Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

Posts

Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#1

Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

Stephen Roth

>Despite the fear of a dust explosion in non-grounded ducts, there seems to be something of a debate here on whether such a thing could ever happen in a home shop. (Maybe Myth-Busters should do a woodworking show.)

That got me thinking about whether spraying a solvent based finished with a decent window fan really requires a explosion proof equipment. Assuming that the following things occur, I was wondering if an explosion could really happen:

(1) There is only one person spraying at a time;

(2) Spraying is not done on a continuous production basis, but in the way most of us probably spray. That is, short 10 second bursts of spray and then 10 seconds of waiting to check the coat and reposition.

(3) Use of an HVLP system that naturally decreased the overspray.

I recognize that most answers are going to start with the tag line "Call the Fire Department." But then again, it can't hurt to ask.

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#2

Call The Fire Department . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If you must, but don't complain when they put you down as a crackpot.

Yes, wood dust does produce static sparks. But unless you've got a serious amount of run-time and a serious amount of dust, the spark produced will not be hot enough to produce ignition. Most people who buy into this BS don't understand that there is a difference in sparking, and you need real differences in charge to raise things to the point of ignition temperatures. Example: I can get a nice spark out of a 12v light line, but if I want to weld steel, I'm going with way more voltage and amperage to get the heat needed for welding.

These myths have had home-shoppers trying to a) ground their PVC dust piping (impossible to do) or b) buy steel piping at 5 times the price for 20 years with fabricated stories of houses exploding.

Now, if you insist on spraying NC lacquer or applying mica with real contact cement in a closed room with a gas furnace and water heater, don't blame me if you go suborbital, but give my a break with the K-BOOM scenarios.

The real danger that is not discussed is when some guy is running a dust collector, but cutting wood that is smoking through the cut. If you insist on sending hot embers from a table saw cut up the pipe into a pile of sawdust with a forced air draft, don't complain when the damn bag catches fire. Duh.

From the people with whom I've talked about this issue, it appears that you'll fall far short of being able to produce the vapor concentration necessary for ignition of the alleged fuel-air bomb.

OSHA notwithstanding, remember that an induction motor (the kind used in most all window fans), can only produce a spark at the switch; their motors have no brushes to create such a spark.

I use a 20" box fan in my K-D spray booth. Hasn't exploded.

[yet] |;-}}}}

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#3

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

Howard Acheson

>Here is something relating to spraying shellac.

Explosiveness of Alcohol

From the WWA Info Exchange

OK .... let's settle this issue for good with some physics ....

First of all, the solvent in shellac is ethyl alcohol, commonly refered to as ethanol. Same stuff that's in Jack Daniels but with poisons added to avoid liquor taxes.

The molecular weight of ethanol is 32 ... the same as oxygen .... so when it evaporates it does not rush to the floor and cruise over to that pilot flame .... it just mixes evenly throught the air space.

Secondly, the lower explosive limit in air for methanol is 3.28% by volume. That is ... you need to have 3.28% of the air space filled with ethanol fumes before it becomes explosive.

Soooo .... if you have a tiny 10 ft by 15 ft by 8 ft shop ..... you need to mix 294 GALLONS of ethanol in the air before you reach the explosive state!!

No ... you will not blow yourself up. I suspect before you can dissolve this much alcohol in the air you will notice it and evacute.

Knipfer

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#4

I am no scientist, but I have to question this.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Let me see if I have this straight. You are saying that in a 10 x 15 shop, that it would take 5 55 gallon drums of alcohol evaporated in the air to reach explosive levels? Really?

Are you sure you are not confusing the liquid state with the saturated air mix ratio or something?

I think If I had a shop 10 x 15, and I spilled one gallon of alcohol, with an open flame present, I would be out of there, or at least trying to spray the pool with an extinguisher.

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#5

Re: I am no scientist, but I have to question this

Fred Davis

>All you need is common sense Keith ;-))

This really happened.

We were doing some VA repo's make overs in San Francisco in the early seventies to have something to do in a construction slowdown like the one now and one little house in the Bayview section of town was all done except for the painter to finish the floors.

The painter went by the house late in the afternoon and turned off the gas to the house in preparation for the next morning.

Unbeknownst to him the Plumber went by after him and turned on the gas to check the combustion mix in the range, furnace and Water heater....

The next morning about ten , the painter was backing down the hallway toward the front door spraying the floors with Shellac and just about the time he got to the door , the place blew , blew him out into the yard and his compressor followed and landed on him.

Blew the walls about a half inch off the subfloor and set the house on fire.

Took out every window and exit door, put the painter in the hospital and we had to resheetrock the whole house after the fire was put out and the adjuster came by from the insurance company.

The amount of Shellac he sprayed was less then five gallons.

FredD

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#6

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too? *LINK*

Phil Smith

>The applicable code for spray booths using flammable solvents is the NFPA 33. There are strict guidelines for spray booths, in particular air flow, booth construction, electrical equipment, and grounding. You do not have to have an explosion to have a disastrous fire.

The biggest issue is a static spark starting a fire, and spray booths almost always have lots of potential fuel from overspray. Fire would make a real mess out of home shop. For me I wait for warm days and spray outside, and dry in warm place where fire risk is greatly reduced. A car or van on a sunny day makes for a nice warm place to dry small pieces. Of course the car has that new furniture smell for several days.


NFPA 33 table of contents

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#7

I'm thinking

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>There may confusion regarding liquid volume and vapor volume. I don't what the liquid to vapor conversion ratio for Alchol is, but for Propane is is around 1 gallon liquid to 34 gallons of vapor. Iam also pretty sure that the concentration won't be uniform. Some where close to the source (spray gun) the concentration will approach if not exceed the LEL. All that said, a friend used to spray cars in his garage. He used a box fan to suck air in and "pressurize" the room with an open window for the fumes to vent. It seem to work for him, but...

glc

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#8

JL

Faulty data DO THE MATH

JL

>Missing a few things like vapor pressure, etc.

A "mole" of air will occupy 22.4 liters (22,400 cubic centimeter) at standard temperature and pressure (0 degrees C, 760 torr). A mole of ethyl alcohol VAPOR will occupy the the same volume. A mole of ethyl alcohol will weigh 32 grams and have a volume of ~26 milliliters when liquid.

Your 10 x 15 x 8 room has a volume of ~33 cubic meters or 33,000 liters or 1473 molar volumes. 1473 x 26 milliliters is roughly 38 liters. This is NOT 294 gallons. To achieve your 3.3% vapor concentration, you would need about 1.3 liters.

Can you have an explosive concentration - YES. You only need it in a localized area.

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#9

Don't be calling my shop TINY......Shorty

Barry Irby

>

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#10

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

John K Jordan

>>you need to have 3.28% of the air space filled with ethanol fumes before it becomes explosive... 10 ft by 15 ft by 8 ft shop ..... you need to mix 294 GALLONS of ethanol in the air

Remember you only need the critical concentrations at the ignition point, which might take considerably less quantity of flammable vapor than to fill the entire space.

BTW, I found an inexpensive source of high-quality "explosion-proof" electric motors - junked gasoline pumps. Remember, although, that the switch and outlet are other potential ignition points.

JKJ

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#11

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

Lee Brubaker

>Using a window fan with an "open" motor results in the motor needing to be out of the air stream of the fan....namely belt driven.

Lee

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

#12

Re: Are Solvent Based Explosions A Myth too?

Steve Jenkins, McKinney, TX.

>It seems like all the stories of explosions occur where there is an ignition source near the floor. Hot water tank, closet furnace etc. I used to have my shop in a warehouse with a typical natural gas flame warehouse heater in one upper corner of the room. I sprayed lacquer and sometimes the fog got so thick you couldn't hardly see across the shop. I think that long before it would explode you would pass out. All disclaimers in effect. :-) Steve