Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

Posts

Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#1

Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Below is the link to my latest epic* about my Automatic Dust Collection System

* I got a little carried away- it is a bit long at over 13 minutes! If you get bored and just want to see my Automatic Blast Gates in action go to the 8 min. mark.

For you video types, at 60 MB, it took around 45 minutes to render and 30 minutes to upload! It plays fine.

This has been fun and a real learning experience, but I'm ready to get back to woodworking!!


Automatic Dust Collection Video

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#2

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection

Grant Wilkinson

>It's a great video and a remarkable system. I want to go down to my basement shop and trash mine now. :-)

Thanks for posting this.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#3

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection

Chuck in ND

>Where is the DC filter ?

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#4

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>For his next project he is building a robot woodworker so he can sit and read the paper while his projects are getting done. ;-)

T.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#5

Re: Constructive critisizm if you don't mind

Chuck in ND

>I hate to be the one to tell you this, but I think you have missed the reason of haveing a cyclone DC. Cyclones are designed to suck the debris into the unit without haveing to go through the impeller, Shaveings going through the impeller can build up on the fins intime, especially wet treated lumber, or a spark from a foriegn object can be created by hitting the impeller. Also, the way you have it setup with no filter your holding air back, you want it to breath, not restrict it. I will say though that the cyclone and the blast gates look good. I just think you'd get ALOT more airflow and be happier if you set it up more like a traditional cyclone.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#6

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection

Larry in NW Ohio

>Alan I read your post with extream interest, because this is the way I set mine up about 5-6 years ago when I put in my cyclon. I bought all my things from Ebay and only have about $100 in all the cylinders and the solenoids and assoseries. Mine are set to open when the machine turns on. I`d be interested in the way yours detects the machine starts up. What kind of coil do you use? Is there a specific size and all you do is run the hot line from the machine thru it. Also the gates are make of what kind of material so it slides easy? Thank You and a very impresive setup. Larry

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#7

And while we are being critical.....

Barry Irby

>I would suggest you put your bag inside a trash can. If you get a rip in it, you won't like the results. DAMHIKT

This has got to be the most sophisticated DC system in Little Washington, NC. Actually, even in big Washington. All kidding aside, very impressive.

Another note. Your pipes in the garage through the ceiling may be a building code violation. The garage has drywall to protect from fire spreading to the rest of the structure. S & D PVC may not measure up for this.

I agree about the impeller being before the cyclone. I don't have a cyclone and have to clean long stringy crap out of mine occasionally. What was your logic in putting the cyclone after the impeller?

Does Norm know you have his shirt?

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#8

Sensor Question

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Very nice system, Alan. I too have my system working on a current sensor, but use a single coil for everything. I have thought about doing something like yours and I like your solution.

What are you using for a current sense module? How are the current sensors connected to the rest of the system? Do you have individual sensor modules connected to each current sensor?

Robby W.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#9

Re: And while we are being critical.....

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Chuck,

"Where is the DC filter ? "

The video had to be edited so I removed the part about the filters. Two large Farr cartridge filters are mounted in parallel above the cyclone in a plenum that is connected to the cyclone outlet and vented to the shop- filtered air is returned to the shop. While the winters are mild here, the summers are hot and humid and I didn't want to suck hot humid take-up air into my shop through the cracks by discharging the cyclone to the outside.


In reality, the purpose of a cyclone is to separate chips, dust and fines from the air before they reach and clog the final filters- which my system does quite well.

Remember, in all traditional dust collection systems the dust and debris laden air hits the impeller first. There is no danger of damaging the 14" very-heavy-duty steel impeller. The high air velocity of this system results in low concentrations of dust, even when using my 20" planer to hog off a lot of wood or when using my dual drum sander, so there is zero chance of ignition due to a spark that might be generated by a errant screw hitting the impeller. I have used this push-through configuration for nearly 10 years, first with my Wood Mag-based cyclone, then with this one I built five years ago- never an ignition even when sucking up piles of dust and metal chips- just not going to happen.

I never use wet wood, typically pressure treated, which is not good for woodworking machines. I build cabinets, furniture, etc. which require dry wood. It wouldn't make a difference to the impeller, if I did cut wet wood, however. When I recently unmounted the motor for the first time in five years, to replace the bearings I inspected the impeller- it was clean, bare metal with no pitch or any other buildup.

As to performance, my 3D, push-through design works great and I'll put it up against any 3 hp Oneida, Grizzly, or ClearVue!

Barry,

With two final filters there is little or no pressure on the chip bag. I do a test after I install a new bag and check for leaks. But . . . to make it easier to drag the bag out into the garage, I usually set it in an open trash barrel. As too whether my ducting meets code- Shhhhhh!

The reasons for the push-through configuration- (1) some studies show it is better at separating fines, and (2) I can use a simple plastic trash bag to conveniently collect the dust instead of a sealed dust drum which can be a messy pain to empty.

FYI, another feature of my DC also not mentioned in the video- My shop is on the second floor and my DC is below in a closet off the garage, so I can't see if my dust bag is full. I built an automatic high dust alarm that shuts down the DC when the dust bag is full. It has worked flawless since I installed it nearly 3 years ago. I'm sure it has saved me countless clogged filters that I had previously and that often plague others with cyclones and cartridge filters.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#10

Sensor Answers

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I mounted an extra electrical box next to each machine's "sensed" outlet box. The extra box holds a "self-powered" current sensing switch (see pics) that incorporates a torroid coil and an NPN transistor. One of the 220V hot leads (or a single hot lead for a 110V outlet) from the "sensed" outlet is routed to the extra box and through the sensor's toroid coil before it returns to the "sensed" outlet box receptacle. Each machine has its own "sensed" outlet. The current sensor switch at each outlet senses when current is flowing (machine is on), the internal solid state switch closes and allows 24V to flow to the solenoid air valve which ports shop air regulated down to 18 psi to the cylinder which opens the associated blast gate (when power is off and the solenoid air valve at rest shop air keeps the blast gate closed.) A 5/2 solenoid air valve is required for this operation. Even using only 18 psi, I found the gates moved too quickly and violently. Luckily the auction solenoids came with flow restrictors which I eventually installed.

The rating of the current sensing switches is very low, only 120mA @ 30V, but sufficient to control the 24V, 65 mA solenoids directly, without a secondary relay or other circuitry- electrically it is very simple and all low voltage! These current sensors are available from DigKey, etc. but cost > $30 retail. I paid a fraction of that on an auction site.


Here is one of my sensor boxes. The orange Romex contains the lead going to and from the "sensed outlet". The small black and orange wire are the switch leads which are polarized so must be wired correctly:


I lined the inside surfaces of the MDF gates with high pressure laminate. I made the slides from two pieces of laminate glued back to back- they move slicker than snot and seal very well, also.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#11

Re: And while we are being critical.....

Barry Irby

>Thanks for the answers.

I was just telling my son about your system. My take is that if your garage catches fire, the DC pipes won't matter much, you're in a world of trouble anyway.

My DC is outside my shop also and I have had an over full bag once or twice. Can you tell us about your "Bag Full" sensor?

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#12

Re: Constructive critisizm if you don't mind

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>"I just think you'd get ALOT more airflow and be happier if you set it up more like a traditional cyclone."

Chuck,

I have an article written by Jim Halbert (he posted lots of info about dust collection on the former Badger Pond site). He said that Taiwanese blowers would have higher CFMs when in push through mode because "the Taiwan DC�s we buy are designed to exhaust into a dust bag, not pull through a cyclone." That's the short version.

I would post the article here, but I don't know how to contact Jim to get his permission, although I'm sure he wouldn't care. The info may be in the Badger Pond Archive cd, but I'm having problems trying to search the cd.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#13

Re: Constructive critisizm if you don't mind

Chuck in ND

>Paul, I guess thats fine, but if he's going to set it up as a push system, whats the bennefit of useing a cyclone in that system ? I see none.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#14

Links to my Auto DC and Gate threads

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Sure. Here is a link to various DC threads on NC Woodworker (you should be able to view as a guest)

High Dust Alarm

The Correct Sensor for Your High Dust Alarm

High Dust Alarm Circuit and Suggested Dust Bin Mod

Portable High Dust Alarm

New, Advanced High Dust Alarm for the Retail Market

More behind the walls auto DC stuff

Controlling a DC- my schematic for my multi-station 3-wire control is on page 2

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#15

Re: Constructive critisizm if you don't mind

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>How do you get rid of the dust without a cyclone or other separator then?

Push through, Pull through- the air goes through the cyclone EXACTLY the same. Dust drops out the bottom and almost dust free air (in a well designed cyclone 98%-100% dust free) proceeds to the cartridge filter(s).

There is absolutely no change in operation of the cyclone or handling of air and dust- just a different blower location in the system.

Again, the big benefit is that the cyclone is under slight positive pressure instead of slight negative pressure, which allows me to use a plastic trash bag to collect the dust instead of needing a rigid, non-collapsing dust bin whose large circumference lid must be tightly sealed.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#16

blower performance

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Paul, I corresponded regularly with Jim in the early days of home cyclones, then with Bill P. I don't recall that discussion, but it is possible that impeller geometry comes into play when dealing with inlet vs outlet resistance. I can't say for sure. I doubt there is much measurable difference between similar reverse curve radial blowers, but there may be a difference between those and caged airfoil impellers.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#17

Benefit is the same as using a cyclone anywhere...

John in NM

>Seperation of heavier parts of the stream. In this case it reduces filter loading. Cyclones are used, among other places, in reverse circulation drilling for mineral exploration. In this case there is no impeller, just a high volume pressurized stream of air and rock chips/dust coming up from the drill hole (drilling can be done with water in place of air, in which case a cyclone is not used). The advantage of not clogging the impeller with long shavings is just coincidental, not required. I'll add a pic of a drill rig, because I like drill rigs :)


img

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#18

Re: Sensor Answers

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Alan - Thanks for the switch picture. I couldn't see the little epoxy block on the bottom of the sensor in your picture of the electrical box. Nice solution. It is similar to the way I am doing my whole shop, but the smaller, cheaper sensor give you more flexibility. Now you got my brain wheels turning....

Robby W.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#19

Re: Benefit is the same as using a cyclone anywher

Chuck in ND

>Well I just figured that if Onieda, JDS, ClearVue, Penn State, Woodtek, Delta, etc. all design theirs on a pull theory, they must be right. I'm sure they have done extensive testing and went with whats the most effective for wood, unless you know of some cyclone manufactures conspiracy that I'm not aware of. But whatever, if Alan is happy with what he has I guess thats all that matters. I just thought I'd bring to his attention what I know, I didn't know what he knew. It all definately gave me something to think about.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#20

Re: Benefit is the same as using a cyclone anywher

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I'll just finish with- take a look at commercial installations- if you look, many factories have cyclones mounted to their buildings- many are push through, some are combo push and pull with multiple blowers and booster blowers. Many manufacturers of smaller cyclones build them in the pull-through configuration, because they can stack the motor on the cyclone for a smaller footprint and can get away with using lighter steel, aluminum, or even plastic impellers. If you dig deep enough at Bill Pentz's (designer of the ClearVue) web site he states somewhere, exactly what I have said, that a push through works just as well and is quite possibly better, especially at separating fines. In any case, it is no worse than a pull through and adds the convenience of using a plastic trash bag instead of a dust bin.

FYI, here is a photo of my old Wood Mag cyclone that I modified with spiral inlet ramp (before Bill P. had added that to his design spreadsheet) and also configured as a push-through. It worked well also.

(the plastic dust bag and outlet piping have not been installed.)


img

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#21

Just be careful

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>If you use the small current sensing switches like I did, pay close attention how you connect them and also to the voltage and current limitations of current switch and the demands of the device you want to activate. If it draws too much you will need to use a relay between the sensor switch and your activated device.

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wonder...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...if the push-through design allows the larger chips to constantly clean the impeller, versus the pull-through setup where the impeller only sees the very finest of particles, which are more likely to stick to the vanes.

Jason

Re: Fully Automatic Dust Collection *LINK*

#23

Re: Just be careful

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Yep. I have a relay rated for 2 HP that is powered by the sensor, so that is good to go.

Robby W.