Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Patio Electrial Switch Question

Posts

Patio Electrial Switch Question

#1

Patio Electrial Switch Question

Larry in NW Ohio

>Believe it or not this will end up being wood related. My son is building a new patio with pressure treated lumber and needs some electrial switchs put around somewhere. Unless someone has a different and better idea, I was thinking, which is pretty dangerous, of putting them in the 4x4 posts. I want to route out a 2x4" hole and put a switch or an outlet in it and rout a 1/2" opening down the post to under the flooring and run it to the next post and do the same thing. What is the thinking of the clective about this? Will it weaken the post to much? It`s going to have a roof of some sort to other posts that I was thinking would help stiffen it up some. I`d like to get away from a box with a switch in it hanging off to the side. Any and all opinions are greatly accepted. Thanks to all. Larry

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#2

Seems like an awful lot of work, not great result

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You would need to use exterior boxes, which are rather larger than interior boxes; and the knockout (for the wires) is toward the back of the box, so you would wind up routing out most of the post.

Aside from the structural issues - you would wind up with posts like the posts that were holding up my porch when I tore into it, which would have collapsed but for the spiderwebs - you'd be doing deep cuts into pressure treated wood, which can't be the greatest thing for your health; and the interior of pressure treated wood often isn't pressure treated, so you'd be inviting rot.

How about surface mounting the boxes and then building what amounts to a fake beam to surround and cover the box and conduit? You'd probably want to use watertight exterior flex conduit (around here, that's gray plastic, unless you get really fussy and use rigid metal conduit). Once you mount your boxes, you could use 1x4s of some appropriate wood to cover the switchbox, running down to the ground to cover the conduit. You could then run the 1x4s up to the canopy of the structure, or cap them off with a little "roof" and some suitable molding.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#3

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

Dan Donaldson

>If you route a hole for the switch, you will have to make it large enough for the box also. You have to have to switch or plug in a box regardless of whether it is enclosed in something. There are some fairly small metal boxes out there, but, depending on the location, they would have to be weatherproof also.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#4

Re: Patio Electrical Switch Question

Fred Davis

>Larry, if your switching just lights and no outlets , why not use say ,dusk to dawn switched lights, or even some clap on ,clap off lights, rather then mutilating a post.

Even pressure switches under a carpet just inside the house ,before you exit into the Patio.

This way the power supply can travel under the roof you mentioned without weather concerns other then using EMT with water resistant connectors, the connectors do not have to weather and water proof under the roof, but the Wire (thhn) should be shielded.

FredD

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#5

Re: Patio Electrical Switch Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Another alternative would be using low-voltage switching circuits, operating relays. These would require much smaller wires that might reasonably be hidden in grooves in the posts without sacrificing much strength. It starts to get elaborate, though, and requires sufficient understanding of 'lectricity.

Depending on code in your area, I wouldn't necessary use EMT - flexible waterproof conduit might well be easier, and it won't rust.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Patio Electrical Switch Question

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>That's a good point about the rust, Bill. With the change to different formulations of PT wood, and the resultant chemical reactions with galvanized and steel fasteners, I doubt EMT would do well in any position on treated wood other than surface mount.

Jason

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#7

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

John E in SC

>I'm not really sure I understand what you're trying to do, but if it would work for what you're looking for, I think it would be much easier and simpler to build a "fake" 4x4 by building a box out of 1x4's that's hollow on the inside. I really dislike working w/ PT lumber, and can't imagine dealing with all the noxious sawdust routing out something that big would create.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#8

Re: Patio Electrical Switch Question

Fred Davis

>EMT does very well outside in any position .

Specially in any area outside called out for shielded wire ,unless it is in a chase , you will find EMT far more often then metal flex.

One of the main reasons EMT is used primarily is because it gives a smooth run for wire pulling and wire replacement.

It is also available in Aluminum which doesn't rust.

You won't live long enough to see it rust out and the other components like the switch even in a weather proof box will corrode to a unusable state long before EMT.

If I went in the post with a wire , I would have to be able to drill the center lengthwise for the hole and that is a chore, even if you have the right equipment.

FredD

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Patio Electrical Switch Question

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I wasn't talking about the weather-resistance of EMT--for that, I'm sure it's fine. I'm talking about it being in contact with the pressure-treated posts, and the resultant chemical reactions between the chemicals in the PT wood and the EMT, be it galvanized, aluminum or whatever.

Jason

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#10

A different thought......

Barry Irby

>Just attended a "Code" class offered by the local county. They no longer permit the use of 4x4's to support deck if they are to be notched to support the framing. And, they require the posts to be notched to support the framing. Or, at least they require direct bearing. The end result is that it's 6 x 6's for decks now. The problem is they think the remaining part of the 4x4 is too flimsy after it has been notched.

I think it is time for somebody to start milling 5x5's.

I would not route away that much of a 4x4, but a 6x6 is another story.

Here's a trick To run a wire up through a post. From the box, drill a hole down from the front at a very steep angle toward the back of the post. When the drill bit emerges, chisel out a recess, and drill a hole down at a steep angle toward the front. Repeat as often as necessary to get below the floor. Patch the recesses after running the wire.

This might be a good place to use the remote switches that have a battery and a sender in them and mount the control in the fan or light.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#11

Re: A different thought......

Fred Davis

>Barry ,

your idea on remote switches should do the trick for the least laborious and aesthetic way to light the patio.

The first paragraph about the posts being notched and restricted that way ,sounds like either a specific method of wrapping a corner post with the rim joists or they weren't very clear on it.

For instance , what happened to hangers, post and beam, cantilevered, Sonotube piers and so on??

FredD

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#12

Re: A different thought......

Barry Irby

>Fred, like many areas we have had a lot of trouble with decks collapsing. What I call wedding party decks. The local county is trying to get ahead of the curve on them and really tightening up on the enforcement of the code.

It was nearly standard to just nail the joists and band boards of deck to 4x4 posts and let the posts extend up to create the rail posts. Then the nails started to fail, so they insisted on bolts. Later they insisted on direct bearing, so deck builders started to notch the posts or "let in" the joists and headers. Then the county realized that weakened the upper part of the post and it might not be strong enough to meet the guidelines for impact resistance. Especially true of corner posts that were notched on two sides, leaving only a 2x2. So, deck builders were using separate pieces for the load bearing posts and the rail posts. Then the county realized the rail posts were not being anchored securely enough and were still flimsy against the impact loads. (Impact load being one of your drunken overweight dope smoking friends falling against the rail. Not that you have any of those.) So, now they want really sturdy decks with bearing for the joists and bands, sturdy rails and everything through bolted with heavily galvanised bolts. They reject lag bolts because they caught some of the deck builders putting in ones that were way too short. A two inch lag bolts doesn't do much to support a deck joist and the county was not going to take the time to pull them all out and reinstall them. The heavily galvanised part came from the use of ACQ lumber. It eats up the others.

As an aside, when they started to require the heavily galvanised stuff, the big box stores discontinued the cheaper stuff and sold it off at a deep discount. Local deck builders bought all of it and continued to use it until they ran out. So, there are a bunch of decks out there with the wrong stuff.

We see decks on brick piers occasionally but usually brick piers are reserved for screened in porches or sun rooms. Generally they just pour a pad of concrete and set the deck posts on that.

Re: Patio Electrial Switch Question

#13

Re: A different thought......

Fred Davis

>" like many areas we have had a lot of trouble with decks collapsing. What I call wedding party decks. The local county is trying to get ahead of the curve on them and really tightening up on the enforcement of the code."

Thanks for the reply Barry , you just pointed out a recurring problem with shabby building practices and fly by night operators , some who even know better , but cut the corner any how.

Now the government is playing catch up and starting to take the Blacksmith approach to building. I realize code is not predicated on aesthetics , but overkill in the opposite direction like using 6x6 posts for corners won't win any awards either. Clunky is the word.

But happily the method your describing for decks in your neighborhood are just one of many and hopefully the Building officials will stop issuing permits to jobs that they know full well has a builder with a bad history, pulling the permit.

In the meantime , you don't sound like you will be short of house inspections any time soon. ;-))

FredD