Making a "Green" table?
Bri in Mtl
>I have someone who wants a dining table made "Green".
Green--meaning no toxic substances (glues, varnishes, etc)
Thoughts?
Frankly I'm not sure where to go with this.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Making a "Green" table?
Bri in Mtl
>I have someone who wants a dining table made "Green".
Green--meaning no toxic substances (glues, varnishes, etc)
Thoughts?
Frankly I'm not sure where to go with this.
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Don Orr
>Couple gut reaction thoughts.
Pegged mortise & tennon, even to edge join boards for the table top. Or some other mechanical joinery.
Beeswax for a finish.
Interesting concept.
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Jesper, Denmark
>I suppose that hide glue is "green", so is linseed oil and beeswax for a finish. Shellac could also be called Green, but then the lady of the house should be very firm with coasters under the whisky glasses.
Screws and wooden cleats must be OK to fasten the top to the frame.
So the question now remains: Will he be picking it up in a green Hummer?
Glue's easy at least...
John in NM
>Hide glue, unless they want a vegan table. Most finishes are non-toxic once cured, but you could use some Tried and True linseed oil or Sutherland Wells tung oil if they wanted non-drier/solvent finish (I think Sutherland Wells makes one like that). Woodcraft sells a raw tung oil, but I don't think you'd get enough of a film for a dining table.
That's easy
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Well, that is easy. Build it any way you are accustomed to for there is no evidence that anything we normally use presents any hazard in the use of a dining room table.
What creates these misguided souls?
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Howard Acheson
>I don't know what "green" means. Does it mean that the table shall be non-toxic when it is finished or does it mean the no items should be used that are toxic when applied?
As has been said, all adhesives and finishes are considered non-toxic when cured.
Hot hide glue is a totally natural adhesive.
Shellac can be a problem as the alcohol solvent is deliberately made toxic to prevent it being drunk. So it's toxic in the can but the alcohol and the toxic component completely evaporate.
Raw linseed oil or pure tung oil are options and are totally non-toxic and natural. However, if you drink them they act as laxatives. They are also very poor finishes in that they have little or no protective qualities and durability.
Carnuba and beeswax are natural products in their initial state. Carnuba comes from a tree and beeswax comes from bees. However, both are dissolved in solvents (turpentine, mineral spirits) in order to be able to spread them. Of course, turpentine is a natural product but it is highly toxic. So, how does that fit in?
As you can see, the whole issue is somewhat confusing. It reminds me of the definition of "free range" when applied to chickens. The government requirement to label a chicken "free range" is that the coop must have a door or method of egress for the chicken to get outside. Whether the bird goes outside or not is not relevant. Most don't, as their food is inside.
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Doug Ridley
>They sell green paint at the big box stores
In the words of Paracelsus..
JL
>"All things are poison and nothing is without poison, only the dose permits something not to be poisonous."
If they mean "natural" as opposed to "chemical" - most products sold on the market today require some sort of chemical processing - including all glues and finishes. You could always used a beeswax finish I suppose, but it wouldn't be very good.
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Trish B.
>I would say if they really want a "green" table, they should be concerned about the wood selection, rather than the tiny amount of glue and finish offgassing. Do they want increasingly more precious mahogany, farmed from questionable sources and shipped to the US by freighter and semi? Or how about the more sustainable lyptus, harvested in a more eco-friendly way, but still freighted and crated thousands of miles? Or is it locally milled walnut or cherry, air-dried for 5 years and transported to your shop in an afternoon? It sounds like you already have a can of worms open, but I would bring this up with your clients and see how "green" they really want to be. (Though all of the above are great suggestions and should satisfy their current wishes.)
yep - local wood would make more difference
Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY
>to the environment than what's in most of the finishes you might consider.
Dining tables are especially tricky given the use the surface will have. I really like the Tried & True on a door and glass-top desk I made, but neither of those gets the kind of abuse a dining table does.
You might also find out if they're concerned about chemical sensitivities. I don't love formaldehyde, but that seems to drive people pretty far into "as absolutely natural as possible."
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryRU4sWQOIA
>From what I've read lyptus is grown on plantations that at one time were cleared from the forest so in some ways it is not so green.
To the original poster what you have is a client that wants something specific, no difference from another client that might have a particular color in mind for a piece. What you need to do is to have a discussion with them about their expectations and what it means to build a green piece. You might have to do some research on how non toxic glues are (origanal titebond is considered non toxic) and were to source either locally harvested wood or FSC certified material. Other questions to ask are about finishes do they want and all "natural" product like Livos brand products or will they be happy with waterbased finishes. Their are a lot of options have the client do some research so they are educated.
I use Fsc certified wood when availble, I've found that it is not always more expensive and sometimes is a much better value since the quality can be much higher.
Tom
Re: That's easy
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Bill,
To be honest, that was my initial reaction. Seems like an awful lot of fuss. However, we both have had fussiness to deal with in our lives. My tactic would be to state that cure=green=health. At least a good sealed finish is long lasting, and prevents little mold critters from permeating partially open wood cells. By the time I finished discussing cumulative "microbial loads", they'd really want the table built conventionally. Then I'd suggest painting it green. :<)
George
A different take.....
Barry Irby
>Everyone has discussed finishes and glue and plantation grown wood.
It seems to me you should suggest Green wood. Not uncured wood/freshly cut, but wood that is the other type of green.
I have some walnut that could be considered green. It is from a tree that flee over in the forest and would have rotted had I not rescued it, giving it an opportunity to serve on as dining room tables. It was 30" on the stump and 43 feet to the first limb. Lots of dining room tables. Air dried. No fuel to cure it. A true windfall. Not a lot of fuel in transport either. Right now it is in a bard about a 1000 yards form the stump. It did go about five miles up the road with some of its cousins to be sawed into it's present state.
How about a tree cleared from the right of way or that fell in a storm. Urban loggers salvage them all the time. I suspect some of them go broke trying to rescue the trees, but your client could support such a noble cause.
Then there is the wood rescued from the bottoms of rivers and lakes.
Or the stuff salvaged from old buildings. How green can you get?
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Jim Dillon
>Very interesting question and what great suggestions. I would try to get more information from your client regarding what they mean by "green". Have they (or perhaps their children, or elderly parents) had problems in the past with certain products, or have read something that concerns them, like formaldehyde outgassing in plywood products and so forth. Based on that, I would try to take the initiative and "guide" them with various options regarding sustainable wood selection (the most important IMHO), finish choices, glue options, joinery techniques, hand vs power tool use, along with the pros and cons of each - as well as price differences in terms of time and labor. After that discussion, they may have a better idea what they really want, and the direction they want you to go - and still stay within their budget. Sounds like an interesting niche market that might be worth exploring, if you are interesting in going in that direction. Just some rambling thoughts. Let us know how this develops for you.
Jim
Re: Making a "Green" table?
Moses Yoder
>One of the most obvious benefits of having a table made well is not having to replace it in the user's lifetime. That is a benefit I would push. I would also probably use hide glue and then a water based finish or shellac. The idea of using salvaged lumber also would need to be used to advantage. What type of green initiatives are you taking in your shop? Such as heating and electricity using wood waste and wind power. I don't think the green thing is just a fad; I think it will be the big thing over the next century.
good point
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>
Green is all I do
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>I only make green furniture and have been doing so even before the term became main stream. I was a recent exhibiter at the San Francisco ACC show and for the past 2 years they have been promoting "green craft" the probelm is that they don't have any gidelines for what green craft actually means so during the three day show I would get people asking me what the green craft sign meant. I didn't mind as it was a conversation starter. So I will tell you what I tell everyone else. for me green means all the wood I use is recycled or salvaged, mostly milled from street trees. I use non toxic glue and natural or low envirenmental impact finishes, but green means something different to each craftsman so if it is important to you than you need to ask what it means to those you do business with.
I use hot hide glue. the glue choice is not for non toxic reasons but for a different side of sustainability. I want my furniture to be around for 5 generations. this means that at some point it will most likely need to be repaired. Since hide glue is the only 100% reversable glue it will make future repairs easier. It also has some other properties that make it very appropriate for some of my work.
Green finishes are much more complicated. most natural oil finishes have a moderate VOC content but if it is a plant oil with a plant based solvent(turp) it would be a zero net gain since the finish can't give off more carbon than the plant took in. the complcating factor is where the finish is produced and how and where it is shipped. as a general rule a product produced in china and shipped by boat to the west coast of the US will have a lower imbedded carbon content than a product produced on the west coast and shipped by truck to the east coast. due to a ship being a more efficent form a transportation. While there is a growing tung nut crop grown in misouri the bulk of the worlds tung oil comes from china and most of the flax grown for linseed oil is grown in Argentina. toss shellac from India and figuring out which is greener becomes a logistical nightmare. and we havent even discussed the actual guality of the diffeent finshes.
It is very dificult to guage the greeness of waterbased poly finishes some have petrochimical componets and some have phenol componendt that my be natural or synthetic and finding out how much embeded carbon content of all the ingredients plus shipping the finish to my shop is a tall order at best.
I have settled on Jasco brand tung oil finish and General brand HP Poly. I use each for different reasons and primary is performance and ease of application, but I consider the oil to be natureal and the hp poly to have low envirenmental impact and in keeping with my philosophy of green.
For me it is more than a marketing stratagy and I encourage others to look into localy harvested or slavaed woods but just like any other client, if they want somethiong you don't feel cmfortable in providing cut em loose.
The "greenist" wood choice is not next door
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I applaud your careful analysis of the complex finish situation. The wood analysis is similarly complex.
If everyone decided to choose wood as you have done then our Appalachian forests would be nearly worthless for timber value. Because these forests are mostly privately owned their fate is in the hands of their local owners. "You" will determine their fate by your wood purchasing choices .
In the last century a lot of the area where I live was cleared and pastured. As the value of the timber became greater, the steep, errodable pasture land was allowed to revert to forest. The bottom half of the hillside in the picture was pasture in 1950. (picture is hazy as it is raining this AM) It now has a nice stand of young oak and poplar that can be harvested in a few years.
Drive the price of mahogany up enough and people will plant mahogany trees instead of soybeans. Make trees worthless and they will be removed to make way for something more valuable.
There is a second factor making woodland more valuable-hunters. Hunters will pay about as much for land to hunt on as the timber is worth. By in large hunters are good land stewards. There are more deer and turkey in TN than any time in history in spite of the fact some get shot each year. So the PITA case is not as simple as some would want to believe either.
What does Green mean anyway????
Barry Irby
>I really want to know.
Its like the joke "We could make a ham sandwich, if we had some ham....if we had some bread."
If you were building a house, you could gather the stones out of your fields (if you had fields with stones in them) and use them to build the foundation. If you did not use fuel to do this, they could be very Green. And it could improve your fields, if the stones were not serving a purpose in the field such as resisting erosion. But, a stone foundation built of stones harvested elsewhere and shipped in with the use of a lot of fuel might be very Green.
A stone table top would be similar. If the top were produced and shipped with little or no fuel use, it could be Green. Most of the stone countertops I see are not green at all. Too much fuel in the shipping and energy in the cutting and polishing.
Using wood would be a form of carbon sequestration. Robin mentions the release of the carbon from plant based finishes as being a Zero impact, because its the same carbon the plant sequestered briefly. Using wood in extremely long lived projects sequesters the carbon for a long time. I have 135 acres of pine trees. I am waiting for someone to pay me to sequester the carbon and not cut the trees.
that depends where you live *LINK*
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>You make some good points Bill and on a larger scale that is one of the reasons I use the wood I do. for example much of the teak used in inexpensive imported furniture is clear cut from mountainsides in Burma, mountians with poor soil before the trees holding things together were cut. I have no doubt that there a responsably anaged forest or plantation somewhare in the world where teak is being harvested. then the only problem is one of economic pressures from the developed world to exploit the resources of a less developed country, one that may need to pay back World Blank loans.
I should have explained more about the wood I use. I use what is sometimes refered to as 'urban salvage" it is a broad term but includes trees from peoples urban yards, trees growing in parking strips and those in public spaces that need to come out or have blow down. Another source of wood for me is old walnut orchards that are removed. in most cases the wood I use would be cut into fire wood, chipped for mulch or just buried in a landfill. I use a chansaw mill with bio degradable oils to mill the wood into lumber. For many woods it is not really to my economic advantage to do this. but for me it is sometimes about more than making the most money I can at all times. I have discovered that there is a growing noumber of urban sawyers who are getting their trees from the same sources and sell the wood. It is this source that I urge others to seek out. I never encourage anyone to cut down any tree. There is no shortage of urban trees being removed or falling over, of cource not all these will make furniture grade lumber and even those that do will have a very high percentage of scrap. And yes I have hit my share of nails but with a 111cc saw pulling .404 chain with 124 cutters it is really not much of a problem.
Green to most people means sustainable. that is a simple word that has a whole depth of meaning when applied to furniture. Is the forest where the wood is harvested from sustainably managed? Are the loggers and mill workers, truckers and lumber yard workes paid a sustainable wage? is the furniture made to a standard that it withstands a lifetime of use? so even a simple word will have diffeent meaning to each person. FSC is a great first step in educating the public about sustainable wood. I hope that what I do will broaden that idea for those I come in contact with.
Feel free to check out pics of my work on my web page, all made from salvaged or recycled wood. I also have a page with pics of all the different woods I have worked with and a bit of info about each wood.
Robin
My Web Page
Re: Green is all I do
Howard Acheson
>>> I have settled on Jasco brand tung oil finish
That product is a thinned oil based varnish and contains no real tung oil at all.
You may want to read the following to understand the marketing misrepresentation that occurs in labeling of finishes.
There are two "true" oils used in finishing. One is linseed oil which comes from flax seeds. The second is tung oil Which comes from a nut tree that originally grew in China. Both are called drying oils although neither really fully dries and becomes hard. The primary use of both is in manufacturing oil based finishes.
A product that is a true tung oil will have a label that says either "pure" or "100%". If it doesn't say that on the label, IT ISN'T TRUE TUNG OIL. Forget about all the other baloney and look for one of those two words if you want to use a true tung oil. If the label contains any other chemicals you are not getting a true tung oil. Real tung oil has acquired a cachet in the past twenty years that seems to elevate it to some type of magic potion. In fact, as a finish, it does not offer anything much different than linseed oil. In spite of the hype, is not significantly more water resistant than linseed oil--both are lousy--nor is it any more durable. Used alone both are fairly inferior "finishes". About the only difference is that tung oil is slightly less amber than linseed oil but it also is slightly less effective at "popping" the grain. By most measures, it is not significantly different from linseed oil.
"Tung Oil Finish" is a marketing expression for products that the manufacturer thinks will give you a finish like the finish you get from a true tung oil. These "Tung Oil Finishes" may or may not contain some true tung oil, but most do not contain any true tung oil. Their only claim to the use of the word "tung" is that they claim to give the appearance of finish that results from true tung oil. You're buying a "faux tung oil finish". Similarly, "Danish Oil" is a marketing expression for an finish that gives the appearance of the Scandinavian furniture of the 1950'a and 60's.
There are two types of "tung oil finishes". One is mixture of varnish, boiled linseed oil and mineral spirits (called an oil/varnish mixture). The exact mixtures are proprietary (more oil means a softer finish. More varnish means more protection and durability). Some manufacturers add a dollop of drier to speed up the drying. If you want make your own, mix equal parts of boiled linseed oil, varnish and mineral spirits which will make a nice finish. This same mixture is frequently also called "Danish Oil". It closely mimics a true oil finish but the addition of the varnish resins gives it more durability and protection. These finishes are designed to be a complete finishing system. They are not intended to be overcoated with a film finish. When you do so, you are destroying the look and feel of the finish. For the most part, "Tung Oil Finish" and "Danish Oil" are identical. They are both oil/varnish mixtures.
Here are some oil/varnish mixtures:(*)
Deft Danish Oil
General Finishes' Seal a Cell
Behlen Danish Oil
Maloof Finish (contains pure tung oil and linseed oil)
Behr Scandinavian Tung Oil Finish
Minwax Tung Oil Finish
Minwax Antique Oil Finish
Velvit Oil
Watco Danish Oil
Liberon Finishing Oil ((contains pure tung oil and linseed oil)
McCloskey Tung Oil Finish (contains pure tung oil, no linseed oil)
The second "tung oil finish" is a thinned varnish made from varnish and mineral spirits. The approximate ratio is 1:1. This is really just a thinned varnish just like the stuff sold as "wiping varnish". When one two or three coats are applied, it also mimics the finish produced by a true oil but it is harder than the oil/varnish above because it does not have as much oil. It is slightly more protective than the oil/varnish type or tung oil finish. For all intents and purposes it is a varnish finish.
Here are some thinned varnishes:(*)
Minway Wiping Varnish
Watco Wiping Varnish
Formby's Tung Oil Finish
Zar Wipe-on Tung Oil
Val-Oil
Hope's Tung Oil Varnish
Gillespie Tung Oil
Waterlox Original Sealer/Finish
General Finishes' Arm R Seal
Jasco Tung Oil
Here is one that is a polymerized linseed oil.(*)
Tried&True Danish Oil.
(*) Courtesy Bob Flexner and some personal information.
One way to tell whether the product is an oil/varnish or a wiping varnish is to read the application instructions. Oil/varnishes are applied, then given some time to set, then wiped dry. Wiping varnish products are wiped on an left to dry (no wiping off).
Finally, I'm not disparaging any of these products. In fact, they are a more protective and durable finish than any pure oil finish. They are what they are and can give you a very nice close-to-the-wood finish when properly applied and not overcoated with a film finish.
good job
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>
I recommend moving this lesson to the Articles
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>