Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

breadboard ends

Posts

breadboard ends

#1

breadboard ends

Kathy

>We are building a large maple dining table with kiln dried maple cut from the farm. Trying to figure out how to attach breadboards in such a way as to allow for seasonal movement in the top boards. Can anyone help? Grandfather is the carpenter, with good skills in that department, but no computer skills. So don't shoot the messenger.

Thanks

Re: breadboard ends

#2

Re: breadboard ends

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I would do it with a sliding dovetail glued or pinned in the middle of piece. The seasonal movement would not loosen the joint and you would only see half of the movement on each side of the table. Do not glue the board full length to the end of your table or the table top may split or warp.. You can also use a tongue and groove method for attachment.

Lee

Re: breadboard ends

#3

Here's a good start: *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

>Here is a discussion on the subject with lots of tips from our friends at Woodweb.

Have him read through this discussion, then repost here with more specific questions once he is done. If need be, we can walk him through the construction of the mortise and tenon assembly. it involves dowels, slots, room for expansion, and then hiding it all.

You should tell us more information, such as the desired width of the table top, the type of climate where the table will be (include if you may move to ...say... Pheonix some day). We will be able to provide good information on how much longer to make the breadboard ends than the current width of the table, etc.

Ask your carpenter to also tell us if the top will be made of flatsawn or quarter sawn maple, or a combination...since that figures into the formula.

Also note that it is best to PLAN on the breadboard end to extend past the edge of the table as this looks better than it being short when the weather turns humid.

We can surely help, so don't go away, just go read the info at my link as a starting point, then come back and we'll continue the discussion.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Woodweb discussion on Bread board ends

Re: breadboard ends

#4

Re: breadboard ends

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If the wood is well seasoned and glued up flat, there is no structural reason for the breadboard ends; and if the top wants to bow across the grain, breadboard ends will not hold it back. I suggest eliminating the breadboard ends in favor of a moulded edge, either just on the ends or all around. Here's an example of a top in maple.

Clint


img

Re: breadboard ends

#5

Re: Here's a good start:

Kathy

>I have printed your message and will have him read through it. Some questions I can answer now. Table will be 96X40, kiln dried maple, combination of flat and quarter sawn. Legs are tapered 3" down to 2" square, with a 3.5" skirt. We live on the Quebec/New York/Vermont border, on the Quebec side, and it is highly unlikely the table will leave this area.

Will be back in touch when Grandpa has digested the Link.

Thanks for the help.

Kathy

Re: breadboard ends

#6

Re: breadboard ends

Kathy

>The breadboards aren't really for structural reasons, we kind of like the look, but aren't sure we can achieve it properly.

Thanks for the input.

Kathy

Re: breadboard ends

#7

Re: breadboard ends

Jim Dillon

>Kathy,

Breadboards are neat! You can make them entirely with handtools, power tools, or a combination of both. I think they add a nice touch, but I can see the other side of the coin as well.

In any case, here are some references that discuss the construction of breadboards:

Garrett Hack, "Breadboard Ends to Keep Tops Flat", in Practical Design: Solutions and Strategies, Taunton Press, 2000, pp 84-89;

Andy Rae, "Working with Wood", Taunton Press, 2005, pp 90-91; and

Darrell Peart, "Greene & Greene: Design Elements for the Workshop", Linden Publishing, 2005, pp 74-81.

They can also be done easily with loose tenons, but I don't have a handy reference to that technique. As others have said, the key is to just fasten the table top to the breadboard in their middle region, thus allowing the table top to expand and contract; one must still supply support at the ends of the breadboard, but that region is not glued.

As these are only a few pages, I would be happy to make copies and send them to you, although it may take a few days. Just e-mail me if you are interested. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: breadboard ends

#8

Re: breadboard ends

Kathy

>Copies would be greatly appreciated. I think breadboards are neat, they just seem to finish off the table.

Thanks for the offer.

Kathy

Re: breadboard ends

#9

Kathy, check your e-mail.

Jim Dillon

>

Re: breadboard ends

#10

Re: breadboard ends

Tony - Memphis

>Wow, that's a big table! I built a cherry table for our breakfast room and decided I liked the look of breadboard ends too. Its kind of tough to get nice tight joints. Mine didn't turn out just great, but they look ok. Getting the tenon shoulders even on top and bottom can be a little tricky. I made a tenon that went almost all the way across the table, then cut out sections to leave little stubs in between the tenons that were left. I glued the middle tenon and pinned the rest with slotted holes. Making the holes was tricky. You have to keep them parallel to the end of the table and not get them too big. Also, if you pin, make sure the pins go through the tenon and into the opposite shoulder. Mine didn't and they get pulled at an angle as the top moves back and forth! I messed up somewhere and my joints opened up, so I don't have a good tight fit between the breadboard and the field. Not terrible, but it bothers me! There have been some good articles in the wood rags about making them. One I recall is by Peter Korn, but I can't remember what rag or when. I also remember a jig that you make that slides over the end of the table to act as a guide for the router that makes the shoulders "perfectly even" on top and bottom. Anyway, good luck with the project. Post a picture!

Oh, one last thing...I recall an article where they made slots in the end grain of the breadboard and used screws to attach it. The slots were then plugged. Looked pretty good and there was no gap to worry about. I may try that sometime.

Tony

Re: breadboard ends

#11

Here's a pic...

Tony - Memphis

>Right after construction. The color is really pretty now.

Tony


img

Re: breadboard ends

#12

Keep in mind.....

Howard Acheson

>.... that breadboard end can be unsightly if you are working with a wood that has a large range of seasonal expansion and contraction. Maple is quite unstable wood and a 40" wide panel will expand/contract between 1/4" and over 1/2" depending on the seasonal range of relative humidity in the area.

Also, you mention that the table will be made with both flatsawn and quartersawn wood. Choose one or the other for the top panel. Do not intermix flat and quartersawn. The two have differing rates of expansion and contraction and the glue joints will fail or the panel will warp.

Re: breadboard ends

#13

Re: breadboard ends

Lee Brubaker

>I agree with Lee Shierer's suggestion re sliding dovetails for breadboard ends. Since I started using a horizontal router table I have not used any other type joint for breadboard ends. The dovetail pulls the breadboard in tight to the end of the table & a single dowel from the underside in the center is unobtrusive. The joint showing at the ends will be a nice looking difference to the usual mortise/tenon joint.

Lee