Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

New Law could close small shop toymakers

Posts

New Law could close small shop toymakers

#1

New Law could close small shop toymakers

Howard Acheson

>You might want to go here: http://www.forums.woodnet.net/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=4027593&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=14 and read about a new law going into effect early next year.

It looks like it could even apply to toys made in our own shops it they are given to our own children under 12 years old.

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#2

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>"VE know better, and YOU WILL )OBEY"....javowl

Welcome to the American Nazi country

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#3

The road to H*** is paved with good intentions

Terry in Edmonton

>

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#4

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

Chuck in ND

>I'm not sure how that would apply to your own children unless they ended up in the ER for some strange reason associated with a toy you made, then I supose it could bring some charge against you, kind of unlikely though unless the toy wasn't safe, as in finished with some toxic finish, or you built something dangerous like a cross bow for the kid. Now if you are selling toys or anything else to people you don't know there is allways going to be a liability issue to think about, especially in todays world.

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#5

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

Howard Acheson

>How about if you asked me to make a toy for your child? Do I have to have it "certified"?

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#6

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

Chuck in ND

>Howard, don't get me wrong, I understand your frustration. It's tough enough out there for the little guy, and that includes me also.

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#7

Re: Saw it coming for years.

Brian in Brighton

>I hate to say I told you so, but the next time you decide to buy a toy for the kids or grandkids, look at where it's made. Odd's are very good that it's made in Asia somewhere. Demanding lower prices have pushed cheap manufacturing overseas. Just give the kid one or two decent toys and the rest can be clothes (nope they are made there too). Think about that the next time you walk into a place like Walmart and demand cheaper prices. I tried to make a business making toys and it failed. People do not want a quality wood truck for $6 when they could go to Wally world and get one with opening doors that makes sounds for $5. We had trucks and cars and blocks and all kinds of things. Took about 9 months to be out of business back in 1994.

Simply put, if we had any regulations at all this would not have happened. All the regulatory agencies that were in place to keep this from happening have been gutted. We need to stop congressmen who believe in self regulation only, as it clearly has been proven over and over that businesses will bend every rule possible to save a penny. We need reasonably regulations. Maybe preliminary testing and then annual, or volume, random testing again. You break the rules on a product more than twice and it is prohibited from entering the US. Unfortunately that only means that these scum making these tainted toys will just push them on the rest of the kids in the world. It can all be handled with the proper, reasonable, regulations and oversight. We can all make a living and make safe toys.

As far as one of us woodworkers being in trouble, unless you sell in large volumes (or are using unsafe products) I would not concern myself. Make your toys and sell them as you wish.

Brian in Brighton

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#8

Re: Saw it coming for years.

steve mackay

>Just my own little, itty-bitty, humble, stupid opinion but I wish there was LESS government interfearance,oversite, control and regulation. I could probably afford to hire an apprentice and stimulate some economy. (Of course I'd make him make wheels 'till he was blind !) But, then, I'm that "rugged individualist" everyone seems to be terrified of.

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#9

Re: Saw it coming for years.

Brian in Brighton

>Steve, It's not your opinion alone, and it's not foolish. I, also, would like less government. I would also like the death penalty for every person who adds lead to toys, melamine to childrens milk, drugs to beef and much else. The company should be shut down and everyone associated with the decision to put other peoples lives at risk without telling them should be executed.

Unfortunately the regulations that are put in place are usually done so because some bonehead tries to save a penny by doing something unsafe. Meanwhile, you and I, have nothing to let us know that. Ingredient labels on food are only on the package because regulations make it happen. Cows can't be fed the remains of other cows because regulations now make that illegal. It was done to save a buck, not because it was better for the cows than grasses.

How can you be sure that the plastic that you store leftovers in is not causing cancer? Because someone else has made a regulation that says that it must be tested to show that it does not outgas hazardous chemicals. How do you know that the ink used to print the picture of Hello Kitty on a little girls shirt does not contain lead?

The simple fact is that people will do whatever it takes to save a buck. Without any regulations nothing that you eat or drink would be safe. It might be, but you have no means of proving it. With the history of shananigans we can say that it has a good chance of being unsafe. We, consumers, must rely on regulations to make sure that some idiot is not adding plastics to our baby formula or lead to our kids toys. This is how we know that if someone decides to use a tank car for corn syrup that was previously used for gasoline that someone gets fined or jailed.

Another woodworking way to look at it. How do you know that the wood you purchase is not contaminated with radiation from Chernoble? You don't know, and neither do I. Someday that lumber from around that plant will come on the market since it will be left alone to grow for a long time and be very nice wide wood. Who will put the regulations on the wood coming from Russia to be sure it's not radioactive? Will it take hundreds of woodworkers being sick to even look into it?

This is why we need regulations. Reasonable ones, but we do need them. As the world gets smaller and we have no idea where our products come from we need some checks and balances to make sure this stuff is safe. Unfortunately it took some moron to ruin it for the rest of us, as usual.

Brian in Brighton

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#10

been through it already

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I took a glance at the relevant legislation pertaining to this thread and one thing was glaringly obvious. It was very poorly written. The requirement for toys to be tested and who will certify who and when were all decided on but the actual requirements were not written into the law.

I am sure there are some loop holes and grey area just not sure where they are and how little guys can take advantage of them. For the big manufacturers they will be able to apply to become a certifying inspector, the old fox watching the hen house gig.

I have run up against something similar when trying to market the lamps I make. I use only Leviton components, all of which are UL listed. I buy my cords with molded plugs already attached and they too are UL listed. This does not make my lamps UL listed or "legal". It would cost me $600 just to find out what the requirements for a UL listed lamp are and another $1,800 to go through the process of getting each lamp design UL listed. Most people assume that Underwriters Labs is a government agency. It's not, it is a for profit business.

For me the grey area or loop hole is that I am an artist and I make art that happens to have light in it. Art is considered decorative and as long as it is not hard wired into a building the UBC has no say in what or how I make my art and it is not subject to UL approval.

I am going to guess that the same would apply to this law, if you sold art it would not come under the jurisdiction of this law. If some parent purchases a piece of your art and chooses to let their child play with it that is their choice. This is not as far fetched as it sounds there are adult toys that are more art than toy. I have seen some beautiful models of cars and planes that are clearly not meant for children to play with, but the wheels roll and they could be played with. The defining language in the legislation is that if the intended user is under 12 then this law applies. If you say the intended user is an adult and it is art who can say you are wrong.

I did say it was poorly written didn�t I?

Robin

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

#11

Re: New Law could close small shop toymakers

Steve Schoene

>The applicability to toys made for our own use, and not sold or offered for sale, seems very doubtful, given the language of the bill.

.... Effective on the dates provided in paragraph (3), before importing for consumption or warehousing or distributing in commerce any children's product that is subject to a children's product safety rule, every manufacturer of such children's product....

Which seems pretty clearly to not apply to items not distributed in commerce.

There are plenty of other points that are not at all clear as to how regulations would be written to implement the legislation. For example, in some contexts, "commerce" , includes only items in commerce between or among states (the consitutional requirement, though of course in many contexts it is hard to avoid being considered part of interstate commerce.

In short, it's not at all easy to tell yet what happens to really small "craft" manufacturers.