Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Posts

OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#1

OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

studio e artworks

>Just got a converter box and discovered that my current OTA antenna is not going to work for digital signals. I'm in a BLUE zone so I need a directional and probably amplified antenna.

Wondering if anyone has their own antenna experience they would share, and/or antenna recommendations.

thanks

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#2

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

>No specifics - except that last fall over the course of several weeks I bought (and returned!) EVERY model of antenna that I could buy at Best Buy, Circuit City (there I am dating myself), and Target.

My conclusions were that the whatever non amplified $60 (!!!) antenna that I have now worked the best. The best feature of the DTV converter box that I use is that you can display the signal strength in real time and just move the antenna around to maximize the signal. We have favorite positions for the various stations we watch.

The one I have is a flat white box - like a thick magazine. We hang in on the wall and it kind of disappears (white walls).

I found amplified antennas made NO difference, and that cost was not a determining factor in performance. Trial and error, and error, and error...

I checked return policies before buying several models of these things.

Sorry this is not specific advice, but there are so many variables that I am afraid you will be subject to the same process I went through.

Henry

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#3

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Kelly Anderson

>Any antenna should work. I was using simple rabbit ears with a converter box and it worked well. I got tired of changing the direction/placement of it though so I went to my local Radio Shack and got a roof mount antenna and put it in my attic because I did not want to have to go to the trouble of mounting it. It works great, improved the signal of the weaker channels, and now I don't have to move anything when I change channels. I would think that they would have antennas that will work in your area.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#4

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

David Hammelef

>First question. Have you been to Antennaweb.org ?

Which box did you buy, some do not have as good a tuner as others.

Personally I second the recommendation to put a nice antenna in your attic I also have an amplifier on mine. But it all depends on where you are, what you currently have, geography in your area (topography) ect.. ect...

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#5

NM why not do FTA satalite ??

del schisler

>do a google search and go from their I have been doing a couple yrs now

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#6

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience? *LINK*

John McGaw

>For OTA digital my experience is not wide but when it comes to antennas in general I can claim fairly extensive experience. There is really no difference for digital or old-style TV: you need an antenna that covers the frequency band, when the frequency is high (UHF) you really want to have line-of-sight, the antenna should be high enough to do the job, and the transmission line between the antenna and receiver needs to be of the absolute best quality you can manage.

At my location I have the problem of way too much signal for most channels and almost none for others so my experience here probably doesn't represent the majority. For my mom's antenna up in PA I chose a Winegard HD 7695P which should prove sufficient since there actually is reception using a "Radio Shack special" and primitive mast-mounted preamp that I put up in 1975 or thereabouts. I'll be going up to install the new antenna later this month and will replace the old coax with new quad-shield RG6. I will make allowance for the possibility that the preamp will be needed but won't install it initially.

After much research I decided that Winegard was my best bet. Their 76 series has a good reputation and is fine for the new digital standards since it works optimally for the high VHF (7-13) and UHF bands where the new broadcasts live. This makes the antenna a bit narrower since it doesn't have to deal with the low VHF any more. The use of quad-shield RG6 is a sort of no-brainer -- it is the least lossy cable that an amateur can sensibly deal with. That and the fact that I have hundreds of feet of it, the best quality Snap-N-Seal connectors, and the requisite stripper, flaring tool, and connector application tool.

After a lot of shopping around I bought the antenna from Solid Signal and had them drop ship it to Pennsylvania. It sure wasn't going to fit into my Miata for me to drive it north myself.


Solid Signal

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#7

FTA in US is VERY limited

David Hammelef

>The Major networks scramble their signals, If you want to hack a box you can, but in North America the channels available in FTA are very limited.

At least thats what a coworker who looked into it told me.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#8

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Lee Schierer - Mckean, PA

>You should not need any more antenna than you needed to get conventional TV signals. The FCC has not allowed most stations to go to full power on digital signals until the new cut in date which is sometime in June or July. We purchased a Direct TV converter for use with our satellite system. It receives all the channels and also integrates the program guide so you can record programs with the DVR. We get all our local signals, but a couple get iffy if the weather is really bad due to signal attenuation. With the Direct TV box, you have to make sure your channel selection shows all channels you receive or it won't show the channels that are available.

Lee

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#9

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

steve mackay

>In-laws have a cabin in Creede, CO. Its tucked deep in the San Juan valley and shoot almost straight up. Don't even get radio. The standard antenna works fine. I'd suspect something else.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#10

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

GalenV in Iowa

>Up until the first deadline change for DTV the only thing that was promoted was the DTV converter boxes and that you could get the government assistance in purchase. After the old deadline things seemed to change.

Now they say you may need a new antenna if yours is an "older style", what ever that was to mean. Then added you may need to point it in a new direction and add an amplifier. Next your wiring may need an upgrade.

Who pays for all that?

My 85 year old mother is in an area that they now say will most likely need everything upgraded for her antenna system.

I have cable and first they said you need to do nothing and now I am told I will lose channels but they MAY add a new package at a higher price.

An all this in the name of progress and efficiency.

Yep!

Wonder if I can get any "old signals" on a crystal radio and forget DTV. Anyone ever build one or am I just too old?

Galen

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#11

Very suspicious

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I suspect there is marketing afoot here. Those of us "in the know" about electronics and RF are aware that there is nothing different between digital and analog with respect to getting RF from the ether into the viewing device. If there are different frequencies involved, maybe, but TV antennas are (and always have been), by necessity, very broad band devices, whether dipoles (rabbit ears) or directional (LPDA—log periodic dipole array). If the digital signals are in (or even near) the frequency ranges covered by the old TV channels 2-13 (VHF) and 14-83 (UHF), the old antennas should work just fine (assuming little deterioration).

I actually came up with a similar marketing scam scheme back in 1976 (or thereabouts) when the FCC mandated the increase in the CB channels from 23 to 40. I thought I could dupe entice a whole bunch of suckers customers into buying new antennas for their new 40 channel radios (the FCC had also taken the Draconian step of making existing stocks of 23 channel radios illegal for sale for CB use on the effective date of the new channels, thus compounding the effect of my plan). Interestingly, much of that obsolete stock was very convertible into inexpensive radios for the Amateur 10 Meter band, and a lively market developed for awhile.

Fortunately or unfortunately, however you look at it, I never got around to doing anything about the antennas. Probably my conscience.

Rod

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#12

Re: Very suspicious

GalenV in Iowa

>Rod

Yah I have never heard anyone say that the digital signal will be carried on a frequency that is near what the element length of the older antenna. I have long forgotten what the element lengths are in relation to full wave or what fractional wave of each frequency.

I know in the days before cable we lived about 20 miles from the three major stations towers and we had to point our antenna in the oposite direct of where the towers were. The reflected signal from the city water tower created a ghost image if pointed towards the TV tower. So we picked up the reflected signal from the water tower.

Mom still has the old flat twin lead, rotor antenna and booster. Think she could still get the old I Love Lucy or Ed Sullivan shows if the signals are still out there in space. :>)

Galen

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#13

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

David Hammelef

>Sort of true. Some have been running their full power Digital signal for over a year. Depends on where you are. Also most but not all stations digital channels will be on UHF even if they were a VHF station. The Station number will no longer correspond to the broadcast channel. So if you had received poor UHF signals before you might be in trouble.

But again all of the details really really depend on where you are located.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#14

Re: Very suspicious

David Hammelef

>Some / Most VHF stations will be broadcasting in the UHF range when they switch to Digital(Should have said when they did as all are now broadcasting in both).

So if you did not have a good UHF antenna you might need a new one and possibly an amp.

First thing, Hook up the converter box to the existing setup run the scan and see what you get.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#15

The best alternative

Dan Donaldson

>I have the best alternative. Guaranteed to work. A few years ago, we canceled all of our TV. No cable, no off the air, no satellite. Ended up with a lot more time during the day and less expense also. ;-)

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#16

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

studio e artworks

>yes ... been to both antennaweb.org and tvfool.com to check antenna requirements -- alas, where i'm located, the tv towers are all far away and with lots of things to block signals (church towers and coastal range).

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#17

Re: The best alternative

studio e artworks

>dan, i'm almost there and have been for years -- but i do like my pbs (TOH, NYW, VG, and Julia, etc.)

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#18

Re: The best alternative

jacomb

>Heres what I did, I returned the first box to RCA, no good. I bought a new box from Radio shack. I have a good antenna, 100 mile range, mounted 12 ft above my second story roof, with a booster, good coaxial. I've had the antenna and booster for years, we get analog great, but with digital its hit or miss. If the weather condions are right I recieve signals from two major markets at the same time without changing directions of the antenna.One is 70 miles south and the other is 100 miles north. Just use the signal meter built into the converter box to adjust your antenna direction.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#19

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Dale Stansbery

>Since you said you're in a blue zone and your existing antenna doesn't cut it, then you'll at least need to put an amp up at the output of the antenna, and maybe even a new antenna if your old one isn't in top condition. You may also want to get the antenna up on a tower if it's not already. You should determine if the stations you'll be watching are going to end up in the channel 7 on up bands. That will allow you to get an antenna that is physically narrower since channels 2 through 6 are the longest elements of your current antenna and may no longer be needed. There's a ton of info on the web free for Googling it. You can also stack two identical antennas on your tower and run their signal into an amp if you really have weak signals. Again Google "stacked tv antennas". I've found that Solidsignal.com has the best prices on rotors and antennas. I'm in the process up upgrading and chose the the Winegard HD 7698P Antenna. Either the best Winegard or Channel Master amps that run about $80 will work.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#20

thanks, everyone, for the info and feedback

studio e artworks

>should be interesting to see what changes take place in reception after the changes june 12th

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#21

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Larry in NW Ohio

>Yes I built a couple of crystal radios way back when, about 1962. Boy those where very interesting. I also had a speech give me a speech synthesizer, as I remember,of course it was very crud, and didn`t work very well. Ah yes those were the days. Larry

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#22

Interesting replies from TV engineers

studio e artworks

>All TV stations in SF have their transmitters mounted on Mt. Sutro tower. The engineers replied to my inquiry about DTV signal strength with information about what changes will take place AFTER June 12th.

They will raise their antenna 5-10ft higher on the tower. AND they will increase signal strength. Currently, NO DTV signals will make it over the coastal ranges to the inner Bay Area until these changes are completed.

Therefore, there's no reason yet to get a new antenna -- they reported that it's probably not going to make much difference to reception at this point in time.

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#23

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

Don Evans

>I have not read all the responses to you question, but as a former TV Engineer let me say this.

Remember the old TV's with a manual tuner? They had channels 2 through 13 on them and another knob with UHF channels with hardly stations on UHF.

Well here is the big surprise for most people DTV IS NOTHING BUT, drum roll here, UHF.....

The 2 through 13 channels are VHF. All of the hoopla is to free up the frequencies being used on the VHF range so new electronic gizmo's will have frequencies for there use.

Remember the TV antenna's with aluminum rods sticking out both sides and they get longer from front to back? But on the front of them is a section that is "V" shaped. That "V" shape is the UHF part of the antenna and the long rods behind them are the VHF part of the antenna.

For DTV all you need is that "V" part on front, UHF is UHF and the new signal called DTV is UHF. There is nothing new about that part of it. Now here comes the hard part to teach in writing. Many factors affect signals. Distance, weather, terrain. Logically, the further you are from the stations antenna, then placing your antenna higher and putting up a larger one may become necessary. But you don't need a "special DTV" antenna. There is nothing special about them except the price. An antenna has to be 'tuned' to the frequencies they are to receive for best results. In TV antenna's this is done with the length of the rods, that is a very simple statement for a very complicated event.

When I went to buy my first HDTV that was one of the things the sales guy hit me with, you'll need a special DTV antenna he said to which I replied (can't say that here).

I've got outside antenna, still using one I have with old TV type, satellite TV (dishnetwork), and cable. Outside antenna has the best picture on over the air digital signal, but SAT runs close second and cable (not digital) isn't worth watching.

What the engineers were saying is that their signal isn't going into the valley you live in. It is shooting too high over your roof. Basically the signal is missing you and nothing you can do will help that. When they raise their antenna it will start hitting your location. It's just interesting that it is only going to take 10 feet to make the difference but you can bet they have spent a lot of time and money to prove that before going to all the red tape and paper work it took for them to get permission to do this raising. So you'll have to wait and see and make sure you have an outside antenna that has the "V" on the front end, no all of them did because there just were not many UHF stations so to make antenna cost less many were made without that section.

Don

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#24

Line of sight

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>UHF are basically line of sight. If your antenna can't see the broadcasting antenna you won't get the signal. With a digital signal you either get it or you don't weak signals don't mean a fuzzy picture, they just don't compute so you get no picture.

I also spoke to a local station engineer and he was quite clear that the FCC has not authorized most stations to broadcast at full power on the new UHF bands they will occupy once the transition is complete. Only selected stations around the country were authorized to broadcast full strength the others have to wait for the new transition date.

I am currently in a questionable reception zone for the new signals. I have a 30 year old standard al channel TV antenna mounted in my attic that still looks like the day it was taken out of the box. I went to the antenna website noted by other posters and found the location of the local stations relative to my home. I aligned the antenna to point directly at the majority of the stations with a compass. Signal strength is sufficient to get a clear digital signal from all of them. Picture quality is superior to the former analog signals from those same stations.

Lee

Re: OT- Anyone with DTV Antenna experience?

#25

VHF

Jerry Nicholson

>It is my understanding that about 100 digital stations are (or will be) broadcasting on VHF, both VHF Low and VHF High. I know that 3 stations in the Wichita Kansas area are broadcasting digital on VHF High. Two of them had temporary UHF channel assignments for DTV prior to the February changeover. I assume that other services are being allowed to share the VHF spectrum.

Jerry