Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Posts

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#26

To name two...

Michael Dresdner

>Watco Danish Oil was reformulated a few years ago when the company was picked up by Rustoleum. It is now about 43% solids, roughly the same as most oil based varnishes and polyurethanes. All the gels made by McFadden (Rockler Polyurethane Gel, Bartley and Lawrence McFadden gel) are also in the same range. This is not to imply these are the only ones; they are simply the first two that came to mind when you asked.

Curiously, the wide scale VOC regulations have played a large part in forcing some of the worst culprits to abandon the practice of selling a lot of solvent with a little bit of finish. As far as finish formulation goes, you are getting more for your money these days, not less. Where else is that happening?

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#27

Re: There's some misinformation in this thread

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I remember your discussing using a scotchbrite pad several ywars ago at Novi. I have tried it and, yes, it does work and well.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#28

Re: To name two...

Howard Acheson

>>> Watco Danish Oil was reformulated a few years ago when the company was picked up by Rustoleum. It is now about 43% solids, roughly the same as most oil based varnishes and polyurethanes.

Michael, are saying that Watco Danish oil is a varnish? It's clearly an oil/varnish mixture and certainly not a hard, durable and protective film finish like a varnish.

Also, from their own MSDS, the contents are 70% thinners leaving only 30% for the resin or varnish and the linseed oil. These, and the Gilsonite are the components of finish after the thinners have evaporated.

We may be engaged in an issue of semantics but, to me, oil/varnish mixtures (danish oil, tung oil finish) are not truly varnishes. To me varnish is varnish, not varnish and oil. Adding more oil significantly alters the characteristics of the resulting finish.

A thinned wiping varnish results in a pure varnish finish. Sure, the amount of solids can be different but it's not the solids alone that make the characteristics of varnish. A standard varnish already contains thinners to make the varnish brushable. Adding more thinner reduces the amount of varnish (solids)in the mixture but not the amount of solids that end up on the surface. I takes more coats to build a certain film thickness but the protective qualities of the varnish remain the same.

Don't get me wrong, I am not disparaging oil/varnish products. They are what they are and can be the right product depending on the results desired. I also understand the marketing implications of VOC regulations but using oil as a thinner in varnish--which in my opinion what many have done--removes the product from my definition of a varnish. To represent the resulting product as "varnish" misrepresents it to one who is looking for the qualities expected from a traditional varnish.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#29

Re: There's some misinformation in this thread

Bill White

>This is one of the most informative, interesting and BS free threads I have read in many a day. MORE, MORE, MORE!!!!

Demystifying finishes is also a valuable part of our "craft".

Let's keep it up.

Bill

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#30

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Would it be generally true that wiping varnish is inherently less durable (softer for example) than the best "brushable" varnish formulated for indoor furniture? Or maybe to word another way, will there always be a price to pay in performance for adding "wiping" to the requirements?

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#31

varnish contains "oil" already

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Traditionally varnish was a mixture of resin (hard stuff) and oil was added more or less to make the resulting finish more flexible/less brittle. So things like spar varnish had more oil so the spars would not chip and a table top finish that was to be rubbed out had less oil so it would be hard enough to be rubbed out. Now days finishes are not quite this straightforward, but the principles are the same. I think it would be said that all varnish has an "oil" component, more or less, though the details of this oil may not be as simple as a slug of linseed oil like one might add to turn varnish into homemade brushable varnish.

I have always had the notion that wipe-on meant inferior properties, which I think is what you were getting at. Let us see what Michael has to say about my question below.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#32

Re: To name two...

Fred Davis

>Howard,

your assertion that Watco Danish oil is not a film finish is not quite right . Even though Watco refers to it as a penetraing oil, it also leaves a film.

It is easy to check ,put some on a piece of flat glass or a smooth wood that is already sealed and you will readily note afer drying, that you can peel off a tough film.

FredD

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#33

Re: varnish contains "oil" already

Alexander Grigoriev

>Varnish is not just a mix of oil and resin. They are "cooked" together into a new compound.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#34

Re: There's some misinformation in this thread

Jerry Gibbs

>can someone explain the scotchbrite method for applying unthinned poly? Jerry Gibbs

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#35

True, but.......

Howard Acheson

>... the proportion of oil to resin can be adjusted to make a varnish harder or softer. Most interior varnishes are have a smaller oil component resulting in a harder varnish. Exterior and marine exterior spar varnishes contain a larger oil component so the resulting varnish film will maintain its adhesion when the underlying wood expands/contracts in changing outdoor conditions.

Adding more oil to a varnish (aka an oil/varnish mixture) makes the resulting finish quite a bit softer and more able to penetrate into the wood surface. Oil/varnish mixtures generally require that the excess be wiped off after a period of penetration so that no film can be built. If you don't, the resulting finish will be very soft and most often, gummy.

I consider that there are two distinctly different finishes under the generic description of a "wipe-on finish". One is the penetrating in-the-wood oil/varnish finish. This type of finish is frequently marketed as danish oil, tung oil finish and Scandinavian finish. The second wipe-on is a thinned varnish where a true varnish is thinned to make it into a wiping consistency. The basic properties of the varnish are not modified.

Maybe we need to consider a third type of varnish which is what some manufacturers are marketing as VOC compliant. These "varnishes" use more VOC compliant thinners but also add oils to maintain the brushability of the product. However, I have never seen any data that indicates that these new formulations are as hard and protective as the more traditional varnishes. To be fair, I've not seen any data that they are not as protective and durable. The one I used (Minwax) certainly accepted a fingernail depression quite easily.

Clearly we are not going to turn back the tide whereby finishes are being legislated toward ever more stringent VOC regulations. Just because some oil based finishes are VOC compliant in some states does not mean that future VOC standards will legislate them out.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#36

Re: To name two...

Howard Acheson

>Fred, that film will also be quite wrinkled and not really a protective film.

But, most importantly, that is not the way the product is used. The instructions tell the user to wipe the surface dry after a period for absorption. If you follow directions, there is only a minuscule amount of surface film. The product is not intended to be a film forming finish. That's its marketing claim.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#37

IMO, no.

Howard Acheson

>>> Would it be generally true that wiping varnish is inherently less durable (softer for example) than the best "brushable" varnish formulated for indoor furniture?

If we are talking about a standard oil based varnish like P&L, Cabot, Waterlox Original, Behlen's or a standard poly varnish like any of the big box brands or the true marine brands, adding more thinner will not change the basic characteristics of the varnish except for its viscosity. The thinner will totally evaporate no matter how much or little is contained in the mixture. Once the thinners evaporate, you are left with "varnish". Of course, each application of the thinned varnish will leave less of a film of varnish on the surface. So, more coats will need to be applied to get the same film thickness as a brushed on full strength (unthinned) varnish.

The big "however" as Michael has said is that some of the consumer brand wipe-on varnish has more added to it than additional thinner. The question then becomes, what do these other additives do to the characteristics of what used be oil based varnish?

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#38

Maybe this will help  *LINK*

Curly Smith

>


The best and easiest