Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Posts

OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#1

OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Hamish

>Hi everyone, I just wanted to issue a warning to anybody on the lookout for an external hard drive for their computer. Don't buy a Lacie one. I have two of them (one only a year old) and they both have been playing up and only work sporadically, which is not good. I've since bought a Western Digital one, which I hope will be more reliable, and am copying over the data when the Lacie drives choose to work.

Cheers Hamish.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#2

Ellis Walentine

Opposite experience

Ellis Walentine

>Buyer beware is a good rule of thumb. I have two 2TB Lacie drives on my desk now and have never had any trouble. On the other hand, I've heard some pretty bad reports on Western Digital drives and just had to replace one in a one-year-old Dell computer. Go figure.

Ellis

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#3

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Some of their power supplies go bad easily. They run a bit hot and then burn out. Otherwise, they make pretty good products. If you catch it within the warranty period, they will send another power supply.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#4

Seagate

Chuck W

>Currently running 3 seagate drives and no issues at all. Had a maxtor that went bad and a seagate sometime back.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#5

Failure averages

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>Poke around on the 'net and you will find all sorts of horror stories. Nobody posts "my HD works fine".

The industry has several numbers of statistical but not individual usefulness. Mean time between failures can be hundreds of thousands of hours. Mean useful service life can be tens of thousands of hours. These are means -or averages if you will.

Factors said to affect life include heat, vibration, start/stop cycles [I think 30K is a common number here] etc. There is always a risk of a dud no matter who makes it.

I think it is safe to say that a HD from a major maker has a very low risk of premature failure.

I look for a name brand with a 5 year warrantee. This is the manufacturer's way of betting that practically all of them will last that long. My main HD may not. I had a WD partially crash after around 4 years. It happens. Hard drives are born to die. That is why I have a bootable clone on another internal drive and another on an external drive.

Paranoid? Maybe. But a lot easier than rebuilding everything on a new drive.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#6

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Alex Grigoriev

>You can have faulty USB in your computer. That happens because of bad PCB design which compromises the signal quality.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#7

Re: Failure averages

Bill Howatt

>How the drive was treated in the shipping steps from the factory to your desk also affect the drive. I have read where this is considered to be one of the principle causes of early failure. It also means that you should always handle HD's carefully and increased handling is one of the things that make any drive in a portable application a bit more likely to fail.

Bill

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#8

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>I am not 100% for certain what is causing all of the drive failures. I have had three drives fail this year. Two of them were close to a year old, and one of them was less than 4 months old. If you are not backing up your data regularly, a drive failure can be a real headache.

One reason I think drives are failing so often is that we are not keeping them cool enough. I think that is what killed one of mine this year. My five year old case was made with 250 GB drives in mind. Those drives sit less than 1/16" apart. The 500 GB and higher drives seem to run a lot hotter than the smaller drives. Without enough air flow, they will die. Heat is the number one enemy of electronics.

I have been looking at building a new computer, and it looks like the cases today are designed for much better air flow over the hard drives.

Most external drives have NO air flow other than natural convection. One thing to look for in an external drive, or external drive case is a good thermal design. In my opinion, this should include a fan if possible.

Just my $0.02,

Rob Hix

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#9

Ellis Walentine

Cooling is important

Ellis Walentine

>You're right about heat being the enemy, Rob. Today's processors and drives generate a lot more heat than those of yesteryear, which by today's standards might be a couple years ago. Whenever I go to a computer fair, I'm amazed by some of the lengths that geeks go to to keep their hardware cool and happy. I've even seen water-cooled computer cases, with goldfish swimming around in them. I must admit I was briefly tempted. :-)

Ellis

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#10

Re: Cooling is important

Bill Howatt

>You can help a lot by putting in the largest, extra case-cooling fan that will fit. To keep prices down a lot of manufacturers only put in a CPU fan and rely on it and the power supply fan for cooling. Unfortunately some power supplies run their fans by the internal temperature of the power supply and it may not accurately reflect the temperature elsewhere in the case.

IMO, machines made by buying a case or from the small, local computer store are better cooled than many from the big brand-name companies. They often have enough extra drive bay locations to permit spacing out multiple hard-drives.

Bill

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#11

Re: Opposite experience

Fred Davis

>Western digital, bad name around here, I bought a Dell and the they had this WD on sale and so I went for it.

Turns out the only way you can get software to run organize it is if you had bought it in England and at only one supplier at that.

FredD

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#12

Re: Seagate

Don Orr

>My wife has had 3 Seagate drives fail in the past year. Two just died at the same time. They are under warranty but what a pain. She is not happy. I believe it is the nature of a mechanical/electronic device to fail. Nothing lasts forever, but a few years would be nice.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#13

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Michael Bush

>My Western Digital, used for automatic backups, died a week ago after nine months of use, so I wouldn't be over-confident!

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#14

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Hamish

>Wow, it looks like I'm not the only person having problems with hard drives, and further more, none of the brand named drives seem to be any more reliable than the other, judging on what has been said here.

I like taking photos and have accumulated over 100 GB of them that I like to use for different projects. Having them saved only on DVD's, which seems apparently safer, is not the ideal place to access them. The comment about hot electronics is interesting. I have just bought a cooling base for my Mac laptop, as it gets too hot to even place on my lap!

Does anybody know of any Hard Drives that have a cooling fan in them? The WD "My Book" that I have just bought, seems to have a lot of air vents along the bottom, back and top which should help in cooling it naturally but it is to soon to say how hot it will get.

Anyway, thanks for all the input,

Hamish.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#15

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Bill Howatt

>I am not aware of retail-packaged portable drives that come with cooling fans but that sure doesn't mean there aren't any. What you can do is go to a real computer store and find a USB enclosure that does have a fan and then buy a HD and stick it in the enclosure. It is easy to do but if you can't do it, then have the store do it. Enclosures with fans do exist. I also think the WD Mybook drives have much better cooling holes than a lot of products.

I have had very little trouble with HDs regardless of brand. I once asked the genius at my local computer store which drives were, in his opinion, the best. His only comment was that, "they all will fail". So for that reason backing up of your personal data files is important. You can always reload Windows, OSX or whatever and your applications from scratch but if your pictures, spreadsheets, etc are gone, there is nowhere you can get them at any price.

I have had more problems reading optical disks than HDs. I normally don't use CDs or DVDs for data storage anymore. I use USB drives but I have more than one drive and I rotate them around. I let the backups build up on the drive in separate folders rather than replacing one backup with another.I also leave the original on the machine's HD so there is never only 1 copy of anything on only 1 device. I would also say that it would be a good idea to make a copy to optical disk so you have diversity of media as well - gets rid of a common failure mode of only using a USB drive for backup.

FWIW, once or twice a year I write my files to a spare HD which I keep at a friend's house in case of total theft or destruction of my house.

Bill

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#16

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

Hamish

>Thanks for your advice Bill. I'll need to get myself or rather my computer organised over these vacations. It's been needing it for some time now.

Cheers Hamish.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#17

Get that data off of the DVDs

Ed Beck

>The DVDs will fail over time, and there's nothing you can do to stop it. The problem is that the dye will break down over time and take all your data with it. Using DVDs as your sole data storage media is practically guaranteeing that you�ll lose it, might as well drag it straight to the recycle bin.

The best way to store data is to use a magnetic hard drive of some type and have a backup routine. Offsite storage for the house fire scenario is a good idea also. I work at Microsoft and we have a couple of free solutions for online storage. You can get 25GB of free storage from Microsoft�s SkyDrive (http://skydrive.live.com) which is part of the Windows Live offering (also free). The 25GB is probably not going to be enough to store your photos, but you can store a lot of documents in 25GB. I�m not saying anything one way or the other about security on the Live site, but I personally don�t store financial data anywhere online.

Another solution Microsoft offers is Live Mesh (http://www.mesh.com). I really like Mesh because I can synchronize data between multiple devices, (PCs at home and work, Macs, and my phone). One very useful application of Live Mesh is to share files with other people. For example, my daughter at college wanted me to scan something for her. Mesh folders are both local and online, so I scanned the doc and saved it locally into her folder in my Mesh (I created a folder in my Mesh and shared it with her). The file automatically synchronized to the Mesh, and as soon as she logged on the file was synchronized to her laptop so she had it local also. I�m using the Mesh as my primary storage for active files, like vacation plans, or woodworking plans. You can have 5 GB in your Mesh.

The only thing that I use CD/DVDs for anymore is when I want to give someone a lot of photos or some other large amount of data. Then I�ll just burn it onto a CD / DVD and give it to them. Might as well, I�ve got a bunch left over from when I trusted the things, and my wife frowns on my nailing them to the wall as decorative art.

Re: OT - Warning Lacie Hard Drives

#18

Re: Get that data off of the DVDs

Hamish

>Ed, thanks a lot for all that information. I knew that DVD's would fail in the long term but judging from what you have said, it doen't sound very long. In your experience, how long would say a good brand of CD-R, burnt at a slow speed, expect to last, if it were kept in a zip up case away from extreme heat? And another question if I may trouble you, do you think it would be advantageous to position my external hard drives on top of one of these laptop cooling supports, the ones that have a fan on them, to help keep the drives better ventilated, or would that be overkill.

Regards Hamish.