>I would like to build some chimney flashing using soldered galvanized thin gage steel. Can anybody point me to some references for soldering sheet metal, either books or good websites?
Specifically, I am wondering about the cleaning and fluxing procedure for galvanized metal, as the variety of procedures seems to be equal to the number of sources I read it from.
Also, is a propane (Bernzomatic type) torch a suitable heat source, or is an electric iron required? This is another area on which I am finding conflicting information.
using 26 G.I. sheet metal, pop rivet the chimmey saddle to shape and then flux the seams and using a propane torch solder the seams letting it flow under the lap and you got it.
If you buy preformed corners and straight run valley tin , you will have a easier time.
>I did some in high school on a sculpture and it worked great. I think we roughed up the areas to be soldered pretty good first. I gotta say though that I'm sure, in this day & age, SOMEONE SOMEWHERE is going to throw a fit over heating up the "galvinized stuff" because it causes some kind of malady. Everything does now.
>I did a lot of sheet metal work in my former life. Mostly autobody and chassis. It's been a while, but let's see what I can remember.
BRAZING - You can braze sheetmetal. You don't actually have to weld it. Brazing is strong enough since sheet metal isn't that strong itself. Temperature doesn't need to be as hot and you can use brass which is easier.
TACK WELDING - Sheet metal tends to disort and buckle due to high temperatures (another good reason for brazing over welding) so to avoid that you first tack (spot) weld every 6"-12" and then after that has cooled you can seam weld the whole thing. The tack welds help keep it in position when you weld the whole seam.
WELDING STEEL - Don't weld galvanized steel, only plain steel. I can't remember the specifics (results in poisonous gases?), but EVERYONE who had anything to do with welding (teachers, bosses, co-workers) always said the same thing: Don't do it.
>I forgot, we always uses Oxy-Ace (gas) equipment and not electric when welding sheet metal. But that was a long time ago, long before I ever got my hands on a MIG welder, so perhaps it's different.
I've done it with those propane-type torches, but not the single tank with Propane or MAPP gas, but the dual tank torch that uses a seperate Oxygen tank and a MAPP gas tank. I haven't tried sheet metal with MAPP by itself, but having used MAPP vs propane for plumbing I would think that a single-tank MAPP gas torch might be able to braze sheet metal fine.
>The poisonous part that several have made a refrence to is zinc poisoning. anytime you get the underlying metal on a galvanized part red hot you will flash off the zinc. The cloud of yellowish white smoke is zinc gas and it should not be inhaled. Mild zinc poisoning is not dedly and will result in a headache and possiblely nausia. First aid treatment is to drink a glass of milk. A wiser treatment is to avoid heating the metal hot enough to flash the zinc. I have no experiance soldering the stuf so I really cant help you there, but I can say that you don't want to get the galvanized coating hot enough to flash the zinc.
>My father was a welder for 30 years with Bethlehem Steel. They always avoided welding galvanized steel. Zinc poisoning is nothing to be fooled with. When he did, he would counter act the effects with plenty of Milk and vitamin E. After he retired he was asked to weld a lot of galvanized pipe. He was paid well because no one else would do it. After three weeks he developed short term memory problems which lasted for about three months. That was a scary time. The doctors were finaly able to get the zinc out of his system and he was back with us. He never touched galvanized again.
>For soft solder, follow Fred's instructions. A regular propane torch should do fine. I'd use plumbers solder instead of electrical if its going to be visible - the lead in electrical solder will eventually turn a dull grey color.
For hard solder, you will have to get the sheet steel hot enough to A.) burn off the zinc which people have been talking about, and B.) probably warp the sheets. Nicely folded corners should help with that. You would also probably need an oxy-acetelene or air-acetelene torch for this, though propane may work ok too, depends on the weight of the metal and the area to be heated.
Hard soldering (aka silver solder) is more difficult to do, but not as difficult as welding thin stock. The only reason to try it instead of plumbers solder is if some code or another required the higher temp solder for work around stoves.
I've always been able to do a cleaner job welding thin sheet metal with gas rather than a wire welder. The pros I knew preferred TIG, but that's more like welding with gas than MIG.
Although often done by the macho and the ignorant, I would never attempt to weld galvanized anything with either gas or electric without wearing a respirator and outdoors. Soldering thin galvanized is safe since the temperatures are low and the zinc is not vaporized.
>Don't make this relatively easy task harder then it needs to be, use acid core solder , that comes in a small roll and heat the sheetmetal slightly ahead of the solder being applied and it will flow right it the sheetmetal laps.
Dont' forget tth flux and it will amaze you how easy it is.
>making it harder? news to me. what you describe here is a soft solder. super easy to use. silver solders use a borax flux and flow around 1300F as opposed to 450F. as I said, there's very little reason to use a hard solder for this application.
John I wasn't refering to you , but it seemed to me that a easy job I have done many times especially with gutters after the sheetmetal shops priced theirselves out of gutter and down spout work was being lost in the details.
It was starting to sound like something really bad would happen druring the process, maybe even evacuate the neighborhood given the tone of the warnings about heavy metal poison, but there I go digressing again. ;-))
>Your local library may have some books. The unfortunate part about the Internet is I can't offer to stop over and show you what is a VERY simple process. I did this for a while, years back.
1. Your hardware store will have muriatic acid. Buy the smallest quantity you can get and some "flux brushes." Also buy bar solder. Preferably, you want the bars about a foot long and about 1 inch by 3/4 inch, but take what you can find. Not all hardware stores have these supplies, nowadays - you need to find an old-line store.
Scavenge a small plastic container (if you or your wife use hand lotion, a small round hand lotion bottle is about right - cut the top off). Pour a little muriatic into the container.
2. I've never had much luck with propane torches. Soldering coppers, which show up in garage sales, are ideal - in my opinion, nothing beats them for sheet metal, and my contractor son tells me tinbenders are still using them. These are a hunk of copper, usually square with a pyramidal shape on the end, fastened to a steel rod somehow, with a wooden handle, altogether about a foot long. You only need one, though two is ideal (one in use, one heating). If you can't find a copper or don't have time to look, then you may have more luck than I with a propane or MAPP torch.
3. I took a piece of angle flashing and bent one end over to make a kind of tunnel, stuffed the propane torch burner in one end and the soldering copper in the other, and heated it up. Heating is part of the art form: you want it hot enough to melt the solder, but no hotter. Watch for the solder to get bright. Rub it on a wet sponge to get it shiny.
4. You want your flashing organized so that the seams are flat (it's possible to solder vertically, but not when you're starting out), and supported underneath. Wood is fine - the solder won't get hot enough to do much more than scorch it (by the way, you want to do this in the middle of your paved driveway or somewhere like that). Brush on the muriatic acid, apply the copper to it, and apply a solder bar to the copper. You want to melt a puddle of solder that flows into the seam. You can use the copper to direct the solder around.
5. It's often really hard, especially at home, to get the seams to bend dead flat. If you need to hold down a spot, when you've got your soldering done, hold the copper up so just the point is touching the spot you need held down (this is why you're supporting the seam you're soldering). When you see the solder "flash," as it turns solid, you can stop.
6. It's a good idea to wash off the flux after, once the flashing has cooled enough. We never did when I was doing it for a living, but the muriatic will eat through the zinc.
7. DON'T lean over the work to inhale the fumes of either the acid or the solder. They're both poisonous.
It is an art - your first attempts will look like a robot hurled its silver lunch all over the flashing. I now do flashings about once every five years, and it takes me several feet of flashing to get the knack again. So you might do some practice seams, but keep trying. Properly done sheet metal soldering is an unbeatable joint, and learning how to do it well is really thrilling.
>I said the fumes from the muriatic and the solder are both poisonous - true, to a degree. My sense is it's fairly mild. But, if you're working outside, the issue isn't major, in my experience.
Of course, this depends somewhat on your chemical sensitivities and so on. "Major" varies from person to person.
If all this is too intimidating, you can pop-rivet and caulk (not in that order) flashing. It's not as sound a joint, nor as pretty, but it beats buckets in your formal living room. Clean the flashing, which usually has residual oil from the forming process (white vinegar is good), and use a butyl or other high-end caulk. Wear strong disposable gloves - the caulks good for sheet metal are great at sticking to everything including you.
>One more time I will say that a simple straight forward operation is beginning to sound a like DOD approach to a military application.
Forget the Muratic acid , that is a accident waiting to happen. like spilling it on you or your clothes.
The acid core solder contains the necessary acid and the flux I mentioned comes in a paste form.
Any conventional size propane torch is all the heat you need , more is overkill, I have done this for years and it is a permanent ,easy way to connect flashing saddles , gutters, corners , downspouts etc.
Glad you've found a system that works - maybe I'm biased by how I was trained in finding soldering coppers and muriatic more effective. I didn't intend to complicate, merely to offer an alternative.
there is always more then one way to skin a cat, but I like the fastest simplest approach as a rule . ;-))
That being said , the use of Muratic acid requires a mind set and preplanning and attention to what your doing that is sometimes lacking in a first time try.
I have used the stuff to clean stone and brick in the past and always did it alone , safe from interruptions.
You were trained in the use of it and find it a techique that produces results, and that is good, getting it on you and not realizing it until it starts to hurt is a whole different story.