Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Design help - natural edge table

Posts

Design help - natural edge table

#1

Design help - natural edge table

JohnM in Mid Mich

>Getting ready to build a dining table in Nakashima-inspired style. Will be natural edge cherry slabs for top. I'm interested in hearing ideas about the base. Nakashima seemed to use quite refined, almost Danish-modern, structural elements as counterpoint to the live-edge planks. Frankly, I think an Arts and Crafts trestle base would work, but I'm hoping for some inspirational thinking. What would you do?

John


img

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#2

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A recurring and distinguishing design characteristic of Nakashima's work are the table bases and their joinery. You can vary the proportions and dimensions to some extent, but a faithful emulation of the style should adhere to your picture, especially with the interlocking bridle joints.

Clint

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#3

Here's an idea

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If you want to go with a trestle style, something on this order would look good.

Clint


img

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Jesper, Denmark

>The table in the picture is very elegant, but I have a problem with the foot. Technically, the stretcher at the bottom will rest on the floor and with the two cross-pieces, you will have a multi-point support, which will tend to rock if the floor is not completely even. Think of the common restaurant tables, where you nowadays cannot find a book of matches to put under the short leg!

If you try to avoid this by building a "lift" into the bottom stretcher, the load on the cross-pieces will be very high where the stretcher rests on them.

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#5

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Jim Dillon

>John,

I bought such a table about 32 years ago, but I won't be able to post a pic until, hopefully, later this week (Thursday?). The top is oak with a natural bark edge. The base consists of two trestle legs connected by a single stretcher. The legs are three pieces blended into one another by lots of bandsaw work and sanding. In this case, having a picture will make things much clearer and I will post again later this week.

Jim

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#6

Re: Design help - natural edge table

JohnM in mid Mich

>I've definitely not ruled out trying to stay true to actual Nakashima designs, but am open to alternatives, as well, if there are any. Although I have several books on Nakashima (e.g. Soul of a Tree), I don't have anything that shows the details of construction. Are you aware of any book, magazine article, or web site that shows the details for a table base?

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#7

Re: Design help - natural edge table *LINK*

Chris Friesen

>You might want to look at the "American Trestle Table" in issue 6 of Woodworking Magazine. The stretcher is raised up high so feet and knees don't hit it, and it's got nice clean lines.


http://www.popularwoodworkingshop.com/product/295/

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#8

Re: Design help - natural edge table *LINK*

JohnM in Mid Mich

>Chris:

Thanks. That might be just the right design. Will have to see if I have that issue, or buy one. Am also thinking of using a "Frenchman's Cove" base, as per the link.


Nakashima Frenchman's Cove Table

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#9

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>John, I have a series of tables that I have been building for around 25 years, that might work with a natural edge top, although I have not used that kind of top before. I usually use a heavy glass top, so you can see through it.

I stretch or compress the proportions to suit the required dimensions. Here is a link to one on my site. Let me know if it looks like something that you might want to adapt. I might could find some old drawings.

Dang, I can't believe I don't have more of them in my digital photo library. I need to work on that. K

http://treetales.com/gallery/furn/furnindex.htm

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#10

Couple more ideas

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The bench is simple trestle design that could be adapted to a table with the slab ends canted either out or in.

The table base is also a trestle, but done in brass tubing with flush fittings. It was originally just polished, but a later attempt to apply a patina went awry, so I finished it with auto lacquer.

Clint


img

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#11

One more

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A post and slab combination trestle by Nakashima's grandson, Ru Amagasu.

Clint


img

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#12

Breathtaking

JohnM in Mid Mich

>Yikes. Humbling experience to visit your web site. Wow, wow, wow! Would love to see your work in person! Yes, the base on Table.jpg looks like the right thing if spread for a long dining table. And yes, a drawing would help immensely! Wow. Interestingly, my cherry slabs are salvaged from a cherry that blew down in a tornado a while back. Highest and best purpose is a living, growing tree, but if nature brings it down, I think next highest is to become loved furniture.

Thanks

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#13

Re: Couple more ideas

JohnM in Mid Mich

>I like your trestle a lot. What is the shape of the upright slabs? Or are they natural?

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#14

Re: One more

JohnM in Mid Mich

>I like this style a lot, but think it might come across as too "heavy". I try to picture it as I approach the entrance to the dining room. That upright slab seems too much of a presence. The more I see, the more I think that there is some kind of sweet spot between too frail and too muscular. And to tell the truth, that spot is probably a matter of taste. (Metaphor abuse here?) My wife actually wants me to pattern the base after the one on my workbench, which represents one extreme of muscular. I think that would detract from focus on the top slabs. Anyway, thanks again Clint.

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#15

Re: Couple more ideas

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The slabs are slightly trapozoidal, wider at the bottom. But it's a design that you could play around with; the slabs could be a combination of either canted in or out, and wider at the top or bottom. Good luck.

Clint

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#16

oval love seat

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Keith,

Your love seat is a wonderful example of a design influenced by a well known existing piece. While it pays tribute to FLW's barrel chair I also see a strong personal aesthetic influenced more by McIntosh. By incorporating the dominating oval element with the asymmetrical pattern in the back you have made it 100% your own original design. I realize you have more experience than I, but this is exactly what I encourage others to do, to use someone else's existing design as a starting point and then make it your own. Beautiful piece.

Robin

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#17

Here is another

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>John, I don't know if you saw this piece when it was first posted in the shopshots, but it is another piece of that series. I will try to find a drawing, and or send you some pics of a model disassembled.

http://www.woodcentral.com/shots/shot728.shtml

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#18

Re: oval love seat

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Thanks Robin for the fine compliment. I think I made that piece about 20 ~ 24 years ago. It would be fun to see what came out if someone offered me a commission to do the next version.

It is a crying shame that there are not more patrons out there willing to give more Designer / Makers more freedom, and steady work.

Thanks again. K

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#19

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Jim Dillon

>John,

As promised, here is a pic of the legs on the table I mentioned. I had to do a little Photoshop work to clone out the remains of dried cat barf that I didn't see when I took the pick 8-). Anyway, yet another option for leg treatment.

Jim


img

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#20

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Alex Grigoriev

>You don't mean cat barf is another option for leg treatment, do you? ;=)

Re: Design help - natural edge table

#21

Re: Design help - natural edge table

Jim Dillon

>Alex,

LOL!! I didn't see the double meaning in that sentence when I wrote it. Cats and nice furniture were not meant to be together I think. And a neighborhood dog once came over and left claw marks on top of a one day old, newly finished outdoor umbrella table; he was going after the soup on the table. Grrrr! Yet we have four dogs and now five cats. So go figure.

Jim