Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

grrr...tablesaw table top problem

Posts

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#26

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

Jerry Nicholson

>I have drilled and tapped several holes in my saw table for various reasons over the past 45 years but then I don't have a Unisaw.

Jerry

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#27

Always wondered if that stuff was any good...

Dan Mitchell

>or just an epoxy marketing gimmick. I've seen it on the shelf a million times and always passed it by, have to pick some up...

Dan

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#28

Re: Always wondered if that stuff was any good...

John K Jordan

>I use it often around the farm for things like repairing a taillight cowling on the tractor, replacing tines on a manure fork, fixing a shattered lawnmower wheel. It works far better than straight epoxy. I buy it in the "industrial" size.

I did find one thing interesting: I was gluing a small supermagnet into the side of a fence staple driver (to better hold the staple while smacking it with a hammer) so I drilled a hole, filled it with JB Weld, and inserted the magnet, gobbing some more around the magnet. The JB Weld proceeded to flow up out of the hole to collect on the top of the magnet! It took some minutes of pushing the goop back into place until it set enough to hold. The stuff evidently consists of iron powder mixed into an epoxy.

BTW, the staple driver modification was a resounding success - a major improvement.

JKJ

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#29

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

Pete in Holland, MI

>Tap the hole, thread in bolt or piece of threaded rod liberally coated with Locktite. Tomorrow, grind it flush.

Putting heat (for welding) to the top is a good way to crack it or warp it some.

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#30

Lee Grindinger

Yanking chains? ..., Well, maybe a little

Lee Grindinger

>I may be yanking a chain or two here but my intention is to take the focus off a pretty tool and put it on a pretty piece of woodwork. I know woodworkers who are so intent on having a pretty shop they forget to make anything in it other than shop shelving. These are trophy shops and while I wholeheartedly support the idea of supporting tool makers I would like to see those tools worn out, not left to age gracefully under multiple coats of carnuba.

By the way..., about the beverage glasses on cast iron. I was in my "generous host" mode for MontanaFest. People working for me found their cups in the garbage without comment, I'd simply throw them away and when the topic came up I'd tell them where their coffee/soda/water was and why.

MontanaFest was a blast! You can attest to how much of a tool collector I am..., NOT.

Lee

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#31

Lee Grindinger

Elitist nonsense

Lee Grindinger

>With all due respect, it sounds you've had a gilded life as far as your tools go. Perhaps you were lucky enough to have never faced the pressures that me and most of my contemporaries faced trying to make a living at furniture making.

While it may be beyond your comprehension to understand why some craftsmen work with different approaches it''s well within mine. I have known very few woodworkers with the rigid standards you have and none of them were professionals. The best of my world confronted gritty lumber that had been air dried in barns, they were contracted to rip gnarly lumber, and used saw tables as workbenches because they are flat, stable and solid.

I wish I'd have worked under your roof, what sort of work did you do?

Lee

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#32

Re: Elitist nonsense

Fred Davis

>My life has been many things to many people, but "gilded" was never in the picture.

As for due date pressure yours would pale in comparison to ones I typically faced every day in construction of custom homes, subdivisions, fancy interiors , cabinets, furniture and you can see some of it in shopshots , though I doubt it would approach your level.

But Furniture making is one aspect of woodworking , not a end all , certainly not more or less then other interests in woodworking.

Since you asked........

Over a fifty year span I either helped build , built or was the Superintendent of Construction on about 3,200 units of housing.

Besides that I owned and operated and still do on a less hectic basis,one at a time, five cabinet shops, Partner in two construction companies, owner in one incorporated construction company , holder of a B-1 general contractors license for many years , taught furniture making and refinishing in the Newark, Ca, unified school district as a instructor for a semester each of four years.

The above doesn't include moderating a cabinet chat on the old American woodworker site for a few years , did it for Ellis on this forum when he cranked it up for awhile.

Of course this didn't make mention of other pursuits, such as raising Appaloosa's, fancy birds , but you did ask.

If your approach to woodworking was different , so what, many are different and many do take care of their tools , because they were taught to and because tools are expensive and because well maintained tools do better work easier.

End of this thread for me.

FredD

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#33

Interesting, I'll have to get some ;-)

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#34

Re: Elitist nonsense

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Interesting, and I totally agree with you on maintaining tools. From a maintenance perspective, mine will stand up to anyone's. From a "tuning" perspective, mine will stand up to anyone's, and are probably more accurately set up than just about everyone's. My tables are square and flat, all edges are all de-burred, factory holes coutersunk to remove stress points, tops/fences etc. sanded/waxed and buffed - all the time.

But my cast iron tables are scarred, scratched and used. My work bench is full of screw holes, stains and the odd saw cut. And I'll take a drill to a tool in a heartbeat to mount a widget that I need to make my job easier or safer - doesn't bother me in the slightest.

I add outfeed tables and infill tables to my saw - all fastened with extra holes drilled and tapped where their needed (in the top, in the cabinet, in the fence and associated parts). Without a doubt the saw's a better tool because of this. My mortiser is a shadow of it's factory self, and is now part of a mortising fixture that supports a x-feed vise (also modified via new holes etc.). My bandsaw is full of holes, all put there to support task lighting, dust collection and various project-specific fence modifications and my drill press has also been mofidied with me to do things never could have accomplished had I left it in "pristine" condition.

Non factory holes in tools do not bother me. They tell a story of trial and accomplishment and maybe, the odd lesson. Scratches, dings and dents in tools don't bother me - they tell the tales of shop moves, re-layouts and the movement of materials or other tools, required to get a job done. All of these things speak of a dynamic environment in which things were created and ingenuity was obvious.

Rust on tools bothers me, poorly maintained tools bother me, cheap tools bother me and tools that are not set up to do the job they were indented in an accurate and safe manner bother me. None of these should be acceptable to a "real" tool guy.

So you put a hole in your saw. Big deal. You did it trying to accomplish something else, and you learned a lesson from it. Leave it there - let it remind you of a lesson learned. One day you'll be proud of that hole because it caused you to change the way you do things in your shop. Maybe even one day you'll chuckle when you look at it. When that happens, that tool's truly yours.

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#35

Re: Yanking chains? ..., Well, maybe a little

John K Jordan

>>I would like to see those tools worn out...

I had to laugh when a visitor told me he knew a lot of people with garages or shops full of tools, but I was the first person he met who actually USED the tools! I guess most of his friends buy tools then sit and admire them while sipping a cold beer.

JKJ

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#36

Perfect!!NM

Jay Lombardo

>

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#37

Farmer's repairs and horse flies

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I worked for a year in a small town in rural Saskatchewan building a small process plant. We hired the local welder, who was very good, to do a bunch of pressure welding for us.

He cursed JB Weld up and down. He hated the stuff because 9 times out of 10 before he could do a weld repair for a farmer, he'd have to grind or file away a big bubble-gum sized wad of JB Weld before he could start welding.

He was also the guy who would catch horse-flies, stick a piece of wire-wheel wire (you know, the stuff that sticks in your cheek as it flies off the wheel) up the fly's bum, then laugh as they tried to fly away...they kind of hovered there bum down and flew in circles before they died :-(

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#38

Tabletops and personal style

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I am intrigued by these academic arguments that have mostly to do with matters of taste and style, yet which devolve into quibbling about right and wrong. Everyone has their own personal style; they need only to convince themselves. There is no last word on topics like style of work and personal preferences.

Personally, I am fastidious about some things and laissez faire about others. Sometimes one approach makes more sense to me, whether or not it can be objectively demonstrated. I don't drill holes in my tablesaw because I never use it for a workbench. In fact, I don't drill on my workbench either without a backing block, but that's not to say that Gary can't have his own method of work or that he should or shouldn't patch his mistake. Even the most freewheeling and least fastidious workers among us might do the same. I probably would, as long as it only took me a couple minutes and didn't cost much. Just solving the problem is often reward enough for me, though I suppose you could argue that I was being non-productive during those minutes or that I was making a mountain out of a molehill by filling the hole. At one stage of my woodworking career, it might have mattered one way or the other, but even then, there was no right and wrong way to handle the situation.

I guess the point I'm trying to make is that everyone is entitled to his/her opinions and style of doing things. In a public forum like this one, we all bring our experience and impressions to the discussion, however well-informed or defensible they may be, and we (ideally) try to keep an open mind. I have a lot of firmly held beliefs about how to do things, but scarcely a day goes by that I don't learn something here that challenges those beliefs or that gives me a broader perspective on them. Naturally, when any of us feels very strongly about something -- especially if it concerns a safety issue -- we're inclined to push our point as convincingly as we can. The trick is to remember that if our golden words fall on deaf ears, that's not our problem; we've done what we could to explain and validate our information to the rest of the participants. What they choose to do with it is up to them.

Ellis

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#39

OT - epoxy *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Epoxy first appeared on the retail market about the time my father owned his foreign car* dealership. One of the cars wound up with a cracked block that, for some reason, they couldn't return to the company, so my older brother inherited it as a fixer. This was a car with a two-stroke motor, so the crankcase operated under pressure. My brother researched for weeks, but managed to find an epoxy that repaired it successfully; he drove it for quite a while before someone totaled it in an accident.

*Borgward/Goliath/Lloyd until they went out of business, then a succession of oddball makes before giving it up and selling used cars for a few years, then getting out of that. Never heard of Borgward/Goliath/Lloyd? You're not alone. Info below. Great cars; finance issues.


About the cars

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#40

Well said, Ellis!

Stuart Hough

>

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#41

Amen

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Have two friends who are contractors. One seems to burn through tools like they're 8' spruce 2x4's, buys more when he can't find what he needs in the truck (or garage), and can't understand how I keep my stuff clean and adjusted. The other guy has fewer tools than the first (has only 1 or 2 of each), and rarely buys new stuff (aside from batteries). No. 1 is a good workman, quite demanding on quality control. No. 2 is a fine craftsman whose stuff is scuffed and worn but in perfect running/use condition; he cuts hair-line miters in moldings with a 7-1/2" Hitachi SCMS that looks like it's been through a war.

I've occasionally borrowed this or that from each and I always return the tool charged and/or cleaner (and a little sharper) than when I got it, but No. 2 cautions me not to mess with any adjustments.

I use my table saw to "hold" stuff all the time so scratches I have by the score. But it's tuned to a gnat's eyelash (without sequins for you Ponders), and, while you'll see discolorations in the iron, you won't find any rust on the working surfaces, and every edge is eased.

mm

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#42

Tools for using, tools for showing off

BobS

>I had a guy come to my shop one day to look at a jointer I had for sale and he spent 45 minutes measuring every possible edge, surface and angle with straightedges, calipers and feeler gages. In the end he decided the tool just wasn't straight, flat or square enough for the quality of work he does.

When I bought the jointer used a few years earlier I asked the owner to turn it on, thats all, and I have been using it since with no fine tuning of any sort. The quality of my work has not suffered with a fence that isn't quite square or a table that isn't quite flat. I know how far the tool can bring the work and at what point I need to take over and do the finish work.

The jointer is currently used as a store-all surface for anything I have in hand when entering the shop and I only clean it off if I need to use it.

And my workbench has hundreds of holes in it as well as router gouges and stain droppings and it is still a workbench and functions as well today as the day I bought it. To me it looks better than a brand new one all polished up and pretty as well.

Bob

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#43

Sounds Like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A guy who expect the tool to "do it for him", knows how to measure, but doesn't know how to tune a machine, and is more likely to "blame his tools" if something doesn't come out perfect. Jointers are pretty simple machines, and (unless damaged or defective) aren't that hard to get into dead-nuts adjustment for plumb and square. Sounds like you had a collector answer your ad.

Re: grrr...tablesaw table top problem

#44

Very well stated!

John in NM

>