Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT- Rant - OT

Posts

OT- Rant - OT

#1

OT- Rant - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I had already decided not to eat anything made or packaged in China. The cough syrup, candy, infant formula, and dog food, all deadly. I am sure there have been many more deadly products but that is just recently.

Today we loaded cattle. On the way to market a tire just purchased and only having about 400 miles on it blows on the cattle trailer. Then after another 25 miles the second tire goes same use. Dan left at 11:00am and just got to the market at 4:00pm; it is usually a 2 1/2 hour trip. Both tires had just been bought from the local farm supply. Guess what? they were made in China. That is it; I am not buying anything of any importance that has been made or packaged in China.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#2

I Understand Your Frustration

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Barbara,

The trick is to find an alternative NOT made or packaged in China. To be sure, food stuffs from here and elsewhere are abundant, but all sorts of other consumer goods are not competitive at the Chinese/Wall Mart price points. Its just not that the goods are Chinese: they are also often shoddy, and I hate shoddy stuff no matter where its made. Sorry about your tires. They sure were mounted on the Pacific "Rim".

George

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#3

Ellis Walentine

Chinese goods

Ellis Walentine

>China has been a tough nut for American firms wanting to outsource there, not least in the machinery arena. The prevailing mentality is that if you can't be there on the ground to inspect production, you take your chances with the end product. We all need to be more discerning when buying goods from China.

Ellis

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#4

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>The tire brand was Liberty.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#5

Re: OT- Rant - OT *LINK*

GalenV

>I did not see Liberty in this article but sounds like they say there may be more tires than they know. Like yours!

I retired from Siemens Water Technologies, who make municipal and industrial water and wastewater treatment equipment. Where some of your billions of tax money goes. They are closing the Ames fab shop to use more US outsource fabrication. They never take the time to inspect these fabrications shops nor the work before shipment.

The quality is so poor for example, one of our service techs spent an entire year at the job site in Omaha correcting problems from poor quality fabrication.

Just saying you do not have to look far to find companies that produce poor quality. Worked design engineering there for 39 years and most of us old timers are sick at what has happened. Big push on local management from corporate office and nobody with enough nerve to speak up and do it right.

Then we wonder why our economy is a mess.

We produced quality products in Ames for 75 years untill purchased by Siemens.


http://consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/08/china_tires05.html

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#6

Re: OT- Rant - OT *LINK*

John T

>I remembered hearing a report about a family that tried to go a year without buying anything from China, and their trials and tribulations.

Link to a story about this is below.

I understand they've written a book about it, too, (which I have NOT read) - but I'll be looking for it in my local library very soon.

I'm not smart enough, myself, to understand global economics, and how it all might be inter related, but I figure buying closer to home is probably safer and better for the planet, anyway.

Good luck on your mission. Let us know how you fare, and share your tips and tricks with the rest of us!

-John-


http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/1220/p09s01-coop.html

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#7

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Very interesting galen! These tires were rated to be used on heavy trailers such as cattle trailers. Dan said the tires felt much hotter than the older ones.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#8

Goodyear Firestone etc.

Dustmaker Mike

>They are all moving to China. I live near Akron and know a lot of folks in the tire industry. I have a friend that goes to China for a month at a time to bring the tire technology over there. Buy high end tires they are mostly made here in the US. The only tires I am told Goodyear makes in Akron are for NASCAR. I am not sure where everybody else is making tires but it is not in Akron anymore.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#9

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>"I understand they've written a book about it, too, (which I have NOT read) - but I'll be looking for it in my local library very soon. "

When you do, check to see if the book was printed in China :)

Norman

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#10

Another thought I was sent this about tires. *LINK*

GalenV

>First I forgot to say you must have put a lot of weight on the cattle trying for a good sale price and overloaded the tires.

No really my sister-in-law transcribes court cases and she sent me this about selling old shelf life tires. Funny they don't say too much about keeping them on the car for extended time with same results.

Kinda long video but made me go check my motorcycle tire too. Just got new tires for my car and they are current manufacture date.

I did have a tire come apart once on a travel trailer and wish I new what the date was on it, as trailer was a year old when it went. Tore up inside fender well and that needed repair too. It would have been a tire like your trailer.


http://abcnews.go.com/Video/playerIndex?id=4826897

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#11

Were the tires inflated to the proper pressure?

Alexander Grigoriev

>

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Here we go again........

Jesper, Denmark

>Back in the Badger Pond days, this was a common subject of rants and discussions. Not particularly tires, but "stuff" made overseas in general and woodworking machines in particular.

The point is this: The owner of the brand has the responsibility to deliver the product in the quality he perports to sell. If the quality is bad, then the brand owner is at fault - no matter where it is made, Timbuktu, China or Podunk, IN. If they fail to monitor the quality properly, then they are to balme, not the opportunist that laughs at the Western company willing to receive goods at less than the quality they contracted for.

Intead, we are now back at blaming another country for poor quality, when we really should examine the purveyor locally. If a US company decides to buy shoddy goods - wheter overseas or locally - the seller is at fault. He probably did not pay for more quality than he got.

And while we are talking tires, let us not forget the Firestone/Ford debaucle some years ago, when the Indiana Firestone plant delivered millions of faulty tires to Ford.

When you but the cheapest stuff you can possibly get, the expect the quality to match the price. Blame yourself for not checking the quality out in the first place and for trading in a store that is willng to sell it to you. If your locla farm supply is in this category, trade elsewhere.

Caveat Emptor. If you don't understand the phrase, Google it.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Spell check.....

Jesper, Denmark

>When you BUY the cheapest stuff you can possibly get, THEN expect the quality to match the price. Blame yourself for not checking the quality out in the first place and for trading in a store that is willng to sell it to you. If your LOCAL farm supply is in this category, trade elsewhere.

Should have been as above.

Sorry

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#14

Radial or Biased ply tires?

Basil

>Since you mentioned "hot" tires I thought I'd ask.

The first 5 years I was in business I had a lot of tire blowouts on my lowboy trailer (hauling bulldozers) caused by overheating. They were 12 ply rated biased ply tires. Then in the mid 70's I started running steel belted radials. Lot less heat buildup in the radial tires and I had only a couple of tire failures on my lowboy in the last 25 years of business.

If they were radials and blewout from heat, they may not have been properly inflated. The radial tires for my lowboy required 125 psi vs 90 psi for the biased ply tires.

When I first went in business, during the summer, I would get up way before dawn. I'd have the dozer loaded and ready to roll at sun up (wide load laws). I didn't move anything late in the day. With the radial tires, I moved whenever I needed or wanted to move.

Basil

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Good article, but........

Jesper, Denmark

>I would have had to bust her balloon.

The Danish Lego blocks were probably made in either Eatern Europe, Malaysia or China. No more production here in Denmark.

BUT THE QUALITY WAS THE SAME!

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#16

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Charlie Self

>Buying closer to home is good, of course, but I recall a guy in a photo forum going into paroxysms of anger because he could "no longer" find high quality photo gear made in the U.S.A., with China stealing all our production.

He was a wee bit late to the ball. It's been roughly 40-45 years since a decent camera was made in the U.S.

Very few top notch cameras are made in China, either. Most are made and assembled elsewhere around the Pacific Rim in places like Malaysia, Vietnam, et al.

Really, the simple problem is to even find something made in the U.S. these days.

When I read not too long ago that the U.S. Army had to be pressured into NOT buying its black berets from a Chinese manufacturer, I knew the downhill side of the road was steepening, and well coated with lard.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#17

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Charlie Self

>These days many, maybe most, of our books are printed in China. Certainly, the expensive, heavily illustrated ones tend to be.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#18

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>The tires were inflated correctly; they were actually rated higher that the others on the trailer. Also, the trailer was not overloaded. Two almost new tires bought on the same day, made by the same company blew out almost at the same time. The other tires on the trailer were fine.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#19

Gonna go with Jasper on this one

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>First off, Barb, buying no-name tires, even if they say meets 6ply rating is a no, no.

Two years ago I bought a folding motorcycle trailer that was a Chinese knock off of the Ca. Designed, Mexico made, Kendon motorcycle trailer. The copy was pretty much a direct match at half the price. On our first outing I lost a fender on the highway, had a hot wheel bearing, and noticed one wheel lug was stripped. I made a list of the problems and took the trailer back along with the broken fender, (The brackets broke just above the welds). Well, they were waiting for me and they had a list of problems of their own. They fixed everything, and installed new wheel bearing/hub assemblies. The trailer shop owner told me they were not going to sell this knock-off anymore and only fix the ones that had been sold. We both agreed that we were BOTH looking to get a deal, he a bigger profit and me a 1/2 price Kendon trailer, and we both paid the price for this.

Many of the high priced items made in China are good. Heck they have the same CNC machines that are used in other countries. It's the US parent company that lets us down by not inspecting every item or following up with manufacturing process inspections. People will only get away with what the CAN get away with regardless of country. Heck, look at all of the crap UL approved lighting and electrical components around. The US importer,if they wanted to, could do a better inspection which would raise the cost and restart the bargain hunt cycle.

Sorry for the long rant, I must have missed my melamine dosage, which upped my lead level today.....:-)

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#20

Re: Gonna go with Jasper on this one

Lee Brubaker

>I don't shop at Walmart because of Chinese products & the poor quality of same due to Walmart's dictation of cost. If the Chinese do not meet Walmart price....they don't get the order. The Chinese have the ability & equipment to produce quality products(note their space program) but like anywhere else they wont be cheap.

In my locale, a ban on Chinese products means that many of your needs will result in doing without which Iam prepared to do & have done.

Lee

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#21

About to show my age

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>When I was young, "made in Japan" was a synonym for "really junky stuff." It wasn't true even then (their cameras were very good starting right after WWII, maybe earlier, not sure), but many of the Japanese products that came to the U.S. were poor quality, including tools (a lot of Japanese tools would show up in the 99-cent bins at the hardware or auto parts store). Much of their industry was focused on that end of the market.

But "poor quality" is not the first phrase comes to mind for most of us about Japanese woodworking tools (whether powered by electricity or sweat) now.

Even there, though, there have been some brand owner decisions to go down-market. I own an early Ryobi TR-30U laminate trimmer that I hope never dies and/or that I hope Ryobi carries parts for forever; it will hold its own with the best. At some point, though, Ryobi made the decision not to compete with Makita, Hitachi, etc., and started making tools at a lower price point, to capture the new or intermittent tool user. While I wouldn't throw away a Ryobi tool that was given to me, my shop space is limited, so I might well donate it to Habitat for its Re-Store.

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#22

Re: OT- Rant - OT

Fred Davis

>I believe that is called "engineered obsolescence" Barb, just imagine how difficult it must have been to build the "one horse shay " ;-))

FredD

Re: OT- Rant - OT

#23

Re: OT- Rant - OT

John K Jordan

>Bummer, Barb. Around here, you tend to trust the farm stores for quality for things like vehicle batteries and tires. What a pain the trip must have been.

As for China, don't buy any honey either. I read of a huge shipment turned back at a port for contamination with pesticides. Where did that boat go - to Mexico and then to Virginia by truck? How many shipments didn't get tested?

JKJ