Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Posts

Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#1

Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi,

I am thinking through a wood choice for my current project. Prnciple wood is qswo and curly qswo. I have been using poplar as my secondary internal structural wood as well.

I am now at the point of making my drawers and I am looking at the wood for my drawer sides, poplar is first on my list becasue I have a good supply at hand. My only concer is do you think it will stand the test of time over say soft maple or aspen?

Thanks,

Jim

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#2

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Bill White

>Poplar will be just fine. Call me in 100 years if it doesn't work out.

Bill

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#3

JL

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

JL

>My favorites are poplar and soft maple. As poplar is less expensive around here (less than $2/bd. ft.), I have a tendency to use that. Most of the time I use hard maple slides or metal slides so I don't have any trouble with the poplar taking any wear.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#4

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Jim,

Most of the time I use poplar. I did acquire some red oak which was milled to 5/8" for a no show customer. I got it for about a buck/bf. I milled it down to 1/2 and used that for my drawer boxes. Pretty cheap at that price, but ratty to rout dovetails. I'm sure it may last longer than I will. :<)

George

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#5

poplar does fine for at least 300years

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Depending on the region where it was made, poplar or yellow pine drawer parts were used from the early 1700's on. In England the wood choice was quartered oak and this hard wood milled robust grooves into the drawer runners of many of the antiques I have examined. But it enabled the thin (1/4" or 5/16")drawer sides the English preferred. If the drawer is going to be sliding on a runner then the drawer side needs to be soft and the runner hard. But if the drawer is mounted in a mechanical devise then any wood will do.

What do you imagine will not "hold up" about a drawer?

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#6

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>I use poplar all the time for drawers. It may be soft, but I think it holds up just fine. And it's easy on the chisels for all those handcut dovetails I KNOW you'll do on this project. (It IS Dana's dresser, eh?)

On the other hand, if you want a little more "Canadian" flavor in the piece, you might use maple. Or just pour some maple syrup on the poplar. ;-)

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#7

Maple Syrup On Poplar=Sweet Gum

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#8

A.J. Hamler

Yepper, poplar

A.J. Hamler

>Hey, Jim...

I'm late to chime in on this but yep, poplar is my vote for best drawer boxes. As others have said, it's easy to work, warps little, and lasts forever. And unless you use some that has a lot of green or purple in it, it looks pretty much like soft maple anyway.

The only "problem" with poplar is that it's kind of fuzzy after a thorough sanding and the first coat of finish (if you use any -- I don't always do so on drawer boxes), but after the first sealer coat and a light sanding with fine paper, the fuzz is gone and the second coat is glass-smooth.

A.J.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#9

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

jan derr

>my coice would be the quater sawn white oak unless your using metal slides. The two large drawers on my cherry desk stick right now in this high humididty; they're plain sawn sides and I don't use an air conditioner. The quater sawn sycamore on my hutch is fine. But then you have the shaker white pine drawers, my parents are collectors of shaker work, and those drawers move fine.

Just remember, it isn't how long they last, but how they move throughout.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#10

Re: Yepper, poplar

Fred Davis

>Best drawer box material? come on A. J., what ever happened to QS Sycamore?

if you subscribe to the notion that a nice piece of furniture should reflect that quality thoughout the visibile parts , then I would go for Sycamore or Maple or select Yellow Birch every time, but that's just me.

FredD

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#11

drawer wear

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When making period drawers, those that slide on runners, it is important to put the wear in the drawer and not what it rides on. Something is going to wear after hundreds of years of use; that is unavoidable. Fixing a worn drawer is a near trivial task while fixing a groove cut into the drawer divider, or runner depending on how it is attached, is a daunting task. To this end I use poplar sides and waxed maple riders and the dividers are the primary wood.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#12

Mahogany and maglev trains

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Most of the poplar I see here is so soft, almost like balsa wood, that I almost never use it.

I'd be tempted to try something like mahogany drawer sides with maple runners. I'm not sure if the mahogany would give enough visual contrast against the QSWO, but I think it might.

...and a bit of Charlie Belden...

While flying down the tracks at 430 km/h on the maglev train in Shanghai two weeks ago, my mind wandered to piston fit drawers and I thought about mounting a number of "north" magnets in the drawer runners and a bunch of "south" magnets in the bottom of the drawer sides....frictionless, wear free, piston fit drawers here we come. :-) hmmm thinking about it even more, if you use electromagnets, you could lock and unlock the drawer by turning the power on and off or perhaps you could reverse the polarity and do some cool stuff.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#13

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Jim, using poplar for drawer slides will depend on how the drawers are going to be used and what sort of slide arrangement is planned. Wood on wood with a heavy load and frequent use won't last long using poplar. I wouldn't recommend it for a kitchen utensile drawer that gets used 10-12 times per day.

If the drawers will see light loads and infrequent use, as in an end table, then poplar will work for many years and can easily be patched in the future to gain more years if the sliding contact areas wear a little.

Lee

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#14

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Thanks Everyone,

I have read your kind thoughts and thank you for your inputs. Soudns like poplar is an option, but concerns are just that Steve mentioned, poplar here is light weight, so I may go with sliders as these will be in a Mission 9 drawer bureau for Dana...

Thansk again,

Jim

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#15

contrary data

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have had poplar kitchen drawers "for ever" and I see no disadvantage to using this wood for this application . The first I made was in 1969 and that one is still with me, reincarnated as a tool cabinet.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#16

Are we talking about Liriodendron tulipfera?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>aka "yellow poplar"? I can assure Canadians that we do not select especially soft lumber from this species to ship to Canada. I live in the heart of yellow poplar country and with my saw mill connections I have a choice of the "best" of this species. What I choose is "deep woods" slow growth yellow poplar because of its superior working properties. It happens to be the softest also. Fast growth "field trees" yield much harder lumber, like soft maple or more so. But it is not as nice to work and the extra hardness is of no virtue. Cucumber is graded in with poplar. It is also harder but again I don't see this as a virtue.

I select a large slow growth log at the mill and have it approximately quarter sawed for maximum stability. I then use this lumber for all secondary wood applications and for especially drawers.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#17

"Cucumber is graded in with poplar"

Dan Mitchell

>Do you mean that cucumber plants are planted in with commercially raised poplar? Any particular reason?

When I lived in the east, I always thought the tulip tree was one of the prettiest in the region, and some are huge. One of the biggest species in its range.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#18

JL

Cucumber trees, not plants *LINK*

JL

>Really pretty tree, and as Bill said, really hard wood. Excellent for turning. I've only done a bowl or two out of some I was gifted a while back.


Cucumber tree

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#19

working cucumber

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>One of its most desirable attributes is that it planes easily, especially when making "veneer" for pickles.


img

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#20

Re: Are we talking about Liriodendron tulipfera?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Bill, I don't know the species of the wood. Most of the poplar I see is very white and very soft. I think it is sometimes intermixed with aspen. Sometimes you see poplar that has a green/yellow and/or brown tinge to it. This wood is harder but the colour isn't too attractive.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#21

Re: working cucumber

Bill White

>Bill, you have been away from the public too long. Go to town more often (under my breath,"cucumber veneer?")

BWAHAHAHA!!!

Bill

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#22

another argument for hand tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>modern automated cucumber-veneer machinery slices the cucumbers too thin for good crunchiness.

Re: Drawer Sides , Wood Choice

#23

Your wife's gonna be PO'd

Dan Mitchell

>when she can't make salad tonight!

The cucumber tree is a new one on me, thanks for the info (and the laugh) ;-)