Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT: Chinese products *LINK*

Posts

OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#1

OT: Chinese products *LINK*

GalenV in Iowa

>I know of the problems of lead paint in toys from China and then powdered milk formulas for babies. Seems more new problems are showing up every day.

I must have missed this one on Chinese drywall.

If this could effect 100,000 homes I would be afraid to buy a home in any of these areas. How do you know even in Iowa?

How many Wood Central members are caught up in this mess? Sounds like this is more in the Southern and Southeasterns states.

My brother lives in Gainsville, Florida in a fairly new home. Wonder how you test for this on your own?

Ken Oakley as a Florida'n has this affected anyone you know?

What next?

Galen


Chinese drywall

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#2

Re: OT: Chinese products

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I don't know anybody that has been affected but all the shyster lawyers in this area are advertising on TV that they will make people rich by suing every builder,supply house, trucking company, Chinese restaurant and laundry this side of the international dateline. I know a few local suppliers carried the junk so I imagine there are many houses in the area that have it as walls. So much for global markets.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: Chinese products

Jesper, Denmark

>Excerpts from the quoted articlee:

"American construction companies used millions of pounds of Chinese-made drywall because it was abundant and cheap."

"The process of "scrubbing" the smokestack emissions creates calcium sulfate, or gypsum, which can then used to make wallboard, experts say."

"But Michael Gardner, executive director of the U.S. Gypsum Association, said American manufacturers gather the gypsum from the smokestacks after the scrubbing, which produces a cleaner product."

So if we just look at those three quotes:

American companies bought the drywall. Did they not specify the quality? or did they just see the additional profits?

It is the scrubbing of the stack gases that creates the gypsum by a chemical reaction with the sulfur in the stack gases. So that the gypsum is collected after the scrubber is clear - as there is NO gypsum before the crubber - not in China, not in Canada or in USA or anywhere else for that matter.

Of the 350 quoted complaints, how many are me-too's, looking for their 60% of the potential pay-out? (Guess who takes the rest!)

If the supplier in question would have been a manufacturer in Topeka, KS, would AP have written the article this way? Not on your nelly, as they would have been sued the next businees day.

Ebenezer said it best: Bah, Humbug.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#4

Re: OT: Chinese products

Fred Davis

>My personal opinion of the Chinese culture does not extend to buying their products if I can possibly avoid it , which means in some cases doing without something , until I can find it elsewhere.

Since they have repeatedly demonstrated a non-caring approach to consumer safety, we really are kidding ourselves they have or would change without some serious consumer boycotting.

Their own people are dying in droves because of their political approach to mining, dam building, food production, so why would any thinking person expect them to to do any different in their trade relations with us or any other country.

And it is not confined to China , it seems to me , any Asian country left to their own devices without any oversight , deliver on a regular basis , shoddy products.

So I believe it is away past time for the American consumer to stand up and say , hell no, to offshore products that not only injure us, but also the low paid people in the country who are making them.

End of Rant

FredD

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#5

Re: OT: Chinese products

Jim Dillon

>Fred,

Bought any peanut butter/crackers lately? ;-) ;-)

Jim

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#6

Re: OT: Chinese products

Larry in NW Ohio

>Fred No Rant, just plain truth, and nothing but the truth. I`ve been saying this since I saw the first Made in "Insert nearly anyplace offshore" or accross the southern border. Larry

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#7

Re: OT: Chinese products

Larry in NW Ohio

>At least when things are made wrong and it`s made here, we can get it corrected and people put in jail alot easier. Larry

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#8

I bought a lot of drywall in 2007...

John in NM

>Fortunately, there is a manufacturing plant in Albuquerque, and you can just drive in and buy 2 sheets or 2 truckloads. Great outfit to deal with, supports local economy, and cheaper than Home Depot by about a buck a sheet - even cheaper for green board and some of the less common stuff.

From what I've heard so far, the Chinese drywall might not be a problem in more arid climates than Florida's.... I'm still wondering how free sulfur or Hydrogen Sufide ended up in drywall, I thought it was made with a slurry of gypsum that was then pressed and dried.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#9

Re: OT: Chinese products

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>"And it is not confined to China , it seems to me , any Asian country left to their own devices without any oversight , deliver on a regular basis , shoddy products."

Make that "ANY country left to their own devices without any oversight", and that surely includes a lot of schmucks here in the U.S.. As was mentioned, ate any peanut butter lately? And how about those unregulated financial markets? No, I feel that the Chinese and whoever else we are buying from are just following the requirements setup by the importers. And the requirement is to make it cheaper. If we had not been gutting so many of our regulations in the past 8 or so years we would not have nearly as many problems as we do. The beauty of the Chinese justice system is that when someone does something like put Melamine in baby formula they quickly try them, shoot them and then harvest their organs. Hmmm... Maybe we should outsource some of our criminal justice to China?

This is why we need nice sharp teeth in our watchdogs.

Joe

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#10

Re: OT: Chinese products

Fred Davis

>I don't partake of peanut butter unless some nice lady has hidden it in some cookies, but my wife was sweating it for a while. ;-))

FredD

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#11

Human greed kills (close to home)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>My wife and I have taught Sunday School at our church for many years with an very dear older gentleman. He and his wife were healthy and active in our church.

She became ill a couple of years ago after a local chemical company dumped some toxic chemicals not too far from their neighborhood. We followed the news and lawsuit closely after she became ill and became almost a sick emotionally as she was sick physically.

She died last year.

It could have been avoided. It didn't have to happen. And instead of help during this, they faced a huge fight... a huge fight with people who were protecting their profits.

We were disgusted and how little value is given to human life when greed and profits are at stake. This wasn't half-way around the world.... this was less than 50 miles from here..... Caused by people who should have been tried for criminal negligence and manslaughter instead of protecting their profits and shareholders.

Human greed kills...... it's absolutely and utterly sickening.

I see him every Sunday, and my hearts still weeps for them.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#12

Well said, Joe

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#13

To those who are bashing Chinese manufacturing

wilbur

>Chinese factories completely have the ability to make safe products for the consumer. What we here in the US forget is that China and other Asian countries also make products for the European Union, which has much more stringent regulations on consumer products than we do here in the US, and they have no problems meeting those regulations.

In fact, in many Chinese factories, there are two sets of nearly identical products coming out of them. One set is more reliably safe for the consumer. Guess which set goes to Europe, and which set comes to our shores.

Ironically, China has also been regularly sending delegations to the EU to observe and learn from how the EU sets up environmental oversight, and actually has more stringent requirements for hazardous materials in consumer electronic products made for their own market than the US does.

In other words, the MP3 player that is made in China for the Chinese market could very well have less lead in it than the MP3 player that comes to the US. Why? Because we here in the US do not demand it.

So whose fault is that?

And if anyone wants to talk about the melamine issue, consider this: the current food safety record of the US is actually worse than China's, and the people in China responsible for the melamine contamination are facing life imprisonment and the death penalty. I doubt that Stewart Parnell, who said of salmonella-contaminated peanuts in a Peanut Corporation of America plant located here in the US, that he "desperately at least need[s] to turn the raw [salmonella-contaminated] peanuts on our floor into money," has to worry about those possibilities.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#14

Re: OT: Chinese products

Jim Dillon

>Fred,

Good to hear, good to hear! I'm hoarding my year-old jar of peanut butter, just in case. Peace.

Jim

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#15

bashing Chinese manufacturing - two sides

north of the border

>There're actually two sides here: 1) China produces inferior or unsafe goods because importers in North America ask for it, in the name of lower costs. Of course, importers do so because we consumers support it by ditching more expensive but quality goods whether it's imported or made in N.A. in favor of 'dollar store' quality items. We, consumers, are as guilty as the importers here. 2) But that's only half of the story. The other half is many Chinese producers do export goods not meeting the specifications they undertake to meet. Quality control is not properly done or followed (corruption in China is still prevalent) and the blame falls squarely on them - not the importers or consumers. Japanese products in 50 and 60s were known for their imitation but of poor quality. It took them some 20, 30 years to take the lead in making quality products and China certainly needs more time and investment to get there. As for the drywall problem, we should get to the root of the issue and find out if it's a scenario under (1) or (20.

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#16

Re: OT: Chinese products

del schisler

>here in port st. lucie fla Their are lot's of houses in a couple big sub division that has lot's of houses that are going to be strip of all drywall It has made some sick It is turning copper wire green and i guess doing some mold problum also Sure is going to be a mess And i wonder who is going to be getting their money back Some one is going to go broke over this The contractor the supplyer distributor ect Goes a long way back to try and collect what a mess

Re: OT: Chinese products *LINK*

#17

Whew! We are Lucky

Mike Fitterling

>Just checked the drywall we used in the addition. It was Gold Bond from National Gypsum and is manufactured in the US (actually have a plant in Apollo Beach, maybe 40 miles from here). FWIW National Gypsum,on their web site, claims that all their products are made in the US and not the troubled product.