Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Difference in router bit noise...

Posts

Difference in router bit noise...

#1

Difference in router bit noise...

Ralph Turney

>Hey all,

I live in a condo and have a really you know what as a neighbor who would love to report me (or anyone for that matter) for just about anything. So to do my woodworking and not disturb any of my more sensitive neighbors, I try to keep the noise to a minimum.

I'm making my daughter a sleigh bed and I spent some time making a template for them. I rough cut the legs out today and will set up the router table to route the legs using the template as a guide. I have a straight bit with a bearing on top, but I saw the same bit that has a spiral cutting edge on it. I would imagine that the spiral bit would make a cleaner cut, but would it also be quieter???

If the spiral bit will be quieter, then I'll spend the money on one, but only if it's quieter.

So what's the verdict...straight or spiral???

TIA

Ralph

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#2

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

mike@American Sycamore

>Ralph,

Fitst of all tell the &*^hole to mind his own business or you will have your CIA,FBI, or KGB friends eliminate him and his little dog too. Now back to reality.....interesting question and I did not know the answer so out to the shop and I chucked up a two flute bearing bit 1/2" diameter and made a cut and then chucked up my solid carbide spiral upcut 1/2" bit and made a cut. With the dust collection on both bits are about the same level of noise but with no dust collection running the spiral bit was (very noticeable) more quite. No way to measure it but I am quessing a 1/3 or so. Hope this helps and good luck with Mr. Friendly Neighbor.

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#3

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

Dick Coers

>Anything spiral will always be quieter than straight. It's about the shearing of the grain. The comment about the dust collector brings up a good point. When you move that extra air around a spinning cutter, all new noise dynamics begin. Does the neighbor live share a common side wall, or lower or upper floor. You might consider having a temporary wall with insulation and air space to kill the sound. Heck, I think you could put cardboard egg cartons on rigid insulation and really kill some sound. Good luck with the neighbor, I've got a battle going with a neighbor and I live in a house. He thinks my big sweetie (115 pound lab/ golden retreiver mix) is a nusiance. Dadblasted dog haters and woodworking haters!!!!

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#4

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

Fred Davis

>Ralph,

buy the spiral because it is a far cleaner cuttting bit.

If your neighbor complains about noise , if it becomes known that you are doing woodworking with power tools in a Condominium setup , you will lose the argument.

FredD

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#5

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Thanks guys, and Mike, that was nice of you to go out and do a test!!! The way my place is set up, is you turn in off the street and it's a very short alley (I'm at the end), with the garage doors (4 of them) facing each other. The only place that's attached to my garage is the nice neighbor with the loud dog...so I don't expect any problem with them. :-) The one I'm worried about is the b.... that lives in one of the units in my 4plex. She's on the board and has some personal problems that she love to take out on her neighbors (it started with me the day I moved in). The thing is, I just don't even want to get into a pissing match with any of them, so I want to do everything I can to keep things on an even keel. Luckily I live over all the garages, so I'm not worried about the idiot upstairs. I hope to be "that guy" pretty soon (I usually am, where ever I live) and maybe they'll be a little more lenient about the noise knowing I can be helpful.

The garages all face each other and do tend to amplify the noise factor.

I'll start looking to where I can find a spiral bit with a bearing on top.

Thanks again.

Ralph

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#6

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Yeah Fred, you're right and that's why I do everything I can to stay low key and as quiet as I can. I didn't find anything in the CC&R's about doing hobbies, but that doesn't mean anything if someone complains. The one that I have to watch out for has a day care business that can get pretty loud itself, but like I said, she's on the board and from a few things I've seen here, corruption starts at a very low level when it comes to elected leaders.

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#7

100.00 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Oh man, what I won't do for my neighbors!!!

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#8

Re: ouch,100 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Ralph, S

Sorry to hear about #hole neighbors. You might try these, maybe a little less than 100 bucks for the spiral, I'm not sure if the shear cut from MLCS is any quieter than a straight cut, but it might be worth the $$ to try.

http://www.routerbits.com/cgi-routerbits/sr.cgi?1230701355_16140+98

http://mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/bt_flush.html

If the DC/Shop vac is noisy, Fein vacs are supposed to be significantly quieter than others.

Good luck

Bob

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#9

Re: ouch,100 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Hey Bob,

Yeah, the bit that would work is 20 dollars cheaper, but it's HHS and not solid carbide. I think that with the difference in how long the SC will last, I might have to go with that, but thanks a bunch. The reason the bits cost so much is I'm shaping 8/4 cherry and I need at least a 2" cutting surface. I just found my Eagle cat and I'll look through there also.

Thanks,

Ralph

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#10

Re: ouch,100 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Ok, I was mostly just shooting from the hip out of sympathy/annoyance at your plight with the neighbor, stuff like that just gets my blood boiling. I wasn't sure what you were cutting, and yes, you certainly would be better off with the solid carbide.

I was just hoping to help save you a buck on something you were buying just to appease people that need to learn to mind their own business!

My sincerest wishes for the neighbor to have to move, and be replaced by another closet condo woodworker who has all the tools and machines that you don�t, and a generous need to share them with you!

Happy New Year!

Bob in NJ!:)

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#11

Condo woodworking..shared walls...tough call

Chris Knob

>Normally I'd tell u to tell your neighbor to go pound sand but what you're describing is a little like woodworking in an apartment.

When I moved into our house, our very close by neighbors had lived there for over 50 years. They were sweet on the surface but in actuality, they thought they owned the street and believed they were the final authority on how things should be run. They were quite a cartoonish couple, the wife was a blonde, beehive haired lifelong housewife who specialized in peeking through the curtains and the husband was a stone deaf former Marine who seemed nice enough but sure followed his marching orders when it came to listening to wifey. One Saturday afternoon, I was busily woodworking in my new garage shop engaging in a particularily loud woodworking act, sanding completed drawers, when I felt a tap on my shoulder. It was the husband, red faced contorted yelling at me to quiet down. There had never been harsh words between us before. Behind him in the kitchen window, I saw the characteristic yellow beehive bobing and weaving. We talked the next day I apologized for disturbing them (he seemes genuinely embarassed...he couldn't hear a thing) but the relationship remained icy. Fate intervened shortly thereafter (no messy details) and they were gone but I never forgot the lesson. Someone always hears you and sometimes, it's all they hear.

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#12

crazy neighbor: I just got out of prisonl

mike@American Sycamore

>when I built my new home in Westfield I had a crazy mean neighbor. Why he ever built a home in a sub division is beyond me? I truly believe he loved being mean and causing trouble. He hated children and pets. Called the cops on the children for drawing chalk hop scotch on the sidewalks and threatened to kill the elderly ladys poodle for pooping on the common grass, even that she always cleaned it up. I shared a common edge of my yard with this person. One day when I was mowing the wind was blowing and some of my grass was getting on his lawn (even with me bagging my grass)

He came over and began to shout at me, I told him to leave me alone or I would hurt him. So he calls the police!

They came and told him if he calls them one more time they were going to put him in jail. Seems the police had enough!

The next day his wife makes him come over to apologize. I lied to him and told him in the future to please not to get the police involed for I just got out of prison for loosing my temper and beating a man half to death. It takes about 5 minutes for this to get all around the neighborhood that I was in prison. My wife is very upset to say the least, she being a law professor. I thought it was funny and effective.....he never bothored us again.

Mike

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#13

Re: crazy neighbor: I just got out of prison

Barry Irby

>I wanted to put up a fence. I have surveyors find the property pins. Neighbor raises h$^L about the little hole they dug to uncover the pin and covers it back up. I uncover it. He covers it. The fence gets put off because the fence people can't find the pin on the day they come. I flash hot and tell the guy, "Look, even if you set off a bomb on the spot, the surveyors could mark it again and its just as much mine as it is yours!" Within a day or two several other neighbors come over and talk to me about threatening him with a bomb. Glad he moved. Don't need the fence anymore though.

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#14

Re: ouch,100 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Larry in NW Ohio

>Ralph I just looked at www.routerbits.com and found a sprial bit with a 1/2" shank, 1/2" cut,with a 1" length cut for $38 #RU5100. It`s a Whiteside bit, they are just about all I use. Good Luck with your neighbors Larry in Ohio

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#15

Re: ouch,100 buck for the flush trim spiral bit!!!

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Hey Bob, I hadn't even realized that the bit I was looking at was in fact solid carbide until I followed the link you posted. Only after thinking about it, did I make a decision to buy the SC bit. So thanks!

Unfortunately, I think my neighbor's here to stay. She's on the HOA board, an owner like me and though I'd like to feel sorry for her, I just can't.

On their cars they each have a sticker that say something to the effect of "RIP", a male name, with dates that indicate that the person was probably her brother and died a few years ago. That's awful, but the only way it's affecting me is that she's a b#%*h who's impossible to even be cordial with.

The day I moved in she threatened me with having to replace all the treads leading up to my upstairs condo, because the movers were rolling the hand trucks up them. But the real reason came out very shortly when she mentioned that it's disturbing her and the kids she takes care of. So instead of coming over and asking nicely if there's anyway we can be quieter, she threatens me with a lawsuit.

Where do people like this come from??? I may not come across like a nice guy on the internet, but I'm not really bad and I'd much rather be able to say "good morning" to my neighbors than have to be face to face with someone who pretends I don't even exist (she shuts the dumpster door on me after seeing that both my hands full of trash).

Like Rosanne Rosanna Danna says, "it's always something".

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#16

Re: crazy neighbor: I just got out of prison

Fred Davis

>This thread is a perfect example of why I live twelve miles from town , nearest neigbor is 300 yards away, raises quarter horses , is normal and friendly.

FredD

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#17

Re: crazy neighbor: I just got out of prison

mike@American Sycamore

>Amen brother Fred! I now live on a gravel road with grass growing down the middle most of the time. Most days I can mark my territory like a hound dog if I want! If I ever have to move back to town most likely I will be arrested. Love the country life. Thank the Lord!

Mike

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#18

Have you considered hand tools?

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>Granted, slower for some applications, but a lot faster than having to move; and often a lot more fun.

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#19

OT: when quarterbacks go to a dude ranch

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>do they ride quarter horses?

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#20

Re: OT: when quarterbacks go to a dude ranch

Fred Davis

>After watching the Dallas, Kansas City, and Oakland quarterbacks this year , I probably wouldn't recommend anything more stressful then a Shetland Pony on a lead line.

FredD

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#21

I hear you

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>Out of 6 adjoining properties only 2 have anyone living on them, and I can only see one of those houses and it is 300 yards away. First time in years I didn't hear the neighbors ring in the new year. I sure do love living in the sticks, yet town is only 10 miles away.

glc

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#22

I've considered hand tools.

Ralph Turney in Huntington Beach

>Hey Bill,

But I just haven't considered them for this part of the project because it's all curved surfaces (the legs) and I'm not that proficient with them when it's not a flat surface. I do most all my finish work with planes and scrapers and try to get away without any sanding at all if I can. The only tools that concern me are the router and the planer, all the others either don't produce that loud high pitch scream that can make people (me included) crazy or they aren't turned on for extended periods of time. My garage door is insulated with 2" Styrofoam and I shut it when doing something loud, but I am starting to use hand tools more and more, it's very rewarding. I have a nice set of hand planes and scrapers, but when it comes to curved surfaces...well I'm just not there yet.

Ralph

Re: Difference in router bit noise...

#23

Step over here, my boy...

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>and let's talk about spokeshaves and scratch stocks and suchlike joys.

Seriously - next time you're at your local library, see what books they have on hand tools. There's a lot of ways to work curved stuff, and sometimes, for making one piece of furniture, it's as quick as or even quicker than power tools. And can be fun.