Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Heat Pump question

Posts

Heat Pump question

#1

Heat Pump question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My Carrier heat pump is 16 years old and it needs a $700 repair. I am thinking about replacing it with a new unit instead of repairing it. What manufacturers are considered the best for reliability?

I was disappointed with the lack of technical information on the Carrier web site. For example, under each series they list several model numbers with no clue as to what is different about them.

Re: Heat Pump question

#2

Re: Heat Pump question

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>Bill, I'm curious as to what is wrong with your unit that is going to cost $700 to fix. I'm a retired refrigeration mechanic and it is very seldom that a compressor goes out. Usually it is something pretty simple, like a circuit breaker, the fuse in the switch panel by the unit, a recycle timer, or a manual high pressure switch. Most problems can be found by using a good volt-o-meter and having some good diagnostic skills.

A little hint about refrigeration mechanics, if they show up carrying a can of Freon, beware! Many refrigeration mechanics will fix a small electrical problem and tell you they had to add some Freon. If they can't fix the electrical problem they'll say it's a compressor. Years ago I bought refrigeration units from the recycle yard, I'd fix the problems and then resell them. Only once did I replace a compressor in a large freezer.

Anyway, let us know what your problems are.

Re: Heat Pump question

#3

Re: Heat Pump question *LINK*

GalenV in Iowa

>Bill

You were just about there for finding the answer on their web site. If you click on the Product Spec tab it will tell you the difference in the models of same Series. Like the Infinity 25HNA9 and 25HNA6 are a difference in SEER rating of 19 and 16. There is also a sound level difference and number of diagnostic features.

Good luck on your shoping as it is snowing here now in Ames Iowa after a warm 40 to 50 degree spell.

Galen


Product Spec

Re: Heat Pump question

#4

Re: Heat Pump question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I just had a geothermal heatpump & A/C sytem installed this past summer. When the unit came, there were two nameplates in the box. One was Bryant and the other was Carrier. Neither company actually made the unit, but both were selling them under their own name.

Lee

Re: Heat Pump question

#5

Carrier Model 100 vs Model 200

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>The Carrier Model 200 is twice as big as the Model 100 about half as large as the Model 400.

Sorry couldn't resist.... but betcha wished I did :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Heat Pump question

#6

Re: Heat Pump question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The defrost cycle is not working. The sensor to tell it to defrost was checked and deemed working and the defrost itself was tested and works. He found that the valve that switches between heat and cool was leaking and he thought this was the problem. The valve costs $315 from Carrier and an estimated 200+ to install it (refrig. needs to be drained, valve soldered in, etc.

I an grateful for your thoughts...........

Re: Heat Pump question

#7

Wandering - how do you like the heat pump?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We're going to need to do something with our house, and I'm curious what your experience has been. I know it's a pricey way to get there, but said to be very energy-efficient.

Re: Heat Pump question

#8

Re: Heat Pump question

Barry Irby

>Bill, I have no actual statistical data for you, but as a Home Inspector in VA, Near Richmond, I suspect my climate is not vastly different than yours, and I see all kinds of heat pumps. If one is significantly better than another I couldn't prove it. I've asked other home inspectors which units they see that outlast the others and no one has a clear answer. Units typically last about 12 years with 10 to 14 being very common. I have seen a few that were twenty and over and one or two that were 28+/-. No particular brand stands out. The oldest ones were a random assortment. My personal opinion is to buy a cheapest one and and put the savings into attic insulation, caulking and other energy saving techniques.

Re: Heat Pump question

#9

Re: Heat Pump question

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>How did he determine that the valve was leaking? This can be a somewhat smoke and mirrors guess. If the valve is leaking there should be a frost line form on it, if the power is removed while in defrost mode. Depending on valve location, determining a slight temp difference (while running) on the three outlet tubes is almost impossible. This is usually inside the unit with all the condenser fan air blowing over it.

Carriar and Bryant have been co-partners for fourty years.

Bill in WNC mountains

NC Licensed Refrig. Contractor

Re: Heat Pump question

#10

Re: Heat Pump question

John K Jordan

>>I'm curious as to what is wrong with your unit that is going to cost $700 to fix

Can't answer for Bill, but I paid over $600 to replace a blower motor. I didn't like it so I checked around and that's just about what the motor cost. Maybe it's the unit - it's a large commercial Trane unit, installed new in '88. The repair company couldn't believe this unit was installed in a residence, but hey, besides the motor problem it works great and seems to be sized fairly well for the space. Since it is over 20 years old I'll probably replace it at the next problem.

JKJ

Re: Heat Pump question

#11

Re: Heat Pump question

Del Williams

>I've found (after owning a GE, Carrier, no recognizable name and Heil heat pumps) that I value the expertise of the installer/maintenance professional more than the name brand of the appliance. The gentleman that I have dealt with over the past ten years has replaced two heat pumps (one worn out and then one succumbed to a ligntning strike), installed a new system in an addition to the house and is the spark that keeps these things working for me. He is an independent contractor and the best thing is great customer service. Things wear and fail, I call, he comes and I have heat/cooling again.

Re: Heat Pump question

#12

Re: Heat Pump question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>How did he know it was leaking.....I don't know. He had a small bottle of yellow liquid at the time. Maybe a leak check "soap' solution?

The valve is to the right and in front of the compressor. Actually, it was quite accessible.

Re: Heat Pump question

#13

Re: Wandering - how do you like the heat pump?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Everyone in these parts has a heat pump. I don't have anything else to compare it to.

The "hot" air from it is not hot. In fact it is about 85F or there abouts. Some don't like the absence of hot air blowing on them when they are cold. We are well insulated and it only takes about $100/month in our coldest months that have some single digit temperatures.

Re: Heat Pump question

#14

Re: Heat Pump question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I got that far. But in a series there are choices in the inside unit that have to do with the fan and heat exchanger and the outside units have differences in compressor. I could not find the next level of technical information.

Re: Heat Pump question

#15

Re: Heat Pump question

Fred Davis

>Del,

you have discovered one of life's rules to live by.

In this thread , one guy . Bill Turpin had a concise as could be answer without actually seeing Bill's unit.

Experienced contractor.

FredD

Re: Heat Pump question

#16

Re: Heat Pump question

Barry Irby

>I have only seen a few Heil units, not popular here. GE stopped making heat pumps about twenty years ago. They were either Trane units or manufactured under a license from Trane and were Identical. Carrier is known as Carrier/Day Night/Payne and I see Payne units but have never seen a Day Night.

I have never seen a reputable comparison test between various brands. Never really looked through. My point is that if one or two brands were better than the others I think I would have noticed that I see X brand surviving longer than the others or that almost all the really old heat pumps I see are brand X. Not so.

And, I got cut off in mid type on my Post. My girl friend walked in and it was time to go to dinner. I agree with all who vote for the contractor. Hard to find a good one, but if you do, stick with them.