Auction site woes and caution (long)
David
>I�ve been thinking about this for a while and how it would play out with list etiquette but was assured that this would be ok to post. My intention is not to bad mouth the E**y dealer but to give y�all a head�s up.
About a month ago, I finally won an E**y auction for a Stanley 5 � that looked to be in very nice shape. The pictures showed some light surface rust but a nice looking plane otherwise, real pretty wood. At the time, I didn�t think much of the fact that the last inch of the tail was cut off in the photo and that it was ever so slightly out of focus (both poor photo conditions not being uncommon). Seller�s description is as follows:
�Bidding is for this vintage Stanley/Bailey No. 5 1/4 Plane. It is in very good condition. The bottom is smooth with no pittting. It was well maintained. Would really clean up nice. Chip and crack free handle. Not to many better. Thanks for looking. Contact me with any further questions. � (item number 140269619226 if you'd like to see the pics).
I was quite excited when the plane arrived and I wasted no time opening and unwrapping the package. I can�t describe the feeling of my heart sinking as I immediately saw that the left edge of tail was broken off and that what appeared to be rust in the pictures was the previous owner�s name engraved in the plane�under the rust. I quickly searched through the box for the broken piece to see if this was shipping damage. It was not.
After getting over my disappointment, for the plane�s condition and my stupidity for not looking more carefully at the pictures, I pondered the ad and decided to contact the seller, Joe (who used the name of the orange big box in his online store). Joe responded immediately, apologized, said he is usually right on with his descriptions, and would refund my money if I wanted. I boxed up the plane and sent it back, he refunded my money, shipping included, and that was it.
I figured that Joe probably knew what he was doing, but hoped it was more professionalism than ratings-saving that prompted his actions. The latter was confirmed when the same plane reappeared a week ago. The only difference in the description was an insertion that vaguely mentioned the owner�s marks, nothing about the piece broken off the casting.
As I said in the beginning, I just want to give a heads up and urge everyone caution and safe bidding.
DGW



