Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Water Poly Questions?

Posts

Water Poly Questions?

#1

Water Poly Questions?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Everybody!

It is getting time to put a finish on the clear pine trim we put in our cabin. I have been told that the water based poly is the way to go. Is this true?

If so, then what brand would be optimum? What kind of brushes should be used to apply it? Will two coats be enough? Are there any other considerations I need to know?

I have never used water-based poly before, and need your help!

Thanks!

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#2

not my choice.... maybe

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have better success applying conventional solvent based varnish in terms of getting a smooth coating and attractive luster. However, it will cause pine to yellow some, or a lot, depending on the brand. So if the lack of yellowing is important then a nonyellowing water based finish would be preferred. If I faced this problem I would call the technical folks at Target Finishes and ask them what they would recommend from their many choices.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Water Poly Questions?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I've used several different brands of WB poly. To me, there is only one worth using for interior trim--Sherwin-Williams' Wood Classics. It approaches the thickness of a cheap acrylic paint, whereas all the other brands I've used are like water. No way two coats of the others would be enough, 4 is more of a minimum. Even with the wood classics, 2 coats on bare wood is pushing it. I usually put two coats of the WB poly over a coat of Zinsser SealCoat shellac, except for high-handling items like doors, which would get 3. Of course, I'm usually spraying...

As for brushes, nylon/polyester brushes work well. WB finishes mess up natural bristle brushes. I usually use at least a 3" sash brush if I happen to have to brush out some trim. With a larger brush, I can work more quickly--put it on, spread it, tip it off and leave it alone. With quick-drying finishes, you don't want to work them any more than necessary.

Jason

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#4

Re: not my choice.... maybe

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Bill,

We have used solvent based poly on the rest of the cabin - it's what I'm used to, so the yellowing would eventually match up with the rest of the place. The reasons WB Poly was suggested was because we would be staying in the cabin as we did the varnishing, and the fumes from the solvents would not necessarily be good for us. Also that the WB dries more quickly allowing the chance to re-coat sooner. Now since I am new at using WB finishes, I don't know if this is true or not. If not, and it would be just as good to use old-fashioned poly, I will likely do that since it is cheaper and I know how to use it. Please weigh in: Do I use the new, or the old Poly?

Thanks!

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#5

Re: Water Poly Questions?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Thanks Jason!

I appreciate the specific answer! It gives me something to go on. I think I'll call Sherwin Williams and check on that product.

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#6

Re: Water Poly Questions?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Thanks Jason!

I appreciate the specific answer! It gives me something to go on. I think I'll call Sherwin Williams and check on that product. Wow, I just checked with them, and this stuff is $57 a gallon! Of course it might only take about three gallons to do our cabin, so that may be doable. Thanks!

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#7

Re: not my choice.... maybe

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>You misread Bill's comment. Solvent-based varnish will give the yellow hue, waterbased will remain clear. It'll look a little pale, even, unless you tint the wood to taste before.

I think you're correct that WB would be better in the circumstance of your occupying the space while doing the varnishing.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#8

Re: Water Poly Questions?

Thomas S Stockton

>Scott

I've used stuff from Home Depot and it was around $45 a gallon, but given a choice I like Sherwin-williams products and am willing to pay a little extra for them. I've had great luck applying the stuff with those inexpensive foam paint pads.

Tom

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#9

Re: not my choice.... maybe

jan derr

>the seal coat shellac will give you some colour; and what? aesthetic or health: it should not be a coin toss.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#10

I use General HP Poly

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I've been using General HP Poly of a couple of years now and it out perforforms the lacquer I used to use. It is water clear, sands like nitrocellulose and has a UV inhibiter and is a true water based finish. the down side is that it costs $62/gal It is brushable or sprayable with no thinning. For brushing I use a 1.5" Raphael #290 which is a synthetic artist brush with a price tag of about $25, but well worth the cost. I apply 2 coats then sand any raised grain. Sometimes 3 coats will be enough but I usually end up with 4 coats giving be a deep gloss that I knock back with some 0000 steel wool. Of course I am using it on furniture and trim work may noot require as high a gloss. it is also available in satin.

I have used a foam brush and it will give a decent finish but the foam will abrade slightly on the wood and leave tiny bits of foam in the fnish and often on the last coat the plastic inner support will tear through and mar the finish.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#11

Re: Thanks!

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Thanks Everybody!

This gives me a good basis to proceed. The guy I called at Sherwin Williams said that if I buy this product by July 7th, they are having a 30% off sale, which sounds good to me!

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#12

unfounded consern

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>For the past 100 years people have done what you want to do and suffered no ill effects, including the painter who was exposed to vastly more fumes than the homeowner. As hot as it is where you live now it will dry dust free in 2 hours and ready to recoat in 4. I just did it so this is not speculative information. Slather on a coat in the AM, open the windows and let he solvent flash off.

Not commonly known is that water based paint/varnish is 30 or so % coalescing solvent. It is what gives these products an odor. So you are not volatile organic solvent free which ever way you go. Personally I don' t mind the smell of mineral spirits.

PS when are the fair dates this year?

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#13

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If this cabin happens to be on the river near an exceptional trout hole I will come do it for you and you can stay home in the air conditioning. I am a very slow painter so it could take a whole week of fishing, er, I mean painting, to finish the job.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#14

Re: Water Poly Questions?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If I had a lot to do, I would use Varathane Diamond Floor Finish, which is a water based poly. It doesn't swell the wood much at all and lays down really nice. The only down side is that they only sell it in gallons.

Lee

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#15

Re: Bill Tindall

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Bill!

Our cabin isn't on the river, it's a whole block and a half away. The river is the Henry's Fork of the Snake, which has been known to produce a fish or two. ;-) Alas, my secretary and her husband are going to do this for us in a few weeks. Yep, they'll have to go stay in our cabin, which is about 30 minutes from West Yellowstone, for as long as it takes. It's a dirty job, but somebody has to do it!

Thanks for the info. The Fair dates are the 5th through the 12th this year.

Scott.

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#16

Scott's neighbor

Scott in Montana

>Wow! We're practically neighbors! My cabin is just east of Cameron, MT... a bit south of Ennis.

Scott in Montana

Re: Water Poly Questions?

#17

Re: Scott's neighbor

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Nice area! We're south of you, just at the head of Island Park Reservoir. I'd suggest we meet in West Yellowstone for lunch some Saturday, but we're not traveling this summer due to some surgery my Wife had. Right now our Son is at our cabin, eating all the food and burning all the gas out of our 4-wheelers! ;-)

Scott.