What I have done...
Grant in Iowa
>First, let me preface this with a warning: Try the less invasive solutions first such as cleaning and the "disc washer" solutions.
Here's my method that has worked dozens of times.
-A spiral sewn buffing wheel at medium speed (maybe 1200 RPM or so...)
-buffing compund suitable for plastic (available at Sears). I use white, the going is slow, but mistakes are also slower...
-Arbor for the buffing wheel to adapt it to your drill press... allows speed control to achieve 800 to 1200 RPM.
1. Install the buffing wheel on the arbor and then into the DP chuck. Set the DP speed to between 800 and 1200 RPM (I use 1200).
2. Turn on the DP and "load the wheel" with rouge. If you aren't familiar with using a buffing wheel, try buffing something indestructable and cheap first, such as a craftsman screwdriver handle. Also practice on a non-critical CD, before you graduate to the subject CD.
-Notes: ALWAYS buff on the side of the wheel spinning away from you, so that the object being buffed cant be thrown towards you if it catches. Any of the objects edges can "catch" the spinning wheel, and be thrown. Also, this is one operation where leather gloves would be a good idea.
3. Now that you are all practiced up, add rouge to you wheel again and hold the CD in your gloved palm so the bottom surface is up, and the part you want to buff is away from you. introduce it to the wheel such that the wheel begins contacting it just outside of the center (BUT not catching the center hole!), and leaving the CD near its edge. Use a light touch and stop to clean the rouge off with water to inspect your work. You'll notice the buffing wheels contact patch has a sweet spot that yields the best action. Pay attention to this and use it to your advantage.
-Most CD's have a layer of plastic that is thick enough so you can even sand with 800-1200 grit paper to remove deeper scratches, then buff out the sanding marks.
I have saved about 80% of the discs I have tried to fix using this technique. Honestly, I have not tried reading up more on plastic polishing, but that might be the best approach for anyone wanting to have the best possible chance of success.
Hope this helps!
Grant in Iowa <---recently saved a WindowsXP disc I needed to reinstall.