Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Air compressors

Posts

Air compressors

#1

Air compressors

doug williams

>What is the scoop on the new oil less compressors as far as lasting as long as the old ones, and supposed to be a little nosier, my old tank has a leak, and I need to start looking. Thanks Doug

Re: Air compressors

#2

Re: Air compressors

Gene Gauss

>My experience with an oil-less compressor was bad. I bought one to supplement the oil lubricated compressor that I had then for about 15 years, and that had seen plenty of use in that time. Since it was a higher capacity, I switched over to using the oil-less as the principle air source, and used the oil lubricated only when I needed higher air flows than the one would provide. One day I noticed a lot of black plastic flying out of the housing of the oil-less. I took it apart and found that the oil-less compressor had destroyed itself. I don't remember all the details now, but the principle reason was that the crankshaft was attached to and entirely supported by the connection to the motor shaft. There was no bearing on the other end. The pistons/cylinders were arranged in a V-configuration on the same crankshaft throw, instead of on opposite throws (or opposed) so that the vibration inherent in this configuration made early failure inevitable. I did repair it, and am continuing to use the oil-lubricated as the principle air source. It's been going for over 20 years now, whereas the oil-less lasted only about 2-3 years in the same service.

Re: Air compressors

#3

Re: Air compressors

SonnyEdmonds

>You are always better off with an oiled compressor than the oil less type.

I run a two stage oiled type in my shop. Because I run a lot of air tools and need good SCFM.

Re: Air compressors

#4

Re: Air compressors

Ray Newman

>Doug: check your Yellow Pages & see if a local compressor repair shop can install a new or used tank. Might save you a few bucks....

gree w/ what others said about the oil free units. Hard to beat cast iron & oil in an air compressor.

Re: Air compressors

#5

Re: Air compressors

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Doug,

I agree with the above. Oil compressors last longer and are quieter. My guess is that when they are in working condition, they break less frequently. When my oiless compressor suffered a pump disintegration after 12 years, I was financially able to buy an oiless model. I chose not to do that. Instead, I bought an inexpensive small compressor from Orange Borg to run my nailers and staplers, and fill the occasional tire. My pneumatic tools went to #3 son's shop. My use of pneumatic tools was never extensive, and I couldn't justify spending a lot of money on something I wasn't going to use very much.

George

Re: Air compressors

#6

Re: Air compressors

John K Jordan

>My experience is the oil-less compressors are fine for casual to moderate use (light construction, home garage/workshop) but if I had ran a body or tire shop I'd get a quality conventional compressor. I have two oil-less about 8 and 12 years old - one is a portable pancake compressor and gets a lot of use nailing, some air tools, and at the lathe. Noisy, but light weight.

I haven't had any trouble with either but if I need to use it a long way from the house I try to use a lot of hose and minimize the extension cord length to preserve the motor. We've put up quite a bit of oak siding on outbuildings, lined horse stalls, etc. using the portable with a big nail gun.

JKJ

Re: Air compressors

#7

Re: Air compressors

Gil Jones--GA

>Has anyone used a rotary screw type air compressor.

Gil

Re: Air compressors

#8

Re: Air compressors

doug williams

>Thanks for the input,I didn't realize oil-less had been around that long,this is the second leak on this tank,so I'll check on a replacement tank, or get a new one. Thanks again Doug

Re: Air compressors

#9

Re: Air compressors

Larry in NW Ohio

>Gil Way back when when I was still working we used rotarymscrew compressors, and I was the one to take care of them. My opinion of them is that they are the wat to go, except they are very expensive. So if you have the need for one and can afford one then go for it. Larry in Ohio

Re: Air compressors

#10

Re: Air compressors

Pete LaBelle

>Oiless compressors are noiser, and cheaper, but they are only suited for occasional use. Yes, parts of the cylinders/pistons are plastic. One thing they need it time to cool down. Continuous use forces them to run more often and break down the plastic.

Most oil-sump compressors can run long durations.

Tip: My oil-sump compressor lives in an unheated garage. In the winter, it is real lethargic to start up. Used to keep a heat lamp on it to keep the oil warm. Went to Tractor Supply and bought synthetic oil & changed out the oil. Now it starts at -10F as it does at 70F.

Pete

Re: Air compressors

#11

Re: Air compressors

Charlie Self

>IME, after reviewing a couple dozen units of both types, the oil-less models are noisier, but the new ones are pretty well shrouded to control that. They are also less durable in heavy use situations, but are great as portable compressors--no worries about oil spillage, oil running back into cylinders when the machine is tipped, etc.

For the careful person, oiled is still the way to go. It is quieter and many pumps outlast the tanks. Don't tip it, and you're fine. If you're doing roofing, go for oil-free. Cost differences don't seem to be truly significant any more.

For stationary air compressors, oiled is the ONLY way to go, if the unit is going to get extensive use. If, as is the case in most hobby woodworking shops, it will be used a couple, three, even four, dozen times a year for little more than 30 or 60 minutes, either is fine.

Tanks on portables: look around, as aluminum tanks have debuted and are less apt to corrode seriously internally. They also make the unit about 5-10 pounds lighter (depending on tank configuration).