Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Posts

OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#1

OT manual vs. automatic transmission

ThomD

>I'm looking for a new manual trans truck. It is getting hard to find them. In addition, these days they often report worse gas mileage than the automatics. A Tacoma I was looking at is a six speed manual vs an automatic 5 speed. Gaming tests is pretty easy. I just don't otherwise get how it's possible to get a 6 speed that is less efficient on the Hwy (no shifting) in manual than a 5 speed auto. One could make one that just didn't have a gear for the average HWY speed (whatever that is), but with 6 speeds to play with, how likely is that? What am I missing?

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#2

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Tom,

Milage was a secondary consideration. It occurred to me that I'd have the truck longer if my kids didn't know how to drive it. So I bought a manual 5 speed transmission for my 1993 Mazda pickup. All but one kid learned how to shift it, but preferred other transport. Its still going strong.

George

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#3

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Kneale Brownson Thru skiing in CO till fall

>The operant word here probably is "play". Mechanically, manually shifted gears usually lose less power than those shifted by fluids because there's less initial slippage, but once you are in final drive, the only efficiency difference is the extra weight of the autotranny, as I understand it. But those who enjoy shifting also tend to enjoy operating the accelerator (at least I do), thereby affecting the MPG figures. I know my wife's Audi S8, which in America does not come with a stick, gets better mileage when she drives it than when I do :~).

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#4

Follow the money

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Most cars built today have automatic transmissions. There was a time not all that long ago where you paid extra for an automatic. The excuse was there were fewer made so costs were higher. Now with the majority of buyers wanting automatics, the majority of cars produced have them as standard equipment. If you want a manual trans mission it is now extra cost and usually a a special order.

I would guess that the reason for better mileage on an automatic would be due to the newer computer controls that shift for mileage rather than performance.

I have two cars that are standard shift and I have to be careful when using valet parking or at the car wash to make sure the kid actually knows how to drive a standard. Most new drivers today have no clue how to shift gears. I recently heard that another reason why automatics are becoming the norm is becuase you can't talk on your cell phone and shift......

Lee

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#5

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have a 2003 Ram 2500 crew cab 8'bed Cummins diesel with a six speed manual that I bought new. I've only put it into first a couple times, by mistake I might add, cause it's geared so low. From a stop, I usually start off in third unless going up hill, then often to fifth and sixth. Fourth is for taking sharp curves. I can't compare it to a similar automatic, but I've measured it on long interstate drives at ove 20MPG. Mileage on the back roads and in town is still around 17MPG. Extended around-town and back road driving is tiresome because of the frequent shifting and stop-and-go.

Clint

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#6

Check fueleconomy.gov

Henry Higginbotham

>Don't know about your specific vehicle preferences, but when I was looking at new Civics a while back, the salesman pointed out that the auto got a bit better MPG in the city. I told him I didn't believe it, and wanted a 5-speed anyway. Owner reports on fuelecomony.gov seem to back me up.

By the way, that was in January. I left the salesman my cell phone number to call when he located a 5-speed. Haven't heard a word. They weren't selling much, so I suppose it's possible he quit (or "got quitted").

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#7

Ellis Walentine

What do you want the truck for?

Ellis Walentine

>I've got an old ('94) workhorse Tacoma 3/4 ton that'll pull tree stumps. (Not really, but the image works.) I get lousy mileage because half the time it's dragging something around the farm, but I don't complain. If you drive your truck at highway speeds and rack up a lot of miles, the mileage may prove to be the factor for you. Me, I'd always prefer a manual transmission over an automatic for a work truck, but then I've never owned a truck with an automatic transmission.

Ellis

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#8

Re: Follow the money

Chris Friesen

>"There was a time not all that long ago where you paid extra for an automatic. The excuse was there were fewer made so costs were higher. Now with the majority of buyers wanting automatics, the majority of cars produced have them as standard equipment. If you want a manual trans mission it is now extra cost and usually a a special order."

Not sure what cars you're buying, but for my Toyota Matrix the standard tranny was the default. The automatic would have been about $1200 more.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Actually, Lee...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...you can drive a manual and use the cellphone...I've been doing it for almost a year now, since I shifted (pun intended) to using an '89 Mazda pickup with a 5-speed as my work truck. I've been yapping and driving for over a dozen years, so it was just a little extra skill I had to learn. What made it really interesting was the period of time when my power steering was out. The rack and pinion ratios are really bad in vehicles designed for power steering... 25:1 for manual, 17:1 for power, so when the "power" was out, I got an upper-body workout.

Not that I talk on the phone while I drive much. Most of the time, with the phone in its holster on my belt, I can't hear it or feel it over the noise and vibration of a 20-year-old vehicle. If I am initiating the call, I wait for a stretch of road that is less busy or requires less driver input (not a lot of turns and/or shifting).

Jason

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#10

Just don't visit California

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>talking while driving is a moving violation here.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#11

Re: Follow the money

ThomD

>"I would guess that the reason for better mileage on an automatic would be due to the newer computer controls that shift for mileage rather than performance."

That is what they would have you believe. I find it hard to accept for the HWY component of the figures since basically one gets in gear and leaves it there, possibly for hours. Gearing is another argument, but that would be relative to the target speed, which varies in actual use.

I'm pretty sure I shift more efficiently than an automatic. I can tell the difference in motor noise etc... to inch my way from gear to gear. On the other hand automatics are now the norm in race cars, so who knows.

I for sure have better control over the car in a standard, and one can tell it when one passes other cars spinning their wheels in the winter.

The manual also has a foot shorter wheelbase which might affect the ride.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#12

Re: What do you want the truck for?

ThomD

>I use it as my all around and only family vehicle. Pulls the boats, and brings home the tools. I am not a vehicle person, though I certainly enjoy them. I was mentioning to my wife that between the two of us, nearly 100 years on this earth, we had spent a grand total of 37K Canadian on vehicles. Two trucks.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#13

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Don Evans

>Your problem in figuring it out is, it appears, that you assume that if you have more gears you should get better mileage. Any vehicle once it is in its high gear is pretty much straight drive from the engine to the rear end axle or it's mate in front end if front end drive.

The extra gears are for prior to the final gear, what is commonly called over drive in the old days. Machines that have smaller engines not much go need more gears to get up to running speed that machines with larger engines.

The other factor involved that affect MPG is the (in rear drive) rear end. Trucks are generally lower geared in the rear that cars because trucks are made for hauling. Example if you purchase a truck that is exactly the same engine, same transmission but get a rear end with 4.11:1 gear ratio, it is going to get a lot worse mileage that if you had gotten one with 2.86:1 rear end.

Also, on a manual your MPG is greatly affected by how high you run the rpms in each gear.

Dynamo test have proven that automatics lose about 20 percent of power to the rear wheels as compared to manuals.

Don

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#14

while that's a good start,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>it ought to be a felony. As a frequent motorcycle rider, I can't tell you the number of times I've nearly been clipped by drivers who insist on yapping on the phone rather than pay attention to the traffic.

Bruce, indignant in MN.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#16

Re: Just don't visit California

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>I live here in California, the Coachella Valley, Palm Springs area, and the JERKS here still drive and talk.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#17

Re: Follow the money

Charlie Self

>I don't know about a shorter wheelbase, and my truck is getting a slight bit of age on it--'98--with its five speed manual. It is at the mileage point where I wish I had an auto for a simple reason: I'm too old to replace clutches, and ye olde basic clutch job, something that used to cost maybe 50-75-100 bucks, is now running $750 and up.

Add that to a gimpy left leg, and I drive the truck a lot less than before, which is a great argument in favor of manuals, I guess. You don't pay for gas you don't burn.

My idiot son-in-law insisted on getting a manual on their new car (which he also insisted they get, although the old one was fine, and he wasn't working [a fairly normal way of life for him: paying for things other than computer games and movie DVDs is alien to him]). It then turned out he didn't know how to drive a stick. I figure his halfwitted attempts shortened clutch life by about 60%. It had been a long time since I'd seen a four door sedan do the bunny hop.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#18

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I buy them because I prefer to drive a manual. I had to special order my truck to get the options I wanted with a manual since most dealers only stocked manuals with the work truck package. The downside is that towing capacity is usually less with a manual. I suppose it's possible that Toyota puts a real high ratio diff in the truck to minimize that difference. First gear may well be a granny gear for towing and your other five gears may still be higher than the auto.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#19

I don't think it's an issue of cell phone use

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the closest I ever came to melding my bike with a car, the driver was about 90% asleep early in the morning, turned right from a left lane in front of me. If I'd been in a car, I'd have hit him - fortunately, motorcycles fit in tighter spaces, so I tucked into the triangle left between his car and the curb. Once I got the bike restarted (hard to start from a stop in third gear), I chased the guy to his driveway (this is close to 40 years ago, when worries about road rage were less), and, when I got off the bike yelling about watching for other vehicles before I even got my helmet off, his asleep at the wheel status became obvious.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#20

Re: I don't think it's an issue of cell phone use

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>On one of my bike mailing lists, a guy told his story of being cut off and nearly run over by a driver who made a left-hand turn immediatley in front of him. The bike rider followed him into the parking lot of the grocery store, took off his helmet and bashed the car driver in the face. While a little direct, I sure sympathized...

Bruce

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#21

Re: I don't think it's an issue of cell phone use

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My roomie at the same time as my sleepy-guy incident lost his bike and quite a bit of flesh on one leg when someone turned left right in front of him.

We were, at the time, trying to figure out how to mount a locomotive Mars light (moves in an oval) on our motorcycles; I noted later than someone figured out how to make the lights fluctuate in brightness, which would have the same effect.

Violence doesn't, of course, solve problems like that - just increased any stereotypes the car guy had about bikers - but there should be something to get their attention.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#22

Re: Follow the money

ThomD

>I do worry about the gimpuy leg part. I have had legs out of action even when I was a tike. I was surprised with the Ford F-150, I got 120 000 miles on it before it croaked, and it was still on the original clutch. Apparently the coollant leaks and seizes the engine thing is a Ford spcialty.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#23

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

ThomD

>Jay, I think you, and others have said the same thing, have the explanation. What is weird though, is that the option that has the 6 speed is the 4 door. Those are pretty plush vehicles, with all kinds of options I had never thought of. Meanwhile the work truck package with a 5 speed manual box, gets the best mileage of any of the options. So I don't get it. Why would you put a low range in an SUV style truck with a lower towing capability. Not even right for people towing a motor home.

I called Toyota, but they apparently exist only to send you back to the dealer. I understand that model but it isn't generating sales from me.

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#24

yet further OT, it's called a headlight modulator

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and is quite popular amongst the goldwing crowd. It fluctuates the headlight from basically high to low beam and is quite the attention getter. It's legal across the nation by federal law, although some local jurisdictions don't like them because they can be misinterpreted as belonging to an emergency vehicle. But, if it causes another driver to pay attention...

I understand air horns work pretty well, too.d

bruce

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

#25

Re: OT manual vs. automatic transmission

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>The lower gearing also gets you off the line faster. So, maybe they did it in an effort to out stat the other trucks in 0-60.