Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

White Oak Tree

Posts

White Oak Tree

#1

White Oak Tree

Ed Wesolek

>Hell-o People,

I have enjoyed reading about the many differnt subjects and have learned many different things over the years from all of you.

My question is about a white oak tree that I am going to have boarded up after they drop the tree. What is the best way to cut this tree up. Quatersawn for stability or regular cut to get the most out of teh tree. Then deal with the drying and holding the boards in place. I am planning on air drying the wood afterwards in a heated area.

The tree is about 30 ft tall and I hope to get as much out of this tree that I can.

I thought that I would ask the masters out there to see what they had to say. I will check back in tomorrow after the day job.

Thanks for your in put.

Ed

Re: White Oak Tree

#2

Re: White Oak Tree

John K Jordan

>Ed,

I'm certainly no master or expert or even all that experienced, but I do have a sawmill behind the barn and have milled a lot of lumber for my own use. I recently cut about 30 logs into large cants for my new horse barn - red oak, white oak, pine, gum, cedar. I cut them into cants for later resawing when I figure out exactly what lumber I need. You don't want to do this for fine lumber - most of my sawing is for barn siding and structural lumber. (Although it is a shame sometimes to nail up a 2x4 from a beautiful piece of QS white oak!)

What do you want to use it for? I generally just plane saw since it's quick. You automatically get a few quartersawn boards this way. If I don't have a specific use in mind, I'll saw some 4/4, some 8/4, and a piece or two of 12/4 just in case. I can always resaw the thicker if needed.

With 30' (I assume you mean 30' trunk) you'll also have to decide how to section it into logs. The longer the logs the harder to transport and handle, before and after sawing, but the less potential degrade from end drying. (I always use Anchorseal on the ends of logs when I want good lumber - the sealer should be applied soon after felling but this time of year that's not as critical as in the heat of summer.) I usually cut 10-14' for structural lumber and 6-8' when I need shelves and such. My sawmill will handle 17' logs but I hate to. :) One thing that might suggest the length is the size of your drying area.

The boards should be properly stickered and weighted for drying. I haven't done oak for furniture but I think it is prone to staining from fungus if you use green stickers. Not as much a problem this time of year, but it's still probably best to cut 1x1 or 3/4" square stickers from dry wood.

You mentioned drying in a heated area. I'd be careful about using too much heat at first, especially indoors where the humidity might be very low in the winter - even kiln operators control the humidity while drying. It might be best to let it air dry outdoors (covered, out of the sun) for a while. Also, don't try to accelerate drying by blowing fans through the stack. Drying too quickly can cause case hardening, surface checks, and severe splitting.

If you want to research drying or ask specific questions, check out the Woodweb and the Forestry Forum communities on the web - both have sawing and drying forums and the Woodweb has an excellent knowledgebase archive. Try searching for something like 'drying white oak'.

http://www.forestryforum.com/board/index.php#2

http://www.woodweb.com/cgi-bin/forums/sawdry.pl

http://www.woodweb.com/KnowledgeBase/KBPP.html

JKJ

Re: White Oak Tree

#3

Re: White Oak Tree

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I'm also pretty far away from any kind of expert, but I've put two stacks of wood out beside the house to dry with pretty good luck. The first was a mix of red/white oak, the second was walnut. For both, I did just plain sawn. I was really interested in getting as much from the trees as possible. As stated above, you'll wind up with some quartersawn in there as well. I cut most of mine 4/4 and then did a bunch 6/4 and 8/4. Always try to have your sawer cut just a bit over the thickness you want to account for shrinkage during drying. The only problem I experienced was with wider boards - some were prone to cracking down the center if there was major grain (like cathedral) there. If you air dry, be prepared to good year or so on the 4/4, up to 2 years on 8/4.

It's a bit of work but a lot of fun and having your own lumberyard is pretty nice. Best thing to do when drying - nothing. Look at it every couple of weeks or so to make sure nothing is amiss (my cover leaked during a bad storm) and no insects have found homes. Then after a year or so, try some out. I think white oak is a little more prone to drying defects, so I'd suggest a good deal of weight on the stack.

Re: White Oak Tree

#4

Re: White Oak Tree

mike@American Sycamore

>I do not mean to rain on anyones parade but...did this tree come out of a back yard full of nails and other things..the time,the work, the mess, the hassle..not being kiln dryed lumber,,a place to stack it, a place to keep it protected...do you have a truck or tractor ,,think about it. I can pick up the phone and Frank Miller will deliver kiln dried fabulous lumber ready to build furniture. I am a furniture builder not a lumber man. In my humble opinion air dried lumber is fire wood. Good luck!

Re: White Oak Tree

#5

JL

Re: White Oak Tree

JL

>Depends on the diameter. I would probably plain saw it in 10' sections. The middle cuts will be quartersawn or near quartersawn anyway. Do a good mix of thicknesses. You'll want fat 5/4 for table tops and fat 8/4 and up for legs and structural lumber.

Think about a solar kiln - it will get it down in moisture content fairly fast.

Re: White Oak Tree

#6

advise

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. Presumably the person sawing the tree knows what he/she is doing. If you don't, then let the sawyer decide how to saw it. For background on how lumber is typically sawed refer to my article in the Articles section on hardwood lumber production. The decisions are whether to saw for appearance, yield or width. You get to choose one of the above.

2. The decision on quarter sawn, or not, is lumber appearance, not stability. There is a huge difference in appearance.

3. Don't air dry in a heated area unless you are experience at drying. Oak is the easiest domestic species to screw up by drying too fast. So if you don't know, err on the slow side. The lumber will dry just fine out doors with a properly prepared pile. Seek sound advice on making the lumber pile or your efforts will be wasted.

4. Has someone knowledgeable determined the log is worth the effort to saw it? This may sound like a dumb question but I encounter novice log owners with some frequency with logs that are only going to yield low grade lumber which could be bought at the mill for the price of sawing the log.

Re: White Oak Tree

#7

clarification on wide board sawing/drying

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have oak boards 22" wide (the limit for common circle saws) that dried without any issues. But, these did not include the heart of the tree, which nearly always cracks upon drying. It would be extremely rare for an oak board to split when properly dried. It can happen as a result of some stress defect in the log, but in this case it will often happen during sawing or on the log yard.

It sounds like some of the experience reported involved what is called flitch sawing. This technique, never practiced in the US commercial trade, will yield some quartered and rift cut lumber, and lots of lumber with the heart intact which will yield split boards. By definition the wide flitch cut boards will include the heart and therefore split. Flitch sawing is easy to do on a portable band mill and I suppose that is why some do it and others don't know any better . Sawing for grade on a portable mill is tedious because it is slower to turn the logs.

If the logs are sawed by someone experience in sawing lumber for grade none of the boards are likely to split no matter how wide they are (if dried properly). Additionally, you will not get any quartered or rift cut lumber. The lumber will be substantially more narrow than flitch cut.

Re: White Oak Tree

#8

reasons to custom saw

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In general I agree with what you said. However, there is a case for custom sawing personal lumber. One may need lumber that is not readily available from commercial sources. For example, I had sawed some quartered poplar for drawer sides in thickness which efficiently resaw the side stock. Or, I found and sawed a huge walnut crotch. There are several species of oak that go in the white oak category. There is a huge difference in appearance. To get true white oak in a soft texture one may need to find and saw the logs. One can not dismiss the "fun factor" until the novelty wears off. It wore off long ago for something as mundane as flat sawed red oak or poplar.

Re: White Oak Tree

#9

Kiln drying is over rated

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>You are 100% correct about the backyard/nail issue as well as the storage issue. I do however take issue with the statement that air dried wood is only good for fire wood and that you need kiln dried wood to build furniture with.

I have been milling my own wood since 1994 and have only air dried it. I have made and sold many pieces with no problems with the quality of my lumber, quite the contrary, my wood is often far superior to what I can find commercially. There are many people who feel that air dried wood is far superior to kiln dried. In walnut the color of air dried wood can be much richer for example, and many luthiers� will only use air dried stock because it has superior tonal qualities. I have found that in some species air drying makes them a bit les brittle. Also with air drying there is no risk of case hardening. I would also add that historically speaking kiln drying is a recent invention and the craftsmen of past eras some how coped quite well with air dried lumber.

As for this thread I would only add that cutting and drying your own wood will add to your overall knowledge of wood and for this reason alone it is a worth while experience.

Robin

Re: White Oak Tree

#10

Re: clarification on wide board sawing/drying

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I believe that is exactly what happened to me. The heartwood was left in the cant as we just sawed down through it. It wasn't much of a loss since only a handful of boards had heartwood. Even those that did cup/crack down the center weren't useless - I could easily saw off their sides - even ending up with some quartersawn in places. Stuff that looked to bad went into the "general use" stack for all of those other little outside projects.

Re: White Oak Tree

#11

definitely...

John in NM

>The only cabinet doors I've ever had come out perfectly flat were of air dried wood, some cherry, some red oak. Though both spent time in a wood pile in the Tucson summer, which is about as close to a kiln as you're likely to find anywhere.

Re: White Oak Tree

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Kiln drying is over rated

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>And the wonderful color you'll get from air dried walnut just can't be done in a kiln!

Jim D.

Re: White Oak Tree

#13

Re: reasons to custom saw

John K Jordan

>>...One can not dismiss the "fun factor" until the novelty wears off.

I think the secret there is to not try to do too much! I've had my mill several years and it's still fun for me.

If I had to run my sawmill as a business I would hate it - it's physically hard work and it would get pretty boring, the headaches high and the return small. But bop down to the sawmill and cut up an occasional log from the stack for fun - priceless!

JKJ

Re: White Oak Tree

#14

Let me Bust This Myth

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I posted the busting of this myth once before but it is worth repeating. But before that, most of the reasons people rationalize for air drying lumber are just that. But for now I will deal with the walnut color myth.

Nearly all the commercial walnut is steamed. So the claim, to be more precise, is that air dried walnut is more "richly colored" (or what ever other description one prefers) than steamed walnut. Indeed, this is the case for a short time. Steamed walnut is quite uniform in color which makes matching boards in projects much easier. However, these colors the air dried enthusiasts extol are fleeting in sunlight. With time unstained walnut will bleach nearly blond which is why I always stain walnut. The purples in air dried walnut are gone in hours in full sun. Ditto for the purple and green of poplar and the greenish in some cherry.

The picture documents an experiment I did to bust this air dried myth. The pieces were cut from one fresh sawed board. One piece was steamed, the other air dried. The steamed piece was typical sooty black from the steaming process, while the air dried piece was rich brown, the purples having long since bleached away during drying. Each piece was finished and set in a sunny room during July. After about a month of sunny room exposure I took the picture. Upon close examination I can still tell which piece was steamed, but I think most will agree they are very similar after simulating only one month of "use" for a piece of furniture. In a few years both will be blond.


img

Re: White Oak Tree

#15

Re: Let me Bust This Myth

Fred Davis

>On a slightly different aspect of Color in Walnut , Blue and Green streaks sometimes seen in Black Walnut are a result of the area they grew in.

So in the four states that Walnut is native to , Kansas being one and Missouri another , the Walnut here in Kansas in beautiful but it does not contain the Blue and Green streaks until you get into Eastern Missouri and on into Illinois.

I personally don't like the effect of steamed Walnut , but it is not a issue where I buy from Kansas Hardwoods sawmill in Belvue, it is just KD.

FredD

Re: White Oak Tree

#16

not all walnut is created equal

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>here is a pic of a table made from claro walnut (juglans hindsii) that has been in a sunny room for 4 years. It was unstained and finished with tung oil. as you can see it still has all its natural color. If it were kiln dried it would not have those beautiful streaks.

Robin


img

Re: White Oak Tree

#17

Nice table!

Tony - Memphis

>Got a shot of the top? Looks like there is some inlay?

Tony

Re: White Oak Tree

#18

Re: Nice table!

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I don't have a pic that shows it any better. The inlay is 3 camphor butterflies used to stablize 3 small cracks. I use a more sculptural shape rather than the more traditional bowtie. Here is a pic of the shape I use for my butterflies.

Robin


img

Re: White Oak Tree

#19

Thanks! Very nice.

Tony - Memphis

>