Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Posts

Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#1

Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Oldest son bought a home and wants to add more lights and outlets to the garage shop, mostly autoshop, minimal woodworking. Everything is wired with Romex (NM-B). His load center is in the basement about 10 feet from the garage wall so no need for a subpanel, since any circuits can easily be added from the main panel. We want to remove three vertical sections of drywall to add the 220 outlets, add light switches and run switched circuits up into the garage attic space.

My question is with regard to how much or little drywall to remove to accomplish what we want. One electrician I know indicated it would be fastest to add remodel boxes that simply grab the drywall from the back and fish in the Romex with chimney sweep wire as a fishtape. I know it's possible because I've seen it done, but I prefer to remove the drywall, add "real" boxes with conduit to enable future changes or additions from the basement to the garage attic and terminate the conduit with a junction box for transition from THHN to romex in the basement and attic. I can see trying to remove just enough drywall to span one stud space being a teensy bit fussy. Trying to cut it so that it allows a new patch piece to lay center to center on adjacent studs sounds like it might be tricky.

Would it be easier to just cut the drywall at the inside edge of each of the two studs with say something like a Rotozip? And then nail or screw a cripple next to each one to fasten the drywall patch piece to?

I'm hoping someone else has done something similar to this before and will show me the way.

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#2

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Hamish

>Hi Tim,

Although I'm not familiar with Romex, I have done quite a bit of dry walling. Mark with a pencil a suitable rectanglar slot on your wall where you want to cut. Make a pilot hole with a drill bit, and begin to saw carefully along the lines with your saw until you remove the piece you want. Once you have done the wiring, file a bevel around the hole you made on the plasterboard, so that the new plaster filler can enter in. Then cut out from a new piece of plaster board a piece that will fit the whole that you made. Put a bevel all round on that too.

Now comes the tricky bit. Cut two (or three) strips of wood that are about at least two inches longer that the width of the new strip of plasterboard and insert a screw partially through the centre line into the middle of one of the strips. Repeat for the other strip, evenly spacing them out. Now insert the new rectangular strip into the whole and swivel around the strips of wood by twisting the screws with your fingers, so that they are at 90� to the plasterboard and overlapping behind the wall. Put some screws through the existing wall and into the wooden strips to hold them flush on the inside. Now all you need to do is tighten up the centre screw and fill up the bevelled joint and screw holes with plaster, wait to dry and then sand flat. If done carefully, you shouldn't be able to notice it later.

I hope all that makes sense and will be of help. Good luck, Hamish.

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#3

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Joe Shelton

>Fishing, especially thru joist- or stud bays, can be daunting. But it isn't beyond reasonable effort.

The new boxes don't have to be installed so that the only support is back-pressure hooks on old work boxes; it's very easy to use that style box and still place it adjacent to a stud, and carefully nail to the stud.

Rex Cauldwell's "Wiring a House" is a terrific compendium of what to do, why, and how. He goes into great detail, for example, on how to route new circuits in existing walls. I really like his book, and his approach to electrical work.

Good luck.

JS

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#4

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>After you've done enough taping and mudding to have confidence in the results, you'll find that you really don't have to consider the size of the patch you'll have to make. Take off enough to do the wiring job with minimum fuss and then patch in whatever 'rock you need to get the thing covered up. Make it small—make it big. It doesn't matter. Especially in a shop.

For the patching I've done all of the methods listed so far—cut waste out halfway across stud, nail sleepers next to stud, screw sticks in hole and cover with patch. I've even said the heck with it and taken out a half sheet in order to facilitate work I had to do. If you stop and think about it, taping and mudding a half sheet isn't substantially more effort (or materials) than a one foot square hole and patch. Maybe twenty minutes instead of ten?

I think you are, but just in case (and for those who might not be), if you're not aware of the cardinal rule of mudding, think three. You need three coats. Don't ever try to get it ready for paint in two. It will always take three. Just get in the habit of thinking three.

The first coat is to get the wall wet and get the tape on. If you're putting on a full or nearly full sheet, and especially if you can use the tapered edges, use paper tape. For patching, it's better to use mesh—Ferguson's rule (Taunton Press). Get a little mud on the work, lay in the tape, remove as much mud as you can with a 6" or 8" knife.

Next application, knock down any severe bumps with the (next larger) knife (8" to 10") and then lay in another layer. You can attempt to feather a little, leaving a bit of a high point in the middle of the joint, but don't obsess about it. And don't use a lot of mud. In fact, each step should actually use less mud than the preceding.

Third application, knock down any severe bumps with the (next larger) knife (10" to 12") and then lay in another layer. This time use the ridge over the joint as a register and feather out from there a couple or three inches. You don't leave much mud.

Finally, you should have enough mud and feathered far enough out to make it look nearly invisible with paint on it. Knock down any severe bumps with the large knife and sand. Vacuum, prime, paint.

Notice I didn't specify time intervals. If you use premixed mud from the box, you might as well figure three days for three applications, and sand on the fourth. You might get an early start in the morning for the second application and have it dry enough at night for a third, but the extra 8-10 hours will really help.

If you use a setting compound, you could get all three apps done in one day. There are different setting speeds. I suggest you don't start out with the fastest. But if you ignore this, please post with the results so we can all have a good laugh.

Once you have confidence in your mudding, a one square foot patch or 32 doesn't make any difference whatsoever. Make a hole as big as you need to get the inside work done easily.

Rod

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#5

My father

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>who was right on about many things, invested way too much energy in patching little bits of drywall.

Drywall and mud are (in relative terms) cheap. It's easier to cut out a huge chunk o' stuff and patch it in than to make lots of little niggly holes and patch each of them.

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#6

I agree.....

Barry Irby

>Read Rod's post again.

Big patches are about as easy as little ones. In fact, one big patch may be easier than two small ones.

Also, three (or four or five) coats is a minimum. As for mud or compound, less is more. Put on the least amount you can, an leave it alone. Much easier to come back later and add a little than it is to sand off a lot. (Trust me, sanding is NOT your friend.) Keep sanding to a minimum. Sand with fairly coarse paper, 80 or 100 grit. Leaves about the same texture as is on the paper itself and does not shine through. If you do a really nice job of mudding, you can wipe it down with a wet coarse sponge and kill the edges and may be able to avoid sanding altogether.

The knives he mentions are also important. I usually start with a 4", then 6" and finish with a 10". Think of the patch as very thin and wide. a very gently wide bulge will not show nearly as much as a narrow one.

The fiberglass gauze like tape is great for this. Has sticky on it and you just stick it cover the seams and from then on you are applying just enough mud to hide the tape.

Also, cut the edges of the hole carefully with a sharp knife to remove any fuzz left by the saw or rotozip. The edges should be flush or sunken. Leave NOTHING bulging. Easy to fill a hole, hard to hide a bulge.

I have used all the ideas about putting sticks into and around the holes. Good idea. I have glued them to the back of the rock with yellow glue to keep the number of screws to a minimum.

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Some good stuff here...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I'll just add that I prefer paper tape, even for patches--because of something Barry said. Anything that sticks out from the drywall is hard to hide, and the mesh tape is thicker than paper tape. I've also seen pro drywallers do patches--they almost always use paper tape. The key to paper tape is to make sure your mud is WET. The pre-mixed stuff in the plastic buckets is not wet enough out of the bucket, it needs a little more water, but I usually use the quick-set powder anyway (5- or 20-minute).

A point that has been touched on needs to be emphasized. One the tape is covered, don't add any more mud to it, but add the mud going out from it to taper it out. Most bad patch jobs I see are because someone put a whole bunch of mud over the tape but didn't float it out. Even after lots of sanding there is a noticeable bulge then. If you look at new construction drywall work, a butt joint (two non-beveled sheetrock ends together), the finished mud job is at least 2' wide, and even then can often be found after sanding, priming and painting.

Jason

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#8

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

Fred Davis

>Tim,

Without actually seeing the proposed wiring layout, it is hard to say which way causes the least stress if you insist on doing it yourself, but here are some general approaches to hundreds of similar remodel jobs I have been involved with over the years.

Since your wiring a shop and feeding from a main disconnect panel and running several circuits from it, it seems to me that a branch circuit panel would be the way to go, since it provides disconnects at the panel in the shop rather then a trip to the basement each time and only one feed from the basement panel.

If your new outlets are more then one horizontal sheet of drywall would cover and you can get it up to 12 feet long, then Old work boxes are a option if you only needed 120 V outlets.

240V. twist lock plugs put to much stress on a old work box and it will work loose in the wall.

If you need to do individual patching , keep the removal of drywall as small as possible, or take off the top half of the drywall and redo it complete.

Electricians have several ways of getting runs through existing studs without entirely removing the dry wall, but since your doing it. do what is easiest for you and fits your skill level.

If you do vertical strip removal , cut the patch first and tack it to the wall and cut around it with a utility knife, it fits much better that way and you will get it the first try.

Drywall compound comes in several forms and the one I use is called "topcoat compound" and it is formulated to sand much easier then general purpose drywall compound which why I use it.

Since taping and mudding drywall is a trowel trade, you may want to just do the drywall installation and have a taper friend or one on a house job close to you drop by on his way home and do the taping.

Minimal cost there and a much better result aesthetically speaking .

;-))

FredD

Re: Need some advice on drywall cut/repair

#9

Thanks guys, you've convinced me....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Thanks guys, you've convinced me to just remove the whole floor to ceiling strip instead of little pieces. That's what I was planning but I just needed confirmation. Rod, your insight was great. Since I will not be doing the patching, I've given #1 a copy of this for his use. I'll do the sparkey stuff and he'll finish patching and buttoning everything up afterward.