Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

dangerous router practice

Posts

dangerous router practice

#1

dangerous router practice

Fred Davis

>Here is a observation I have often wondered about, particularly when I repeatedly see it described in wood magazines and even recommended as a way to reduce tearout while doing a router run with a hand held router.

That is the practice of climb cutting when you run into a interlocked or reversed grain,

Having done this for many years , I know how dangerous it could be for a first attempt, when a novice really doesn't realize how much power the router can exert trying to leap out of your grasp , often ruining the wood profile cut and maybe taking a chunk out of your front end.

Depending on the size of the router bit and the depth of cut , it is a practice that requires all of your attention and focus and can still occasionally backfire on you.

One note about chainsaw use, in California, OSHA came out in the late seventies with a preliminary caution about a rule being considered , that would require guards on chainsaws while in use.

Naturally this didn't happen for obvious mechanical reasons and the rule never became a requirement, but it did show the rididculous lengths that desk bound governmental dimwits would go to ,in order to make themselves feel needed and important.

So I would say from my point of view , if you climb cut , be very careful.

FredD

Re: dangerous router practice

#2

Ellis Walentine

Good advice, Fred

Ellis Walentine

>Climb cutting is something that is hard to describe in words, yet every magazine and instructor seems to recommend it as an option for routing where the grain direction is unfavorable. I've always shied away from recommending climb cutting simply because of the "touchy feely" aspect that is so critical to success and safely.

Routers are precision instruments. Most of the time, we achieve our desired results by holding our routers and/or our workpieces rigidly in relation to each other.

Climb cutting goes against our natural instinct. To do it successfully, you have to carefully test how much force the bit is going to be exerting as it attempts to fling your workpiece in the direction of rotation. Even then, you need to constantly be aware and able to moderate your pressure to allow the router to climb without digging in and ruining your whole day. Yet, you need to be ready to control any tendency of the router to run away.

I'd welcome more discussion on this.

Ellis

Re: dangerous router practice

#3

Re: dangerous router practice

Stephen Kirk

>I'd second that. Usually your better off sneaking up on the final profile and taking the last cut to remove just a tiny amount of wood. Good sharp bits, the right speed and proper wood are generally better than climb cutting.

The few times I've had to do it I prefer to have the router in the table and good control over the wood using guides, push pads, etc.

Another rule of thumb here - just because it's in a magazine doesn't mean it's a good idea.

Re: dangerous router practice

#4

Re: dangerous router practice

Bill Howatt

>I have a general distaste for routers. If you must climb cut I agree that climb cutting in the table is a better idea when possible.

Be sure you and any observers are out of the line of fire. I have shot pieces of cherry across the shop with very respectable velocities!

Bill

Re: dangerous router practice

#5

Re: dangerous router practice

john lucas

>Well as someone who learned woodworking with nothing but a handsaw and router I'm really comfortable with the router. I learned fairly quickly that you can get some nasty tearout or even big chunks coming off the piece when routing against the grain. So of course I tried taking very light cuts with success most of the time.

It didn't take long before I tried climb routing. I didn't know what it was but knew that I needed to cut with the grain if possible. It worked and I've been using it ever since.

I will agree wholeheartedly that it can be dangerous. Clamp the work well, and use 2 hands on the router. I do mention it when I teach someone to use a router but I do so with all the cautions just mentioned.

Re: dangerous router practice

#6

Only for the very experienced

Chris Knob

>and I agree that magazine recommendations for the hobbiest are ill advised. It requires lots of feel and light bites. My first climb cut was on a router table and the piece of white oak shot across the shop and broke a panel on the garage door. I've never forgotten it.

Re: dangerous router practice

#7

I can't imagine doing woodwork without it.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Woodworking became my profession before variable speed routers were even on the market. My first routers were cheap ~ 1 HP 1/4" shank size routers. I recall how hard it seemed to be to control those under-powered tools.

I think it is easier to use a powerful router with a larger bit for climb-cutting than a under-powered motor with a small bit. Because when the motor slows down, the bit can't take a proper size bite / chip that it can handle. When this happens, the user's tendency is to let up or relax, just as those larger chip bites mean more traction, and the router takes off. It is easier to choke a small router down to that level than one with enough power to just keep cutting.

Having said that, I am sure there is someone out there who has had their ass kicked by a big honking router with a big bit. You just have to know that the bit is turning clockwise as you look down on it when hand held, so it will want to go counter-clockwise whenever in contact with the work. Learning proper holding positions and stance are important, and knowing what you can do, and what you should not even try is very important.

If you don't know your limitations, and what to expect, may make it dangerous for you, but that doesn't mean that it is dangerous for everyone. I guess I own four large routers now, none of them VS, and have at times run bits with 3.5" diameter for several days at a time. I never let the router reach its full 20.000 rpms, and usually make the first three passes climbing, and the last pass the opposite.

Without doing that, I would be burning more of my work than I would send out the door. I just never like to deal with tear-out.

I remember about twenty something years ago, watching Norm demonstrating how to run a round-over down the edge of a hard-soft abrupt transition wood like fir. He said, "always go from left to right". I said to myself, I don't think I would say "always". Of course they show him starting, and ending the cut, but just before the cut-away, any keen observer would have noticed that old familiar kikk sound of the grain lifting and running down into the wood ahead of the cut, of one frame left on before the cut.

I quit living with a TV about then, but always thought. Wouldn't it have been nice if he had actually shown the right way to make that cut? They had to know he screwed up, but went ahead and showed it the wrong way anyway.

Well, that is my rant. Pile on if you must, or ask as specific a question as you can make it if you want to really learn how to do it.

Re: dangerous router practice

#9

Please help a novice...

John E in SC

>I've heard of "climb cutting" but I still don't really have a good idea of what this means. Is it feeding wood in the opposite direction than you normally wood on a router table, where the rotation of the bit tends to to "pull" the wood away from the direction of feed, and away from the fence?

Just curious,

John

Re: dangerous router practice

#10

Re: desk bound governmental dimwits

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Where did this come from? First, OSHA is a federal agency and doesn't make rules for California. Second, you're talking an alleged activity from 30+ years ago. How is that relevant to anything, especially router use?

I resent your implication that government regulators are some sort of subhuman dolts. I worked 32 years for a governmental entity and never, ever met anyone who made up rules in order to make themselves feel needed and important. We had to implement some really stupid laws, but you work with what you're given.

Re: dangerous router practice

#11

Re: Please help a novice...

Jim Dillon

>John,

You got it. Normal feed on a router table is from right to left, counter to the rotation direction of the bit which is left to right. Thus the leading edge of the bit will try to pull the wood toward the fence. This is considered safe operation and just about the only thing one has to worry about is keeping an eye on where your fingers are. Going from left to right causes the router bit to try and push the wood away from the fence. This, while somewhat dangerous, is not the truly dangerous part. The really scary thing is that the bit can grab the wood and tear it from your hands, despite your best efforts to hold onto it - and possibly pull your fingers into the bit. The danger escalates when working on small pieces of wood. There are ways to minimize the danger, especially on small pieces, but climb-cutting, at least in my hands, is something to be treated with due respect both in a table mounted and handheld router. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: dangerous router practice

#12

Very Bad Advice

Rick Christopherson

>

Bill Howatt said:
I agree that climb cutting in the table is a better idea when possible.
Climb-cutting with a table mounted router is much more dangerous, because more often than not, the workpiece does not have handles comparable to those of the tool, and secondly, because the mass (inertia) of the workpiece is much lower than that of the tool. It is far easier to lose control of the workpiece than it is to lose control of the router. I use climb-cutting very frequently, but I will never do so with a table mounted router.

Re: dangerous router practice

#13

Re: Please help a novice... *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

>The real problem with learning about climb-cutting is that it is a real catch-22. It is a common practice by many woodworkers, but no one is willing to discuss it in any instruction manual--until now.

Every single router manual by all known manufactures automatically states to never climb-cut, without making any type of acknowledgment that many woodworkers will eventually try it. As a result, novice woodworkers are left to make their own mistakes in learning about the procedure. UL 60745-2-17 is the document that controls what is presented in a router's instruction manual, yet nowhere in UL60745 does it make any mention that climb-cutting should not be practiced. It is simply an exclusion that manufacturers imposed on their own because no one was willing to explain it.

The newest version of the Festool OF2200 Router Manual (PDF) now discusses climb-cutting, and what to avoid in the process. It took a lot of work to get this information past the lawyers. The link below goes to the page displaying all of the Festool documents I have written for them.


img

Festool Manuals and Documents

Re: dangerous router practice

#14

Re: Good advice, Fred

Glenn Clabo

>I agree... however...it would be helpful if comments like this didn't start the discussion...

"desk bound governmental dimwits would go to ,in order to make themselves feel needed and important."

Re: dangerous router practice

#15

Re: I agree - many times it's very useful

Bill White

>In defense of Dave (not that he can't hold his own), it has been my experience that ALL instructions, manuals, etc. have to be written at the level plausable and helpful to the first-time user. If they were not, the books would weigh tons, and nobody would read 'em anyway.

Let's not "pound" the tech writers.

Bill

Re: dangerous router practice

#16

Re: desk bound governmental dimwits

Fred Davis

>The note about chainsaw use was intended as a reply to the thread on chainsaws.

Also I don't remember if it was CalOSHA or the Fed version , but they both suffered from the same lack of common sense.

I dealt with these people , along with every other contractor and developer in the State of California , and I challenge anybody to find one of us who had to put up with their ill thought out and difficult to down right impossibile to do rules that remembers them fondly.

My brother in law was a GS 16 for the feds in Washington , he certainly wasn't dimwitted , nor did he work for OSHA.

One last word on goverment workers, some certainly are neccassary , many should have to show that their employment serves a useful purpose , just like private industry .

FredD

Re: dangerous router practice

#17

Re: Please help a novice...

Fred Davis

>Rick , that link to Festool router use is very informative and you would be doing a service to paste the section on climb cutting on this thread.

FredD

Re: dangerous router practice

#18

Re: Please help a novice...

Rick Christopherson

>Thanks Fred. Actually, the whole center section of the manual spanning Basic Routing and Advanced Routing Techniques is valuable information for any router owner, not just Festool owners. So it would be a disservice to focus solely on the climb-cut section. There is a lot more good stuff in there.

Re: dangerous router practice

#19

Necessary Evil

Chris Knob

>Like any creation of government, there are going to be actions and protocols spelled out by OSHA that will cause you to double over with laughter and grind your teeth with anger but we have no one to blame but ourselves. If you want to define dumbwitted, look at the practices and expectations of industry 50, 60 years ago and the equal ignorance and stupidity of boneheads like myself who would still rather breathe in dangerous wood dust than wear a simple mask in the shop and you have a recipe for comic folly. For example, a non-OSHA story...I'm a biomedical researcher in real life and the guidelines for shiping research bacterial strains through carriers are maddening and they change almost monthly...and we have no one to blame for the senseless hoops we have to jump through because some of us still would dry down staph bacteria on a filter disk, shove it into a regular mail envelope and send it off to a collegue across the country to sit in a mail sack next to your electric bill and your neighbor's birthday card. The dumbwittedness usually starts with the morons on the front lines when it comes to safety regulations.

Re: dangerous router practice

#20

Re: Please help a novice...

Fred Davis

>Rick,

your right about the overall discourse on router use at the Festool site, but I fail to see a disservice anywhere in excerpting a few short paragraphs on the dangers of climb cutting , since that is the subject this thread was started on.

The reason I asked for a posting of that particular section is because I am aware of the reading habits of a large section of the population that will not lift a finger or a cursor to go there , but will read the section if it is presented.

Beyond that , you have done all you can trying to inform.

Thanks for the entire section , it's to bad a American company could not have done that , but we seem to lag greatly behind our fellow European woodworkers in safe working habits and practices.

FredD

Re: dangerous router practice

#21

Ellis Walentine

Follow up on climb-cutting

Ellis Walentine

>Thanks for the link to your manuals, Rick. Your climb-cutting discussion is definitely a breakthrough. It's hard to believe that the lawyers went along with this -- very forward-thinking on the part of Festool and a testimony to your credibility.

One thing I would add from my experience is the concept of taking a very light pass on the first climb cut. The amount of "grab" you encounter on a climb cut is proportionate to the density of the wood and the size and rim speed of the cutter. A very shallow pass gives you a chance to test the grab of the bit before committing to a more ambitious pass that might push the limits of your ability to control the router. Also, the main reason to climb cut is to eliminate or reduce tearout at the entry point of the cutter. A very shallow pass is usually sufficient to give you a nice clean edge, after which you may be able to follow up with a regular push cut. If the grain direction is still too nasty for a push cut, you can take several more light climb cuts to arrive at your final depth. As far as I know, there's no real reason to try to hog it out in one or two passes except to save some time.

On another note, I used to use the climb-cutting technique for jointing the edges of particularly gnarly or splintery veneers. Normally, I just sandwich the veneers between plywood cauls with straight edges and trim the edges with a block plane. But, for those really unfriendly veneers that can't be planed by hand, a pattern bit and a climb cut is an excellent way to go. This is one operation where there is very little grab, so you can do it with relative confidence.

Ellis

Re: dangerous router practice

#22

Re: Follow up on climb-cutting

Rick Christopherson

>

Ellis Walentine wrote:
Thanks for the link to your manuals, Rick. Your climb-cutting discussion is definitely a breakthrough. It's hard to believe that the lawyers went along with this -- very forward-thinking on the part of Festool and a testimony to your credibility.

One thing I would add from my experience is the concept of taking a very light pass on the first climb cut.....


Thanks Ellis. I too was surprised that I was able to get this information past the lawyers, but that is only because no one had ever done it before. I explained to them that climb cutting is kind of like the dirty little secret of woodworking that most users will eventually try, and it is a common practice for many, but it is treated as though it doesn't exist in any of the documentation. It was the explanation that users are left to learn by mistake that gave me enough justification to get it put in.

However, being the first manual to ever acknowledge the practice, I didn't want to throw caution to the wind. I tried to focus the discussion more on "what not to do" versus "how to do it." Unfortunately, telling people what not to do is too similar to a warning message (for lawyers), so the final version of what I wrote is not the same as what I originally intended.

The importance of making a shallow pass is there, but its predominance got lost in the edits. It is also kind of difficult to explain how to make a shallow pass when the router's guide bearing is not guiding the pass.

Re: dangerous router practice

#23

Re: dangerous router practice

John Crouse

>With climb cutting what they don't tell you is you can do it with the newer router bits. They are designed so that they are limited in how much of a bite they can take much like the rakers on a chain saw. It is very difficult to try a climb cut even with a 1/4 round over with the older bits. A lot of your shaper cutters are designed that way, but I don't recommend trying climb cutting by hand. You can climb cut on a shaper using a power feeder.

Re: dangerous router practice

#24

Re: dangerous router practice

Fred Davis

>Glad to hear it John, it is stress relieving to know the bit can only bite a limited amount of whichever part of you that gets in the way. ;-))

FredD

Re: dangerous router practice

#25

Re: Good advice, Fred

Richard Beveridge

>I have used climb-cutting with a router for many years and have had no problems in doing so. As long as the wood is securely held down, and reasonably light cuts are taken with a good heavy router, then I dont see a problem. One should take into consideration when climb-cutting around the outside of a door frame, that at 2 points, you are going to strike end grain unless the frames are mitred, and this can cause a severe change in the ammount of strenght required to hold against the router.Always be aware of this.

Richard Beveridge

Fremantle Australia