Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Deck Refinishing/Product Question

Posts

Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#1

Deck Refinishing/Product Question

Nat Robison

>I'm a novice finisher at best. To date, I've only ever used prepared stains and polys for things I've built. I'd like to try out oil finishes on something.

I'm refinishing my cedar deck and want to use Cabot's Timber Oil. I believe it's a mix of tung oil, BLO, and iron oxide pigments. From what I've read about people finishing with oil, they generally do several coats or until the wood is "saturated" and won't accept any more.

The Cabot's product says to do one coat only. Is this due the presence of pigments? How is this different from projects where people use several coats of BLO or tung oil? There may be a good reason but I'm not experienced enough to know what it is.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#2

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I don't know if it contains BLO, but I used it with the addition of BLO on cedar shingles, and within six months, the shingles turned almost black. Caveat emptor.

Clint

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#3

BLO + Black

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Linseed oil is a smorgasboard for any number of molds and mildew spoores. Put it on your deck or siding and you're looking at black mold in short order.

I learned this the hard way. Thought I was a "knowledgeable woodworker" and finisher so "I'll show those weenie manufacturers" . .

Fortunately, the stuff power-washes off pretty easily the following year.

Cabots oil does well on siding provided you work it in with a brush (got 5 years out of a stain job on Eastern Red Cedar). Don't think much of it for decks.

The waterborne stuff sucks big time.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#4

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Penofin oil has been applied this year on rec of contractor friend. PIT*A to wipe off the excess [read "many old towels" here], but does do well.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#5

It's Linseed Oil, not BLO. Sorry

Nat Robison

>

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#6

.....if that makes a difference

Nat Robison

>

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#7

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

John in NM

>I'd say follow the instructions, they're probably intended to keep you from getting a heavy film finish that would eventually start to flake and peel. I think people put on heavy repeated coats because they think it looks more protected - like its varnished. But if the finish isn't kept in good shape - recoated before it starts flaking, not after - then you have a lot of sanding and scraping to do, defeating the purpose of using a deck finish to begin with.

Personally, I've had better luck with Sikkens SRD and Penofin than with Cabot's, but I'm mostly finishing ipe rather than cedar.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#8

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

David

>I used Cabot's Australian Timber Oil on my front porch. It's mahogany and covered but gets weather. The short of it is that if you lay on too heavy a coat, it won't dry. Cabot's directions say to apply until it puddles then wipe off, don't do it or you'll be using their deck cleaner to remove a gummed up finish a week later. After stripping off the gummed finish and reapplying the porch looked good but not after its first winter. I put on another coat. Two years later it still looks good.

Lay it on heavy, wipe off, let it dry. If you want more protection apply a second coat, after a couple of weeks but don't treat it like an oil finish on a furniture project.

BTW, there's no film to chip or peel off so that's not an issue.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#9

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

Howard Acheson

>You might want to go to you local library and look at the July 2009 issue of Consumer Reports. They have their annual ratings of outdoor deck coatings.

Most of the coatings that were good a couple of years ago have been reformulated and are not the same product today. CU tests coating for three years before they issue a rating. But, the also give some insight into which ones seem to be doing best.

The issue also has some good info on preparing the deck for treatment.

As far as I recall, the Australian Timber Oil has not been to highly rated.

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

#10

Re: Deck Refinishing/Product Question

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>I use Penofin on my Ipe deck and cedar railing. Clean and reapply every two years or so. Yes, it is a pain to wipe of the excess especially if I wait until it gets tacky.