Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

Posts

Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#1

Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

wilbur

>Anyone care to chime in on what their favorite cordless tool power combo is? I'm looking for a set that includes a hammer drill (probably the most limiting factor), circular saw, and reciprocating saw, and a light.

Also, is there that much performance difference in the voltages? I see options for 14V, 18V, 24V, and there may be more. I think that with increased battery voltages, you pay for it in weight, and I have a feeling that this is more of a marketing point than an actual performance issue.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#2

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb

Joe Shelton

>Hope this doesn't come across as a rant, but I think the kits are overpriced and ill-focused. Except when you get a good quality one on significant markdown, they give you too many tools you don't need, and too few batteries.

Further, cordless tools tend to be less capable than the ones you plug in to a real power source. So, you pay more for a lesser tool.

I have several cordless tools. The ones I use most, and like best, are the Bosch series with 10.8v li-ion batteries. Compact, easy to have with you, and surprisingly capable.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#3

I'm loving the new Milwaukee

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I know it's not exactly what you're asking about, but I've got the new Milwaukee 12V Lithium-ion drill and impact combo and I'm loving it. Lightweight, well-built and plenty of power.

Again, these are to replace my nice lightweight Makita 9.6V and heavy DeWalt 12V drills, not those 18V monsters.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#4

Re: That was my question, too

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I often verbally confuse the hammer drill with the impact driver.

The Bosch impact driver I bought several summers back is a go to tool that never disappoints. When a hammer drill is needed, for me, I rent a corded brute.

What? There is no Japanese hand tool equivalent? ;-)

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#5

I bought the Bosch rather than the Milwaukee

Scott in Montana

>I was intending to buy the Milwaukee 12v lithium set for my woodshop but was disappointed that they didn't have a drill in the series. Sure I could have bought an aftermarket chuck and mounted it in the driver, but then speed was a factor; I think the Milwaukee tops out at 500-600 rpm. And that often isn't enough to thoroughly clear chips.

So last month Bosch introduces a two-speed-range drill to go with their lithium series of tools. I think it goes up to 1200 rpm, comes with a tooless chuck and works like a dream. I bought the driver, the drill, and will probably buy the close quarter drill in the near future.

It sure is nice to have one kind of battery for several tools.

I would want to look into this closer, but I believe that even though Milwaukee is advertising their series as a 12 volt system, I believe that is a peak rating and that it too is a 10.8 volt battery. I could be wrong on this. I think I've seen Bosch advertise there system as a 12 volt system someplaces too.

BTW, there is an impact driver in the series too, but I have never found myself needing that force in building furniture. I've got a couple year old Makita impact driver for other projects.

Just my humble opinions,

Scott

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#6

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

>I used to think that all cordless tools were junk, or doomed to be short lived due to the batteries. Then I got a Milwaukee 18V hammer drill. The hammer part is pretty weak, and I have a corded hammer drill I always grab first when putting holes in concrete, but the drill is fantastic! I also have the 18V vacuum and light. If my NICad batteries ever die, Milwaukee was smart enough to make their newer lithium ion batteries fit the old tools. I also have the Bosch Lithium Ion 12v driver, but it just doesn't have the umph to sink large screws like the 18v Milwaukee can over and over. It is still really fantastic for its size though. If its a smaller job, I usually grab for the Bosch first, and my wife keeps stealing the Bosch 12v driver on me too, if that says anything.

Still if I had to do it over, and pick just one over the other, it would be the 18v Milwaukee set or their 28v set, with just the drill, vacuum, and light. I still like my corded tools more for the rest.

Ken

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#7

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb

Hank Knight

>Wilbur,

I've been a Panasouic fan for years, but I bought this little Makita Drill/Impact Driver combo recently and it's fast becoming my favorite:

Makita Drill Driver Set

My only complaint about it is that both the drill and the impact driver require hex shanked bits. Not so bad for the driver, but it's a pain with the drill. Finding quality drill bits with a hex shank is not easy.

For woodworking you don't need much over 12 volts for most things. The little Makitas are 10.8 volts and they are fine for wood. I think for a hammer drill, you'd need much more power - the bigger the better. But the big boys are cumbersome for cabinet work. I don't know about cordless saws.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#8

Slight clarification

wilbur

>Slight clarification:

I completely forgot to put this in my post, which is why I initially said "Slightly OT". I'm looking for a cordless combo tool set more for construction-type projects around the house -- cutting 2x4s, framing projects (walls, not pictures), that sort of thing. Hence the need for the circular saw and recip saw.

Sorry!

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#9

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb

Barry Irby

>Hank, Find a Jacobs type chuck that has a hex shaft. Leave it in the drill. You will like it.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#10

In that case... Milwaukee all the way! :O)

Scott in Montana

>

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#11

A pair of impact drivers

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I've had the Milwaukee 14.4 I-D for 4 years. It totally replaces any straight driver in that power range. I'm gonna get the little Makita Lion I-D for when I need two-gun action. I don't really have a use for the saws.

Clint

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#12

Hand tool equivalent

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've picked up several star drills at garage sales, and, while it is possible to drill a hole in concrete with them, you need (a) patience and (b) a willingness to accept a good deal of physical punishment.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#13

No direct experience with cordless

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think cordless drills are the cat's PJs, and watching my son use his 1/4" hex drive impact driver left me drooling with envy (some time I'd like one of my very own).

The one cordless circular saw I've used (9.6V) was so underpowered as to be ridiculous, and the 9.6V jigsaw I picked up takes more energy on my part than a handsaw (vibrate, vibrate). I don't know what the higher-voltage tools of these types are like.

When I use a reciprocating saw, I am usually doing serious damage to some piece of my house; when I use a circular saw, I am usually doing a lot of cutting. For these two tools, I prefer something with a cord.

If I were a contractor, I could probably justify a cordless reciprocating saw, for those times that I had to do one cut at the far end of a crawl space; the early reviews were that this was about what they were good for before recharging - not suitable for, say, a full partition wall demolition.

Again, I haven't kept up with the current evolution of these tools, but you might consider whether the cordlessness is worth it to you - for a weekend worrier, a cord for the heavy duty tools might be worth while.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#14

In that case, I repeat my advice above

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you're doing construction, you want the serious grunt a corded circular saw and reciprocating saw will give you.

There are lots of good circular saws.

I personally think the little Milwaukee (about $100 if you can find a local sale; $115 or so at more or less retail) is just about right. I had a used Makita for years, and it was OK. When it went south on me, I followed my contractor son's recommendation, and got the Milwaukee, and am sold. Durable, strong, seems bulletproof.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#15

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb

al heath

>okay...I have two sets of cordless tolls that I use often. A 14.4v Milwaukee and an 18v Dewalt. The Dewalt hammer drill is invaluable, I have found it has the power and the "heft" to drill concrete, brick, etc. the milwaukee not so much (14.4v). The reciprocating saw is more than sufficient for the jobsite, and is ALMOST as good as my corded milwaukee. I am not impressed with the cordless circular saw though...it just doesnt have the rpms or the power needed, particularly in thicker material (like a2x4). I use the lighter weight 14.4 milwaukee in the shop mainly, but if I go to a jobsite, or away from the shop, I grab the 18v Dewalt.

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#16

Voltage = power

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Hi Wilbur,

Personally, I agree with several of the others that I don't have a lot of affection for combo packs, although they are ostensibly a big savings if you need all the components. To me, each tool category has a different power requirement, and this is especially so if you want a hammer drill as part of the package. Cordless drills and impact drivers in the 12v - 14.4v range are more than adequate to most tasks, unless you're driving lag screws or something. But IMO circular saws and reciprocating saws need more power and battery life than you'll get from the lower voltage ranges. And anything over 12 volts is overkill for a flashlight unless you need a million candlepower. :-)

Bosch makes cordless 24v hammer drills that will drive a 3/4" drill bit through a two-foot concrete wall. Sounds like DeWalt has a good one, too. But, this is a situation when you really need the additional power. Weight shouldn't be your main concern in a hammer drill, again, unless you're doing lightweight work. When I use a hammer drill, it's usually to blow a hole in a stone foundation or block wall or something challenging like that.

Ellis

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#17

:@)

wilbur

>Hitiachi, Makita, and Panasonic come to mind. :@)

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#18

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool comb *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

As a slight hijack of this thread I was just in my local orange borg and they have the Makita 10.8volt lithium-ion kit on clearance for $129.00.I didn't have a couple of unused gift cards with me but I will be returning to pick up a set in the near future.I am enclosing a link to the same item on Amazon so everybody is clear on which set it is.

Andy


Makita on Amazon

Re: Slightly OT: Favorite cordless power tool combo?

#19

18v Milwakee

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>I got it a couple months ago and love it, Lithium ion batteries, lots of power, good balance, feel good in hand, no hammer drill, it has a 1/2" drill, an impact driver, great if you screw a lot, a circular saw and a sawsall and a light and comes in a nice big red bag.

Highly recommended

Jorge