Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Selecting box hinges

Posts

Selecting box hinges

#1

Selecting box hinges

Dan Mitchell

>This is proabably a dumb question...

I made a small box, about 10" x 6", out of poplar. I would like to install hinges such that when the box is closed, the lid & box are flush with one another. In other words, just as they are with the lid simply sitting on the box. I got a set of hinges at HD, but they're too thick. Of course I know I need a mortise for the hinge to sit in, but with these particular hinges, it's clear that, even with a mortise depth the thickness of the hinge plates, there will still be a gap at the rear edge of the box where the hinges are located. I hope I'm making this clear. Is there a particular type of hinge I need for the installation I'm attempting? Or maybe I just need to flatten/bend the hinges in the area of the pin, so the plates meet when the hinges are closed???

I'm afraid my knowledge of hinges is sadly lacking...

TIA

Dan

Re: Selecting box hinges

#2

Re: Selecting box hinges

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Dan -

If I'm picturing this right, you can get a gapless fit if you bevel the hinge mortises. The part of the hinge leaves closest to the pin will then be slightly recessed when viewed with the box open.

You can get high quality hinges from Woodcraft, Rockler, Whitechapel, Lee Valley and other vendors.

Ed

Re: Selecting box hinges

#3

Re: Selecting box hinges

John McGaw

>Inexpensive stamped sheet metal hinges almost always have the problem you describe. A glance at the hinge end-on will show that when it is closed and the plates are parallel there is a considerable gap between them. One option is to mortise the hinge more deeply. The other is to "adjust" the hinge. I've had fair luck simply flattening them using a bar of steel, hammer, and anvil. Of course the real solution is to find hinges that fit the requirements better.

Re: Selecting box hinges

#4

Re: Selecting box hinges

Dan Donaldson

>They are not cheap, but Brusso makes very nice box hinges. You can get them from Joel at www.Toolsforworkingwood.com, and I think, Lee Valley.

Re: Selecting box hinges

#5

Hinge installation instructions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Proper hinge installation seems to be the bane of many woodworkers. I see a lot of crappy hinge installation, even on high dollar pieces.

1. Buy a quality hinge. I get mine from Whitechapel. They are the same kind as what Woodcraft sells. Select a hinge with a blade a bit less than the thickness of the box side. Hinges are sized by their open width.

2. Place the hinge on the box lid where you want it. The center of the hinge barrel should be located just outside of the lid edge such that about 1/3 of the barrel is buried in the mortise after installation. Scribe around the hinge with a marking knife, pocket knife, Exacto knife, etc. Scribing is the hardest part. The hinge must be square to the lid or the lid will set crooked on the box. To ensure alignment I use a marking gauge to mark the width of the mortise on the lid. The marking gauge gives me a perfectly straight line for the mortise width. If you are careful to get the hinge perfectly aligned you can skip the marking gauge and just scribe around the hinge after aligning it with a square. I have been known to clamp blocks to a piece to aid hinge alignment. I repeat, this is the critical part.

3. Remove waste from scribed mortise. I use a small router to remove most of the waste and a chisel to get up to the scribe line. The depth of this mortise is a tiny bit less than one half the hinge barrel thickness. If the mortise is too shallow the lid will sit proud of the box. If too deep the hinge will bind. I use a practice piece to get the depth just right.

4. Install hinge on the lid. Ideally it should press fit into the mortise with zero gap showing. (Advance technique. I file a tiny chamfer on the hinge plate bottom before scribing so the scribe line will be a few thousandths inside the actual hinge width and length. Hinges fit tighter in mortise by doing this step) I use Vix bits for drilling holes. If the hinge sits tightly in the mortise it will not move out of alignment when drilling holes. If using brass screws first establish screw holes with a strong steel screw. I use a test block of the same wood to get the pilot hole size perfect.

5. Align lid on box and mark hinge location with a knife mark. Scribe and make mortise on box as was done for the lid.

I suggest practicing before doing the finished box.

Re: Selecting box hinges

#6

Re: Selecting box hinges

Larry in NW Ohio

>Dan I don`t know if this is what you are looking for, but would a barrel hinge work for you. In Lee Valley the # is 00H35.10. I have used these before and they can close the gap between the lid and the box very close. Larry in Ohio

Re: Selecting box hinges

#7

Re: Selecting box hinges

Jim Dillon

>Hi Dan,

Others have offered good advice. First, get a good quality hinge and you will not have the gap you mentioned when correctly installed. Second, the hinge mortise depth is critical. If the box is big enough, I use a plunge router and use the hinge leaf to set the depth. Otherwise, I use a small laminate router and adjust the bit depth by trial and error. In both cases I practice on a test piece. Sometimes too, I've left the hinges a little proud of the wood and placed a couple of felt bumpers on the leading edge of the box thus leaving a small gap all around the box lid. Maybe this is just a ploy to cover up sloppy technique and wanting to avoid cutting the mortise too deep - which is a lot more trouble to fix. I second the use of the Vix bit to center the screw hole, although I have a Starrett punch that provides a centered start-hole too. In my clumsy hands, I've found hinge installation to be fussy. Beall Tool offers gizmos that assist cutting the mortise with a router, but they are not inexpensive - though very well made. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Selecting box hinges

#8

Re: Selecting box hinges

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the great replies, especially the "step by step". I guess being confused by hinges isn't so dumb after all ;-)

I'd like to use some type of stop hinge, which holds the cover slightly more than half open (~95 degrees). When I looked at the price of some of these at Rockler & Lee Valley, I almost fell out of my chair. 58 bucks for a set of hinges?!?. Is there any elegant/simple way to use regular brass hinges, and have a stop function? I guess I could just attach a bit of chain, but that's not really "elegant", plus I can see it getting caught in the closing lid half the time.

Thanks again.

Dan

Re: Selecting box hinges

#9

Look here *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Here are the Brusso hinges that I mentioned. They are nice hinges, not cheap, but still better than the price you had.


Box hinges

Re: Selecting box hinges

#10

Re: Selecting box hinges

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Yes, Brusso makes a box hinge that has a built-in stop. I have used it and it works well - at least on a small box lid. Brusso also makes a lid support that is installed in the sides of the box. Like Dan, I have had good service from Tools For Working Wood and they offer a nice discount on four or more pairs IIRC. $58!!?? Exactly how big a box are you making? Maybe we are talking apples and oranges here.

Jim

Re: Selecting box hinges

#11

Re: Look here

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Dan, I think those are the ones I'll end up using.

Re: Selecting box hinges

#12

Re: Selecting box hinges *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>The box is 6.75 x 10 x 3.25. The $58 hinges are Brusso quadrant hinges, pic below, sized 1.5 x .5 (said to be "height by single leaf width". I'm guessing height refers to the length of the long arm to the pin?). For my box, I could probably use the smaller size, "only" $38.20.

If someone had shown me the larger of these & asked what I thought they might cost, I would have probably said "Umm, gee, I dunno, eleven bucks?"

Must be getting old... ;-)

I also found the piano-style stop hinges in the link, which seem interesting and are more reasonably priced.

Dan


img

http://www.leevalley.com/hardware/page.aspx?c=1&p=

Re: Selecting box hinges

#13

correction

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The extruded hinges I prefer have a barrel the same diameter as the thickness of the closed hinge. There is another type of hinge rolled from sheet stock where the barrel is larger in diameter. So rather than saying make the mortise a bit less than half the barrel diameter, a more general statement should be to make the mortise a bit less than half the closed hinge thickness with the closed hinge leaves parallel.

In cases the mortise depth is more than the hinge leaf thickness. I just did a pair that turned out that way using a stopped box hinge from Whitechapel.

Re: Selecting box hinges

#14

Re: Selecting box hinges

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

OK, your box is what I would consider a medium size box. And I have also installed the Brusso quadrant hinges you are thinking about. If I rememher right, my boxes were about 13 inches wide (see photo below). If I had to do it over, I would have picked the smaller quadrant hinge. I'm away from my shop right now so I can't give you a measurement on what I used and what I wished I had used. The Brusso quadrant hinges are massive and superbly well-made. And keep in mind that my box sides and top were made from 8/4 cherry or maple. Nonetheless, I would have still gone with a smaller hinge. If you are building an ordinary 10 inch wide box, with say 1/2-5/8 inch walls, I would look at the Brusso regular box hinges with the built-in stop. They might meet your needs better. Not that there is anything wrong with the quadrant hinges, but they are REALLY fussy to install - at least in my hands. Beall Tool has some nice instructions (and end-cut drill bits) for help in installing them though.

Jim


img

Re: Selecting box hinges

#15

Re: Selecting box hinges

DizD

>The Whitechapel website has a technical section on right side of the page with discussion of hinge installation. I frequently use the second technique - installing the hinge barrel flush with the back with a bevel on lid and box to act as a stop. After mortising the hinge to the box, I mount it and then remove it and use a block plane to cut a small bevel on the back edge. The lid is then marked with hinge reinstalled on the box, mortised and mounted, then removed to cut the bevel. Its a great way to use a relatively inexpensive brass hinge and still have a lid stay feature.