Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Heating a woodshop

Posts

Heating a woodshop

#1

Heating a woodshop

Rod Rentz

>Here in south Georgia, I don't often have days that I cannot work in my unheated shop. But there are a few days that a little heat would not hurt. A kerosene heater is relatively inexpensive, but is it safe in a woodshop? Any other suggestions?

Re: Heating a woodshop

#2

Re: Heating a woodshop

Karen

>We don't often have a need for it here in central Louisiana either but when we built this shop we did two things -- insulated EVERYTHING and included an area for a small woodburning stove. Haven't had to burn a fire yet (although today is a possibility with it being only 29� this morning). So far, the only thing we've needed is a Coleman propane camp heater and because of the insulation, we've burned it only about an hour at a time to take the chill off. Once the shop gets to a comfortable temp, we can shut it off. This little heater takes one of the small (16 oz?) disposable cylinders that just screws in.

Looking at the week ahead weather, today may be the day to install the stove pipe. :)

Re: Heating a woodshop

#3

Unvented heaters

Forrest Addy

>I don't like unvented heaters. Unvented heaters in a tightly closed space may not be a good idea. You need some air exchange with the outdoors to encure refreshment of the air and to carry away the humidity (a little less than a quart for every pound of fuel burnt)and the CO2. If yours ia a humid environment an unvented heater may exacerbate a rust problem.

If your shop has a few gaps and cracks then you don't need to worry. If your shop has more than a few gaps and cracks, whatever heat is generated may be carried away.

A vented heater doesn't put moisture into the heated space and the combustion gasses are vented outside to the Great Dilution. Also a wood stove eliminates evidence of mistakes. RIt also consumes the rippings and remnents of the $20 per bf lumber you buy for your projects, and if carefully managed your sawdust and planer and jointer waste.

Re: Heating a woodshop

#4

Re: Heating a woodshop

John K Jordan

>Rod,

Note: like most of what you'll probably read hear, these are my opinions only, not those of a professional shop safety consultant.

It's been unseasonably cold here in TN (in the low 20s at night) and I use a kerosene heater in my little garage shop. It sits on the other side of the room from the shavings from my lathe. I tend to fire it up about 1/2 hour before I go to the shop then turn it off while working, mostly so I don't get too hot. I wear insulated overalls while working so I like it a bit cool. I did insulate walls and roof when I moved here so the room holds the heat a long time. I've never seen sawdust on it but I do run dust collection and an air filtration box when sawing and sanding.

However, I suspect it would be safe to run while working. I know I would not want wood shavings falling on a hot heater, but is just how unsafe would it be for airborne dust? You certainly can set fire to a cloud of dust resulting in a flash explosion, but it takes a significant concentration of power-fine dust in the air AND in the vicinity of the flame (inside the heater). The outside gets hot enough to cook but not hot enough for combustion. Some years ago I tried sprinkling fine sawdust all over mine to see what it would do and I could not get it to ignite.

I've heard of many people who have wood-burning stoves in woodworking shops. An old cabinetmaker down the hill heats his shop with a big woodburner while two or three people are cutting and sanding. I worry about him since the floor is usually covered with sawdust, but so far he continues.

Note: I would NEVER use something with a flame in a room during or after finishing with volatiles.

One other issue - you can't use a kerosene heater in a room without ventilation. This can defeat some of the advantage of heating since ventilating means exchanging air and losing some heat.

I've read that an electric heater is a good option, either a baseboard or one with ceramic elements, but it you may have to keep the fine sawdust cleaned off unless you have a good dust collection system.

JKJ

Re: Heating a woodshop

#5

Re: Unvented heaters

Karen

>"Also a wood stove eliminates evidence of mistakes."

LOL!

Although I prefer to think of it as a project that has been re-planned.

:-�

Re: Heating a woodshop

#6

Re: Heating a woodshop

steve mackay

>Probably same-same weather as you and I love my little over head 'lectric radiant. 'Bout just enough to take that morning chill off and warm up the glue bottle.

Re: Heating a woodshop

#7

What I do...

John E in SC

>I'm in SC, and my shop is in my unheated basement, so like you, I really just need something to "knock the chill off". I use one of those heaters that screws on top of a 20 lb propane tank. It only costs about $30 (+ the cost of the propane tank), fires right up, doesn't leave much if any smell, requires no maintenance other than the occasional spritz with compressed air to blow the dust off (NOT while in use), and it usually takes me a couple winters to empty the tank. One of my biggest dislikes of kerosene heaters is the smell - every one I've ever been around leaves an odor that seems to permeate everything. Also, you have the mess of dealing with the kerosene.

My 2 cents.

John

Re: Heating a woodshop

#8

Re: Heating a woodshop

john lucas

>I've been using a Kerosene heater in my shop in Tennessee for the last 15 years or more. It is perfectly safe as long as you follow 2 rules. Keep anything flammable more than 3 feet away and clean all dust and shavings off the thing regularly.

As a woodturner shavings are everywhere, all the time, even though I clean the shop regularly. Following the 2 rules above I've never had a problem.

Unfortunately it isn't big enough to heat my shop properly on days like today. I have been able to get it up to 50 yet. That's why I'm in here typing right now. I have to come in a warm up about every hour or so. It will probably get up to 55 or more by the end of the day. I need more insulation in my shop and a little bigger heater.

Re: Heating a woodshop

#9

I use propane also

john lucas

>I also have a small propane heater. I use it when I run out of Kerosene of the local station runs out. It doesn't heat my shop as well as the Kerosene but is much easier to fire up and doesn't smell. Having both gives me the option to use whichever one is easiest or cheapest to get fuel for. My local dealer told me I could fill a 40lb tank cheaper than my 2 20lb tanks, and of course it will last longer so I'm going to price one this week.

Re: Heating a woodshop

#10

Heating a Georgia Woodshop

Gil Jones__ SW Georgia

>Rod,

I do not know where in South Georgia you are located, but I am on the north shore of Lake Seminole (South-West GA). I insulated my shop very well (R-19 walls, and R-30 Ceiling), then bought a used 2-ton Carrier heatpump and installed it. The heatpump seems to be quite economical, and it heats and cools the shop as needed. I removed the electric heat coils and the system does a fine job of controlling the inside temperature. Insulation is the key factor. You are welcome to come visit and check it out if you are not too far from here.

Gil

Re: Heating a woodshop

#11

Re: Unvented heaters

Rob Sandow

>However, unvented heaters throw all of the heat they produce into the room. They do require some outside air to be drawn in to replace the oxygen used in combustion but they are considered safe for use indoors. Vented heaters, unless they are the type that draws in outside air for combustion, require more air to be drawn in through cracks and gaps, because the products of combustion go up the chimney, along with some portion of the heat they produce. That volume of air needs to be replaced in the room, through cracks and gaps, drawing in cold outside air and decreasing efficiency. Some very efficient and expensive vented heaters draw in outside air for combustion in a sealed chamber and send cooled exhaust gases out through PVC pipe. These are arguably better than vent free units. But a low end vented unit is less efficient than vent free.

I don't see humidity as an issue either. In the winter, the RH is low anyway, so throwing a little moisture in the air is not a bad thing. Admittedly the lower dew point will make the water condense, but it will do so on cold surfaces such as doors, windows, and exterior walls, not so much on metal tools which should absorb radiant heat.

Finally, I like to point out that if you have a gas oven in your home, you essentially have the same kind of burner as a vent free gas heater. None of them are vented, and you don't hear anyone worrying about CO or humidity problems when cooking indoors in a gas oven.

Rob

Re: Heating a woodshop

#12

Re: Heating a woodshop

David

>Up here where the snow typically lasts from late October through early April, I heat an uninsulated barn/shop (34x36) with kerosene and wood. I have a large salamander (155,000 BTU) to take off the chill and a wood furnace (60,000 BTU)for regular use. If it's not too cold, I skip the salamander. I used to have a small wood stove but upgraded, largely for the fan and thermostat. The salamander does put a lot of moisture into the air. When I relied solely on it for heat, my windows would ice over. I love the wood heat, especially because it's free (scraps and 70+ wooded acres). My neighbor uses a wall mounted, unvented propane unit that really gets his shop toasty. He's well insulated though, and the shop is about 12x30.

Just a couple of considerations. Wood heat, whether in a wood stove or furnace, comes with clearance issues. Most stoves need 3' of clearance from combustible surfaces, the stovepipe needs 18. You can cut that in half with non-combustibles. Furnaces vary (see mfg) but usually follow the 18" rule. In short, be prepared to give up floor space. Salamanders throw a lot of heat and it goes a surprisingly long way. A friend and I were working in his barn, he was on a wooden ladder, I was in the rafters, there was a salamander blasting away in the corner about six feet from the ladder. You know what's coming... couple of hours of work later, friend "falls" off the ladder. Actually, the ladder fell out from under him. One of the legs was quietly burning through--no flame--until it gave way. He was fine. But since I laughed to much for his ego, I had to find my way out of the rafters without a ladder!