citris solvent, d-limonene
Michael Dresdner
>Steve wrote: "The other solvent seen talked about is the d-limonene or citrus solvent. This seems to be promoted as a somehow "safer" solvent in products marketed as "green", but that's not what I read in other sources. Do you have a take on this material?"
d-limonene is one half of a racemic mixture. For the non-chemists, a racemic mixture consists of two molecules in equal measure that are mirror images of one another in so far as how they bend light, but are otherwise identical. They are designated as d and l, which stand for dextro, or right rotating and levo, or left rotating.
Taken together, d and l limonene form a racemic mixture called dipentene, a solvent that happens to occur naturally in a number of things, citric fruit among them.
Dipentene is a most peculiar racemic mixture in that claims have been made that one half of it (d-limonene) is more hazardous to health than the other half. In fact, I've seen reports of it being carcinogenic. Although this seems quite unlikely and counter intuitive, chemistry is full of unlikely things, so I really can't vouch for the veracity one way or the other.
At any rate, by isolating only one half of the mixture, in this case the l-limonene, you can create what is viewed as a safer solvent, and that is what most of the sellers of citric solvent are doing.
To me, it seems like a very expensive way of selling mineral spirits, since even the safer half is not much different in terms of human safety than plain old mineral spirits. However, if it is extracted from citric rinds, it tends to retain some of the citric oils, and hence has a more pleasant smell.
For everyone: Please don't assume that because something comes from nature that it is safer than things we synthesize. Poison ivy comes from nature, as do poison dart frogs, toxic toadstools and a host of other natural dangers. Of course, in this case both mineral spirits and l-limonene or dipentene come from natural sources. Mineral spirits comes from crude oil, which is just as natural, though less renewable, than orange rinds.