Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Wall Switch for Compressor

Posts

Wall Switch for Compressor

#1

Wall Switch for Compressor

Mark Brennan

>I have a 3hp 60gal, 220v compressor. I would like to hook this to a wall switch that would allow me to cut the power prior to leaving the shop.

What type of switch would I need? Will a single-pole 120/277 30A switch work, safely?

Thanks for your help.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#2

No

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Your are proposing to switch a 220 line that is breakered at 25-30 amps. The switch should, therefore be double pole/single throw. In fact, were it me, I'd use a rated disconnect box rather than a switch. Does your air system leak such that you feel the need to cut power? My compressor (60gal/3hp) is on all the time except when I go away. Then I just flip the breaker.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#3

Re: No

Mark Brennan

>I recently have a hose burst that caused the compressor to run continuously. Not sure how long.

I have the compressor located in a closet, so I thought a switch would be more cost effective.

Have been looking at a 2 pole/single throw 30A switch from Grainger, but says it is rated for 2hp. Was not sure if it would still work.

Thanks

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#4

Rated

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Only 2 hp, won't do.

You can get a full disconnect safety switch or even an A/C disconnect box from Grainger or the big box jernts. Cost you between $15 and $50. Remember too, that you have a switch on your pressure-trol (that gray box mounted on the tank). Just flip the lever and your pump's off.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#5

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor *LINK*

GalenV in Iowa

>If you cannot use a manual lever on your pressure switch or shut off the breaker supplying power than you could add the 2150 KO5 switch shown on page 6 as a local disconnect.


Square D

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#6

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

McKay

>I have an electrician coming in tomorrow to put a switch in. I never remember to go across the shop and throw the switch. He will put in something that is to code. I will not know 'till tomorrow evening when I get home from the school shop what he will use. I can write tomorrow if you wish.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#7

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

Pete in Holland, MI

>I once wired an ice-cube relay into the shop compressor where I used to work. A 110v lead from the same circut the lights were on closed the little relay, which allowed voltage from the pressure switch to continue on to the motor starter. Still had the original switch to manually turn the motor on & off.

Lights on? Compressor enabled. Lights off? Compressor stays off.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#8

It'll work but there's more

Forrest Addy

>You can use a plain vanilla wall switch to start stop a compressor if you are willing to assume risk and code violations but there are serious practical snags.

The usual residential wall switch is rated for 15 Amps or so which is plain not beefy enough for a 3 HP motor. Wall switches are all single pole so you can only break one side of the 230 you propose to switch. NEC and ALL local electrical codes require that you break all energized conductors to a load simultaneously. For 230 Volt single phase that means a two pole switching device.

Addressing the 15 Amp issue your motor may be rated for 15 Amps @ 230 volts but the starting in-rush may be as high as 60 Amps for a tenth of a second or so. It's that in-rush that's the contact killer. Also when you open contacts serving an inductive load a momentary high voltage develops that you never experience when breaking a resistive load like a heater or a string of incandescent lights. This high voltage arc, though momentary, is also a contact killer.

For that reason motor controlling contacts are often several sizes beefier and the arc path may have blow-out magnets, double break contacts, chutes, or other arc mitigating features. In small motors like 3 HP you can use manual starters, motor rated switches, a molded case motor rated breakers, drum switches, and combination starters all of which are rated for motor contol by UL and other certifying bodies.

Getting back to the question, you can use a wall switch to control a compressor but use it as a pilot device: to control a motor rated contactor (essentially a relay with beefy contacts.) In a pinch you can use a specific purpose relay having contacts rated for 50 Amps or so. I suggest you find a recent copy of the WW Granger catalog. In it they have excellent tutorials on compressors and motor control and how to spec the components you need.

What are you using for motor over-current protection? That's a big issue too. A properly sized molded case breaker, overload relay etc will save your motor should it become overloaded, forced to function to ratings in a hot environment, or any of several other motor eating scenarios.

While WW Granger will give you info you can take to the bank naturally it's slanted to sell you WW Granger stuff. If you are a talented scrounger, chances are you can find what you need in the electrical junk HVAC shops inevitably collect in their take-out pile. Once you identify your needs you can go shopping.

I really doubt it but if your compressor has a starter on it, you can break the lead to the starter coil and put your wall switch (pilot device) in series with it. Most consumer grade packaged compressors require external switching and that's where you came in.

Don't forget the motor over-current protection. A residential grade circuit breaker isn't adequate. If you are lucky the makers of your residental electrical panel may offer a motor rated breaker that plugs right into the old slot. Prepare to spend 3X the price of a plain breaker.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#9

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

Mark Brennan

>Yes, I would be interested in how your electrican handles this situation.

Thanks

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#10

Re: I would use

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I would use a single phase Magnetic starter switch that is rated for three HP, like the the one on your 3 HP cabinet saw.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#11

Cheap Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If it's already not so equipped, install a 1/2" brass ball valve on your tank outlet, then just close it when you leave the shop. Unless your unit is leaking air (a far more serious problem that needs to be fixed) that precludes your unit running while you're gone, regardless of the shape of your air hoses.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#12

Re: Cheap Alternative

Larry in NW Ohio

>My solution to this is to turn the main off. I have a basement shop and have two mains at the steps, one is for the things that need to stay on, such as the sump pump, dehumidifier and such. The other box is strickly for the shop. When I go out for the day I just switch off the main power for the shop, and that has the compressor on it and it also has a solenoid air valve on it also, so when the main goes off it automatically shuts off the air right at the tank. Works for me. Larry

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#13

Re: Cheap Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Larry,

Any electrician worth his sparks I think will tell you that breakers and box mains are not to be used as "switches" as you describe. Their internal parts are not designed to take the repeated motion and arcing that a real switch does. If you really want to shut down the shop that way, you should install a safety disconnect with a double throw lever.

But don't my word for it. Ask a "license."

mm

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#14

Re: Cheap Alternative

Larry in NW Ohio

>Mark We use to do that at the place I worked and we use the switchs to shut the plant down at the end of the day. We did that for 30 some years and believe it or not we changed very few switchs in that time. So I figure in the time of going in and out of my shop I don`t think I`ll need to change the switch more than twice, so the cost difference is very little, unless there is another. Thanks Mark. Larry

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#15

Re: Cheap Alternative

Howard Norman

>In the industrial world where I spent almost 40 years the circuit breakers were always used as switches for the major light circuits. I have used circuit breakers as switches in my own shop for such things as compressors for 20+ years without ever wearing out a breaker. The fear of using a breaker as a switch is greatly overrated even by many electricians. Just because someone is a "licensed electrician" doesn't make them an expert on the use of breakers.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#16

Also my experience

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I worked at a shop for 12 years where the only way to turn off the lights at night was using the breakers. During the 12 years I was there we never had to replace a breaker and I know some of them were at least 30 years old and hand been cycled 5-6 days a week every week of the year.

Lee

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#17

Okay, Folks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I raised the issue based on what I've always been told in the residential setting. So long as y'all make the informed choice, I'll stand down.

Not my shop, not my house. |;-}

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#18

Re: Cheap Alternative

Chris Friesen

>Technically you're not supposed to use regular breakers to switch off circuits that are under load. The problem is that the contacts tend to arc.

If there's no load on the circuit, there's little problem with flipping the breaker off.

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#19

Switch is in and works great

McKay

>Now that I think about it, the idea is very simple. The electrician used a relay switch on the 220. The relay is controlled by a simple 110 switch. You can hear the relay make contact when the switch is turned to "on". I had forgotten that I use the same principle on a nine router station that I have set up at the school where I teach. At the school, I wanted the DC to turn on whenever either of the nine routers was turned on. It works beautifully. Has done for many years. My neighbor now loves me because when I walk out at night I don't forget to turn off the compressor.

Best of luck.


img

Re: Wall Switch for Compressor

#20

Re: Switch is in

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That's how I have my DC wired, with 110 3-way switches, so that I can turn it on/off from either the basement shop or the garage where the lathe lives.

Good choice!