Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Finishing (color) woes

Posts

Finishing (color) woes

#1

Finishing (color) woes

David

>I've formally entered the frustrated stage of finishing a small Shaker style nightstand. It's made of ash, probably sanded it too much (up to 220 plus grey and white pads). I used Behlen's Solarlux dye/stain in Golden Fruitwood to give it some color and then followed with a couple of coats of Bush oil, which is a proprietary BLO blend.

When I ran samples, the dyed wood was golden brown with an orange tinge that mellowed after a day to a nice golden brown. The oil gave it some depth and darkened it some. On the nightstand the color didn't mellow and has remained orange--very Allis Chalmers orange. Did I mention that I don't want an orange nightstand?

I'm hoping to alter the color. My ideas (and here's where I'm begging for suggestions):

1. use an aniline dye in oil (figure NGR dyes won't take because of the oil finish).

2. use tinted shellac after the oil has cured

3. seal with shellac and use a glaze or gel stain

4. use tinted oil base poly

5. Give the table to my sister

Suggestions are greatly appreciated, thanks.

DGW

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#2

Pigmented oil stain

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#3

ash

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I gave up trying to stain ash some years ago. It is about the only wood I work that I don't try to stain, because I was never successful. It will age to a light brown over time if left natural.

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#4

Ditto +

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You'll need to apply by way of wet sanding using 320 SiC paper on a block and move in straight lines with the grain. The abrasive will break the BLO film enough to get some penetration.

ps: save your white pad for rubbing out waterbased film finishes. The powder can interfere with adhesion of subsequent applications and gets stuck is open pore grain.

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#5

Re: ash

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Ash responds well to water soluble dye stain. I pre wet the wood so the surface is quite damp before mopping or spraying on the stain, then wiping it down.

Clint


img

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#6

nice color.my problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I need to learn to use water soluble dyes. The problem is that there are dozens of available colors that are then mixable into thousands of shades. Mixing color is not my strong suite. The color charts offer only a clue as to what the dye will really look like on the wood. So coming up with a successful color has been too daunting to try.

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#7

Re: nice color.my problem

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I'm happy if I get close to what I imagined. Otherwise I chalk it up to Karma.

Clint

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#8

Paul Kramer

Clint, That's a really nice looking piece!

Paul Kramer

>

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#9

Re: Clint, That's a really nice looking piece!

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Thanks, it's a riff off a desk designed by G&G, that was the only piece they had made in ash.

Clint

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#10

Re: ash

David

>That's the color it was supposed to be! But even my tester didn't look that good. Beautiful piece Clint.

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#11

Re: Ditto +

David

>Until I attended a finishing seminar given by Bill Bush, I never sanded that finely. 180 was it, 220 if I was feeling ambitious. At the seminar we went from 80 through 220 plus grey and white pads. Oil only, no coloring and the test pieces (that's all we worked on) were beautiful.

Just read an older article by Glen Huey that says anything beyond 180 is largely a waste of time. Time to rethink my finishing strategy... Honestly, I need a class or a teacher.

Re: Finishing (color) woes

#12

Re: ash

AZ in Colorado Springs

>That's a nice looking dresser.