Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
Ed Beck
>Does anyone have a recommendation for a benchtop drill press or band saw? I don't have room for full size ones.
Thanks,
Ed Beck
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
Ed Beck
>Does anyone have a recommendation for a benchtop drill press or band saw? I don't have room for full size ones.
Thanks,
Ed Beck
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
John K Jordan
>I've had a Delta drill press for many years that has served me fine. One thing to consider is the quill depth - my benchtop will not drill as deep a hole as my floor Delta.
I've never seen a benchtop bandsaw that wasn't a whimpy little thing with a toy motor. Due to the need for a wheel below the working surface, you are limited to small wheels with a limited throat. A three-wheel bandsaw will give more working room, but they are harder on blades (with the tighter turning radius) and most seem to be cheaply made. For the bandsaw, I'd try to find room in the shop for a floor model, even if I had to shorten a workbench or something. You can also put it on wheels to pull it out for use.
JKJ
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
A Wright
>You should think about what you need the bandsaw for - benchtop bandsaws have very limited capabilities (small throat, small motor, no resaw capability), and I suspect you will will be disappointed in whatever you buy. I would either figure out how to put a 14" bandsaw in your shop or invest ina good jigsaw.
As far as drill presses, I have a 12" bechtop Craftsman that is about 10 years old and have never had an issue with it.
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
Charlie Self
>I've got a Ryobi benchtop drill pess that is heavy as a horse and works just fine. I am like the others in not believing a benchtop bandsaw is going to be satisfactory, but Sears has recently come out with a 12" bandsaw on a stand that might work. It's a 3/4 horse. Now, I have NO experience with this saw, but it does look pretty good, the specs (HP and 7" depth of cut) could do light resawing.
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Morning Ed,
I bought a used Delta 12 inch Drill Press and cleaned it up for #1 son. Very nice tool which will last a lifetime. I also looked at a Ryobi of similar size at the orange Borg. It semed to be worth looking at.
My #3 son was given an ancient Penncraft bench top radial press, which he uses almost every day in his contracting business. It is massive, and there is no discernable deflection. Look at the used market too. There is some good stuff out there as well as junk.
George
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
James Fox
>I've had a Ryobie benchtop drill press for 2 years and it has had given good service for the money. What I like best is the speed adjustment with just the shift of a lever...no belt to mess with.
Had a benchtop bandsaw...sold it as quickly as I could. Save up for a 14 in floor model.
James
Inca bandsaw
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>Inca bandsaws are a three wheel bench top machine with a great reputation. I'm not sure if they are still imported but their reitively high resale price is a testament of how highly they are regarded.
Robon
Agree 100%
John E in SC
>I used to have a 3-wheel Craftsman benchtop band saw when I was first starting out. Yeah, I made some stuff with it, but man was that thing aggravating. Had cheap plastic wheels, and the blades were always coming off or breaking. (And you almost had to have 8 hands to get the blade back on!) Also had a very small table with poor workpiece support. I don't think I've been happier to see any other tool in my shop "go away" that that one, when I finally was able to upgrade to a floor model Grizzley. The difference is night and day. I still have a benchtop Delta drill press, which I would like to upgrade just because of the limited quill depth and limited table depth, but so far I've been able to work around it's limitations to do everything I wanted to do. Haven't been able to justify that upgrade just yet.
Bottom line, don't waste your money on a benchtop bandsaw if you'll be using it AT ALL.
John
Thanks - No benchtop Band Saw for me
Ed Beck
>The reasons that were cited are pretty much the reasons why I don't have a benchtop band saw, all the ones I looked at had too many limitations. I'll hold out for a full sized band saw.
Thanks for the recommendations on the drill press.
Ed
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
Nick Tuzzolino
>Had a 3 wheel benchtop bandsaw. Eventually GAVE it away.
Stick to the brand name your trust
Bricofleur
>Ed,
In 1972 I bought this Delta (was named Rockwell back then) and it still doing its job. No complain except the fact there is no crank to lift the table.
If you look closely on the picture, you will see the benchtop Delta radial drill press I bought few years ago. It doesn't have a crank either. Therefore, I have full confidence in Delta.
Again, look closely on the picture and you will see the Delta 14" band saw I bought two years ago to assist the old 10" Rockwell band saw I bought in the '70s also. And this late is still running. I only changed the upper trust bearing once.
In few final words, stick to a brand you fully trust. And check if you can easily get accessories for the one you will be choosing.
Best,
Serge
www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com
Good decision
Bricofleur
>Good decision.
Best,
Serge
The Absence of a Crank Can Be A Blessing
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Serge,
Just ask my neighbor, who married one.
George
Really?
John E in SC
>I hated mine so bad by the time I got rid of it, I didn't know anybody I didn't like enough to give it to! I took the (wimpy) motor and chord off, (who knows- may come in handy one day!), and trashed the rest. Probably should have busted it up with a sledge hammer just to make myself feel better.... :)
John
Re: Inca bandsaw
Hank Knight
>I'm a fan of Inca machines. That said, I had an Inca 710 3-wheel bandsaw with a 20" throat. Although it sat on a base above the floor, I wouldn't call it a "bench top" saw - it was a big machine. I didn't like it. I never could get the shakes out of mine so I sold it and bought a big Laguna. My dad had the smaller two-wheel 10" Inca bandsaw (I can't remember the model number - 510 maybe?). I liked it better than my big three wheeler. The capcity was limited to resawing 6 to 8" and the throat was 10" (all from memory which may be faulty - usually is). But it ran very smooth, was very precise and was capable of some pretty heavy work. Mark Duginske has (had?) one and there are photos of it in his bandsaw book. It is a true bench top and in my opinion they're the best small bandsaw around - if you can find one. Inca went under years ago so they're not imported anymore, although I think Inca was trying to get started back up in Europe a while back. I don't know the status of that.
My$.02.
Hank
Re: The Absence of a Crank Can Be A Blessing
Bricofleur
>I like it George !!!!
Best,
Serge
www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com
Yup ! . . .
steve mackay
>I throw my benchtop DP around from table to bench and back, no sweat. The BS would be a different story. Pretty ungainly. And the smaller ones are awfully "light duty".
Re: Really?
John K Jordan
>>I didn't know anybody I didn't like enough to give it to!
>...Probably should have busted it up with a sledge hammer
I do that with really bad books (although the sledge hammer is not needed) to make sure no one else somehow gains possession and suffers like I did. I actually got out of the car while on a ferry at the Outer Banks once and threw a book in the trash can.
JKJ
Re: Benchtop Drill Press / Band Saw
Jerry Gibbs
>i have a second workshop on the deck of out FL trailer. I have a Tradesman 9" bandsaw I bought used for $50 and it is worth it. Not haveing a table or radial arm saw will drive you nuts when you want to cut parallel and straight lines. I have a Grizzly DP which works fine. The issue is depth of cut, especially with a longer shaft forstner bit. I like the Grizzly products and their service is great. The quill depth is something you have to look closely and make a decision. Jerry Gibbs