I disagree.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>What's gone is the diagnosis aspect of being a mechanic. With all the electronic wizardry in today's engines, most trouble-shooting can be done by hooking up a $200-300 scanner. Sure, you still have to know a little about how the system operates, but the basics are still there--they still take fuel, spark and air, and they still have pistons, crankshafts, camshaft, valves, rockers and the like. No, you probably can't rebuild a modern transmission on your own, so I'll give you that one, but everything else is quite serviceable. In general, factory service manuals are more readily available as well, so you don't have to blindly take things apart to do them.
Here's the biggest difference, too. The old, carbureted, non-electronic vehicles required constant maintenance just to keep them running, and even more to keep them running well. My '96 Grand Caravan has nearly 180k miles on the clock, and I've hardly had to touch it. There are two spark plugs I couldn't get out the last time I tried, but they were changed at about 70-75k, so they've got over 100k on them. Still running. I had to have the transmission rebuilt about 40k ago, but it's going strong. Brakes and tires are normal wear items. Also on the engine, it's gone funky a few times, but I limp it in to AutoZone and have them read the codes for me, then I figure out what I need to replace. Once was the electronic fan relay, another time was the EGR valve. Neither took very long to do, and no special tools.
Now, we also have the internet--there are a whole host of repair forums out there, many with dealer mechanics selflessly helping folks with their problems.
Sure, there are the $400 light bulb jobs out there, or the occasional engine replacement at 30k miles, but those are rare. The Pinto was designed with a 25k mile service life. Now, vehicles that go 10 times that are commonplace.
Jason