Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Planning Curly Maple

Posts

Planning Curly Maple

#1

Planning Curly Maple

Greg Earley Brentwood Ca

>I'm making my daughter a jewelry box using tiger maple. Bay Area Carbide sharpened my blades so they are good and sharpe. I can just envision tearout happening. I don't have a wide belt sanding machine. Any pointers before I give it a try.

Thanks

Greg

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#2

Planing Curly Maple

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Norm,

How much material do you have to remove? If it is lot; like a 1/4 to 3/8" perhaps you could consider re-sawing. When I have a board(s) to plane like you are talking about I will take extremely light cuts through the planner. If I normally move the handle a 1/4 turn per pass I will move it an 1/8th, or less, per pass. The first pass should give you a pretty good idea of what to expect. Good luck.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#3

Louie Lovas

Re: Planning Curly Maple

Louie Lovas

>I've used the common technique of wetting the wood on the tear-out spots. Initially I read about this technique in various woodworking magazines (sorry can't remember which one - or ones). But it does work. After a few initial passes, it becomes clear where the tear out is occurring. Using a sponge soak those spots, letting the water soak in for about 30 seconds (or so).

I used this technique until I upgraded to a planer with a spiral cutter head (I use a lot of curly maple, birch, cherry). Now, I get very little tear out.

Also, I find a few passes with a finely tuned smoothing (hand) plane will clean up any remaining tear out.

best of luck, curly maple is a fantastic wood.

The trick however it in the finishing - getting the figure to "pop".

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#4

change the angle on you knives

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>The best luck I have had with curly wood is to add a bevel on the back of the knife. The exact bevel for your knives will depend on the cutterhead of your planer. You will have to figure out what the angle of atack is when the knives are at the bottom of their arc. you then hone a bevel at what ever angle it takes to result in a 55* angle of attack. basicaly you are converting your planer to a York Pitch. This will result in more of a scraping cut and it will reduce the amount you will be able to remove with each pass, but it will also result in an edge that will be stronger and last longer. This last property makes this a good modification for abrasive woods like elm and teak.

Robin

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#5

Re: change the angle on you knives

Greg Earley Brentwood Ca

>Thanks Guys for the input I'm going to give them a try.

I'm going to plane Weds morning.

Thanks

Greg

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#6

Re: Planning Curly Maple

Fred Davis

>Well Greg ,

If you had a need when I had a shop at Ray Nebergall's you could have used mine. ;-))

If I have a gnarly wood prone to tear out like a figured Maple, I use a large sponge wet with water and dampened the surface right before I run it though the planer at a angle, you will find this stops a lot of tearout.

FredD

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#7

No big secrets to reduce tearout

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>You need to read the wood before making your first pass. Look at the sides of the pieces and feed it through the planer so the ends of the grain on the surface being planed are pointing away from the direction of feed. On curly wood this can be tricky, but there is always one way that will produce less tear out than the other. Once you determine the direction of feed for each board mark it on the side with chalk so you don't get confused part way through the session. Note, if planning both sides, you need to read both sides for feed direction. This is more art than science, but after you do it for a while you will get better at it.

Take very light cuts. Take off less than .015" per pass. Yes it will take longer to plane, but clean up afterwards will be less.

Then use the angle techniques and wetting as others have suggested.

Lee

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#8

Re: change the angle on you knives *LINK*

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Robin, I agree that sharpening changes can make a huge difference, and while I don't doubt that you know what you are talking about, I think you may be speaking a different language than what I am accustom to.

What you call a back bevel, I would probable call a face bevel, because it is on the front of the knife as it meets the wood.

If the a line from center of the cutter-head to the bottom of its arc is 0�, then the best grind angle for the face bevel should subtract from the cutting angle of the head, to change the cutting angle to 10� ~ 15� range.

Here is a link to some of the best information that I know of.


http://www.woodweb.com/knowledge_base/Knife_Grindi

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#9

Mineral Spirits

Dan Moening

>I've found that mineral spirits work better for me than water.

Seems to raise the grain enough and lock the fibers together to reduce tearout.

The added bonus is that it doesn't evaporate as quickly and wont rust my plane blades.

As stated above, grain direction is really the key. Skewing the stock into the planer will sometimes help as well.

~Dan.

Re: Planning Curly Maple

#10

Re: change the angle on you knives

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>You are 100% correct about the change being to the front or leading edge of the blade. I hesitated about calling it a back bevel and only did so because it is adding a bevel to the reverse side of what is the primary grind. The article you linked to has some good pics. The one thing I find a bit confusing is what they refer to as the cutting angle. I refered to it as the angle of atack, not necessarily a better term. I prefer to keep it consistant with hand planes and refer to that angle as being between the horizontal surface of the board and the face of the knife the same as on a hand plane. no matter what the angles and bevels are called the modification works and the pics on the linked page will hopefully make it clearer than my muddy description.

Robin