Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

Posts

Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#1

Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi,

Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps vs. Naptha vs....

I know I've read this before, and I did a search. However, I didn't find the answer.

So, what are the differences between the subject products? Which are the same? Which dries or evaporates faster? Which should be used to thin varnishes and so on?

Thanks.

Joe

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#2

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner No doubt there is some subtle difference but I consider these equivalent and buy whatever is cheapest. Also multitasks as a charcoal starter.

vs. Turps a prohibitively expensive tree based alternative to the above stuff. It is probably "organic" and "green" so long as the tree it came from didn't die. I like the smell of it. I'll bet artists use it.

vs. Naptha Chemically equivalent to mineral spirits but significantly more volatile.

the last time this issue came up someone fretted about benzene in one or another of these solvents. I had checked my cheapest generic brand of paint thinner and it didn't contain any significant amount of anything aromatic(including benzene). If you want to fret about benzene hold your breath while refueling the car. Unleaded gas has plenty, or at least it used to. I guess now days it may be "corn squeezins" as we say in TN. Actually, gasoline is a superior (better solvent) brush cleaner so long as the flammability hazard is managed.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#3

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks Bill.

I was hoping you would answer.

Joe

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#4

specifics on ms, naphtha, odorless and turps

Michael Dresdner

>Paint thinner is another name for mineral spirits, but it is usually a cheaper mixture.

Bear in mind that mineral spirits is a 'soup' of various alkanes (aliphatic hydrocarbons) and depending on how much of which ingredients are in the 'soup' you can get a slightly oiler or faster mineral spirits. In the formulating industry you can buy mineral spirits that are faster or slower, some as slow as turpentine, but in hardware stores, you get whatever that company decides to call mineral spirits or paint thinner -- a bit of a pig in a poke.

Naphtha, or VM&P (varnish makers' and painters') naphtha, is the same basic alkane soup as mineral spirits. However, it is a slightly different mixture designed to dry faster. The difference has to do with flash point. If the flash point is above 100 F, it is called mineral spirits. If below 100, it is called naphtha. This is a legal definition so it is one you can count on. Lower flash point translates into faster evaporation.

Odorless mineral spirits, or Stoddard solvent, is another similar soup, but instead of the wider mix of alkanes you find in naphtha or mineral spirits, it contains primarily isoparaffins. These are alkanes that have lower odor, but are usually not quite as good a solvent for some materials as are the ones used in more smelly mineral spirits, and dry slower than naphtha and slower than many other mineral spirits formulations.

Turps or turpentine is an entirely different class of chemical. Derived from wood rather than from petroleum, it is largely made up of terpines, which generally do not occur in the other three. Although it will solvate many of the same resins and waxes, it does have the ability to solvate some resins the others will not. Hence, it is still used in some natural resin varnish formulations, mostly among violin makers. It is more dangerous to humans, smells worse and costs more than its petroleum based counterparts, and is best used only when you actually need its special solvent properties. It dries slower than naphtha and slower than most mineral spirits.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#5

Turps are more dangerous to humans than MS?

Chris Knob

>I had always heard use it when you could find it because it was a wood product rather than a petro product and was frendlier. Not that it's an issue anymore...the cans of turpentine have all but disappeared from the home center shelves. I'm glad I stayed away from it.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#6

Re: Turps are more dangerous to humans than MS?

Fred Davis

>I used to as nearly everybody including professional painters pay the price for "paint thinner" until one day I was talking to a Shell guy at their fuel distributor in Fremont , he said their solvent , sold by them and called sovent was the same as paint thinners and about a fourth the cost of branded paint thinner.

All I had to do was brin a empty five gallon container and they filled it at the local shell station.

It looked and smelled and acted like retail paint thinner at 22 cents a gallon, probably more now ;-))

FredD

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#7

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Keep in mind that the EPA rules on hazordus (sp) waste designate that any material with a flash point below 140 degrees F. falls in this catagory and must be handaled according to EPA rules (read MSDS's)

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#8

How strange!

John in NM

>I always thought turpentine smelled waaaay better than paint thinner! (But not quite as good as Hoppe's #9)

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#9

Re: specifics on ms, naphtha, odorless and turps

Sgian Dubh

>Michael, just to add an international dimension to your descriptions, here in Great Britain and I suspect in many other English speaking nations that don't use American English, mineral spirits is called white spirits, paint thinner, thinners, or turps. I think there are subtle differences in chemical formulation between the three much as you outlined for the American formulations, but I'm not sure of the formulations that match the names I gave.

Real turpentine is known over here as 'genuine gum turpentine' or sometimes 'genuine American gum turpentine'.

For others that come across British texts and wonder what the the author is describing, another one to watch out for is what is commonly called 'meths' or 'industrial methylated spirit' over here-- it's alcohol. Slainte.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#10

Hoppe's #9

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Now that brought back fond memories-pheasant season. Don't have pheasants in TN.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#11

Re: No pheasants in TN just elephant sanctuary

GalenV

>

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#12

Re:Could we use paint thinner in place acetone?

North of the Border

>

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#13

Re: specifics on ms, naphtha, odorless and turps

Steve Schoene

>The other solvent seen talked about is the d-limonene or citrus solvent. This seems to be promoted as a somehow "safer" solvent in products marketed as "green", but that's not what I read in other sources. Do you have a take on this material?

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#14

Thanks for the replies!

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#15

JL

No, acetone is entirely different.

JL

>Acetone is a ketone with the basic structure of CH3-CO-CH3 (2 methyl groups on either side of the ketone carbonyl). Paint thinners, mineral spirits are petroleum distillates. They are basically a mixture of different isomers of alkanes (of various lengths) and sometimes include aromatics.

Acetone has some dipole moment and is miscible (dissolves) in water. Paint thinner and mineral spirits will not dissolve in water.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#16

miscible - I didn't know that!!

John K Jordan

>

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#17

citris solvent, d-limonene

Michael Dresdner

>Steve wrote: "The other solvent seen talked about is the d-limonene or citrus solvent. This seems to be promoted as a somehow "safer" solvent in products marketed as "green", but that's not what I read in other sources. Do you have a take on this material?"

d-limonene is one half of a racemic mixture. For the non-chemists, a racemic mixture consists of two molecules in equal measure that are mirror images of one another in so far as how they bend light, but are otherwise identical. They are designated as d and l, which stand for dextro, or right rotating and levo, or left rotating.

Taken together, d and l limonene form a racemic mixture called dipentene, a solvent that happens to occur naturally in a number of things, citric fruit among them.

Dipentene is a most peculiar racemic mixture in that claims have been made that one half of it (d-limonene) is more hazardous to health than the other half. In fact, I've seen reports of it being carcinogenic. Although this seems quite unlikely and counter intuitive, chemistry is full of unlikely things, so I really can't vouch for the veracity one way or the other.

At any rate, by isolating only one half of the mixture, in this case the l-limonene, you can create what is viewed as a safer solvent, and that is what most of the sellers of citric solvent are doing.

To me, it seems like a very expensive way of selling mineral spirits, since even the safer half is not much different in terms of human safety than plain old mineral spirits. However, if it is extracted from citric rinds, it tends to retain some of the citric oils, and hence has a more pleasant smell.

For everyone: Please don't assume that because something comes from nature that it is safer than things we synthesize. Poison ivy comes from nature, as do poison dart frogs, toxic toadstools and a host of other natural dangers. Of course, in this case both mineral spirits and l-limonene or dipentene come from natural sources. Mineral spirits comes from crude oil, which is just as natural, though less renewable, than orange rinds.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#18

The attributes of gasoline

Yonak

>I needed to use a paint sprayer I had not used in awhile. As a matter of course, I store the nozzle and bezel in a jar of the solvent for the type of finish I use that sprayer for (whether that's a good idea or not, I don't know, but it works for me).

I found the supposedly-clean solvent sort of a light green, and the nozzle and bezel were coated in a very tough green gunk. I gunked-up two old toothbrushes trying to clean up using the solvent. I guess I must have used lacquer thinner to store the nozzle in after using it for an oil paint.

I remembered this thread and decided to try gasoline. It worked like a charm. It got every bit of gunk out of all the holes .. whatever it was that was in them.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#19

Re: citris solvent, d-limonene *LINK*

Alex Grigoriev

>Many "left" and "right" variants (optical isomeres) of compounds have different biological activity. The most striking example is meth (see the link).


Chirality

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#20

It is a wonderful solvent

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Looking at gasoline from the perspective of it as a solvent you could reasonably consider it a mixture of naptha like stuff and xylene like stuff. Xylene is a way better solvent than naptha for paint materials. So it follows that gasoline is an excellent paint solvent. And it is cheap and readily avaiable from your lawn mower gas can. And it has a flash point that makes it very scary to use if there is any ignition source within many feet of where it is used. Hey, it ignites in N. Dakota this time of year.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#21

Be careful...

Mike Bauer

>I had a boss who died of leukemia that the doctors linked back to skin exposure while using gasoline as a solvent. He used it to clean the oil based paint out of his brushes after some painting, just months before his death.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#22

do I understand correctly.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That your boss, within months of an exposure, contacted this disease and that the doctor knew that this boss got the disease from gasoline and not the other unknown factors causing this disease in everyone else that has gotten it? Furthermore, that the zillions of other persons that have had more contact with gasoline somehow avoided this fate? And that the perception of this doctor to determine this cause and effect just from interviewing the patient as to what he had done in the last few months has failed to make him news worthy, if not rich and famous?

There are lots of reasons to be wary around gasoline but I am skeptical that this is one of them. Of course anyone living in CA is uniquely exposed to all sorts of things known to the State to cause cancer, including a fishing lure I bought there.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#23

Re: do I understand correctly.....

Howard Norman

>Yup, I think that you have it right Bill.

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#24

Re: The attributes of gasoline

John K Jordan

>Gasoline can be a terrible hazard. A guy we knew was burned badly when FUMES from his can drifted across the yard and were ignited, resulting in the nearly empty can exploding. Remember that a gallon of gasoline contains enough energy to propel an automobile perhaps 20 or 30 miles through the air, discounting air friction.

If no other solvent would work, I think I would work outdoors away from everything.

JKJ

Re: Mineral Spirits vs. Paint Thinner vs. Turps...

#25

Am I going to DIE????!!!!

Barry Irby

>I have had far more exposure to gasoline than that. I grew up on a farm. Almost everybody I knew as a young man had more exposure than that. Oh No! How many times did I wash my hands with gasoline. How much of id did I syphon? Did I swallow any? How long do I have?