Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Posts

OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#1

OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Barry Irby

>I have posted about this before, but it has come up again. I have a 2003 Honda CRV. The battery started giving me trouble and the dealer replaced it in 2005. (It would go dead if the car sat for a few days.) The problem started up again and they replaced the battery again in 2007. Each time they checked for sacrificial or parasitic draw and found them to be in the "normal" range. The car sat over the week end and Monday the batter was dead again. (Visualize me out there in the snow, cleaning off the car, hooking up the battery charger, pacing while it charged enough to start.) I made a trip to the vets office and then to the dealer. Left it running for maybe 45 minutes. The dealer tells me I have 460 cold cranking amps and that's good for that battery and car. If I want to leave the car for two or three days, they will check it again. Of course I am not prepared to leave it.

This is also the car that sometimes when you get out, the key is hot. Won't burn you, but hot enough to notice it on my leg through the pocket. Dealer says that is normal, they all do that. (I never noticed it on any other car.)

So, my question is, Take it back and pay them to do their mumbo jumbo and tell me there is no problem? Or buy a heavier duty battery and keep on truckin'? (The battery in it appears about 2/3's the size of the tray. Could it be that these are just crappy new car batteries?)

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#2

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Ralph Lipeles

>How about installing a battery disconnect switch to get rid of the immediate dead battery problem. Then, when time permits, disconnect fuses/circuit breakers one by one and hopefully you will isolate where the problem is.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#3

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Barry Irby

>If you disconnect the battery for more than a few seconds it a PITA. The radio loses it's preset buttons and other stuff I can't think of "goes away". One sort of weird one is the drivers window has "Auto up" and "Auto Down". When the battery goes dead or nearly dead the auto function goes away. The button will still open the window, but not with the Auto function. A minor thing, but I like the Auto function. I was taking it back tot he dealer and having them reset it. I discovered by accident (procrastination) that if you just wait a few days it resets itself. Strikes me as odd that it takes a day or two but it does.

I have rechargeable flash lights in the car. (I'm a Home Inspector and use them in my work. Cop lights.) Dealer tries to blame them. But, they have been in every car I have owned for the last 25 years. Never bother any of the others and some of them were Hondas.

It seems to me that this is one of two things. The car has some intermittent problem that draws the battery down and no one has found it yet. The other possibility is that these are really crappy batteries and they just wear out after two years.

I am going to try to remember to remove the flashlights next time i leave the car sitting for a couple of days to see if that solves the problem.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#4

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

paul in AZ

>If it comes to replacing the battery, go to Costco. They will replace for up to 3 years without prorating for the "expected" life. They just give you a new one in exchange. They're also cheaper.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#5

A couple of questions

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>Barry is there an Automotive electrical specialty shop in you area, with a good rep. Try them not the dealer. Can you figure out a pattern, we had a jeep that would, for no apparent reason, have the battery die. We turned everthing off in the car, pulled the + battery cable off and put an amp meter between the positive post on the battery and the positive side of the the cable. The meter showed a current draw, we pulled fuses one at a time until the draw went away. It turned out that the rear window defroster relay was sticking. Quite using that feature for awhile and it confirmed the problem.

glc

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#6

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Curly Smith

>If your key is getting hot then you've got a short somewhere in the ignition system. A quick pull of the appropriate fuse might confirm the problem and, if so, a kill switch tied to the ignition is an easy fix. In addition to being an anti-theft device, it wouldn't kill your radio presets or other system devices since they aren't tied to the ignition.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#7

Re: A couple of questions

Bill Howatt

>Gary has outlined the procedure you need to follow to trouble-shoot it yourself. Since this has happened at various times it appears to be the worst of worst, an intermittent fault. Does it only happen in the winter when you do perhaps use a rear-window defroster or other typical winter accessory?

I had a 78 Camaro and it suffered the occasional dead-battery problem. One day I heard a click every few seconds while standing by the car. It was a thermal circuit breaker clicking opening and then cooling off and resetting for the power window circuit. I fixed the problem (can't remember if it was a bad relay or wire) and put a fuse in series with the thermal breaker so it would blow rather than open/reset if it happened again.

Electrical problems are a difficult thing to find sometimes and I notice garages in our area charge more per hour for electrical problems. When my father had a garage he used to hate them - "How do you spend hours chasing a problem then charge $$ for wrapping a piece of tape around a wire?". Of course, these days, 50 years later they will charge you $200 for wrapping a piece of tape on a wire - and so they should. However, I agree that you need to go to specialized electrical shop, I have found a lot of mechanics have a pretty primitive understanding of electrical stuff.

Bill

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#8

Barry, try this...

Stuart Hough

>Next time you take it to the dealer, have them leave the key in the switch, in the off position, and then test the circuit. I surmise what you have is a faulty ignition switch. It may be that when you pull the key, some internal part is not disconnecting and thus causing the battery draw-down. Good luck!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#9

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hey Barry,

The intermittent problems are always the hardest to chase down. This could be a continuation of your previous issues or it could be weather related.

Here's some info on lead acid Battery Charge vs. Temperature.This is from "Pocket Ref" compiled by Thomas J. Glover.

Degrees F = % Charge

80 = 100% charge

50 = 82% charge

30 = 64% charge

20 = 58% charge

10 = 50% charge

0 = 40% charge

-10 = 33% charge

-20 = 18% charge

The other thing you could do yourself is the ammeter in the postive cable. If you have a VOM it probably has a 10Amp scale, plenty for this application. Of course, when you take the cable loose to put in the ammeter, you could be resetting whatever relay is sticking to cause your problem. I suspect that is what is happening at the dealer.

We used to use a shunt which allowed hooking up the ammeter and then switching the circuit through it without ever disconnecting the hot wire completely from the battery.

Gary

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#10

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Barry, I own a 2003 Honda CRV. For what it's worth:

1. The first battery on this car died in 2008 - after a five year life. This is a bit short, but not so short that I'd complain.

2. The original battery was weak and went dead twice between 2006 and 2008, caused by leaving the lights on for ~10 minutes while we were sitting in the car. This is unusual in my experience.

3. Our battery completely fills the battery tray. I'm not sure the CCA, but it was around the 460 mark.

4. Our ignition key does not get hot.

Good luck.

Steven

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#11

Trailer hook-up?

Mark Goodall - ATL- tooljunkie

>I'm sure it's already been eliminated as a possibility, but I thought I'd mention this.

A friend of ours had a similar battery problem... fine for a month, then draining to empty overnight requiring a boost in the morning, fine for a few weeks, dead overnight, etc.

She took it to several (3 I think) automotive garages, who replaced the battery, tested the charging system, and ran all sorts of tests.... every few months the same deal. No one could find a problem. Certified mechanics using sophisicated diagnostic devices.

She described it to me, so I looked at it. Found one of those electronic taillight T-converters used for connecting to a trailer. All looked fine visually, but for kicks I removed the whole darn thing.

It's worked perfectly ever since.

What I can't understand is how half a dozen certified mechnics couldn't figure that out.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#12

Steven and Mark.....

Barry Irby

>I don't have a trailer hitch. The only "after Market" thing I have added is the flashlights. I really don't believe they are the problem.

If my battery had lasted five years I would have been pretty happy and just bought another. I've had three in about five years. Not happy.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#13

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Alex Grigoriev

>Regarding ignition key overheating, I know there was a recall for different Honda models (Accord). I wonder if your Honda CRV also has the same problem.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#14

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Ronald from NW Ohio

>Take it to the honda dealer and if it is there problem they should fix it free. I worked and retired from honda at the east liberty plant in ohio.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#15

Just found a Honda Bulletin.....

Barry Irby

>Sadi the key being warm was normal. Still Don't know wnat the problem is, Back to the dealer.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#16

Re: Just found a Honda Bulletin.....

Ronald from NW Ohio

>Good Idea!!!!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#17

Flashlights? We've come a long way, baby.

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"The only "after Market" thing I have added is the flashlights"

Is that some sort of rechargable flashlight that plugs into the cigarette lighter? I'm assuming you've disconnected that to ensure that's not causing the problem.

On a recent trip, I asked my kids to plug in an extra phone charger into the "cigarette lighter outlet in the back". My kids had absolutely no idea what I was talking about.... they didn't know what a "cigarette lighter" was...... our van has an "12-volt accessory outlet". They've never really even seen much cigarette smoking in their lives, thankfully. I can remember being trapped in a car for an hour in the winter with all the windows closed tight with my Dad smoking. We've come a looong way baby!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#18

Re: Just found a Honda Bulletin.....

Ed O'Neill

>Barry, I had a luxury van years ago and had a sililiar problem that was driving me nuts. The dealer was also shaking his head. It took an EE friend to figure it out. The vanity mirror was staying on when it was shut and in the upright position so we could never see any light. The draw from the mirror light was enough to kill my battery every three days. Look in the most unusual places for the draw. Hope this might help. Ed

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#19

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Until you find the problem you may wish to invest in one of those jump start battery thing with cables. It can recharge from AC or the cigar lighter and if you keep it in the house it will be warm with a full charge.

I have a 2K Tahoe with the same problem, looking for the cause has ceased to be fun, I wish you luck.

Bill

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#20

I took it back tot he Dealer, over night

Barry Irby

>They insist it is the Maglite that rides in the car, wired to be hot all the time. I use it in my work and have found that it must be live all the time or it goes dead over time, because I don't drive enough to recharge it. It has been in every car (including other Hondas) I have owned over the last twenty five years. It is supposed to be a smart charger, only using enough current to recharge the flashlight. (Its a "cop light", every cop car has them)

Now they think its the fact that they gave me an undersized battery. The battery is about 2/3's the size of the tray. They suggest I buy a larger battery. For telling me this they want $92.

Buying a larger battery was my second choice. I was thinking that if these cheap dealer batteries were lasting two years, maybe a bigger one would last three or four. A couple of more batteries and I will be letting the car go.

And I do have a trickle charger. Maybe I should just put that on the battery about once a month.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#21

Please tell me

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Please tell me that you tried disconnecting the flashlight for a few weeks to make sure that wasn't the issue. Considering all the hassles you've had, this is definitely something I would do.

Electronics go bad. That trailer hitch module worked for years without a problem and then started causing a big problem.

Eliminate the flashlight from the equation if you haven't already. Just my 2 cents.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#22

Re: I've read about your problem

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>and all I can think about is the advice I learned from my Dad.

First thing is, you never own a battery. You only lease them, really. Seldom do they last as long as their 'warranty'.

Second is that you can definitely underspend on a battery. Buy the largest that will fit, with the most cold cranking amps that you can get. It WILL cost more, but the battery will take more abuse, more neglect, and last longer before it dies on you in the parking lot of a quilt store at 11 am.

I don't think it's your flashlight, but I don't have a dog in that fight. I also don't own a Honda, although my son does.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#23

Re: Please tell me

Barry Irby

>Yes, I did. At least I took the flashlights out and left the car for about four days. It was dead. I did not remove the chargers, but I don't have any reason to believe they have gone bad, other than the battery in the car dies. What I mean is, without the flashlights, the chargers don't draw any power. I do suspect that they are not very "smart". If there is any electronics in them, I don't see it. I think the smart part is that once the batteries reach equilibrium with the car battery they quit charging.

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#24

Not a safe assumption at all

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"... I did not remove the chargers, but I don't have any reason to believe they have gone bad, other than the battery in the car dies...."

The fact that they are plugged in, and you're having battery problems, is enough reason for me to remove them.

."... without the flashlights, the chargers don't draw any power...."

Yes, they certainly can.

"... I do suspect that they are not very "smart". If there is any electronics in them, I don't see it. I think the smart part is that once the batteries reach equilibrium with the car battery they quit charging...."

The chargers really don't have to be sophisticated to go wrong and cause the problem.

I can't guarentee that the flashlight charger is the problem, but I can guarentee that if you remove it you'll know for sure one way or the other. I've worked my whole life troubleshooting electronics and technology and I can tell you with certaintly that it's the things you assume can't go wrong are the things that will give you the most trouble.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Repeated Dead Car Battery?

#25

Re: Not a safe assumption at all

Howard Norman

>>it's the things you assume can't go wrong are the things that will give you the most trouble.<

Amen to that Mark. Back in my working days I can't remember how many times your statement turned out to be correct.