Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Posts

Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#1

Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Larry in NW Ohio

>My daughter and SIL are building a new house and they started to put in the outlets. For some reason I remembered a post awhile back about the push in wire type and how dangerous they were, so I took one off the wall and sure enough they had the push in wire locks and they were using them. So I mentioned that to my SIL and how bad they were, that they can come loose and cause a fire. So he got ahold of the electrition and asked him about them. He told us that was true a few years ago but that they have been improved alot since. That since he was working for this electrition that they have not had any problems. So my SIL took his word for it and gave him the go ahead to put them in. My question is of course have these outlets been improved enough that they will not start fires anymore? I know I can trust the people here. Thank You Larry

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#2

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

GalenV in Iowa

>The push in connections can be used with 14 gauge wire and 15 amp circuits only. For 12 gauge 20 amp circuits they must use the screws.

The outlet should have this information right on the body of the outlet.

Galen

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Clint Searl

>Properly installed, they are reliable and safe. Wires installed under loose screws can cause fires.

Clint

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#4

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Rod Peterson * Ormond Beach

>There are two types of receptacles which can accept wire from the back (as opposed to "curled under the side screw")—one is the "back stab", which is what I think you're thinking of. They typically still have the side screws, so either connection is an option. At one point in the '70s (when my house was built) they were even available without screws at all—back stab only.

There are none remaining in my house as a consequence of the remodel. They were all replaced with back clamp receptacles, the second of the two types. At a quick glance they look just like a conventional receptacle with side screws, and there are no holes in the back as on the back stab model. Instead, there is a movable plate between the screw head and the metal panel that the screw goes into. You stick the stripped wire (un curled) into the space behind the plate and tighten the screw.

No bending loops, no too big loops climbing out from under the screw head, every bit as much clamping force as the loop under the screw head (maybe even more). I love 'em. They're a couple of bucks a pop, but for one house, I can't imagine justifying using the 69¢ "contractor's receptacles" for the few dollars it would have saved me. There's just not that many.

Rod

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#5

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Fred Davis

>The problem with sparking and starting fires with using the strip holes in the back of the outlet is no longer a problem since they outlawed Aluminum wire inside the house.

The continual heating and cooling of Aluminum caused it to eventually become loose and start arcing.

In the days when I hired Commercial Electricians for side jobs , they wound the wire on the side , under the screw.

I don't know if that was a commercial code requirement or their method of work, but that grade of Electrician put's your mind at ease about possible problems arising from wiring.

FredD

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#6

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>The problem isn't confined to aluminum. I will guarantee that if you check any receptacle, switch, or panel that has been in use for any number of years you will find screws that could use a little snugging up. That's always the first thing I look for when somone has a problem with lights flickering, and about 80% of the time it solves the problem.

I am a firm believer in "wires under the screws". I have had to fix way to many problems where the problem was caused by pushing wires into the holes instead of under the screws on the side. In my case, better than 99% of the time it was copper wire.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#7

I am not an Electrician, but

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I don't think it would meet code, if it were not considered safe enough.

That being said. I would ask the electrician if he were wiring his own new home, would he still do it this way. I would like for him to do it the way he would wire his own home.

I just went out into the shop to check something out. With a hammer and chisel, I surgically removed part of the plastic housing from the back of a receptacle to reveal the works inside.

What this revealed, is that the little piece of brass or whatever metal plate, is stamped and folded in such a way that it, from the supply side has the female thread for the screw, which provides a contact area for ~ 1/2" of wire contact, plus another 1/2" on the screw side with lots of pressure from a tight screw on both sides.

As it bend around on its path to the stab in ports for the male cord prong contacts, it provides a 3/8" contact area which the wire is pushed up against by the little spring loaded gib on the other side, when the stab-in holes are used. With a short piece of wire sticking in there, I would estimate that the spring only provides one pound of pressure or less to compress the spring away from that contact area.

It is not hard to imagine that with heavier wire, the act of folding the wires as you screw the receptacle into the box, could torque the wire enough to only make contact with one end of that 3/8" area, leaving only one small point plus the little gib on the opposite side. That would be like touching the opposite sides of the wire with the edge of two credit cards.

While I would not worry about this causing the house to burn down if the breakers are sized right for the wire. However, That little contact area could cause more resistance under high loads might not be able to deliver the amps or watts needed to meet full capacity of the device plugged into it. I suspect that would be harder on a tool, or maybe heat at those contact point causing the receptacle to fail quicker over time.

I am not an electrician and did not run any test to prove anything stated above. I have been taking care of my own electrical needs for about 40 years, and have tracked down some faulty circuits over that time. I always use the screws whenever I wire something.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#8

Re: I am not an Electrician, but

Larry in NW Ohio

>Thanks everyone, I also use the screws on my own wiring, and I use the outlets with the clamps. Larry

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#9

Not so

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The problem with the stab-ins is that the spring eventually loses its temper, and the wire becomes loose. Once it starts, I imagine it's a self-feeding cycle, since the loose connection would create heat which would further damage the spring temper.

In my foolish youth, I installed some outlets that way. A couple of years ago, I had occasion to replace one (long story, involving an inexperienced and not very smart young satellite TV installer), and when I opened up the outlet box, the black wire came right out of the outlet as I removed it.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#10

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Tony - Memphis

>My house is 11 years old. All of the outlets use the push in type and we've never had any issues. I have removed a couple of them to put in dimmers and such and the wires were VERY secure.

Tony

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#11

That and...

John in NM

>The problem is also the result of a relatively tiny contact area leading to a high impedance connection. Adds to the heating/cooling of the connection, which works the spring. Pile Al wire on top... what a mess.

Wouldn't use the back stab for any reason personally. Wires under the screws are well worth the minimal effort. Now the back clamps like you see on GFCI outlets are fine by me.

Pigtails are also a minimal effort and well worth it, but not required the last time I had an inspection (2005). If they're adding to box fill to the point of inconvenience, then its time for a bigger box!

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#12

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Jay Lombardo

>Having been an electrician for 40 years I can tell you they have not improved one bit in the last few years. It is still very poor practice to use the "backstab" holes on the very cheap residential outlets. Ask the electrician to please use the screws and pigtails. It is not acceptable to daisy chain the wires using the screws. I personally don't use solid wire, stranded only, so stabbing is not an option (personal preference, not looking to fight, solid wire is perfectly safe). The reason the electrician is doing it that way is speed, time is money, and the way work is now prices have been beaten into the ground. I guarantee you he wouldn't wire his own house that way. Ask him nicely, bring him a coffee and a donut and he will do it, it always works on me!

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#13

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Alex Grigoriev

>What's wrong with daisy-chaining using the screws?

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#14

You're leaning on a weak reed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you use the two screw terminals, you're depending on the current passing through that tiny little bit of brass between the two screws - not much, and it's already scored to allow for easy breaking off.

Plus, it's twice as many screws to loosen.

I've seen some outlets that have two back holes for each screw going into the clamping arrangement; in theory, that should be OK; but I'd still trust a properly applied wire nut more in the long run.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#15

Harder to isolate faults....

John in NM

>a bad connection at one outlet effects all the others down the chain, and unless you know the order they go in back to the panel, it can lead to confusion.

I've never been convinced it had anything to do with the physical properties of the outlet, but either way its widely viewed as a poor practice.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#16

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Jay Lombardo

>Bill has it right, you are asking that little tab between the screws to carry the same current as a #12 20A or #14 15A wire when you essentially wire it in series with all the outlets on that circuit.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#17

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

Larry in NW Ohio

>Jay What is Daisy chain? Thank You Larry

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#18

I'm not buying this argument...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Not trying to start a fight here, but I'm not buying this argument against daisy chaining because of the little brass tab. Jay, I know you were an electrician for 40 years, and while I agree with you on the merits of using pigtails, I can't say I agree with the reason you and Bill referenced.

I too generally use pigtails to connect any device when there's more that one wire entering the box, but not always. To my knowledge, the only place in the CODE requires pigtails is Article 300.13(B) which deals with device removal in multiwire (shared neutral) branch circuits - and for good reason. Doing otherwise could kill you. If there's another instance in the Code, I'd like to know where it is.

Unless you wired the house yourself, you have no way of knowing if a neutral is part of a multiwire (shared neutral) circuit. Opening a neutral connection of a still alive shared neutral could ruin your day - quite literally. So for that reason, I ALWAYS use pigtails on the neutral connections. But I don't always use them on the hot leads.

If you say that relying on the little brass tab on the receptacle is unsafe or unreliable to power the downstream equipment, you've just declared all UL listed duplex receptacles unsafe because they use that same brass tab to power the second receptacle on the yoke. And UL has declared that perfectly safe. In my mind, there is absolutely no difference between passing current through that little tab to the seconnd half of the receptacle and passing it the screw on the second half to be continued downstream - at least from a safety or reliability standpoint.

That being said, I feel the use of pigtails to be a very good wiring practice and I commend you for recommending it. But I don't agree that daisy chaining with the second device screw is inherently unsafe or unreliable because of the little brass tab.

Just my opinion. Have a nice day.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#19

Yup...

John in NM

>The brass tab is about the same size as 12 gauge wire. A weak argument could be made that the crimping for breaking the tab off increases impedance, but I still don't buy it. Running the whole circuit through a series of screw-clamped connections is probably what would increase the failure incidence of daisy chaining, if there is such an increase.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#20

Not Jay, but I'll try

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Imagine the outlets or other fixtures as the daisies - the "chain" is then the wires between daisies. You're running the current through each outlet on its way to the last one, as opposed to creating a continuous wire by splicing (wire nutting) the wires together and powering the outlets with extra wires - pigtails, no named because they're short - from the splices in the box.

Re: Electrcal Outlets (OT)

#21

Re: I'm not buying this argument...

Jay Lombardo

>Tim, actually using the screws as a means of splicing instead of pigtails is much less of a problem than using the backstab method of wiring the outlet. I have never seen a failure or fire from using the tab. I HAVE seen many failures from sticking wires in the back, heat buildups and melted insulation several inches up the wire. The pigtails have become an issue with inspectors who require them(with or without any code to back them up). They interpret the code to mean they want pigtails on all receptacles and switches. Since I consider it the preferred method there is no reason for me to argue with them. Even though those 39 cent receptacles have UL listing they are still junk and not a wise place to save money in your own house. Since this was a new installation and I assume subject to inspection the advice was to convey the way I would do my own house, and not have any issues with the inspector. Your caution about the neutral is exactly right and in my opinion it is not that much more trouble and better practice to treat the hot the same.

My .02

Jay