to compress the spring away from that contact area.
It is not hard to imagine that with heavier wire, the act of folding the wires as you screw the receptacle into the box, could torque the wire enough to only make contact with one end of that 3/8" area, leaving only one small point plus the little gib on the opposite side. That would be like touching the opposite sides of the wire with the edge of two credit cards.
While I would not worry about this causing the house to burn down if the breakers are sized right for the wire. However, That little contact area could cause more resistance under high loads might not be able to deliver the amps or watts needed to meet full capacity of the device plugged into it. I suspect that would be harder on a tool, or maybe heat at those contact point causing the receptacle to fail quicker over time.
I am not an electrician and did not run any test to prove anything stated above. I have been taking care of my own electrical needs for about 40 years, and have tracked down some faulty circuits over that time. I always use the screws whenever I wire something.