Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Need help with repro chair detail

Posts

Need help with repro chair detail

#1

A.J. Hamler

Need help with repro chair detail

A.J. Hamler

>Hi gang ...

I've reproduced the chair shown in the image below. That's Lt. Kelly at the Army of the Potomac headquarters tent in Culpeper, Va., in 1863.

Chair - full view

the chair came out great, but I'll be darned if I can figure out something in the photo. If I've done this photo thing correctly, you should be able to see a detail below.

Chair - detail

On the upright post of the chair right about elbow level is what appears to be the remnant of a hinge. It's held on by two screws, and is certainly metal. On the horizontal post of the chair, near the Lt.'s left thigh, there is a lighter area in the wood, and what seems to be a hole. Any idea what these things might be?

My first thought was that it was indeed part of a hinge, and that it was being used to "lock" the chair in the folded-up position. It appeared that the hole in the seat portion might line up perfectly with that hinge barrel when folded up, and maybe they slipped a nail or hinge pin in there to engage the hole, thus keeping the chair in the closed position.

I can't think of what else that hole in the horizontal member is for, but I don't think it has anything to do with the construction of the seat. Both the headrest and the seat crosspiece are attached to the sides with through-mortises. If you look at the headrest in the first photo, you can see where the through-mortise was pegged.

My second thought was that the hinge was a mounting point for a leather armrest. I've seen a number of other folding chairs -- although none of this design -- that had leather straps affixed that hung as kind of slings, acting as armrests. Because they were flexible, they didn't interfere with folding up the chair. Not sure if that was the case, though, as it wouldn't have made for much of an armrest, since the distance from the hinge to the hole is pretty short and low on the chair.

In zooming in to the photo, though, it seems that the barrel of the hinge has been pried or pulled open. Certainly it wasn't being used as a locking point, since you couldn't slip anything into the barrel and get it to stay. However, the ring that a leather strap might have been attached with could have once been in there before the hinge barrel was opened. It's quite possible that the stray armrest broke or was pulled out and the metal hinge was just left there, even though it's no longer being used for anything.

Any thoughts?

A.J.

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#2

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

mdclor

>From the "light" shadow on the seat it seems to me that it might have been a hinged arm rest. It would have folded up with the chair when not in use and down when the chair was in use. Basically a parallelogram with two hinges and two pivot points with the hinges on the top corners and the pivot points on the bottom ones. Does this make any sense?

HTH,

Merle

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#3

arm rest

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>It looks like there is an arm rest on the other side of the chair so I would guess the hinge and hole are some how related to the mounting of the arm rest.

Robin

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#4

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>It looks like the chair arm to the subject's right belongs to the chair to the right, but it might have some information. If you enlarge the arm, can you see a hinge? I tried to enlarge but the low resolution from the screen image was not useful.

I agree the subject's chair had arms. Haven't seen an intact example so maybe there's another explanation. I looked through a book on British campaign furniture and saw the chairs with the leather straps for arms but didn't see anything like your example.

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#5

A.J. Hamler

Figured it out

A.J. Hamler

>Thanks, guys. I think I've got it now.

When I first found the photo, I had ruled out that the armrest on Lt. Kelly's right was on Kelly's chair, as the other officer on that side seems to be hogging up the armrest as you can see in the first posted photo, and Lt. Kelly only has his elbow on it. I'd been assuming that the armrest was on the other officer's chair. In fact, I actually have a second photo of this scene taken at the same time, in which Lt. Kelly has both his arms in his lap, and a different officer was sitting in the chair next to him and was using that armrest to lean on heavily. Lt. Kelly's elbow is still blocking the view of the back of the armrest so you can't see where it's attached, but in the second photo it looks even more like the armrest is on the other chair.

So late last night I went to search some more on the Library of Congress Web site, and lo and behold I found a THIRD photo of the same group. (This was common during the war; a photographer would come along and snap several shots of the same group, with everyone changing positions.) In this third photo, all the chairs have been moved around except Kelly's. The one next to Kelly has been turned at a 90-degree angle, and it clearly has no armrests at all. Kelly has his arm on the armrest now, and it's obivious that it is indeed part of his chair. There's a tiny spot under Kelly's right arm where you can see just the tiniest portion of the rear of that armrest, and -- while you can't make it out clearly -- there appears to be a hinge barrel visible at the arrow in the photo below.

Chair detail 2

I went back to my original photo and zoomed in on the front of that armrest (the Library of Congress photos are online in huge 20 to 25-meg files, and Photoshop loves them), and sure enough, that armrest has a hinge underneath the front joint, as in the shot below.

Chair detail 3

My new theory is that there was once a left armrest that matched that on the right as some of you suggested. The light-colored area on the side of the seat by Kelly's left thigh is about the right angle that an upright armrest support would have gone there. That hole is in the perfect position for a rivet to anchor the armrest upright. With the armrest upright support riveted at the bottom in the side of the seat, the hinge underneath where the upright joins the armrest, and another hinge on top/rear of the armrest where it joins the back post of the chair, that armrest would have folded up nicely when the chair was folded. The lighter area on the back post just underneath the hinge is where the end of the armrest would have been.

The bottom line is that Lt. Kelly is simply using a broken chair. It only has one armrest remaining, on the right side of the chair. The broken hinge and those two light areas where the wood of the armrest would have been confirm the rest of the story.

Thanks! Without a couple of you guys making me look again, I would still be thinking that armrest was on the other chair.

Guess I'd better get back out into the shop and finish that chair.

A.J.

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#6

Classic Strategy!!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>A.J.

Most likely the chair arm was shot off by a sniper. That was a classic move in the Civil War. First shoot off the arms of Officer's chairs and leave them exposed on the flank. ;-)

Tom

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#7

Not quite right!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>You'll notice that Lt Kelly only has one bar on his eppulettes, which the Captain seated next to him has two bars and also two arms on his chair. When you were promoted you got additional bars and also arms on both sides of your chair. ;)

Rumor has it that Vice Admiral Rickover had the front legs of his guest chairs shortened so that the seats tilted forward, rendering any guest to his office slightly off balance and therefore uncomfortable, when they took their seat, giving him the advantage.

Lee

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#8

Re: Not quite right!

Barry Irby

>Lieutenants got one arm rest and captains got two. Majors got two arm rests and a little foot stool, for one foot. Colonels got two arm rests and a bigger foot stool, for both feet. Generals got a recliner.

Actually, I thought the arm had been removed to make the chair more comfortable for a gentleman wearing a sword.

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#9

information please

tek,brunswick

>How do you access and search the pictures in the library of Congress?

TIA

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#10

A.J. Hamler

Re: information please *LINK*

A.J. Hamler

>Just go to the link below. This will take you to the main page. Once there, click on "Search the Catalog."

This will take you to the main catalog where they have all the topics listed. Naturally, the photos I had came from the Civil War collection. Once you find a photo you're looking for, there are usually three options for sizes. There's the online size (pretty small), a larger JPG of a couple hundred K, and usually a monster-size TIFF file that is sometimes 20 or 30 meg in size.

Have fun.

Tip: Have something to eat and go to the bathroom before you start digging around in there. You may not come up for air for hours.

A.J.


Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Online

Re: Need help with repro chair detail

#11

A.J. Hamler

Well, that explains...

A.J. Hamler

>.. how they came up with the name "Lee-Z-Boy."

A.J.