Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

Posts

OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#1

OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

In my quest to upgrade my computer's software so that I can actually USE my new Ipod Touch, I've been searching through the internet for a good price on Windows XP Professional Upgrade.

DISCLAIMER: I want to upgrade and not perform a clean install. And I can't use XP Home because there is no upgrade version available from Win2000 to XP Home. In addition I'm not interested in Vista or the new Beta Windows 7.

The prices I found range from $102 to $189. The lower priced ones are labeled "Academic". Of course, I'm looking to save some dough here. I don't want to "go cheap", but I sure as hell don't want to waste money! That's dough I could be using for more tools,..eh.....I mean HOME projects!

Windows XP Pro Upgrade Academic Version

Discount Mountain Software has the following blurb about the so called "Academic Versions"

"Academic software includes the same software and packaging as the regular retail versions but with a label "Academic" on the box and is "Academically priced." The software is not limited or different from the commercial version. Manufacturers offer Academic software to Students and Teachers at discounted prices, but again, the software is not different in any way than the Commercial version. DiscountMountainSoftware does not require any proof that you will be using academic software for academic use nor does the manufacturer. It is on the honor system between you and the manufacturer.

Now this sounds good. Too good. And I have a suspicious mind. Does anyone have any experience with these Academic versions?

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#2

Get a Mac

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Dom..... what can I say, for all the @#$$#@$& I had with a Dell, my year with my IMac and Mac Book has been a blessing...... seriously... others may agree or disagree, but everything I have done with them WORKS!

LOL

;-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#3

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

Howard Norman

>Dom, I built a new XP box a couple of years ago and of course made a clean install at that time and have no experience with an academic upgrade for XP. However, I do have experience with academic Office 2003. As far as I can tell it works exactly the same as the standard product.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#4

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

Carol - headed home

>I have academic versions of several pieces of software - from AutoCAD to MS-Office 2007 and a few in between. But then I bought them as a student.

That really is neither here nor there.

Your question seems to be is there any difference. I don't how to tell. If I have the academic version and have never used the non-academic version, how would I know?

In any event, to my knowledge, I have not been prevented from doing something with any of those programs that was limited because it was an academic version.

That help?

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#5

Thanks Carol

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Yeah, that does help! Thanks!

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#6

Thanks Howard

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#7

You know, as much as I'd love to

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>get a Mac, it ain't happenin' anytime soon! :>) Too many other expenses that take precedence.

Thanks for the input anyway.

And say, don't you have a kitchen you should be working on? :>)

(Says the guy with (2) bathrooms to finish!)

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#8

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

BobP

>Dom, While I'm here I will offer my 2 cents.

First, whatever you buy, make sure it is a very reliable source for the software and not some OEM or "unauthorized" version of Windows. To get proper support and updates it must be a genuine Microsoft product that has not been previously authenticated with MS. My neighbor had the misfortune of working with a less than above board computer service guy and ran into a situation that the version of XP installed during the "upgrade" had been used previously. Microsoft helped them get it straightened out but it cost them about another $40! That being said, the academic versions are typically the same as the "professional" versions. As you know there are a few "home" versions of XP and there is the "Professional" version. There are some differences between these items. When I purchased "academic" versions of Microsoft software from Princeton (former employer) I was told that ALL support had to be handled by the university's own support group, that is, don't call Microsoft. Supposedly that was the reason for the reduced cost. Well, MS support policies have changed quite a bit over the years so I don't know how this will play out. I do know that you can buy the academic version of Office 2007 at Staples. So, the academic versions are indeed available from reliable sources.

Good luck with your upgrade.

BobP

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#9

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

wilbur

>Hi Dominic,

Being in academic medicine, I get to take advantage of those academic versions/discounts on software all the time. They are fully functional with very few exceptions. One of the few exceptions that I can think of is that the academic version of Microsoft Office 2007 comes with Word, Excel, Powerpoint, but doesn't come with Outlook.

But I agree with Jim. Get a Mac if you're looking to do any sort of upgrade. A Mac Mini can be had for $600, and you can use your present monitor, mouse and keyboard. A better solution would be an iMac, which can be had for $1200. Either one will be a big step up in hardware if you have a Windows 2000 machine.

Or, in terms I'm sure you'll appreciate, Mac : PC :: Jet 1642-EVS : Harbor Freight. :@)

And actually, if you take care to make a truly equal comparison, the price of a Mac compares very favorably to a comparably equipped PC.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#10

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

David Yoho

>Dominic, my experience has been you will find the pricing is higher for the full stand-alone version, lower for the OEM version, and even a little lower for the academic version. All versions function exactly the same as far as I know.

Perhaps the only difference between the two lower priced versions of XP and the higher priced one is where you have to go for support when and if needed, as Microsoft is not the main support for these. In the case of OEM software, you would get support from the manufacturer or dealer that made or sold the computer. With the academic version, support would come from the IS or Tech Support folks at whatever academic institution you're part of.

David

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#11

Re: Get a Mac

Hamish

>Hi Dominic,

I see that a few readers have suggested changing platforms, ie from Windows to Mac. That seems to make real sense to me if you want to get the fullest out of your new iTouch which is a Mac product. The same readers also mentioned the prices of new models but I'm sure if you call in at a Mac centre they will have a few second-hand machines from a year or so ago. Although they might not go quite as fast as the newest up to date models, you would be hard pushed to tell the difference doing normal everyday tasks and they will come with up to date software and cost a lot less. Further more, all the Intel chip Macs can have the Windows operating system incorporated if you need it. It might be worth having a chat with a salesman and see what they can offer.

From one happy Mac user. As Jim said, they just seem to work without hassle.

Regards Hamish.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#12

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

Bill Howatt

>I don't believe you can upgrade Academic licenses. You have to buy a new full version of the academic, retail or oem product.

Bill

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#13

What Makes a Mac a Mac....

David Yoho

>I just wanted to set something straight about Mac computers. This is not directed at anyone in particular - but I think there are some folks who think a Mac is better than a PC because of the computer itself (the hardware).

Make no mistake, what makes a Mac a Mac is the Operating System (OS). Hardware is hardware and Macs don't have anything over a PC in that department. However, when comparing the Mac OS to any version of Windows, the Mac OS is heads and shoulders better - period!

Another mis-belief about Macs is they don't crash and don't get virus infections. Believe me, they do crash but nowhere like Windows does. They are also susceptible to viruses and with their record of increased sales they may just be targeted more by the folks writing viruses. The main reason they weren't affected in the past is the virus guys wanted to make the largest impact they could with their dirty deeds and with so many Windows users out there it was easy as pie. If I owned a Mac (my son does) I would run anti-virus software anyway.

David

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#14

Re: What Makes a Mac a Mac....

Jerry Nicholson

>What are these "crashes" you Mac evangelists talk about? I have been running XP for years on multiple machines and have never had a crash. Firefox has crashed a time or two but not the operating system. As far as that goes, I don't think I ever had a crash with Win98SE. I have never had Win ME at home but the ME system I supported spent more time crashed than running. I have played with numerous versions of Linux and have had several Linux crashes.

Jerry

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#15

The difference

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>between a "Retail" version of XP and the "OEM" version is that the OEM version can only be installed on the machine you buy it for. If you buy a new machine, you cannot move the software, even if you call Microsoft. With the Retail version, you can move it. The Academic version is a full version (they are just trying to give students a break and indenture them to Microsoft for life!). I am not sure about the reinstallation issue. That feature is probably only more of a pain with copies of Office. Chances are, if you buy a new machine, it will come with its own OS.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#16

PS:

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>They used to require that you show proof of being a student or educator in order to purchase an academic version. With all of these places online, I'll bet they overlook that requirement.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#17

Academic vs Commerical

Ron in Drums PA

>You can't upgrade any MS Academic version to a later version.

This goes for Office, XP or anything else.

So if you never plan on upgrade to a newer OS it shouldn't be a problem.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#18

Re: What Makes a Mac a Mac....

Ron in Drums PA

>I have 10 XP Pro machines running and I have not had a crash or a virus in years.

Davis Yoho is right, inside the box of a PC or Mac is the same hardware.

In 1997 I was running a program called MacInDos on a Win95 machine. It took quite a number of years for Mac to catch up and invent this idea.

Mac Crashes

Mac Viruses

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#19

Dell

Ron in Drums PA

>There are two versions of Dell computers

A consumer version and a business version.

The consumer version uses the cheapest components available to keep the price as low as possible. You would be lucky if they last more than a year. You can only get a one year warranty with this grade.

The business version uses better hardware and even comes with a standard 3 year warranty which Dell will gladly extend. The reason they are willing to extend the warranty is because they last.

You will pay 3x-4x the price for a business machine over a consumer machine, but you get what you pay for.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#20

Da@#$ Dell...I love my Mac!

Tom Dunlap

>My work laptop is a 'rough duty' Dell...HA! The rubber flaps that go over the ports take three separate motions with two fingers to close them. One is already bent and kinked so it doesn't work. The u-shaped hasp for the cover broke.

The worst issue is the jumpy cursor!!! A problem that has been known by Dell for at least five years. In one line of typing the cursor will jump back two or three lines all on it's own! I carry around my ergo keyboard to eliminate this known problem.

My personal laptop is an iBook G4 that has worked flawlessly for the almost four years that I've owned it.

Ditch Windows!!!

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#21

Re: Dell

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>The consumer version uses the cheapest components available to keep the price as low as possible. You would be lucky if they last more than a year. You can only get a one year warranty with this grade.

I believe you are mistaken regarding the bolded text. I am looking at the configuration screen for the $299 Inspiron 537, surely the cheapest of Dells, and they will happily sell it with everything up to a four-year in home service agreement. Somewhat humorously, the warranty costs much more than the computer itself (best I can figure, it adds $498), but nonetheless they offer it.

I've bought more than my fair share of Dell computers, probably a couple hundred over the past few years, as part of my job. I was always pleased with the overall price/quality ratio from their products.

Re: OT:WinXP Pro Upgrade ACADEMIC Version?

#22

Get a Mac------WebKitFormBoundaryOA+wdTAYbUnF1pGs

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada------WebKitForm

>Dom..... what can I say, for all the @#$$#@$& I had with a Dell, my year with my IMac and Mac Book has been a blessing...... seriously... others may agree or disagree, but everything I have done with them WORKS!

LOL

;-)

Take care,

Jim

------WebKitFormBoundaryOA+wdTAYbUnF1pGs