Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Posts

OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#1

OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Paul Leuba - Hunt Valley, MD

>I'm planning this summer to purchase and install a fireplace insert to help reduce our oil consumption for heating our 2 story 1,800 sq. ft. home.

I had pretty much settled on a pellet fireplace insert because of the convenience until I learned that the pellets are now selling for $360 a ton here in central Maryland. On an equivalent $/BTU basis, that is not less expensive than oil at current prices. I understand from local suppliers that there is a shortage of pellets due to the slump in the housing and furniture industries. Wood waste products are not as available as they were previously. The local forests still have plenty of firewood and at about $225 per cord it appears to be a wiser choice at this point. Every pellet stove sold will put more pressure on the demand side of a constrained supply situation.

What is the general sense of the community on the choice of pellets vs. split firewood given the supply situation?

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#2

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Larry in NW Ohio

>Paul I burnt wood since we bought a house in about 1975. If to do over and it was available I would go Ground thermal and if I had the time to recoup it I would still do it. I wouldn`t go through the hassle of firewood and the present administration when done you probably will not even be able to fart without being fined, now I don`t want to get anything started. But I would really look into GO thermal. Larry in Ohio

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#3

Corn ?

Basil

>Do they make a heater that will burn either/or wood pellets or corn?

With the failure of a few alcohol plants and other reasons, the price of corn is down somewhat per bushel from last years high. Corn supposedly burns clean with little to no ash to worry about. You'll want to check the BTU rating per bushel of course.

And some areas have already outlawed the burning of wood, I look for others to follow suit.

Me...I think I'll start burning stocks......LOL

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#4

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

steve mackay

>Just for what its worth. LOML's aunt sold me their "wood" stove and bought a pellet rig a couple years ago. They laid in a stock of pellets but it ran out 'bout mid-winter and they could'nt find any. They thought it had to do with demand for plywood or such. She lamented to me that she wished they had kept the stove. I figure I can always find SOMETHING to burn but they're limited.

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#5

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Gitche Gumee Kid

>You need electric power grid to be up and running. The recent ice storms across the center of the country caused folks to be without power for a week to ten days; Pellet stove --> no go.

GGK

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#6

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Sawman

>Paul,

SOmething you might want to consider is a coal stove. I started heating with coal this January. I am using a stoker furnace.

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#7

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I have a pellet stove but I am hoping to add a real woodstove this summer. Pellets are 250 ish a ton around here, I don't know the price of fire wood but I have 5 acres of Juniper that is in dire need of thinning and limbing so I think I will have 5 years supply with out going off site. I am doing pretty well on pellets this year, I am only on my second ton and I may make it through without out buying more. My biggest problem with the pellet stove, as somone else mentioned you must have some kind of power and you must have availability of fuel. With a wood stove you could "bust up the furniture" or at least burn your mistakes (I am assuming that you must make a few, for me that in it's self would be a ready supply of fire wood). By the way the green boys claim that biomass fuel is carbon neutral, they are trying to sell me on converting from propane at work and that along with price per btu is one of the selling points.

glc

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#8

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

GalenV in Iowa

>Paul

I assume you have first invested in trying to improve the insulation in you walls and ceiling. Your windows and doors are the best you can do to prevent heat loss. You get your best return for your money there.

You did not say the wood stove is for emergency heat just to cut heating cost. It varies a lot on your local alternate fuel cost but if you look at buying the stove and continue to purchase cut wood is it going to be as much as the added fuel oil cost?

I had a cast iron wood stove and if I acounted for the stove, installtion, cutting, hauling, splitting I probably did not save over reduced LP gas but it was also emergency heat being in an area with known power outages for days. With 2x6 walls and triple pane windows I could heat 2800 square feet, but it was a lot of wood.

Too old for that wood cutting and splitting now days!

Galen

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#9

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Paul Leuba - Hunt Valley, MD

>Thanks, everyone, for your perspective on this wood pellet vs. split firewood decision. I have gotten the house insulation and weather stripping in pretty good condition. It's not too tight, but I believe its at the point of diminishing returns.

I like water source ground thermal heat as well, but 2 years ago when I priced an installation the price of $20,000 was too much for me to swallow. I believe it is "the choice" for new construction.

Emergency back up is not too much of a concern for me because I do have an 8KW generator that covers the key living functions of the house: well, microwave, refrigerator, oil burner, lights, sump pump, etc. As long as I can get gasoline, I can keep the heat and lights on. It uses about 7 gallons in 10 hours.

My principal reason for considering the wood/pellet fireplace insert is to defray, somewhat, the rising cost of oil, and to provide a means to still heat the house for a period of time in the event that oil availability becomes a problem (weather, politics, etc.).

I'm a little to far from the corn belt to consider it as an alternative fuel, but if I was near the mid-West, it would be high on my list. I wouldn't even know where to get a ton of coal around here, let alone find a decent place to store it.

I'm leaning in the direction of going with split firewood logs. It's generally available and has reasonable cost. A wood burner, as pointed out in a previous message, would allow me to disappear my workshop mistakes pretty fast. This is not an insignificant factor.

Thanks All!

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#10

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

Curly Smith

>I've seen these advertised but haven't used one since I have more "free" wood than I can burn. If it actually works then it would give flexibility to a wood-burning stove/insert.

Prometheus Basket

from the website:

Baskets are sized to hold from 10 to 25 pounds of pellet fuel and will provide 2 to 12 hours of effective heat without refueling. Pellets start easily and burn with attractive flames in just minutes. Air flows through chamber dividers in the basket for a more efficient burn. The pellet fuel basket turns woodstove and fireplace owners into pellet fuel burners!

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#11

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

R. Gryder

>Paul,

My son recently installed a wood burning gasification system. Installation is pricey but provides lots of hot water and gets a lot of heat for the amount of wood burned. Give it a look. R.

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#12

Grond source heat pumps

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've heated my house for over 25 years with a groundsource heat pump. In fact we just replaced the old unit, even though it was still working witha combination heater air conditinioner. So far I am very impressed with the new unit. We turn on the A/C in July and ran it all summer, keeping the house at about 72 degrees. Our KW useage was exactly the same as the previous year running fans and a dehumidifier in the basement.

We heat & cool abour 2200 sq ft ranch style house in NW Pennsylvania. Our only utility is electric and we pay $130 per month. My system is a two well system and cost about $10,000 when we first installed it 25 years ago. Compared to baseboard electric we figure we broke even in about 5-7 years on the installation costs. Even thought the new unit is more efficient than the old one, it will take a long time to pay back the cost. I'm not sure we'll ever pay for the new unit we installed, except for being able to sleep, work in the shop, and do other things comfortably when it is 90 degrees outside. Of course as the cost of utilities go up, and they will, our payback period gets shorter.

Lee

Lee

Re: OT Wood Pellets vs. Split Firewood

#13

Re: Grond source heat pumps

Paul Leuba - Hunt Valley, MD

>Lee, that is a terrific energy arrangement you have with the ground source heat pump.

A couple years ago I got an estimate of $20,000 from a local contractor. The greater portion was for installing the outdoor "radiator" in the ground. MD does not allow using a ground water source, so the systems are all closed loop systems using the ambient ground temperature for a heat/cooling sink.

I understand that the savings are still substantial, but I could not get past the upfront cost of $20K. I do not believe my wife and I will be in the house long enough for a payback of that size. Although, there is the real possibility of the investment increasing the value of the house.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD