>Over the weekend I did most of the woodworking on a coffee table made almost entirely of spalted sugar maple (legs are not spalted). Here's a shot of the top.
Now a days, I would pad on some shellac (my new favorite finish), but I need to darken the wood a bit so that it fits better with the furniture (Stickley Mission) that's already in the room. I'm leaning toward one of the tinted Watco Danish oils, perhaps cherry, and then shellac, but am worried about hiding the grain and spalting. Any suggestions out there? FWIW here's a "before" milling shot of some of the wood. Most are about 9-10' long and up to 20" wide.
I'd start by using a plain good quality oil and see how it looks. Some maple darkens quite a bit with oil alone. You can always coat additionally with a tinted oil for a darker color.
>Spalted maple presents some specific challenges that are dependent on several variables. First, it it is punky, which it often is to some degree or another, you have to be careful with penetrating finishes as they will muddy the color. As far as staining, you probably want to stay away from dye stains if you want to preserve the variations in the color and figure, as dyes tend to even everything out.
So where does this leave you? You want to match some Craftsman-type furniture in the same room, so you want a color that will be along the same hue lines as the prevalent color of the existing pieces, which is most likely some shade of medium brown, maybe with a bit of reddish tone to it. That's going to be very tricky with any stain, including pigment stains, as you're likely to lose the color variation as I mentioned above.
The solution is to prepare a bunch of samples from your cutoffs and try out some possible combinations of stains and finishes to see which will get you closest to your goal. Colored Danish oil might work, as it is essentially a dilute oil stain. It will not obscure the dark veins in the spalted wood, but it will tone all the other colors gently. Personally, I see no need for shellac anywhere in this process. On a coffee table, I'd probably follow up the oil/toner coat with a few wiped coats of a wiping varnish or poly, since the table top will get no end of hard use over time. You want the abrasion resistance of a hard varnish. At least, I would.
Try a few things on scraps and go with the best one.
>Good call, Clint. The follow-up to advice about toners is to be careful that you apply it evenly, as the color added is directly proportional to the thickness of the finish in that area. If your spray technique is good, this is not too difficult.
>In my opinion, it would be a real shame to add color to that wood. Mother Nature did her job, celebrate her work!!!!! Back away from the stain and toner!!!!! Just back away!!!!
>I did a couple of samples, but can't upload pictures right now.
Danish oil yielded no color change but a little depth. Amber shellac at 50% dilution and full strength turned the light areas yellow and more yellow. Played a bit with a Mahogony pigment in alcohol, which I don't like at all and it muddied it.
Spraying is tough for me, the only equipment I have is my old autobody stuff, which I can use well enough but given the temperature (and snow) right now and that I heat my shop with a woodstove, there may be a problem...
Back to the sample board and I do appreciate all the suggestions.
>I have brushed thinned lacquer, but only to get a fast build before spraying, which melts into and levels the brushed coats. The piece shown was only sprayed.
>If you're trying to match Stickley Mission furniture the color was probably acheived by fuming the piece with industrial strength ammonia(the kind they use for making blueprints). The oak darkens when the tannins in the wood chemically react with the ammonia. I've tried it on maple without the dramatic results produced in oak or mahogany.
Another option that mimics and enhances natural aging are chemical stains. A number of publications on finishing give a variety of chemicals for different effects. The link below is to a Taunton Press online book "Taunton's Complete Illustrated Guide to Working with Wood". The requisite section with formulas and techniques starts on page 256.
>Hi Dave, I had a bunch of this that I purchased at the Amana Colonies furniture wood shop.I finished the first bed frame and nite stand with Minwax gloss varnish. After a year or so it yellowed. I really hated the way it looks. The next bed I used Wabco natural danish oil. It brought out color that I didn't know was there. This soft wood really sucks it up though..........Good luck with your project.
>There is a finish that was offered by Stickley that is not commonly seen, a warm sagey green. I think that would look great on the maple. It would not hide the spalting. Red and green are complementary colors. It must be a warm green with just a hint of yellow to work with the brown tones of your other furniture. It worked for Stickley!
>After playing with sample pieces and attending a finishing seminar I ended up going with an oil and wax finish. Specifically Bush Oil. I may live to regret not using something harder but LOML saw it in the oil only state and I was told to not do anything more and "ruin" it!
The oil really made the grain pop and its yellowish hues go fine with the Stickley.
Not the best pictures:
I have a feeling I'll be varnishing it one day but so far so good.
>I suggest you try out whatever you want to use on the bottom or a cutoff piece. I have done some mission oak using minwax combinations. My favorite is golen oak/maple about 47.5 of each and about 5% jacoben. These stains/dyes will cover a little grain, but if you wipe it off right away, most grain comes through. The jacoben will bring out the grains and darken some of the grain ends, but you will have a rich reddish brown finish on most of it. You may get some grayish tint in the pithy parts, but it will contrast ok. I end it up with tung oil or poly. Also, I have found the best thing for a lusterous finish is to sand through 3 or 4 grades. I lightly sand about 180 to get the scratches out, this will leave smaller scratches, but 220 will pull these out. Then 440 the heck out of it and buff it with leather to get a glass like finish. Your coffee table will not match, but it will have a similar color. A second option is to just use a natural poly to seal it and go with the lighter color. It will contrast with the darker furniture, brighten up the center of the room and you will have all your color of your original wood. I use poly for areas with lots of use and moisture, which a coffee table is sure to get, but the purests will tell you to use lacquer. It's your call.