Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Posts

OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#1

OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Randy G

>Hello all, I was hoping I'd catch someone out there with a lot better know how than me electrically. (and that won't take much). Having two little ones that are just at the right height to play with light switches, we invariably had one break on us from overuse. I've replaced light switches before, so didn't figure this one would be a problem. Went down to the store, picked up a new light switch (white, instead of cream, at the Wife's request). Got home, Turned off the breaker, pulled out the old switch, then started looking. 4 wires coming into the switch and only 3 slots on the new switch. Hmmmm, OHHH so that's what these three pole switches are all about. Okay, put the old switch back in, turn breaker back on and back to the store. Got the new switch, came home, run through the same steps. Breaker off, pull switch out, put in new switch, breaker on... and then comes the question.

So for the question..I seem to have done something wrong. There's two switches for this light. 1 at top of stairs and 1 at bottom I just replaced. Now, with the new switch in, the 1 I replaced always has to be on (up) for the Switch at the top of the stairs to work... I tried swapping the black wires in the new switch, but that didn't seem to change anything. Any ideas on what I can look at or what I've done? I did have the old switch out thinking I had another switch around that I could replace that one with, maybe I reversed those wires and that's what's causing this? Any help would be appreciated.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#2

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>In order to do a multi-point switch (3 way or 4 way) right, you really need to know where your power is coming in and how your switches and the light fixture relate. Go to your local library and look through the books on the subject for good diagrams. When I wired our house, some years back, I had to draw out the layout in order to figure out the switch wiring.

By the way, if you've got little ones, when you replace light switches, you should consider "spec" switches rather than the cheapest ones. They'll last longer. I know that's not always easy when you've got kids - the most expensive hobby in the world (teasing - they're worth every penny and every minute of lost sleep) - but an extra dollar or so will pay off in fewer trips to the hardware store.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#3

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Robert Lemon - Sacramento CA

>Randy, just did a Google search for '3 way switch wiring diagram' and came up with a multitude of diagrams. One or more should work for you.

When doing the Google search, search for 'Images'. It always speeds up the search for diagrams or pictures.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#4

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong *LINK*

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Here's a site that offers several diagrams for wiring multiple switch locations with single or multiple lights. It sounds like your original installation may not have been wired correctly. First step is to open both electrical boxes and determine what wires are in each and where they go. Do this with the power off. Once you know where all the wires go, match tehm to a diagram and tehn rewire your system to match.

Just in case, draw a diagram of how each box is wired up now in case your new wiring doesn't work you can get back where you stared.

Lee


3 way switch wiring

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#5

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Pete Stahl

>I would say look at the other switch and see what color the wires are that are on the 2 screws that are the same color. Do the same for the other switch. Usually there are 2 wires in the box, one is a 12/3 which is White,Black,Red and Ground (bare) and the other wire is a 12/2 (Black,White and Ground) which either brings in power or is going to the light unless you had a electrician that did a loop to both switches. How many wires in each box?

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#6

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Mark Nowicki

>If you still have the old switch check if the the upper and lower screws were separated by having the metal tab broken off (on the hot side)

Mark

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#7

Right-oh ! . . .

steve mackay

>The little bit extra for the better swtches is well worth it. They are also more "positive" ( ? ). Just by feel you KNOW its on or off.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#8

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

David

>I know this is going to sound dumb, but did switch mfgs change the position of the common on 3-ways? I've replaced dozens of 3- and 4-way switches over the years. About a year ago I went to change out a couple of 3-ways, hooked 'em up and they worked like Randy describes. So I look at the terminal designations and they're different from the old ones! Put everything where it belonged according to the new switch, i.e., didn't simply swap terminal for terminal, and everything worked fine. Had to change a 3-way for my neighbor last week and this time I read the switches first. Low and behold, they were different.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#9

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

GalenV in Iowa

>I'm not sure there was ever a universal standard on an electric switch. I find the same thing in replacing and three way can be a lot of fun without checking for common side as I have seen on opposite side when you face the switch between brands. They do not all have a different color screw to identify the common as well on different brands.

I did the same thing as above and found I was just swaping one switched hot to another but still putting it on the common cause it did not match old layout. Finally checked the switch action. That's what you get for getting in a hurry when someone wants the lights back on NOW. Always end up taking longer.

I have one circuit that is to have a four way switch but they put in three three-way and that is fun to trace what wire is what to put the fourway where it needs to so switches control right from three places. Same light on a motion sensor that has logic to make right too. Right now one switch taped over so someone does not use.

Rented townhome so not in a big hurry to fix but landlord never will.

Galen

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#10

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>Covering a few bases at once here.....

The location of the common terminal can vary from one company to another. I have never seen any made in the last twenty or thirty years (at least) that didn't have different colors on the screws to denote which was common and which were travelers. Dark was common, bright, travelers.

Pete has the right idea, particulary if your figuring the problem out without some kind of voltage tester. Look at the switch that wasn't removed, see what color wire is on the common, and it's ALMOST a sure bet the same color wire will be common on the other switch. The common is the only important one. It doesn't make any difference which of the other two terminals the travelers go on.

Where this gets interesting is in older houses with knob and tube or even really old romex. The wires are all the same color.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#11

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

Barry Irby

>You mentioned the old switch had four wires. Were there four insulated wires (black, red, or white) or was one of the the ground wire, (bare or green)? If all four wires were insulated then it was a four way switch. If there three insulated wires and a ground it was a three way switch. In a three way switch, there are two switches, in a four way, there are three or more switches. (there may be another one you are not thinking about, like at the other end of the hall.)

I just wired a house for my cousin. Everyone contributed what they had on hand to the project. We had at least three different brands of switches. The screws were in different positions on the switches and were of various colors. What I did find was that the COMMON terminal was labeled on the back of the device. It was impressed into the plastic on the back. At least it was on the ones I was baffled by, the last ones I got to. In my case, I had wired them all so that the HOT feed IN was in one box and the Load feed out to the lights was IN the other box. Hook the Hot feed to the Common Screw and the other two wires (red and Black) to the remaining two screws. In the other box hook the feed out to the COMMON screw and the other two wires to the other two screws.

(My job is not over yet. They have decided they don't like the slight mismatch in the color and appearance of the switches and want me to come back and change them all tot he same brand so they will match. I should have seen that coming.)

Black & Decker has a wiring book at Lowes that has nice neat diagrams. It was about $14 marked down to $11. May have been discontinued, but the style of the diagrams suited my decrepit brain well. About four ways to wire them side by side. Might be worth a look if they still have the book.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#12

PS to make it simple......

Barry Irby

>Look on the new switch and find the COMMON screw. Look in the box and find the black wire coming from the 14/2 with ground cable and put that wire on the COMMON screw. Find the red and black pair coming from the 14/3 with ground cable and put them on the other two screws. Should work.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#13

Re: PS to make it simple......

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>To help, the common is a diferent color than the other terminals. It is usually a dark bronze while the other terminals are brass.

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#14

Thank you everyone...

Randy Gleckler

>Based on the diagrams and advice, I did some volt checking and found I had mixed the wires on the switch I didn't replace when I put it back in. Swapped those wires back and everything is working now. Really appreciate all the feedback on this...

Re: OT Electrical question - what did I do wrong

#15

Re: Thank you everyone...

Howard Norman

>Glad you got it figured out. Three way and four way switches can be a bear sometimes.