Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Help on tree ID

Posts

Help on tree ID

#1

Help on tree ID

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have 15 acres of hardwoods with one example of this tree. The trunk is about 6" in diameter, and it's about 45' tall. The bark looks like sycamore, but the leaves are totally different. The leaves get to about 4.5" long. Any guesses?

Clint


img

Re: Help on tree ID

#2

The leaves 

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>


img

Re: Help on tree ID

#3

Re: Help on tree ID

Michael Bush

>Looks like American Hornbeam to me.

Re: Help on tree ID

#4

No, nevermind. the bark doesn't look right

Michael Bush

>

Re: Help on tree ID

#5

Beech

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Looks like a Beech tree to me. Tom

Re: Help on tree ID

#6

Re: Beech

Larry in NW Ohio

>I go along with Tom, my neighbor has one and looks just like it. Larry

Re: Help on tree ID

#8

Re: Beech

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I'll keep an open mind, but there are plenty of beech trees in the woods, and this guy bears no resemblance to their bark. The pattern of leaves is also different, each twig having a cluster of three.

Clint

Re: Help on tree ID

#9

not like any beech I ever saw

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It certainly is not American beech. Where in the world is this tree growing? Could it be no-nnative. The bark sure look like sycamore and there are sycamores beyond the american sycamore. I can't find my tree book to look them up.

Re: Help on tree ID

#10

Sycamore

Gene Gauss

>The flaking bark is very close to what we call sycamore around here. In the fall it drops seed balls about the size of golf balls.

Re: Help on tree ID

#11

Re: Help on tree ID

Victor Parisian

>Looks like Sycamore bark and Trillium leaves.

Where are the trees and you located?

Good luck

Victor

Re: Help on tree ID

#12

Bark and leaves are different trees

Tom Dunlap

>The bark is sycamore...leaves look like beech...you should have a much closer pic of the leaves for a better ID.

Re: Help on tree ID

#13

Dale Lenz

Re: Help on tree ID

Dale Lenz

>Leaf margins, edges, are not beech. It is somewhat common, especially in the woods, for folks to be looking at another tree's leaves due to crown overlapping. Could that possible be the case here?

Re: Help on tree ID

#14

Re: Help on tree ID

James Runchey

>It looks like a mountain stewartia according to the picture in the North American Audubon Field Guide. Grows in Kentucky, Virginia, Northern Georgia.

Re: Help on tree ID

#15

Still a mystery

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I'm convinced that it's neither beech nor sycamore, and have not found a likely suspect in any reference. It may be a non-native specie, as the previous owner was a botanist, and may have planted it. It's very attractive and seem to like a moist environment, since the water table is only about two feet down.

Clint

Re: Help on tree ID

#16

Chinese Elm ?

Don Orr

>

Re: Help on tree ID

#17

East central PA, near Quakertown

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Help on tree ID

#18

I don't think so

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The leaf configuration is different and the bark doesn't look scabby enough.

Clint

Re: Help on tree ID

#19

Re: East central PA, near Quakertown

Victor P

>Sorry Clint, I was turning off the computer after that post and just before i did i Googled Haycock Mountain and there you were in Eastern PA.

Its a dogwood tree. I can tell by the...

Victor

Re: Help on tree ID

#20

Re: Help on tree ID

Dale Stansbery

>The bark looks a lot more like London Plane tree (non native, related to Sycamore) than it does to Sycamore. You'll have to climb the tree and hold a branch with those leaves on it showing them coming out of that trunk,and take a picture of them before I believe they're related to that tree though.

Re: Help on tree ID

#21

Re: Chinese Elm ?

Fred Davis

>No

FredD

Re: Help on tree ID

#22

Re: Help on tree ID

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It's not London plane. The leaves and leaf pattern are totally different.

Clint

P.S. I'm beginning to think it was brought here by aliens.

Re: Help on tree ID

#23

That's it! Venusian Sycamore!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Help on tree ID

#24

Dale Lenz

Re: Question

Dale Lenz

>Can not tell from your leaf pic., are the leaves/twig arraigned in an opposite pattern, as in pairs, like the ears on your head, opposite to one another. Have you noticed flowering in the spring, if so what color etc.

Re: Help on tree ID

#25

Re: Question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>As shown in the picture, all the leaves are arranged on each twig tip in a triangular pattern. No variation. They are fat canoe shaped up to 4 1/2" with edges in a fine tooth serration. They are soft, rather than crisp like dogwood or beect, without prominent veining.

There were several, what appeared to be dead blossoms, up too high to really make out, and nothing scattered on the ground.

The mottling on the bark, in shades of gray-green, tan, brown, and coffee extends on to the branches.

On this tree, from the base to about three feet up on one side, where it looks like it had been used as a deer rub and is scarred, the bark is actually exfoliating in quarter size chips that can be flicked off.

A couple main lateral roots show above ground.

Clint