Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

garden tiller suggestion?

Posts

garden tiller suggestion?

#1

garden tiller suggestion?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have a Troy built 8 HP monster that is just too big for my current garden and its loose soil. It was great for my old larger heavy clay soil garden where I used it as an alternative to plowing the garden.

I need a tiller that is easy to maneuver in a 40 x 60 garden with river bottom soil. I mostly use a tiller to grind up the top layer of soil for weed removal and for pulverizing soil after plowing or spading. Often I am just doing enough to plant a couple of rows. I guess the main attributes I am looking for are maneuverability and sturdy. I want to be able to till around obstacles and already planted stuff, and the machine needs to last.

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#2

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I would go with the 5 Hp Troy Bilt pony

Lee

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#3

Ellis Walentine

I had a Troy-built for years

Ellis Walentine

>When it finally bit the dust, I got a Mantis and love it. It is so light and maneuverable and tills like a bandit! (However that is.) It is on the small side for a 40 x 60 foot garden, but I can till a 20 x 30-foot garden in a couple hours at most.

Ellis

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#4

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Tom Minehan

>I will also vote for the Mantis. I bought one when they first came out as I got tired of wrestling with my Gravely. I'm on my second set of tines as my soil is far from river bottom quality (it's getting closer as I till stuff in). I wore the original set down to nubs. I also have the edger attachment for edging around flower beds, trees, etc.

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#5

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Larry in NW Ohio

>I just bought the Electric Mantis last fall and also bought a Toro electric blower and just love them. I have a special cord for them, it is a twist lock so as not to pull out. I also have the edger and that thing just can`t be beat. If you want to try one, they have some kind of deal that you can try the Mantis for a year. May be worth looking into. Larry

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#6

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

"I want to be able to till around obstacles and already planted stuff."

We really like our Honda Harmony for that sort of thing. It is 4-cycle, and starts like a champ every year with no special care. It is small (like the Mantis) compared to your present tiller, but sure acts "big" for its size. Highly recommended after 6 years of yearly use.

Jim

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: garden tiller - Mantis, again

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I've had mine for about five years, and till a small - 25 X 30 - plot with it, as well as a number of small planters.

Turning the tines around on it makes a very effective weeder, too.

Jim D.

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#8

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Ken Bleadow

>Good Evening Bill,

I, like you, had the troybilt horse tiller which was great for breaking new ground, but not so good for keeping the weeds under control after the garden was planted. I sold it and replaced it with the Troy Pro-line tiller. It is the largest small framed CRT tiller that Troy makes. It has a till width of 16", and has the 160cc Honda engine. So far it has been great. It's very good at breaking new ground, and is a lot lighter and easier to control than the old horse. So far I'm 100 % satisfied with the new tiller.

Ken

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#9

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

John L. Blue

>Bill, I've got a Troy-bilt monster, also, use it every year to till up our garden. Like the others, also have a mantis to keep the weeds out, it works great, so easy to take the tines off and clean it, had it 3-4 years, no problems. John Blue

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#10

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Ron in Sterling, CT

>Bill -- I have had a Mantis for 20 plus years and swear by it. It is great for working around things, and does a great job at tilling in a garden that already exists. The only work I have had done on it is to rebuild the carb. A great little machine.

Ron

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#11

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

Ronald

>I have a Mantis and for the bigger jobs I have a Cub Cadet w/160cc Honda engine. Use both and love them both. The Mantis is a ground eater and the Cub is great. With the Cub i can run the tines in reverse and the wheels drive it,really eats the ground too. Good Luck!

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#12

Mantis?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I feel like I have been living on a remote island and missed this machine. It would seem that all the gardeners on WC have one! Where do I buy one, or look at it?

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Order online.  *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>


Mantis Tillers

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#14

2 or 4 cycle

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Thanks for the tips. Any opinions on choosing a 2 vs 4 cycle engine?

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#15

Ellis Walentine

Re: 2 or 4 cycle

Ellis Walentine

>Mine is the 2-cycle. I don't know anything about the 4-cycle.

Ellis

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#16

Re: 2 or 4 cycle

Hal Smith

>Sears makes a 4 cycle. Bought one a couple months ago and am pleased. My garden is about 12 x 30. Had a Mantis some years back and would rate it (as I remember) as slightly superior to the Sears in performance, but not having to mix oil with the gasoline more than makes up for that. 4 cycle is also "greener"; less emissions. Think either one will do you just fine. Hal

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#17

Re: Mantis?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The local garden equipment dealer sold us ours. The little thing is perfect for our raised beds. I wouldn't use it too much on the clay soil that is native here, without some serious amendments. A buddy, though, has a 12 horse monster that tears that stuff up, if we get it on the right day.

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#18

Re: Mantis?

Frank in Forest Hill

>I have a 5 hp Troy built that has a problem with the carb..... you are welcome to it. Live in Forest Hill Md..... even have an apartment over the garage you can use to cut the drive time in half. My wife is tried of looking at the tiller. The garden you are thinking of tilling is too large for a Mantis ( have one now) A carb kit and an hour of time and you will be in business.

Frank in Forest Hill

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#19

Anyone have the Electric Version???

howard

>

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#20

Re: Anyone have the Electric Version???

Larry in NW Ohio

>Yes I have an electric Mantis, as I stated in my post whay up at the beginning. It is a mean digging machine and not a bit noisy and of course no gas lying around and it always starts at the flip of a switch. The only draw back is the cord. Of course you have draw backs to everything. But I would buy it again, and the edger that comes with it is really nice. Larry

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#21

Re: 2 or 4 cycle

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

When I was shopping for a small tiller 6 years or so ago, I seem to remember these differences:

1. 4-cycle doesn't need oil/gas mix, whereas 2-cycle does;

2. 4-cycle was somewhat physically bigger (and probably heavier);

3. 4-cycle is probably quieter, whereas 2-cycle is probably noiser (no experience here though with 2-cycle tillers);

4. 4-cycle has a smooth torque curve at low rpm (can easily till at a very slow engine speed); and

5. 4-cycle is more expensive (haven't compared pricing recently though).

Both 4-cycle and 2-cycle (I assume, since I have no experience with a 2-cycle tiller) will get the job done. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#22

Thanks Larry

howard

>

Re: garden tiller suggestion?

#23

Re: Thanks Larry

Larry in NW Ohio

>Howard Go to Mantis.com and look at their ads, if I remember correctly they have a 1 year trial with their equipment, but you need to look if it is with all their equipment. Good Luck Larry