Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

New "green" finish *LINK*

Posts

New "green" finish *LINK*

#1

New "green" finish *LINK*

Tony - Memphis

>Anybody tried this yet? How about a finish made from cheese production byproducts (whey)? Sounds very interesting. I may order a quart and try it just for the novelty of it.

Tony

http://www.vermontnaturalcoatings.com/made_green.html


Vermont Natural Coatings

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#2

Re: New "green" finish

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>Tony,

I have tried it. They first came out with their flooring finish which I've never tried but I understand that it is excellent and I actually saw a flooring sample that had been coated for some time (a couple of years at least I think) and purposely put through a lot of abuse...you'd never know it. As for the furniture finish, I tried it last summer. It was not brushable nor wipe-able...it could only be sprayed. It simply dried too fast and there were brush marks and smudges galore. I was actually helping out another Vermont furniture company do some R&D on the product and that was what we found. We reported it to VNC and they went back to their developers (good folks at the University of Vermont)to work on it.

I now have a can in my possession that is the new formula. I have not tried it yet but hope to within the next week. I'm looking forward to good results but my test will be the judge. Vermont Natural Coatings is a good company and they're trying to make an excellent green product for the industry.

Another thing to keep in mind about this finish is that this whey formula is like a water based finish. It imparts no color to the wood like the oil based finishes do.

I'll report back after I've tested the new formula.

Sue

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#3

JL

Thanks for sharing

JL

>I guess I'll have to try a quart also.

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#4

Re: New "green" finish

Paul Woolson

>Sue, a question for you: Did you find that it tended to "blue" the surface at all. Some of the waterborne finishes I've tried give off a blue cast when applied to very dark woods (Zircote, Ebony, etc) Please tell me that this one is different.

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#5

Re: New "green" finish

Alex Grigoriev

>Essentially, this is based on the same thing as milk paint. Caseine plus alcali. The tricky part was probably to make it into water emulsion with enough shelf life.

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#6

Very useful review. Thanks

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#7

Re: New "green" finish

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Thanks you, Sue,

I am looking forward to when you whey in again. :<)

George

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#8

Re: New "green" finish

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have tried it and I was not impressed. I felt it made the wood look hazy and it hindered any "pop" in the figure of the wood. Others may disagree but I do not find it suitable for my work.

Tom

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#9

Re: New "green" finish

Fred Davis

>I wonder if it comes in flavors mild , sharp,??

FredD

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#10

Why?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Many of us build furniture with the hope of it lasting for generations. I would not put a product on my furniture that had not stood the test of time. If someone feels guilty releasing a few ounces of hydrocarbon to the environment by finishing with a tested product, off set this angst by driving a few miles less next week.

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#11

Guda one, Fred

George@Colonel's Workshop

>

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#12

Re: Guda one, Fred

Fred Davis

>I'm a sharp Cheddar man myself George , Guda stuff

Monterray Jack about three years old will tickle your palate too.

One of the few things I miss about CA.

FredD

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#13

Re: Why?

Fred Davis

>Just think Bill , if all the smokers gave it up, we could spray all of the VOC'S we wanted and still be ahead, just a thought mind you.

FredD

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#14

Re: New "green" finish

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>did you try it over the top of a coat of oil? it sounds odd and you have to try a sample with the brand of oil and the brand of waterbased finish you have on hand but I have had fantastic results with a coat of jasco brand tung oil followed imidiately with General HF poly. The neat part is that with the wet oil under the waterbased finish it glides on silky smoth and doesn't raise the grain. I have tried the durability of this and to chip the waterbased finish it pulls the oil and a bit of the wood with it.

I just ordered a sample so Ill give it a look see.

Robin

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#15

Re: New "green" finish

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>Paul,

I don't remember seeing any bluing. I was applying it over curly maple that had a water based analine dye on it.

Sue

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#16

Re: New "green" finish

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>George,

Hopefully I'll whey in sooner than later or whey down the road.

Sue

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#17

Re: New "green" finish

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>Tom,

You are absolutely right, it did nothing to pop the grain. When I test the improved product I will be sure to test in on some curly maple. I also remember the haziness that you mentioned when I brushed or wiped it. I don't remember the haziness after we had the pieces sprayed. I'm able to often see one of the pieces that we tested the product on and I don't even think of the haziness issue now, but I'll look at it more closely the next time.

Sue

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#18

JL

How long has milk paint lasted??

JL

>OK - maybe it had linseed oil over it :).

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#19

Re: New "green" finish

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I did some test panels so I tried over different scenarios like raw wood, shellac sealer, Danish oil etc. Of course the results varied but at the end of the day it just didn't win me over.

Tom

Re: New "green" finish *LINK*

#20

two comments

Michael Dresdner

>First, their claim that "The production of oil-based wood finishes and other coatings, such as paint, have relied solely on petroleum � a non-renewable resource" is not really true.

Most oil based finishes are based on either linseed oil, tung oil or soy oil. All three are plant based oils, not petroleum based. (One could even argue that plant oils are greener than animal products, though personally, I think the whole thing is hair splitting.) Only the solvents are petroleum based, and our use of petroleum solvents is not even making a dent in the oil consumption in the world when compared to that used in cars and energy plants.

Second, I rather agree with Bill Tindall on this one. Yes, I am interested in checking this stuff out and will do so, and yes, I am glad they are working on such alternatives, but the sad truth is that we woodworkers, with whatever finishes we use, are not really part of the problem, so no matter what we do to change, we will not effect a solution. When you are already off the radar, going further off is meaningless. As Bill said, drive a few miles less if you want to do something significant, but woodworking, even including professional shops that out-spray us a thousand to one, accounts for less than one half of one percent of the VOCs emitted. Further, most of the readers on this board tend toward wipe on and brush on finishes, which are even lower in VOCs than spray finishes.