Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT - GFCI circuit question

Posts

OT - GFCI circuit question

#1

OT - GFCI circuit question

Nat Robison

>I want to install a bath fan over a tub in my house and it's allowed as long as the circuit is GFCI-protected. The power that would supply it is a standard household circuit with no GFCI's on it.

What do I need to do in order to be in compliance and how does one GFCI-protect a circuit with no outlets on it? Is the breaker GFCI-protected?

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#2

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You can buy GFCI breakers, though you should do some deep breathing and make sure your wallet has recently been topped up before you do. It's been a while since I bought one, but you should probably expect $35-40 (unless I'm not keeping up with inflation).

This will protect the entire circuit; if you have other things on the circuit that might trip it, you could find yourself doing a lot of resetting. Also, of course, the test and reset buttons are on the breaker. All this can get awkward if your electrical panel is, say, in the basement and the circuit being served on the second floor.

Alternatively, depending on the circuit layout, you could install a GFCI outlet in the box from which you're taking the power for the fan, and attach the wires leaving the box to feed the fan to the "load" side of the outlet. (forgive me if I'm about to tell you something you already know) GFCI outlets have "line" terminals on one side, to which the wire with the power from the panel should be attached, and "load" terminals on the other, which can be used to feed other outlets or loads (like a bath fan) downstream from the GFCI outlet. The outlet will then protect the downstream loads. In my kitchen, for instance, there's only one GFCI outlet for each of the two countertop circuits; it protects all the other outlets on that circuit, because they're wired to the load side.

There are devices that are shaped just like outlets but serve only as GFCI protection, but they're more expensive than an outlet (economies of scale/unit cost of production, I suspect).

Regardless, it's worth testing the GFCI function monthly. When they fail, although they often fail by becoming more sensitive, even reaching major prima donna stage when they'll trip for no apparent reason, they can fail by becoming less sensitive.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Jesper, Denmark

>An alternative is to install a GFCI on the whole house circuit - then you are protected everywhere.

Probably not more expensive either.

It is code requirement here in Denmark and probably also in many other places.

The older ones are sensitive to lightning storms, but the modern ones have overcome that.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#4

Follow-up/Possible Solution??

Nat Robison

>I just looked again at my bathroom's electrical setup. Next to the sink, there is a box with a light switch for the over-the-sink lights. These lights are on the circuit that the fan would be tapped off of. In the same box are two outlets on a different circuit, one GFCI and one regular.

Could I remove the regular outlet, replace it with a GFCI and have it share power with the light circuit? I would end up with a dedicated GFCI next to the sink, another GFCI sharing power with the light circuit and as long as the fan is "down line" from the outlet, I'd be OK, right? How can I verify the fan and other lights are "down line"? Would I have to try my suggested setup, test the outlet, and if the lights go out they are down line?

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#5

Re: Follow-up/Possible Solution??

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>If you already have a GFCI outlet, you can use the protection of that outlet to protect the fan. The outlet will have terminals on it for other outlets. Use those.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#6

But...

Nat Robison

>I thought of that but the dedicated GFCI circuit ends at that box and I can't run new wire, this is all finished space. Does your solution assume unfinished?

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#7

Re: But...

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Not necessarily. If you know what you are doing, you can pop out one of the holes in the top of the existing electrical box, drill a hole in the top plate of the wall over the electrical box stud bay and fish a new cable to the box. This assumes attic access. It isn't as hard as it sounds and is commonly used to run new wiring from old boxes. Be sure to connect your ground wires correctly.

Check the back of your existing GFCI for terminals to extend the output to another outlet. If it doesn't have it, you can get a new one fairly inexpensively.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#8

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Check the ceiling light to see what circuit it is on. Most likely the light and the GFIC outlet are on the same circuit. Adding a fan light combo would be the easiset way out.

Or they make GFCI switch outlet combinations. Replace teh switch you plan to use for the fan with one of these.

Lee


img

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#9

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Alex Grigoriev

>Are you sure the fan (that is in the ceiling and doesn't have exposed metal parts) requires GFCI? I thought only outlets do require it.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#10

Concur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Lighting switch circuits are often very difficult for someone without a lot of experience to sort out - there are several different ways to wire a switch to turn a light on and off, not all of which will provide you a complete circuit in the box (for more information, go to your local library and get out a book on residential wiring).

I concur that, if you can reach the attic above the box, you can probably run an additional wire down to the box, and tap off the GFCI outlet you've already got. You may be really lucky and find that the electrician before you drilled a large enough hole for the existing wires that you can snake another wire through. If not, be VERY thoughtful in drilling your holes, to avoid drilling through the existing wires.

This isn't rocket science, but it does require stopping and thinking at each stage; and often involves sweating and cursing, too. Loop back here for ideas.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#11

Perhaps....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Perhaps the GFCI is required because the fan is directly above the bath.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#12

I always

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I always adjust and work on the bathroom ceiling fan wiring while standing in 3-4" of water with the shower running.........don't you?

Lee

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#13

Re: I always

Richard Krieger

>Don't know if this is relavent here or not, but.........Depending on which NEC code your jurisdication in under.. the 2008 code specifies that: 1- All convenience outlets in a bathroom MUST be on a "dedicated" 20 amp GFIC circuit that is NOT connected to anything else other than other bathroom receptacles. Lighting and fan circuits DO NOT have to be on GFIC and if they are, can result in "false tripping" due to motor leakage from "less than excellent" quality devices. Lighting and fans can be on a separate 15 amp circuit (14 ga.wire), but outlet MUST be 20 amp dedicated circuits.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#14

GFI not required

Rick Christopherson

>I just searched through the entire 2008 NEC and there is no requirement for GFI protection on a bath fan or light located directly above a tub or shower. If the fan has a light, it must be listed for wet locations, which I would assume it automatically was.

The only section in code specifying GFI for a light is in articles 551 and 552, which are for trailers and recreational vehicles, not homes.

Who told you that GFI was required for this application? If this came from someone like a home inspector, it is not uncommon for these individuals to have significant misunderstandings of codes. Even if it was a state electrical inspector, sometimes there is a misunderstanding of either the question or the answer. If it was an electrical inspector, there is nothing wrong with asking him for a code reference. A state inspector cannot enforce requirements that are not written either in the adopted version of code, or in local code ammendments.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#15

your answer

Nat Robison

>I believe it was the installation instructions with the fan. I guess it makes sense in a wet environment but I'm glad you confirmed that it's not code. Power to the fan will be coming thru a GFCI outlet anyway and the fan will be in an 8' ceiling so I'm not too worried about it. Thanks for checking.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#16

You can also angle a hole through the plate

John in NM

>from the surface of the wall, leaving an ~1" hole to patch, which is not too hard. Perhaps you could also relocate the intended fan to outside the tub area, and thus avoid the whole GFCI problem all together....

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#17

GFCI saved my wife's life

Joe Pack

>FORGET ABOUT THE MONEY!!!! For the $50 you might spend on a GFCI breaker that will protect your entire circuit, probably your bathroom circuit, you may have a wife or child that lives because you spent less money on their safety than a good saw blade costs.

My wife is alive today because of a GFCI protected circuit. She was washing dishes one day shortly after we moved into our new house, which I built, plumbed and wired myself. When she put both hands into the water in the metal sink, she felt a quick tingle and jerked her hands out of the water. After the surprise wore off, she found that the light over the sink was out and would not turn back on. She called me and told me about the shock. I hurried home, found the GFCI had kicked off, and used a meter to test for voltage problems but found none. Petrified that my wiring of the garbage disposal had caused the shock, I took everything apart and inspected for breaks, rubs, bare spots...anything that could have caused electric shock, but could find absolutely nothing.

Afraid of what might happen if the problem was ignored, I called a licensed electrician who came out and went through the same procedure I did. And he found nothing; he said everything was done exactly right. Not giving up, though, he asked my wife to recreate the exact circumstances, down to everything that was plugged in on the counter even if it was not being used at the time. To cut to the chase, he found that the stainless steel mixer that had belonged to my wife's grandmother, and that was on the counter just a couple of feet to the right of the sink, was shorting out. When he touched his meter probes to the mixer and to the stainless steel sink, he found just shy of 90 volts! Even though she had both hands in the dishwater and was not touching the mixer, the water on the counter from splashing dishwater was enough to complete a circuit and send much of that voltage through to the sink and my wife's hands. He said that if the GFCI had not kicked out, my wife may not have lived to call me.

Buy the GFCI breaker and protect the entire circuit. It's only money.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#18

Re: GFCI saved my wife's life

Fred Davis

>You followed code Joe and your wife is alive because you did.

No better testament can be had them for doing it right then that.

I wish I had that story some years back when GFCI's were being mandated and could have told it to more then one person who was on a money saving crusade to avoid the cheap way in dealing with electricals.

FredD

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#19

GFI outlet verses GFI breaker

GalenV in Iowa

>In the master bath in the home I had built the bath fan was powered from the GFI outlet at the vanity. 90% of the time if you flipped on the fan on it tripped the GFI outlet. They found nothing wrong with the fan but I seldom used it because of the tripping.

Apartment I lived in they retrofitted the breakers to the bath and kitchen to meet updated city code. The bath fan was on same circuit but never tripped the GFI breaker nor the vent fan in the kitchen.

Made me wonder if GFI outlets are more sensitive than GFI breakers.

Both rated 20 amp but may be for different time inrush current?

Galen

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#20

Re: GFI outlet verses GFI breaker

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>An electrician friend told me that some GFCI outlets are hyper-sensitive. Given the price - very low, considering the technology involved - I can understand that tolerances must be pretty broad. I'd have tried replacing the outlet.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#21

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Ronald

>i was told as long as one outlet on the same circuit is a GFI the whole circuit is protected.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#22

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

Howard Norman

>>i was told as long as one outlet on the same circuit is a GFI the whole circuit is protected.<

That is only true if the rest of the circuit is piggy backed to the GFCI outlet.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#23

Re: GFI outlet verses GFI breaker

GalenV in Iowa

>Bill

To try and resolve the GFI tripping the first thing done was put in a new GFI outlet. Tested the bath fan houseing to earth ground and then replaced the wall switch to the fan. Thought they had covered all the potential areas but did not change the overall problem. They did not try to replace the bath fan.

Attic had blown in isulation and about 60 feet from access hatch to fan. Good chance they would have went through the ceiling trying to get there.

I now today there is a big price range in GFI outlets and wonder how you trust which would work best as I do not always believe the highest cost is the best!

Galen

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#24

Re: GFI outlet verses GFI breaker

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've tended to buy the cheap ones, and have had just a couple of failures: hypersensitivity or a reluctance to reset after I tested.

Re: OT - GFCI circuit question

#25

Outlets BEFORE the GFCI are not protected.

Joe Pack

>A GFCI outlet will protect that outlet and all outlets after the GFCI. Any outlets on that circuit between the breaker box and the GFCI (all outlets before the GFCI) are not protected.