>I have a two year old Dewalt XRP 12v drill. It has not been used very much at all. I keep the batteries indoors in the winter and I don't leave the batteries in the charger endlessly. All of a sudden, one of the two batteries won't recharge. Is this normal? Is there anything I can do? Now I don't know if I should replace the battery or buy another new drill and if so, what brand. Suggestions please.
I've got two of those 12V drills. First came with two batteries, when they died their death and I saw the price fo replacements I bought a whole new kit (driver and 2 batteries) for the same price. Then when those two died, well..... I didn't want to spend more on those blasted batteries. I tried all the different cures. The "Freezer" trick worked really well. Stuck them in the freezer, tlet them warm up a bit, throw them in the charger and voila, full charge once again. but only for 3 or 4 cycles. Then back to dead. The frezzer trick doesn't seem to work twice, by the way.
Same is true for my Panasonic and Makita cordless drills/drivers. ( batteries all act the same.
I didn't use mine every day, but just about every weekend. Some weekends for hours at a time, but most weekends only minutes at a time. Certainly not 5 days a week jobsite type use.
I've been using my corded drills for the last little while. Love 'em except for the cord part. But dealing with the cord is a heck of a lot better than the battery issues.
I'm not buying a cordless tool like that again. I think I'll try a Lithium next.
It wouldnt' take much to find a ton of threads about this very subject. But I know that there will be quite a few responses again this time around.
>Two years ? You did good ! With my first (and LAST !) cordless drill I ordered a new battery ( $60.00 !) but the drill itself died while I was waiting. Never again.
>FWIW, I have 2 Bosch drills (14.4v & 18v NiCad) and leave one battery in the charger while the other battery is in the drill. I use the drill until the battery is noticeably low, then switch batteries. They are in my shop which ranges between 60* and 80* depending on the time of year. Both have lasted over 5 years and are going strong, knock on wood. I use them for various projects, maybe 1-2 times per week, but not for hours on end.
Now, if I could get the switch on my Bosch router to be as dependable...
This has been discussed here before. In my previous life I spent a lot of time with batteries and people who really new batteries. A buddy and I did a lot of research into batteries and built custom charging systems for nicads and lead chemistry batteries as part of our insane cave diving days. (You have to be a little insane to put on dry suits scuba gear and make decompression dives in deep holes in the rock.)
Nickel chemistry (NiCad, NiMH) batteries have the best life if used a lot. I have some Dewalt 12v batteries that are many years old, but I use them quite a bit. It is important to discharge before recharging, but also very important NOT to totally drain them dead. Nickel batteries also self-discharge by a small amount each day so if left unused long enough they can self-discharge to damaging levels.
Nicads that sit unused sometimes grow crystals or "whiskers" between the layers which will short the cell. The short is tiny but enough to prevent charging. Short just one cell in a pack of 10 cells and the pack is shot. We fixed some cells by locating the bad cell and zapping it with a significant current, usually from a bank of large electrolytic capacitors. If lucky, this can vaporize the tiny whisker and restore use to the cell.
Unbalanced packs of cells wired in series (say where one battery is weaker than the others) can develop another problem - if drained too far the weaker cell can experience voltage reversal, being charged by the other cells. This is also bad.
If you have a battery store nearby (we have a Batteries Plus near here), and if the pack can be opened (some have screws), they can rebuild battery packs for a fraction of the cost of a new one. It will probably be better than the original.
When I needed additional batteries once, I found a drill and two batteries on sale for a lot less money than just the batteries. I have too many drills now.
Another thing to check - the Dewalt rep told me that most people forget about the standard warranty on their batteries - I think she said it was three years. You might call them and give them the s/n and see if they will replace them.
However, if you rarely use the drill, getting new batteries may have you shopping again in a couple of years. A better option might be dump the drill and get one with a lithium battery. Lithium chemistry is far more forgiving for casual use. I'd get a higher voltage as well. I personally haven't gone to lithium since mine are still working fine, but I do get more use out of my 18v devices than those with 12v. I especially like the reciprocal and circular saws.
An even better option for casual use is a revolutionary new and exciting drill technology - the drill comes with an attached power cord you plug into the wall! It will always be ready to go.
>I had an Old 12v Skill drill, one of the first 12v out there, pretty sure it was at least 12 years old. I wore out the first set (2) of batteries and replaced them 7-8 years ago, these batteries were just getting to the point where I was thinking about replacing them. I used this drill alot but alway ran the battey all the way down before recharging. Then Me, a stepladder, and the drill had a disagreement with gravity. You all know who won there. I WAS holding my own for the first 7 feet, but that last inch or so and gravity kicked my ..... The good news for me was the drill didn't hit me, the bad news it did not survive the fall. Lisa and I went drill shopping I was looking for 14.4 DeWalt, based on very good luck at work. Well, the 18v Makita Hammer drill/drive kit with the impact driver fit Lisa's hands much better than the DeWalt, so I guess you know what we bought, The Makita Twin Pack. I don't know which is the biggger gloat, the new tools or a Sweetie who wants new tools too and helps me pick them out. Well, yes I really do know which is the bigger gloat.
>I don`t know why but the way I hear from messages here on WC it seems that DeWalt it the worst batteries for lasting. It seems they don`t last longer than two years. I don`t buy batteries anymore, I have then rebuilt with at least a 2400ma battery. or I`ll go to a corded drill. There is a rebuilder in Massilon, Ohio I think that can go to 3200ma. I think or higher. Go to ebay and search for battery rebuild. Larry in Ohio
>I have had outstanding service (a little slow maybe) from Ridgid on their Lifetime Service Agreement replacing the batteries and charger on my 12 volt drill. and on my ROS sander. You hve to follow the directions to the letter to rgister the tool. 5 years ad 3 free batteries.